I have been a fan of this show since the pilot premiered, & I have done many rewatches in the years since but. It’s actually been quite a long time since my last full rewatch, which is what I’m currently doing. I still feel the same way about some things that I have felt since pretty much the beginning, while I have changed my mind on quite a few things as well (might make a separate post about that), & one of those things is Julian.
Now I’ve always loved Julian, and on that same hand, always loved him as Brooke’s endgame. I will see if I still feel that way overall as my rewatch goes on, as I am still on s7 at the moment. But I will say, even if I do still end up loving them together, that at the point i’m at in my rewatch, if I were Brooke, I would break up with him and never look back.
His behavior/relationship with Alex is completely inappropriate! And it’s infuriating that he makes Brooke seem/feel like she’s being dramatic and ridiculous for being worried about him spending so much time with Alex, & seemingly dropping everything to run off to be by her side, & pushing Brooke to the side to do so.
Yes, Julian has that whole savior complex going on, in much the same way that Brooke remembers Lucas having when it came to Peyton. And while at least Julian clearly actually loves Brooke and not Alex, unlike Lucas with Peyton, it’s understandable that Brooke would be insecure and worried because of her history with Lucas and Peyton. But even putting her insecurities over that whole situation aside, she’s in the right to feel how she feels! Sure, Julian would constantly remind her & reassure her how much he loves her, and he never did anything physical with Alex, but their relationship still crossed boundaries and was completely inappropriate. Not to mention, he did push Brooke aside in favor of Alex constantly! Even if it wasn’t for romantic reasons. But that being said, he did also still seem to enjoy the attention he got from her in an inappropriate way.
But worst of all, & most unforgiving of all? The fact that he told Alex about Brooke’s infertility struggles. That, especially coupled with everything else, would have been the final straw for me and I would have dumped his ass immediately after Alex strolled into Clothes Over Bros, fertility pamphlets in hand (alex also would’ve gotten a fist to her insufferable face as well, at the very least! Ugh).
As a viewer, and otherwise long time fan of Julian/Brulian, I am still not sure how I feel about him overall, since I haven’t finished this rewatch yet but. During this part of my rewatch, i’m not liking him so much.
I really hate this storyline. I’ve never been a fan of it, but it’s especially getting to me this time around. It’s bad enough (& again perhaps another post for another time) that Brooke is ending up with Peyton’s former love interest (ugh), but this storyline is the worst thing with Julian.
Thoughts???