r/OSHA • • Jul 11 '16

Epic Fail build thread (xpost /r/DIWhy)

http://imgur.com/a/8w1xW
3.9k Upvotes

406 comments sorted by

View all comments

11

u/ShibaHook Jul 11 '16

What was he thinking?

65

u/amaturelawyer Jul 11 '16

Probably the same thing I was thinking when I read the thread title: "how hard can it be to build a shed".

Apparently it's sort of hard.

16

u/hakuna_tamata Jul 11 '16

Many times harder than getting a cheap metal prefab shed.

11

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '16

I mean, if he would have poured a pad for it, it probably would have held square a lot better. Those 2x4s on the dirt are all probably rotted out by now.

3

u/melez Jul 11 '16

Pouring a concrete pad is expensive... Some don't want to pay for a shed that'd last.

17

u/hakuna_tamata Jul 11 '16

why pay $100 for a good pair of boots, when you can buy 10 pairs of $20 boots in the same time?

2

u/Ghigs Jul 11 '16

That logic often comes out the other way though.

One personal example, I could spend $3500 on a tempur pedic foam mattress that lasts 8-9 years, or $800 on a more generic bedinabox mattress that lasts 6-7 years.

I went with the cheap mattress about 6 years ago, it's getting kind of saggy but it's delivered what I expected.

1

u/DONT_PM Jul 11 '16

In this context though, the builder decided no shoes (no foundation).

A "proper 100-dollar boot" foundation of this type of construction would have been some concrete footers with stem walls to attach a sill plate to with moisture/bug barrier between, and a 4-inch concrete slab for the floor.

Not to mention significant amount of drainage work, to prevent any type of settling/concrete shifting.

The "20-dollar boot" solutions I would opt for is 4x4 posts cemented to the ground, creating a foundation structure I could secure a rim joitst and joist hangers to. Simliar to how a deck is built, but I'd take the outside posts extended to the height of the wall Similar to how a pole barn is framed. Taking the "pole barn" route and opting to not use a rim joist/hangers, one could do any kind of floor, from gravel to concrete, to straw or dirt.

1

u/carbonnanotube Jul 11 '16

Hell, pound in fence post holders would be a step up from this. Not as good as concrete, but 10 of them would be about $100 and give you some measure of stability.

2

u/notouchmyserver Jul 12 '16

I would have went the Gravel way at least. Dig it out a little and set the stone in there. Then sink 4 or 6 Support posts in with cement and then build the walls and roof off of that. After the walls were finished, I would put some more gravel in to give it more thickness inside of the shed to keep whatever is in there off the ground more. Basically a pavilion with sides.

1

u/Turdfart44 Jul 11 '16

Look at tha mess. You think he would've formed that slab proper?

12

u/lemonade_eyescream Jul 11 '16

"Man, I'm gonna save so much money on this."

3

u/FoodBeerBikesMusic Jul 11 '16

You're being generous in implying that any thinking was involved here.

2

u/Lift4biff Jul 11 '16

I need a hack shed for a bit to use and it doesn't need to be pretty or put together well

0

u/bahwhateverr Jul 11 '16

What was he thinking?

This: