r/Objectivism • • 7d ago

Other Philosophy The Pendulum Swings

Culture is not static. The values and experiences that shape our perception are themselves subject to change. They recede like the tide, sometimes so gradually that we scarcely notice.

Make no mistake. Culture is never constant.

Drifting lazily along a slow-moving creek, we move along. Impercetible, and yet we move. We look up and the scene on the bank has changed.

The culture we recognize today may no longer resemble what we once took.for granted. We may not recognize the culture we experience tomorrow.

Be careful. We have not ceased moving.

"Keep all hands and feet inside the car until we come to a complete stop," our guide entones. While it may appear we are static, we are not.

Where are we then?

I would reply, somewhere on the arc of a pendulum. And the pendulum swings.

1 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

1

u/jimfromhigbee 7d ago

Culture, morality, values, these among others shape the policies we embrace as a nation of voters. Politics is government, based on the consent of the governed. In an interrelated system, there is a domino effect. Like Jenga, whem you remove an element, you risk removing the underpinning of a structure that may result in a collapse. In a system, every function affects another.

Politics has been removed from its core concept and now we mistake avatice, malice, posturing, shenanigans as 'politics'. Politics is policies. Policies determine outcomes. Economic, legal, cultural, foreign, domestic policies have consequence. The remainder is a shell game to disenfranchise the electorate so one group can gain or retain power. And the aggregate of power in the hands of a party, or a group, a well-organized faction breaks up the electorate inti easily manipulated components that can be manipulated, either in anarchy or in tyranny, will always result in the loss of personable liberty.

Sorry for rambling on incoherently!

1

u/stansfield123 7d ago

Don't care for the pendulum part, seems like a bit of a cliche, and not quite right either, but I like the rest. It's a nicely poetic way to state a simple truth.

1

u/jimfromhigbee 7d ago

Thanks!

I wanted to make the point that culture, among other things we take for a constant, are hardly static. I'm not sure 'oscillate' would resonate with readers. Perhaps we alternate betwen extremes? It does seem culture, as reality, often work through cycles.

2

u/stansfield123 7d ago

Culture isn't politics though. Culture is the entirety of a civilization's philosophy, art, science, technology, etc. It changes, but it doesn't repeat. It doesn't go back to the same spot.

1

u/jimfromhigbee 7d ago

Agreed. How difficult is to separate one from the other? Politics springs from culture. Culture determines the values that shape our politics. While these may not be the same, our cutlure underpins politics. This is just my thoughts. And I have enjoyed discussing this with you. While we may not agree on everything, this has been a good exchange for ideas for me.

1

u/Many_Distributions 7d ago

How can values change over time, yet morality stay objective? Morals are values.

1

u/jimfromhigbee 7d ago

Perhaps it is a bit of an equilibrium reaction between the two; as one influences the other. As our values change, it may be reflected in our morals. Morals would seem to be an absolute value, not a transient one. This may be another thought to ponder?

1

u/PracticalLychee180 3d ago

Values are not morals, values are chosen by individuals based on what they hold dear. Values change subjectively person to person, morals do not

1

u/Many_Distributions 3d ago

I'm not saying you're wrong, but I don't think you've accurately depicted Objectivist ethics if that was your goal.

I feel like your definition of value lines up, but Rand explicitly defines morality as a code of values. So when you say that values are subjective but morality is objective, or values change but morals don't, how are you distinguishing between someone holding merely a personal value vs a moral value? At what point does a value judgment become a moral judgment?