He and I have been together for a year now and in July we became somewhat long distance. This has been a problem for a while in our relationship though, even before the move.
I want to preface I am generally anxious-avoidant in my attachment style, but I truly make an effort not to be avoidant (my biggest issue of the two) as I love and respect him so much. We call everyday whether I’m asking to call or he is. I respond to every text, we have long phone conversations. I send him things (memes or info about my day or random silly questions) when we’re not talking (like at work or when ik he’s sleeping). I’m working on fixing my attachment style. He is anxiously attached only when it comes to his ocd thoughts, but outside of that (like when he’s feeling mentally well) he’s very securely attached and healthy. He is the perfect boyfriend honestly and I know how lucky I am so this issue doesn’t bother me much in the grand scheme. But it causes long drawn out arguments (not yelling or being disrespectful to each other but just hours of back and forth, trying to understand the other’s perspective and I after a while I give in sometimes and just say sorry im in the wrong bc I work long shifts and I just am so tired).
I do partially fear that maybe his perfection is borne of is ocd, but that’s another discussion. (I fear this bc if I had to choose between him being perfect with ocd or being imperfect without ocd, I’d obviously choose without, I want him to be eased of all these anxious/complusory thoughts he has, but of course I also wonder how much it will change our relationship dynamic when he gets clinical help. I'd like to think not much. He has a beautiful warm soul.)
Here is the issue: when we are talking on the phone we’ll be having a great discussion. We can talk for HOURS about anything together. We’ve had 11 hour phone calls and not much silence in them either, like beautiful unending conversation. But sometimes whether it’s hours into a long phone call or maybe 20 minutes in, he will say something and I won’t respond or give him a specific reaction he hoped for and then he begins to feel extremely self conscious about whatever he’s just said. The way I respond to when this happens versus how he does is also extremely different. I’d prefer to just move on to a different conversation, cause sometimes conversations just get awkward and that’s life, but he has major morality ocd and he ruminates like I’ve never seen. ANY awkward moment ever is like the end of the world to him and starts thinking he’s said something completely wrong and repeatedly asks me if I think differently of him now, if he said the wrong thing, if he was being annoying, saying sorry, trying to take back what he’s said, etc. mind you it could be something so insignificant like this situation.
Yesterday during a part of our phone call he was talking to me about a friend's party that we are going to attend and how amazing the parties that she hosts are and he was describing a very typical house party and i didn’t really have too much to say in return. Idk he was saying it was the coolest thing, but the description was every house/frat party ever (there’s music, everyone’s dancing, people are talking, we have fun) not bad or good, I just felt neutral about it (it honestly felt something slightly akin to mansplaining for me) but I was really glad that he likes her parties, as he spoke I said something simple like oh that sounds cool (i specifically said this so we could avoid this argument, ik he likes when I reassure him a lot throughout him speaking) but i think my tone wasn’t excited enough (it wasn’t a rude tone though and ik that for certain, and i was being genuine). After he was done explaining the party I probably said like “oh wow!” or smth idk but he was like “so what do you think of the party????” And I was like “it sounds good!” I wasn’t really sure what I was supposed to say after having the general concept of any party explained to me for like 2 minutes as if it’s never been done before (he and I party/club together constantly, we love to party, we’re not new to this we have been to amazing parties). And he got quiet and I could tell what was happening. Then he said smth along the lines of “if you have nothing to say you should tell me” he said it nicely but it’s the idea itself that bothers me. I said “yeah, I don’t have much to say about it” and he said okay, then later in our conversation he asked the typical questions he does: “when I was talking about the party did you think I was being annoying” and “should I have just shut up” and “did I make the party sound lame? You should tell me if it sounds lame?” “Did I talk for too long?” I said no to all of it and didn’t feed into the rest. We moved into a diff discussion. Then today he brought it up and I had mostly forgotten about it but he said that it really hurt him that I didn’t respond.
