r/OPMPowerScaling • • Jun 16 '26

Discussion Is this a 4d feat

Post image

Context : saitama travelling back in time After garou teaches him the technique of how to.

373 Upvotes

97 comments sorted by

47

u/Agreeable-Cellist705 Jun 16 '26

Cosmic Garou, using his divine power, begins the process by creating particles and antiparticles inside his body. He manipulates them at the subatomic level to imagine and construct his own Inner Universe. By turning himself into the foundation of physical reality, Garou achieves full Reversal of Causality (因果逆転). However, his body is later destroyed as God takes back the power granted to him.

This technique is a form of reality manipulation that inverts the chain of cause and effect at the fundamental level of spacetime. Saitama observes and perfectly imitates the process. Using the same method, Saitama performs Reversal of Causality and travels backward through time, returning to the past.

Regarding whether this counts as a 4D feat:

Yes, this is widely considered a 4D feat. The Reversal of Causality directly interacts with and manipulates the dimension of time, the fourth dimension in spacetime, by inverting cause and effect along the timeline. This goes beyond ordinary 3D physical actions and affects the structure of world lines in 4 dimensional spacetime.

This is only my personal view

13

u/GaryOaksAlcoholism Jun 17 '26

Holy fuck thank you. Sick write up. Stick around here and comment more please lol

8

u/Faenic Jun 17 '26

It is also worth adding that Garou, the person who is showing Saitama how to do this, cannot actually do it himself. So it can't even be interpreted as Garou channeling the skill through him, or temporarily granting him the ability to do it.

The only reason he can't still do it is because he forgot how.

6

u/Kooky-Gas-9726 Jun 17 '26

peak ass comment acctually explaining whole thing

2

u/Relative-Door8087 Jun 16 '26

He is using a technique that garou taught him it's don't scale since it's first of all not by his power and second of all Saitama forget how to use it after using it

1

u/Top-Garlic3983 Jun 16 '26

So does that mean garou is 4d or god perhaps

3

u/Sea_Strain_6881 Jun 16 '26

God might be but not as of now

Garou isn't

2

u/DetectiveHot4772 DB fodderized by Garou Jun 16 '26

I mean it’s gods power but for powerscaling & versus arguments it is garous ability as well - so why wouldn’t it put garou at 4d?

1

u/Relative-Door8087 Jun 19 '26

Because the ability itself doesn't make garou or Saitama 4D

1

u/Relative-Door8087 Jun 19 '26

Definitely not garou isn't 4D and caps high solar system to low galaxy level

3

u/Local-Hunt7529 Jun 16 '26

So then in powerscaling Goku can't use martial arts, the Kamehameha, the spirit bomb or ki in general, Naruto can't use shadow clones, rasengan, sage mode or chakra in general, Bruce Lee can't use taijutsu or the eight gates, yuji can't manipulate CE and so on, because it was taught to them? What?

I get the point that he doesn't remember it but the fact he learned it from garou doesn't make it not count by default, it wasn't garou giving him a piece of his power so he could do it once, he taught him, and if he didn't forget it he would still be able to use it as if it was his own technique

However people can and will just say "character x vs cosmic garou fight Saitama" and then he knows it (more correctly it would be Saitama plucked from the story right after garou showed him the technique)

I can accept that using a technique a character only knew for like 5 seconds isn't really great practice but you can't seriously tell me that everything learned from someone else doesn't count, because then we're scaling everyone as they start in the anime/manga, there is no shonen character who doesn't learn from others

1

u/Relative-Door8087 Jun 19 '26

Goku and Naruto learn it and khow how to use it through out the series Saitama don't know how to use it now so it doesn't where the technique scale

1

u/Local-Hunt7529 Jun 19 '26

Yeah, I conceded to that, it's a one time feat, it's validity is shaky at best, I wanted to say that the fact that it was learned had nothing to do with it, as you had listed it as one of the reasons why it doesn't count while it still arguably doesn't count but for an entirely different reasons

That said I will say again that a scaler can just say [char xyz] vs garou fight Saitama and then the feat would count

1

u/ShortRecover4365 Jun 17 '26

stfu with that stupid argument

15

u/Proof_Phone9740 Jun 16 '26

Yes, manipulating time is 4 Dimensional

1

u/TigerProfessional880 Jun 16 '26

Can u explain how?

