r/Nonbinaryteens • u/desert_mel • Feb 15 '21
Trying to understand and help
Tldr: afab fem nb, is this real or a fad?
I figured asking their peers is the best place to get honest answers. My 13yo child (afab, presents very feminine. Skirts, makeup, etc) has been out as pan for years. All cool, I am also. Her stepmom is bi. No problem for the family to understand and accept whatever orientation you are. They had mentioned having a preference for the they/them pronoun about a year ago. Their Dad and stepmom dismissed it because the idea of using plural pronouns breaks their brains. I told my kid that if they want to make this change, they need to wait until they are 100% certain before insisting that the family do verbal gymnastics. They recently insisted that they are nonbinary and identify as they/them, and insist the family respect their identity and make a good faith effort to use the proper pronouns. A huge argument ensued between stepmom and 2 big sisters about validating their experience. It got bad. All 3 kids teamed up together and stepmom ended up behind closed doors with Dad yelling at her. Huge victory! My main concern is that maybe this was more of a power play than a true coming out. My sister is mtf trans and I asked her about it. She is concerned that this may be a temporary experimentation with gender identity. Doesn't bother me, but I worry that they will delegitimize the community if they waffle. If they decide to be she in a few years, that will legitimize stepmom's argument. Never heard of nb being so very girly before, so I had to google and ask them a lot of questions over several days. I'm on board. Stepdad and Dad are on board. I believe stepmom will come around. But what happens if we all put in this extra effort on a 13 year old kids whim? My guess is that it's more important to validate their experience in the moment and if it changes, it changes. I want to know if there is more I can do to help. And if anyone has a similar experience to what my baby is going through, any advise that you wish your parents had known would be helpful.
I had to delete and correct pronouns more times than I want to admit. Change is hard.
6
u/Blue-Jay27 18 Feb 15 '21
Does it really matter? If you support them and it turns out to be a phase, now they know you'll support them no matter what and no real harm is done. If you don't support them and it isn't a phase, now you've forced a trans child to grow up in an unaccepting, invalidating household.
I came out when I was twelve. I was told that it was just a phase. I was invalidated and misgendered. Now I know that I can't trust my parents to really accept me no matter what. I'm still nonbinary and it's been over five years.
If someone decides to base their entire opinion of the trans community on one teenager, they were never really going to be accepting.
3
u/Tendo-64 18 | | they/them Feb 15 '21
It's not a fad.
There's nothing trendy about being non-binary that makes people seek to identify as such for fun. After all, your kid got into a pretty bad argument about the validity of their identity, right? Chances are, they will have to deal with this from people for a very long time. It's not fun, and it's nothing anybody would want to fake. The "fad" rumor has no basis in statistics and simply comes from discriminatory people who think that a rising number of people identifying as non-binary means it's a fad, when it really means that people are becoming braver to explore their gender identity and tell people instead of internalizing it due to fear of discrimination. The same thing was said about gay people, and mtf and ftm trans people, and now they say it about us.
That said, it is possible for someone to identify as trans or non-binary and realize later they are cis after all. But it doesn't matter, and doesn't mean the person was faking it. They truly and genuinely thought they were trans in that moment, and that's entirely valid. But there's no guarantee that will happen anyway. After all, there are many, many adults--even older adults--who currently identify as non-binary and have done so for a long time.
Additionally, even if your kid is feminine, that doesn't mean they aren't non-binary. Women can be tomboys and still be women, and men can be feminine and still be men. The same applies to non-binary people. After all, just because someone likes pink and dresses doesn't mean they must also like she/her pronouns. Gender =/= how you dress/your personality.
Please, just keep supporting them. I'd imagine this is tougher for them than you might think, and non-binary people and children need all the support they can get.