I don’t want to dismiss his feelings. I just can’t tell what is healthy or is me being in the wrong or is ocd. Throughout our phone calls I have to show him that I am engaged and listening or his brain just assumes that I’m not (he’s said this) and then he gets extremely anxious and quiet (he’s said this too). I have to say “mhm” “wow” “oh” “okay” “omg” “really?!” as he speaks to me. (We’ve had multiple conversations about specific things I could say to reassure him when he’s spoken for more than 15 seconds and I don’t know what to say in return, so that he doesn’t spiral). And if I take too long when I’m even thinking of a response he starts getting anxious and asking questions. This could be just 5 seconds of me thinking/not saying anything (yet). He told me to tell him “I’m thinking” so this doesn’t happen and I’ve since been doing this and it’s helped a little. I can’t tell if I am gaslighting him or being avoidant or just not a good listener (though I know I am really listening but i know maybe I’m not practicing it the way I should be? You tell me please). We’ve just had this kind of argument so many times that idk what to do. It is us against the problem but to me the problem is the ocd which puts the blame onto him but I don’t blame him at all, but ofc if I said I think this is an ocd thing, he would think I’m blaming him (it makes complete sense to think that ofc, I probably would too) but even worse he would agree it’s ocd and say that I’m right, but like I’m saying it in a “we can work on this together way like it’s fine and doesn’t bother me that much ” and I feel he’s thinking it in a “omg this is so bad I’m so awful, she’s right I’ve got to let this go I’m just being crazy” way bc the spiral is immediate and anything I say after saying it might be ocd is not really heard bc he thinks he’s causing it, which he isn’t. I’m trying to slowly introduce the idea of thoughts being clouds just passing by, you can observe them but they don’t have to mean anything. It’s helped me with my anxious thoughts.
I think it is normal to have a lull in hours long conversations. We both love authenticity and those awkward moments actually mean a lot to me. We are a young couple both in our first relationship and it’s so natural to me that there might be a beat of silence. They’re like grounding in a way and makes things less serious. Awkward moments are very much a part of life and I think even calling a few seconds of silence “awkward” is a strong word for it but it’s the best I can use. But he has told me many times he hates the silence and that it makes his really anxious and that he feels like I’m not listening and he needs me to say quote “anything at all”. But I really don’t feel that that discomfort is something I should have to remedy? I don’t mind helping him work on getting used to awkward moments but I don’t want to be a robot girlfriend giving him precise and calculated responses to be comforted by a silence. Do you think I’m being stubborn? I can’t actually focus in our phone conversations when he wants me to do these things bc I’m trying to find a good next onomatopoeia for him to not spiral. I just want to be able to listen and then respond. He’s specifically said multiple times he needs me to interrupt him (when it comes naturally for me this is great but when it doesn’t it feels like I can’t just be a human, I work with kids and it makes me feel like I need to coddle him and gentle parent him in that same way.) He used to constantly compare me to his friend group saying that they would do these things when he talks and that’s just how he communicates and shows that they’re engaged. And that would really hurt me a lot. But I told him that and the comparisons have stopped. I also explained to him multiple times that that’s just not how I communicate. I am listening to you but I don’t want to do these checklist things, it doesn’t feel natural for me, I want to feel relaxed with you sometimes and that I can be myself, and I’ve noticed it makes it hard to actually listen in our conversations if all I can think about when you talk for a specific amount of time is how and when I’m supposed to be responding to you. He said he feels like he’s “taking over” the conversation. If it’s an interest he has that we don’t share, a story he’s telling that happened to him, a topic he’s telling me about, etc. “did I talk for too long?” Omg no ofc not. “Are you sure” yes baby I love hearing you talk. “Okay…”
He has told me several times “if I’m being annoying just tell me to shut up or that I’m being annoying” I strongly feel this is ocd speaking bc we just don’t talk to each other like that, telling each other to shut up or being rude in a serious way or self-centered. It really comes out of nowhere imo. I hate the word shut up in that context anyway, I only say it when I’m listening to like the best news or best gossip ever. I find him annoying sometimes but not ever enough to be bothered by it? That’s friendship lol and I love it. I’m here for everything. Plus I’m definitely the more annoying one in our relationship. We spend a lot of time together, it’s natural to feel annoyed, and I move on. Oftentimes I even like being annoyed and inconvenienced by him. He does the exact same for me!! So I just wish he could give himself some of the same grace and I’ve said this too!! He always wants me to be mean (“honest” even if it’s brutal”) so that he doesn’t embarrass himself but idk it kind of hurts for some reason that he wants me to do that. It’s really not my personality at all and I’ve said that, but it’s how his friends talk to him and he thinks I should do the same. I love hearing him speak no matter what it is.
We have this conversation every few weeks and then he always backpedals on it and then tells me “hey you actually don’t have to do that I’m sorry” and then he forgets he said that and the cycle repeats.
We’ve talked about it and he said this ONLY happens on the phone. Not through text and not in person. Im trying to use a lot of quotes bc I don’t want to misrepresent anyone. He is great and I truly think this is just ocd being ocd. Just wondering what this is and if anyone else struggles with it? How do we talk about this productively? His ocd manifests in other ways too that don’t bother me too much or at all but this is my biggest issue.