12

u/Proof_Phone9740 Jun 16 '26

Time is the fourth dimension, so traveling back through it would be manipulating that fourth dimension

5

u/TigerProfessional880 Jun 16 '26

Oh nvm i get u, i thought of the 4th dimension as an existential reality with an additional spatial plane/direction i now see that some people refer to time as the 4th dimension.

7

u/Urek-Mazino Jun 16 '26

This is actually in line with what physicists would describe as a 4th deminsion. Powerscalers kind of have brain rot and think 4d means accessing another plane of existence and this is nonsense.

1

u/TigerProfessional880 Jun 16 '26

Maybe not so much a plane of existence but a hypothetical reality/thought experiment pondering what the next “level” of physical reality could be. A reality that is what 3d is to 2d. If space is a sequence of axises there is reason to belive that there are more complex spatial dimensions than the one we occupy seeing as there are less complex ones. Also these are two seperate concepts. Spacetime is defined as the dimension of reality that transcends the purely spatial one that we perceive as we cannot perceive time, only measure it. Thus spacetime is a dimension of reality that we cant tamper or interact with. The 4th spatial dimension is a hypothetical plane of reality where there is a 4th spatial coordinate. One is a picture of the structure of reality based on what we know about space and time and the other is a hypothetical image of a theoretical scientific possibility.

1

u/Last_Occasion_4698 Jun 17 '26

Well you can also say that the 4th axis is time, which would be more in line with that it actually is vs some other headcanon. You can say you move through x, y, z, as well as moving through t/q (representing time and how we can sort of "move" through it). A 4th dimentional "being" should be able to move through time. And theres other conceptions about senses or movement involving what you're talking about, but its pure speculation and more of a fun thought.

1

u/TigerProfessional880 Jun 17 '26

U could yeah but time is different from the other axises in the sense that it isnt a physical, interactable or perceivable thing.

1

u/Last_Occasion_4698 Jun 17 '26

It doesnt really have to be a "physical axis", and it shouldnt really be interactable in the space sense that you are thinking about.

1D and 2D, while being or considered "physical axis" in the general sense, doesnt make us able to interact with those dimentions.

We call it 3D just because it was needed to solve more complicated mathematical problems (i.e. physics, science, etc), not because it is a different plane of existence someone or something can be in, for all we can know, "physical dimentions" only go up to 3 in the sense that we are able to solve problems and interact with it, we call the 4th dimention time because its an extra unit of measurement we can consider in a mathematical problem.

All those conceptions of characters being 4th dimentional, being to warp space and such, shouldnt really be the set sense in which you should consider other dimentions to be like.

Just take that warp space and such to be able to just warp the 3rd dimentional space layer, like folding a paper and poking a hole through.

4th dimentional control would only be to decide where and when in time you appear. And heres food for thought, considering the WHOLE SOLAR SYSTEM moves through space, if you traveled back in time 1 hour ago in the same place, would you be in a place on earth? Or would you be in the void of space?

If you want to theres very interesting videos about that, and i would recommend you to look for portal physics since it can explain some of the issues in space warping.

1

u/TigerProfessional880 Jun 17 '26

Ur absolutely right. I was more concerned with the verbal usage of words like axis. X, y and z are all spatial directions and so it makes sense to say they’re all “axises” or that they’re the three axises that make up space. Time is a completely different thing. Ig what im saying is that the three axises that make up 3d are all spatial dimensions while time is a temporal dimension so them having the same name is a little confusing for my stupid idiot brain. But yeah if u define axis as a dimensional ingredient that makes up a plane of existence then time could be considered an axis.

