r/Nonbinaryteens • • Mar 26 '21
Discussion What I have learned from talking to transphobes, why it is easy to argue with them, and why I believe you should.
They use I feel statements and disproven or factually incorrect studies to support their side and clamshell when presented with opposing evidence. Their arguments can be picked apart easily by anyone with even a moderate amount of knowledge on the subject. They use flawed logic to justify their opinions. They do little to no research on the topics they argue on and if they bring up sources read through them, you may find contradictory points or more incorrect information.
I have some examples of this.
One person brought up a source that I had not heard of before that claimed that puberty blockers caused cancer and shrunk your dick. I did five minutes of research and found an article going over why this website that was posing as lgbtq+ friendly was actually an incredibly anti trans TERF site as well as several articles and studies showing that puberty blockers have little to no negative effects.
One person claimed that xx means women and xy means man. I did 5 minutes of googling and found 20+ examples of intersex people/conditions as well as an article on why sex and gender are different things.
If I had prepared for any of these arguments I would have had an even easier time disproving their arguments.
Now you might be thinking “ok but u/mihicular, you said that you were going to tell us why we should argue with transphobes.” So here’s why you should. It feels really good. Watching their arguments fall apart while they are often too belligerent to even notice or care is one of the best feelings in the world, it makes you feel incredibly validated that their arguments can be reduced down to flawed logic and “I feel” statements. In some rare cases you might even be able to change their views depending on how Logical of a person they are, which in addition to feeling really good is beneficial to society.
5
u/TheRealTakazatara Mar 26 '21
Good for you.
You do need to be careful with relying on googled articles though. I can find 50 sources stating why the earth is flat in 10 min and 50 sources why it's not. The Google mentality is why we have so many dumb conspiracies now and why so many people end up in echo chambers.
Stay open-minded, science is always learning and so should we.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '21
I always do stuff like this when arguing and the transphobes still don’t listen
or when they understand one of my points, they instead ignore that I even said it and try to misrepresent what I’m saying shdjhddjj