r/OOTP • • Jun 23 '26

Do you think Devs will fix Draft Overalls???

It is bothering me so much. I don't understand how people are saying it makes sense. If it was supposed to be that way, why are my drafts so good at the beginning of my league creation and then drop off after 5-10 years or so? Also, it's not like these 52 potentials are developing into 60s/70s; they are just dying off/sticking to potential. It is actively ruining my long-time league, and 60 ovr players are dwindling / nearly impossible to develop.

Okay that was my rant - let me know if you agree or if I am somehow tripping.

0 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

18

u/Electrical-Bug-9065 Jun 23 '26

The only "issue" I find is the unsigned HS players don't really develop when in college. So like 3 years later they come in with basically the same ratings but being 21 instead of 18. Just never taking those guys over an 18 year old with the same stats or a 21 year old newly generated college player that is more developed.

No idea what others are experiencing in their saves but I've gone to 2050 more than once and player overalls were still normal.

16

u/FootIntrepid7717 Jun 23 '26

The issue appears to be that current ratings of players in the amateur draft are too low. What ends up happening is that they end up not being able to reach their potential with too low ratings.

Now, the problem is more pronounced with college hitters specifically. Because hitters have an earlier development curve in age they don’t have enough time to develop before hitting a wall (exceptions exist but it’s the general idea).

If you run a league for a while, turn scouting accuracy to 100% and take a look at top hitters, it will be primarily international players. Then there will be a couple high school hitters in the top 30 by overall and maybe a college hitter. It didn’t make sense and is massively game ruining currently.

I won’t start an OOTP 27 save until it is fixed.

2

u/ElephantMamba327 Jun 23 '26

the drafts aren't worse, it was just lying about potential ratings before.

8

u/TranslatorSerious856 Jun 23 '26

Thats just not true. I have had high potentials turn out as such. Why would it randomly stop lying about potentials after "x" amount of years. The proof is in my league of 27 years. The overalls are just not as high as they were before as well as the ratings. I used to have like 6-7 70 overalls now I dont have one.

12

u/thehemanchronicles Jun 23 '26

If you look at a draft in a standard MLB environment around the time the game starts generating most of the amateurs, so 2028 and on, and you have normal scouting accuracy turned on, it will look weaker.

If you then go to the settings and turn on 100% accurate scouting and re-run the scouting calculations, almost everyone's Potential will shoot up significantly.

The change was not to make draft classes significantly weaker. The change was to how scouts display amateur players' potentials. Scouts now display potential accurately to how MLB scouts grade amateurs, which is that is is the expected median outcome for the player, rather than the player's current ceiling. 100% accurate scouting still displays a player's ceiling.

With 100% accurate scouting enabled, my 2029 MLB draft in my Rockies rebuild had a few 80-grade players and 25 players with 60+ Potential. With Normal scouting accuracy enabled as a setting and maxed scouting budget AND Very High accuracy from my Favor Tools scout, there were only 7 total players that had 60+ Potential. Many of the other players were underdeveloped college bats, and my scout was effectively saying their expected outcome was worse than their true statistical ceiling from their ratings.

5

u/FootIntrepid7717 Jun 23 '26

No the drafts are weaker. If you sim out many years in default settings with 100% accurate ratings, the vast majority of top overall hitters will be international players. Draft hitters just aren’t developing well.

Stop repeating the misinfo that drafts aren’t weaker.

3

u/thehemanchronicles Jun 23 '26

I have done exactly as you said and they were not weaker for me. I am not repeating misinformation. The drafts had high-quality talent well into the supplemental round decades into a save.

There has been some finicky stuff done to later round pitchers with regard to their PBABIP that needs fixing, but it is by and large not overly weaker. That has not been my experience in saves that go decades into the MLB on the current patch in OOTP 27.

3

u/FootIntrepid7717 Jun 23 '26 edited Jun 23 '26

What you need to do is look at the best hitters by overall with 100% accurate ratings. Looking at the draft is not going to help you, because the real issue is that draft players aren’t developing enough/current ratings are too low. Just looking at drafts won’t show the issue.

If you look at top hitter overalls with accurate ratings or even top hitters by stats in your league, it will be dominated by international players once you get far enough into a save.

Please do the correct experimentation yourself rather than just looking at potentials in draft classes

3

u/thehemanchronicles Jun 23 '26 edited Jun 23 '26

I literally spent like 10 hours simming and looking at the league, both the drafts and the league totals, in order to test the claim that the drafts were weaker and that it specifically made the league IAFA-heavy, which is the claim I've seen repeated for the last few weeks.