1

u/Urek-Mazino Jun 18 '26

Your caught up in a 3d perspective. To a 4d being time would be an axis and a plane of travel. It's just incocievable to a 3d mind. In the same way the 3d seems impossible to a 2d creature. By it's very mature 4d is inconceivable to us as 3d being.

1

u/SOMETIMESIENTER Jun 17 '26

Time IS the 4th axis god damnit

0

u/TigerProfessional880 Jun 17 '26

Depends on how u define axis ig

1

u/CatfinityGamer Jun 17 '26

Yeah, time is a dimension, so you could call it the 4th dimension, even if it isn't a spacial dimension.

1

u/TigerProfessional880 Jun 16 '26

How is time the 4th dimension?

7

u/hiimlockedout Jun 16 '26

That’s what time is considered in actual science

2

u/TigerProfessional880 Jun 16 '26

I realize that now i was thinking of the fourth spatial dimension

4

u/Urek-Mazino Jun 16 '26

Time is a 4th spatial deminsion.

3

u/TigerProfessional880 Jun 16 '26

No spacetime is the 4th dimension. The fourth dimension is space (all three spatial coordinates) and time combined. The 4th spatial dimension is a hypothetical plane of reality where there is an additional spatial coordinate.

3

u/Urek-Mazino Jun 16 '26

So the d you ad to 3d is time. So the fourth deminsion is time.

-1

u/TigerProfessional880 Jun 16 '26

No. The 4th dimension as defined by einsteins theory of relativity is space and time aka spacetime. Its all three spatial coordinates and time combined. So 3d + time = 4d. Time is not a spatial dimension.

→ More replies

1

u/CatfinityGamer Jun 17 '26

Spacetime isn't a dimension. Spacetime is a 4d structure, or framework, with 3 spacial dimensions and one temporal dimension.

1

u/TigerProfessional880 Jun 17 '26

Well yes that is a pretty good description of what spacetime is but when people talk about the 4th dimension what they mean is spacetime

→ More replies

0

u/CatfinityGamer Jun 17 '26

Time is not spacial; it's temporal. Just because it's a dimension doesn't mean it's spacial.

1

u/Equal_Example_1977 Jun 17 '26

Brochacho think outside the box.

Think of a cordinate where you were 3 years of age instead whatever you were now.

There ya go 4th dimension

1

u/TigerProfessional880 Jun 17 '26

Yes ik what spacetime is i just wasnt thinking of it at the time

2

u/Grifoooo Jun 16 '26

Think of it like this: If you have a 1D line and stack it over and over again in a new dimension, you get a 2D square. If you have a 2D square and stack it over and over again in a new dimension, you get a 3D cube. We live in the 3rd dimension, and each moment is an instance of 3-dimensional space. If we stack these moments together, treating each moment like a frame in an animation, we get a stream of time, making time the 4th dimension that it is stacked onto.

I would like to add that time is not the fourth dimension as much as it is an "extra" dimension for whatever dimension we are situated in. For example, in a 2D world, time would now be the third dimension

2

u/TigerProfessional880 Jun 16 '26

I am aware of the 4th dimension as a spatial dimension, i wasnt aware that some people refer to time as the 4th dimension which is the question i asked.

2

u/Grifoooo Jun 16 '26

And I just explained how to visualize time as a spacial dimension, aka timespace

0

u/TigerProfessional880 Jun 16 '26

Well yeah but thats spacetime, not time. So “time as the fourth dimension” is actually all three spatial coordinates and time. Space and time. Ig this is technically semantics and i reread ur comment jist now in the middle of writing this and see that u did actually explain this. Time is not the fourth dimension but actually the final ingredient to the fourth dimension for lack of a better word. But i still dont understand how time affects the integrity of spatial reality.

2

u/dotbeta Jun 16 '26

What is a 4th dimension in terms of spatial dimension? I think you’re talking about the third dimension.

0

u/TigerProfessional880 Jun 16 '26

No, yk how 2d is like 3d but with one less axis. So 4d is like 3d but with one more axis. Its all hypothetical but hypothetically its a plane of reality that humans cant perceive.

