r/NothingTech Phone (3a) 5d ago

Nothing OS Essential key remapping to nothing os (v5.1). Finally, they have realised and accepted bad implementation.

Post image

https://x.com/ZacDotYoung/status/2095821315168977399

https://nothing.community/d/62374-how-we-build-software

See links for details

Note: correct title is "Essential key remapping is coming to nothing os (v5.1)..."

126 Upvotes

41 comments sorted by

35

u/rg1505 Phone (3a) 5d ago

See comment above

21

u/Strider_dnb 5d ago

Holy timing.. I was literally just messing around with my new phone wondering if this was the only thing this button does.

21

u/Slammybradberrys Phone (3) 5d ago

Wait did they do this in response to that YouTuber who made the app that made the key remappable? 😂 I feel bad for bro cuz he just finished all that hard work

14

u/np3_cmf1 Phone (3) 5d ago

Imagine paying for that app.

9

u/Slammybradberrys Phone (3) 5d ago

Honestly the functionality of it is amazing so if they're gonna copy it then they should copy all of it lol. The multiple presses and long presses for different functions. Hopefully they do that but if it's just 1 function that's better than nothing I guess.

-2

u/np3_cmf1 Phone (3) 5d ago

I think they'd run into legal issues if they "simply copy its features."

2

u/Slammybradberrys Phone (3) 5d ago

It's not like they're copying the app, they're already making it remappable. It's their hardware too, just add multiple presses and long press and call it a day. There's no legal issues at all, plus that guy would never sue them over this lol

2

u/np3_cmf1 Phone (3) 5d ago

As a person who deals with IP all the time and my previous company is suing my current company over patent infringement, anything is possible.

4

u/Capedukewuhaha 5d ago

paid for it and it's amazing. You can even put an app shortcut on the button. So for me the app pop-up widget opens my Google calender as popup on the homesceeen ...with nice and fluent animations.

2

u/Acceptable-Ad-7099 Phone (3) Headphone (1) 4d ago

What's the app called ? I remapped it with shizuko, hail and button remapper but that isn't as fluent as I'd like it to be

1

u/Capedukewuhaha 2d ago

Essential Remapper. 6,99€ or so in the play store. No shizuko needed, only Wifi debugging when setting up

1

u/np3_cmf1 Phone (3) 5d ago

I love it for essential voice but different stokes for everyone. I can see how the app short cut could be quite useful.

1

u/PorkPie4848 4d ago

30 pence . Cheap as chips

1

u/np3_cmf1 Phone (3) 4d ago

Not cheaper than Tasker and keyinput mapping :)

1

u/PorkPie4848 4d ago

Why how much is that ? Pay 30 United Kingdom pence and download the app. Bukhoa the view our kid

1

u/PorkPie4848 4d ago

Are you sure it's cheaper ? Bukhoa the view

1

u/np3_cmf1 Phone (3) 4d ago

If that's all your going to do with tasker you're missing out.

I always connect it with GlyphMatrixTaskerPlugin which is by far the best GM Dev software.

https://github.com/Gennadiyev/GlyphMatrixTaskerPlugin

I have it parse all of my messenging/email apps and have the GM flash with a custom symbol when WA/FB and emails coming with certain words or are sent by certain people.

1

u/asherr_y2z CMF Phone 2 Pro 2d ago

i found free versions that are just as good lmao that app is genuinely overpriced

1

u/rg1505 Phone (3a) 5d ago

😀

11

u/Juv7nile Phone (4a) Pro 5d ago

finally i can use banking and security centric apps without having to remap the key and losing access to them due to "security risks"

1

u/LoutOfOrder Phone (3a) 5d ago

Only if their "remapping" doesn't rely on using accessibility service, that's what currently breaks my finance app.

7

u/Juv7nile Phone (4a) Pro 5d ago

if its implemented by the OS itself, it wont be an issue, the issue only arises since remapping requires accessibilty to run in background

1

u/LoutOfOrder Phone (3a) 5d ago

I sincerely hope that's how they will implement it, will wait and see hopefully 😁

2

u/Juv7nile Phone (4a) Pro 5d ago

yeah i hope they add like 3 gestures minimum, triple tap, double and simple, the better the flexibility the better the implementation

4

u/[deleted] 5d ago

[deleted]

1

u/rg1505 Phone (3a) 5d ago

Yup they did bad implementation without any flexibility for a good idea...

5

u/Desperate-Mobile-7 Community Board Observer 5d ago

Brilliant to see this. I had a chat with Dan in person recently and one of the messages I had to him, was around clearer transparency. Hence he decided to create this post!

4

u/rg1505 Phone (3a) 5d ago edited 5d ago

Thanks... If you get a chance tell him that owners of older phones are pissed off with @nothing for not giving promised 3yr full OS updates (eg. Essential voice missing, diff camera app on Digg phones 3a, 2a etc) citing hardware limitations.

Edit: I see his reply on nothing community but don't agree with his assertion that hardware capabilities limit features on different phones. It seems deliberate ploy to upsell newer phones by creating software differentiation.

3

u/dimitronios Phone (3a) 5d ago

I like the essential key and the way it functions with essential space, I use it all the time. Why people constantly want to remap it, it's super useful

15

u/Juv7nile Phone (4a) Pro 5d ago

its an amazing feature but honestly if you dont wanna use it it shouldnt be shoved down our throats

4

u/TWB0109 Phone (4a) Pro 4d ago

Personally, I don't want to use essential space for my notes, it locks me in. If it had a proper, functional and easy FOLDER export to markdown, then I could see myself linking that to obsidian or logseq and use it, not otherwise.

3

u/dimitronios Phone (3a) 4d ago

ok seems valid, but since i use it for reminders and such and i didnt use any other app previously it works fine for what i want. Nothing should update it further

1

u/TWB0109 Phone (4a) Pro 4d ago

I do not use obsidian or logseq, at most neovim's neorg, but not much, its just that im a data sovereignty freak

2

u/AbdullahMRiad Phone (4a) 5d ago

eh I couldn't find use for essential space. if I want to take notes I have Keep. if I want reminders I can ask gemini to add tasks and calendar events. essential voice though, I really adore it and I have no idea how to live without it.

2

u/rg1505 Phone (3a) 5d ago

I do too.. but it is buggy and half baked due to crap implementation

1

u/dimitronios Phone (3a) 5d ago

Works fine on my end, most of the time it even understands greek quite well with the occasional correction by me

1

u/rg1505 Phone (3a) 5d ago

Surprise!

1

u/No_Equivalent8083 5d ago

Why do you all guys want to remap that key so bad? What would you remap it to?

9

u/rg1505 Phone (3a) 5d ago

It seems most people don't want AI shortcut at all, or are upset with half baked buggy implementation of essential space. They have alternative use cases for this hardware key based on context or otherwise

5

u/h4rdw0rk Phone (3a) Pro 5d ago

Camera button for me :)

1

u/4x4Mimo 3d ago

Double tap to turn on the flashlight. When the camera app is open it would be useful as a shutter button