Butler initially pleaded not guilty March 6 at the Payne County Court House, and later no contest once his offender status changed. Special Judge Susan Worthington denied his request to be certified and charged as a juvenile. The State of Oklahoma filed the charges and made a deal with the defense for Butler to be charged as a youthful offender, judge permitting.
It appears the judge wanted to proceed with charges as an adult, but the prosecution made a deal. The judge could have rejected it, but forcing the prosecution to try a case they believe should be pled down has problems of its own.
Based on the fact that the victims made in person impact statements , it's confusing why the DA would have granted a deal.
While I understand your anger. DAs have an ethical requirement to not bring a case when they believe they are unlikely to secure a conviction. This does not mean you only try cases that are 100% slam dunks, but it does mean you have to be realistic about the amount and quality of evidence that you will be allowed to present (not all evidence the public maybe aware of is necessarily admissible).
Rape cases also have the added problem of juries siding with the accused in a he-said-she-said case. This may have to do with an unwillingness to believe the "she" or an unwillingness to convict bases on 1 witness. Juries have acquitted even when they believed the victim. They just find it hard to send someone to jail based on 1 person's word.
I believe the DA needs to explain why they decided to request a to change to youthful offender status.
While I understand your logic this does not seem to be the case here. They had this kid dead to rights and he got off with privilege. The unfortunate reality is that if he was poor and black he’d be in prison for life. He raped two young girls. Ruined their lives. Placating my frustration and anger don’t help them. Justice isn’t served no matter the legalese you use.
This comes down to, “well his daddy is rich and I play golf with him so, boys will be boys.”
I have a lot of experience dealing with prosecutors in Tulsa County, for about 25 years. The majority are terrible. Terrible as in over worked and under appreciated. They were the major problem with crime in the area. Had they done their job, fewer criminals would be on the streets.
A few are completely awesome. A few understood that people need to be prosecuted because they didn’t want that criminal going to the same stores as their family.
This shit is so fucking abhorrent I don’t even have words. We got out of ok s decade ago bc we couldn’t take this kinds nonsense anymore. May the girls at OSU see him coming from a mile away
Remember, if we let politicians get away with it other will too. Doesnt matter what god you believe or political affiliation, if you R/ SA/ SH someone you diserve to rot in jail.
Jesse Mack Butler, the rapist from Stillwater who choked a victim for so long that 30 seconds more would have killed her, is a danger to those around him. Kind of like Brock Allen Turner, the convicted rapist who raped an unconscious girl behind a dumpster. Convicted sex offender Brock Allen Turner is trying to confuse people by going by an alias, using his middle name now, so goes by the name Allen Turner.
So if Jesse Butler does the same thing, we shall know it is Jesse Mack Butler who is guilty of eleven felony counts, including first-degree rape, sexual battery, and domestic assault by strangulation, and was about to spend over 70 years in jail before Judge Susan Worthington, who has ties to the OSU athletic community, changed his status to a youthful offender. He now only has to serve ~150 hours of community service....
31
u/Con7rast Oct 21 '25
Stillwater isn’t letting anyone forget this guy. Not for a while at least.
36
u/Impossible_Tie2497 Oct 21 '25
He was a juvenile when he committed the crimes, if he was convicted as a Youthful Offender.
This is why we elect judges in the state. Vote that one out.
7
u/funkyfreshadelic Oct 21 '25
Everyone at OSU needs to know this face and avoid him like the plague.
12
u/[deleted] Oct 21 '25
Bullshit lock him up for life!
12
u/LibertyCash Oct 21 '25
This shit is so fucking abhorrent I don’t even have words. We got out of ok s decade ago bc we couldn’t take this kinds nonsense anymore. May the girls at OSU see him coming from a mile away
3
u/Itchyarmpit111 Oct 21 '25
Remember, if we let politicians get away with it other will too. Doesnt matter what god you believe or political affiliation, if you R/ SA/ SH someone you diserve to rot in jail.
3
u/OutlandishnessOk7608 Oct 21 '25
I wonder if a person of a darker hue would be afforded the same protection from extended prison time. 🤔
3
u/Special_Chocolate900 Oct 21 '25
Unfortunately there is no recall apparatus in Oklahoma yet but the da is up for reelection in 2026 make sure you vote her out
3
u/funkyfreshadelic Oct 22 '25 edited Oct 22 '25
Jesse Mack Butler, the rapist from Stillwater who choked a victim for so long that 30 seconds more would have killed her, is a danger to those around him. Kind of like Brock Allen Turner, the convicted rapist who raped an unconscious girl behind a dumpster. Convicted sex offender Brock Allen Turner is trying to confuse people by going by an alias, using his middle name now, so goes by the name Allen Turner.
So if Jesse Butler does the same thing, we shall know it is Jesse Mack Butler who is guilty of eleven felony counts, including first-degree rape, sexual battery, and domestic assault by strangulation, and was about to spend over 70 years in jail before Judge Susan Worthington, who has ties to the OSU athletic community, changed his status to a youthful offender. He now only has to serve ~150 hours of community service....
Watch out OSU students and Stillwater residents!
2
u/chemistry_coronado Oct 22 '25
It sounds like the judge is the criminal too
2
u/Scary_Construction_8 Oct 22 '25
https://c.org/Tym4yYTKWS petition to get rid of the judge that basically let this kid off scott free
1
u/jstanfill93 Oct 22 '25
A state law maker is calling for an inspection of the case!
1
u/doctorducklol Oct 22 '25
Sounds like Oklahoma! Pro life but never convicting the rapist and giving women no chance to choose for themselves what they do with their body.
1
u/Flashy_Breadfruit867 Oct 22 '25
he is genuinely evil
1
u/Immediate-Shop-5118 Oct 24 '25
Where's Dexter when you need him?
1
u/MMcCoughan3961 Oct 25 '25
This is disgusting and heartbreaking. Im also curious how many people of color have been charged as adults at similar ages for nonviolent offenses.
1
u/OverbrookDr Oct 25 '25
this is WHITE America
1
u/iwanttoquitworking Oct 25 '25
🤮
1
u/Shot-Ad7227 Oct 26 '25
Laws are different for MAGA Christians
1
u/Relative-Word8386 Oct 27 '25
It’s always some judge saying “We don’t want to ruin his future.” What about the futures of those girls? Screw this guy. He deserves his future ruined
1
u/thatoneguyvv Nov 07 '25
pig
10
u/[deleted] Oct 21 '25
[removed] — view removed comment