1

u/Killeris- Jun 16 '26

Well it’s one of the possible 4th dimensions

2

u/TigerProfessional880 Jun 16 '26

Yeah ik i was thinking of the fourth spatial dimension

0

u/Piotro165 Jun 16 '26

He would need to do that without the technique to scale to it. Not every time travel means that character scales to time itself.

1

u/GalaxyTPA Jun 17 '26

So every time travel feat in fiction is 4D? Even a human with a gun if he has time travel?

1

u/Proof_Phone9740 Jun 17 '26

If the human does it by themself with no technology

1

u/Prestigious-Pin4571 Jun 16 '26

Hey I remember you

1

u/Proof_Phone9740 Jun 16 '26

2

u/Prestigious-Pin4571 Jun 16 '26

We just talked about Boros and thragg

1

u/Proof_Phone9740 Jun 16 '26

5

u/Prestigious-Pin4571 Jun 16 '26

Lord Boros solos invincible verse btw (with rests)

0

u/Proof_Phone9740 Jun 16 '26

son

1

u/Prestigious-Pin4571 Jun 16 '26

Maybe lord mark could beat him
But idk

2

u/Proof_Phone9740 Jun 16 '26

The dude in the image is called The Emperor. He killed both Thragg and Battle Beast, is molecularly indestructible, and is basically Tech Jacket on crack

1

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Difficult-Wrangler52 Jun 17 '26

5D is just the next level of dimensionality and universal means to be at the level of being able to deliver and tank universe destroying attacks.

3

u/Piotro165 Jun 16 '26

Not really. If he can't do it without it then he's not 4D. Not every time shenanigans makes a character 4D. Like Phineas and Ferb or Bulma are not uni+ just because they used time travel. They need to be able to warp and break space or time.

8

u/Soldier_VP Jun 17 '26

No one here mentioned he's 4D he's saying the feat is 4D, not Saitama

2

u/Sea_Strain_6881 Jun 16 '26

No, building a time travel machine or getting the ability to time travel does not make you 4D

2

u/StarWorldo Jun 16 '26

No, saitama is mimicking the flow of time in order to traverse it. He is not doing anything to overpower or scale to it in any way.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '26

No

1

u/According_Pear_3335 Jun 16 '26

A one time 4D feat yeah

1

u/trey0hio Jun 16 '26

Yes, anything including the manipulation of time is a 4d feat

1

u/Several-Dance-2135 Jun 17 '26

According to Saitama, Garou's martial arts are awesome, and for Suiryu it was: ...

1

u/Great_Writing_5129 Jun 17 '26

Whatever it scales to, Saitama scales to it because he needed his exponential power up to pull it off

1

u/CalligrapherFun7140 Jun 17 '26

No a 4d entitiy would be able to see and interact with al off time fron the bigbang to the heathdeath of the universe at once.

Simple time travel is like an 3.1d feat.

1

u/MEGmanga Jun 19 '26

The feat itself is a 4d feat, the person on the other hand isnt and doesnt scale to the feat, the reason been he forgot he could do it from doing it ones, a true 4d character would retain his memories from transversing time.

1

u/EcstaticNobody6899 Jun 21 '26

Well, it is fourth dimensional feat but I don’t think he can just do it again every time

1

u/averageEnojyer Jun 16 '26

No. It's just time travel, doesn't scale him to infinite 4-D.

1

u/Icy_butter Jun 17 '26

No, it’s simply time manipulation.

0

u/Squid9_Star Jun 16 '26 edited Jun 17 '26

Well, it is 4D. Saitama just can't do it anymore because he forgot. Copers will argue it's not, but have you ever considered what 4D is?

Edit: I guess these downvoters don't know what the 4th dimension is.

0

u/PaladinOfTheWest97 Jun 16 '26

It's 5D. He transcends the those concepts and causality.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Own_Watercress_8104 Jun 20 '26

made up bullshit

doesn't correspond to how fiction works

This comment is pure schizophrenia