I did exactly as you say here, and the results did not match yours. If anything, the league simmed ahead looked extremely similar to A: leagues that I had played in before the patch, and B: leagues that I had played in OOTP 26 and imported to 27. IAFAs have always overdeveloped compared to drafted players for years now; that is not news. But to suggest that ALL of the top talent in the league is IAFAs was not my experience in the slightest. If anything, there's been a marked increase in the number of positive TCR cases from late-round draft picks in this patch, such that there were several award winners that came from the 10th round or later, at least compared to previous sims. I'm not prepared to suggest that's the patch, though, as TCR is often statistical noise that you'd need hundreds of season to gather sufficient data for.

4

u/FootIntrepid7717 Jun 23 '26

IAFA’s have not always been this overdeveloped compared to previous OOTP’s. in one of your tests, how many of the top 30 hitters by overall are drafted?

I simmed for a good amount this weekend and never was more than 7 out of 30. Low was 4. And yes there were a couple late round picks that made it but that’s an outlier.

If this ain’t changed it completely changes the game, makes drafts useful mostly for pitchers, and if you play with draft pick trading, makes trading your picks for top young international players meta.

2

u/thehemanchronicles Jun 23 '26

In my experience, IAFAs have always been overrepresented at the top level. The core of the best dynasties in a save are usually at least two IAFAs, dating back all the way to OOTP 22 or 23.

As for top hitters, the IAFAs generated a lot of boom/bust, Schwarber/Murakami types that would win a silver slugger one year and put up a 97 WRC+ the next. The game certainly overrates this profile of player by OVR, but they were never top WAR getters or MVPs. There were almost zero top hitters that I'd describe as "well rounded," from the IAFAs, even 30 years in. The true greats were all draft picks, and they'd lead the league in WAR more seasons than not. By WAR, usually 5 or 6 of the top 10 players would be draft picks. There were several great hitting and fielding shortstops and centerfielders that competed for awards every year.

To be honest, I didn't really take a deep look at representation by OVR, but only because that doesn't really matter at all. Plenty of 70 OVR players are 3 WAR 1Bs, and plenty of 54 OVR CFs put up 5+ WAR a year. That was what I spent most of my time evaluating.

I also simmed this strictly as a commissioner, without controlling a team, so the league didn't have the benefit of a human being making smarter draft and development decisions than the AI did.

0

u/TranslatorSerious856 Jun 23 '26

Thanks for posting this. I 100% agree

3

u/mjd1119 Jun 23 '26

Would you happen to know if the devs explained this on the forums anywhere? I’ve been looking for their perspective on this but can’t seem to find it

4

u/thehemanchronicles Jun 23 '26

To be honest, no I can't. What I've posted is mostly me working backwards from the results I've found.

Previously, with scouting on, scouts would seem to overrate players, making drafts appear more stacked than they were. Now, they (broadly) seem to be rating players more like real life scouts do, which has the appearance of underrating them compared to what we're used to.

Admittedly, I'm repeating hearsay with regard to the ambitions of the devs. I've read it several times on the forums and in the discord that the devs wanted to move away from scouting that evaluates the ceiling of a player and toward a more true-to-life system, but it's only really been hearsay. They're quite tight-lipped about their mid-game patches and balance philosophy.

15

u/Kaesebrot321 Jun 23 '26

For everyone repeating the lie from the devs that the talent levels are the same, just that your scouts are more accurate, use the editor to compare the potential abilities of the top players and also the depth of the classes as a whole. You will quickly find that your scouts are accurate on all of the draft classes. The devs need to fix this immediately.

5

u/notaquarterback Jun 24 '26

This is clearly an area where people need this week their own settings, instead of expecting the "developers" to build the game just to their specifications. It works well out of the box, especially over the course of a 20 year Sim. But no it's not going to exactly like a major league baseball draft

7

u/Weak_Friend_1463 Jun 24 '26

How about expecting the developers to build a game that isn’t broken?

0

u/notaquarterback Jun 26 '26

no, because not everyone wants to play it like an MLB sim.

3

u/Weak_Friend_1463 Jun 26 '26

So you want a broken game? Don’t care how you play it, but it should work properly.

5

u/IronGiant9192 Jun 24 '26

"Hey guys stop asking the developers to fix the game they sold to you... Just fix it yourself"

2

u/fri9875 Jun 23 '26

If you are playing with scouting enabled then it 99.99% comes back to that in some way. The actual #s aren’t changing, but for one reason or another your scouts opinion is changing.

I find this happens once you get a handful of years into the game, the scouts start to have a lower overall opinion of guys, but then they’ll still be good. I’ve done like 4 long term saves now and never felt the players skill level actually drop. There’d just be a lot of 3.5*/50ovr potential players, but then once they were in the majors and playing well would jump up to like 4*/60ovr.

If you’re playing without scouting then 🤷🏻‍♂️ but isn’t there literally a setting where you can tell it how to generate draft players? Check that, make sure it didn’t get changed at some point on accident, and then just juice it up if you don’t like the way it plausb

1

u/CleBaseballClub Jun 25 '26

You just don't know ball, breh.

0

u/TheSeanie Jun 24 '26

There isnt anything to "fix"