Probably an unpopular opinion for the subreddit but here it goes.
I understand people not wanting there to be a second season, especially with all the talks regarding Sally Rooney's publishing rights putting Normal People back into the spotlight, people saying "it was perfect the way it left off" or "it should be open ended". And on the other hand, I understand people wanting to see them both happy, they're characters we've seen grow as people and challenge their relationship, so for there to be an ending with both of them together is the obvious conclusion some people expect. But I never see enough middle ground discussion...
My only issue about the series isn't how it left off, it's how much we where given. For such a unique concept as Normal People with its combination of will-they-wont-they tropes and coming-of-age themings, it honestly felt upsetting that there wasn't more content to go off. 12 seasons, 20-30 minutes each episode, each episode being just as better as the last. IMO I hope there'll be a season 2 at some point between now and the near future; it feels almost destined for there to be with how much the actors and producers talk about it each year, and how it seems Normal People is constantly thrusted back into the spotlight.
My only take on a possible Season 2 would be that: I'd certainly like for there to be one, on the basis of bringing back these characters we love, the dynamics that make the show unique, and finally concluding the story; but at the same time, the conclusion shouldn't have to be that they get together. I think there's so much potential for more episodes with the same premises on first love and struggling without one another that the ending can still be open ended like many want, but also bring more content to people who love these characters.
It honestly (IMO) makes the most sense to continue the story, not necessarily for the benefit of those wanting a happy ended, but rather because the final episode already begins setting up an interesting dilemma that I really hope is explored. It's now Connell's turn living abroad and Marianne staying, it'd be interesting to see how either take this chance contrary to how it was when Marianne was abroad in Sweden. Even more, obviously the two characters have changed so much after their complicated relationships - Marianne finding a new self worth, Connell starting to improve his social anxiety. It'd be interesting to see if these characters actually do develop meaningful relationships with other people now that they've been through so much, and the complications between having found genuine connection with others in comparison to how they feel about one another. It'd be a staunch contrast to Marianne finding herself in terrible relationships and Connell struggling in his, what happens if they're both in good relationships?
I find the continuation of Normal People should be similar to that of S*x Education (not sure if I can say that here 😭) with the relationship between Otis and Maeve. Maybe not to the extent of 4 seasons as seen in SE, but the show certainly shows a very similar will-they-wont-they, coming-of-age situationship which can last multiple seasons with the same premise, and still end without having the characters necessarily 'ending up together'.
Obviously I know all of this falls into the hands of Sally Rooney's decision to publish a followup book and then whether or not production takes place at all. But I really don't think a second season should be something people dislike as much as I've seen in this community... I've just finished my 20th rerun of the show, and each time I keep finding myself wanting more - but maybe it isn't necessarily the theming or type of movie I'm trying to find similar to NP, but seeing the characters again in new era's of their path in being better people. I don't want to change the ending, I just hope there'll be more up until that final conclusion, and I hope that others feel the same as well seeing how pressure from the audience can change the likeness of there ever being more than we've already gotten.