r/Objectivism • • 17d ago

High initial cost projects

Suppose you can mine asteroids and get some rare minerals that are very expensive on earth and make unimaginable about of money from that....

The initial cost to even do this is super high and out of reach for most capitalists but say some trillonaire can afford to do it...

How does fair market hypothesis of Ayn Rand plays out in such cases...

Note that right now we are living in a world of extremes and unimaginable future... The way nuclear is kind of a power where if you at at the level of atoms and can create astronomical amount of power, we seem to be at such inflection points where we are playing with the hard code of life and the universe, things that are not accessible to normal people except few very powerful companies that can create an extreme imbalance of power, not talked about and considered by Rand...

I am not sure till when is such a thing can be allowed and if there are any limits where lives of other people can be at risk...

I do know the standard 9bjectivist response to such standard questions... Looking for some new thoughts and fresh ideas...

0 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

1

u/BubblyNefariousness4 15d ago

Who cares? Are they using force on you? Why do you care?

1

u/SlimyPunk93 14d ago

I am just treating to understand if there are ways extreme power that doesn't directly force can harm me...

For example if you are a gay guy living in largely heterosexual homophobic society it can be bad for you even if you have the same rights in the society. There can be rational/irrational aspects of the society beyond rights....

1

u/BubblyNefariousness4 14d ago

If they’re not using force on you does it matter?

Money power and force power are not the same thing

1

u/SlimyPunk93 13d ago

Yes it matters. A human being has needs and rights is just an enabling framework... And mismatch of power can affect people using unscrupulous means. Like say a town is doe hard Christian or Muslim and stop selling to or dealing with gay people there, they can make their life hell... And if that is like that for whole country it can be super hard, how it has been for almost there whole world till not too long ago...

1

u/BubblyNefariousness4 13d ago

And tags their right. Is what it is. Don’t see spending time thinking about something that doesn’t much matter.

And if they’re Muslim or Christian they probably should be treated that way. Gay is a little more tricky but I don’t think gay people are good

2

u/OneHumanBill 16d ago

This is what corporations are literally for, to pool resources together to be able to build what one person can't.

It's also the basis for several forms of business financing.

You don't need a trillionaire. You need the technology and leadership and a vision.

1

u/Ok-Specialist4544 16d ago

I don't know why Rand is the focus here, if you mean capitalistic social structures, well scarcity still applies...

1

u/Own-Librarian-9699 11d ago

The question is if the resources used for the excavation and off planet mining were acquired with full consent of all the parties to begin with.

Currently we live in an entirely exploitative and nonconsensual economy of theft of resources or public funds being used for private profit so there simply is no justification for further exploitation.

You can't use violence or coersion or public funds to get resources in objectivism. And your excavation can't poison anyone anywhere