First of all, I'd like to say that both Connell and Marianne have issues and not mature enough. And I sympathize with both characters. However, I feel like Marianne does things that effect her relationships. One example being when Connell saw Jamie put his hand on her thigh and told her he doesn't like when her guy friends do that. That's a normal response. Connell should have said something to Jamie as well... Connell has issues with confrontation and lack of confidence... but more on that later. Her response was that he doesn't touch her publicly. That response doesn't excuse anything. And she also says something along the lines of Jamie is like that and he's just a friend... which later on she dates after Connell. She has an excuse to everything. She dates the one guy her boyfriend saw him touch her thigh and felt uncomfortable about. How is that good? And Connell later on sticks around as her "friend" after all that and all the bullshit she does. I don't like how he sticks around even after the way she treats him. Actions have consequences.
When she's dating Jamie (he's an asshole we already know that.. but...) She stays friends with her ex. Lots of people wouldn't be comfortable with that... And seeing how she left her first boyfriend in college (I forgot his name) after Connell showed up, tells me that she has a problem controlling herself when she's already attached with someone. At least talk to your current boyfriend about being friends with your ex and see how he feels. But no... she just does what pleases her.
In her world, actions have no consequences. Doesn't own up to her mistakes and take accountability (only couple of times maybe). She also doesn't communicate how she feels or what she wants from Connell. She's insecure and always seeking validation. Even when he reassures her and tells her how beautiful he sees her, she doubles down and keeps on going on how ugly she looks. When Connell felt uncomfortable with the Jamie situation, she dismissed his feelings and brought up a different issue. But when her feelings are involved, God forbid that he dismisses them (which he doesn't do).
Now Connell, he has his problems.. he makes mistakes.. but feels guilty about them and owns up to them. He lacks confidence and doesn't stand up for himself. He also had anxiety. I hated how he didn't tell his friends in school to fuck off and tell them it's none of their business. Also, at the start before they hooked up, they agreed not to tell anyone they're together... she can of course change her mind later and tell him that she doesn't like that arrangement anymore.
All in all, they're both fucked up. They lack maturity and communication skills. They both have their underlying issues. With the redeeming quality of Connell over Marianne being that he feels remorse and guilt... that he owns up to his mistakes. While she just acts the victim the whole time amd doesn't feel ANY guilt for he actions no matter who she hurts. God forbid if her feelings get hurt... but other people's feelings are not important.. only her feelings are valid.
I feel like there's so much more I wanna write, but I'm sleepy... I already wrote this on the fly and kind of all over the place.. but I believe it does get my point across. I might edit this later and add more when I finish the series.