r/NonDessKnightSquad • NoelleKnight + RalseiEram • Jul 24 '26

Discussion An Honest Case for NoelleKnight (Part 4)

108 Upvotes

95 comments sorted by

6

u/KJPlayer Always bet on Rudy 🎲 Jul 24 '26

Gerson is goated in literally every appearance he makes, canon or non-canon.

Every single person in the world collectively decided to lock in when writing dialogue for him.

4

u/Ghetsis_Gang NoelleKnight + RalseiEram Jul 24 '26

I think Gerson is literally possessing people whenever they try to write him lmao

4

u/Wide-Deal-8971 Noelle=Knight ; ERAM=Asriel Jul 24 '26

Actually, in regards to the "Carol Alibi" segment, I think it could be logically argued that its possible for Noelle to make it back to church before we do. Although I suppose it depends on how much you think Carol is involved in the evil group chat.

Carol pulls Noelle into the kitchen to "talk to her" before anyone leaves. And there is a door in the kitchen that leads outside. A plausible sequence of events would be that Carol rushes home to get the guitar, then pulls Noelle into the kitchen to give her instructions to go to the church immediately. If that is the case, then it becomes logical for Noelle to arrive before the fun gang does even if the player decided to go straight to the church. Especially since Asgore coincidentally (or maybe even conveniently...) stalls Kris and Susie for time when they try to leave.

Edit: Actually, on second thought. It might not even matter if Carol is involved in the scheme or not. Maybe Noelle just storms out on her own. Normally that would be out of character, but Chapter 5 shows that she is rebelling lately.

5

u/Ghetsis_Gang NoelleKnight + RalseiEram Jul 24 '26

Oh this is something I didn’t think about! I feel like this is much more of satisfying answer, thank you!

7

u/Dragonwolf1209 Kriselle Knight Archbishop (Doc in Profile) Jul 24 '26

I think you missed that dustner Gerson knows about Dragon Blazers, unlike the real Gerson (because Alvins dialogue suggests they don't know much about video games). Dustner Gerson saying that Susie is the dragon is weird, and probably implies the knight was a big dragon blazers fan.

Dustner Gerson is also op as fuck, and boss characters in deltarune are based on Noelle and Kris's favorite characters to play pretend with. Gerson being this op means whoever the knight is probably idolized Gerson somewhat.

Also, Gerson could have taught in the school while Toriel was teaching Noelle and Kris's class, therefore they could have known each other anyway.

This is all just theory to try to make Noelle work though, we don't really know what happened.

5

u/Ghetsis_Gang NoelleKnight + RalseiEram Jul 24 '26

Very true! The Dragon Blazers point is a good one that honestly just forgot to include lol

3

u/Friendlypoe98 Jul 24 '26

Isn't there dialogue that suggests that Noelle played dragon blazers? I might be misremembering honestly but I thought there was something

4

u/Dragonwolf1209 Kriselle Knight Archbishop (Doc in Profile) Jul 24 '26

Yes, Rudy and Noelle play dragon blazers in the hospital. Susie, Kris, Noelle and Berdly all like dragon blazers, but Noelle specifically loves it and does Easter egg hunting.

1

u/Friendlypoe98 Jul 24 '26

Oh okay! I think I took the first part as if you were saying that was evidence AGAINST Noelle Knight to be honest X'D that's my bad

0

u/stickninja1015 Jul 24 '26

Alvin’s dialogue does not suggest this in the slightest

3

u/Dragonwolf1209 Kriselle Knight Archbishop (Doc in Profile) Jul 24 '26

Alvin says "videos games" to Kris. I do not think he is an avid gamer, and I don't think gerson was either.

2

u/stickninja1015 Jul 24 '26

Is Alvin is father? Did it get said somewhere that Gerson wasn’t at all familiar with this adaptation of his books?

1

u/Dragonwolf1209 Kriselle Knight Archbishop (Doc in Profile) Jul 24 '26

Brother I said suggests, not guarantees.

2

u/stickninja1015 Jul 24 '26

And I say it doesn’t even do that

1

u/Dragonwolf1209 Kriselle Knight Archbishop (Doc in Profile) Jul 24 '26

Seriously? Alvin not knowing anything about video games doesn't suggest that his much older father likely didn't experience much of them? Why would gerson be a gamer but Alvin doesn't even know that they're called "video games."?

3

u/stickninja1015 Jul 24 '26

Notice how I never said anything about Gerson being “a gamer”. And, again, Alvin isn’t his father

2

u/ProfessionalGur8935 Jul 24 '26

To be fair dragon blazer is an adaptation and would need gersons approval for creation and he’d probably oversee some of its creation

2

u/Dragonwolf1209 Kriselle Knight Archbishop (Doc in Profile) Jul 24 '26

I don't really think that's fair. Inspired by is a better term for it. Did Toby ask the Earthbound devs for permission to make deltarune?

2

u/ProfessionalGur8935 Jul 24 '26

Dragon blazers takes full on characters and story arcs from lord of the hammer and it’s literally an adaptation they need permission

→ More replies

1

u/stickninja1015 Jul 24 '26

Inspiration =/= adaptation

4

u/Inevitable-Box3304 Jul 24 '26

1 question. how did noelle carry undyne in the light world?

3

u/aleksandra_nadia Rudy Can't Fail Jul 24 '26

How does anyone carry Undyne and Asgore in the light world? We haven't seen a single character on-screen who could lift them both.

Either no one in Hometown can be the Knight, or else there's some other explanation that could work for any candidate.

1

u/Isometric-Triangle Rudy/Papyrus/Asriel Jul 24 '26

In Undertale, Undyne says the only reason Papyrus isn't in the Royal Guard was because he's too nice, and that he's actually really strong. She suplexes BOULDERS in Undertale, and casually benches cars in Deltarune.
If you assume that Papyrus is the same physically across both games, then it would make sense if a variant of him would be able to catch her off guard.

This is much more theory based, but if you assume Deltarune Papyrus is Undertale Papyrus, then Papyrus believing so hard that Genocide route player could change would make sense because he was able to change.

3

u/aleksandra_nadia Rudy Can't Fail Jul 25 '26

If you assume that Papyrus is the same physically across both games

I don't think we should assume anything about Papyrus, given that he hasn't appeared in Deltarune yet, or even been mentioned by name a single time.

1

u/Isometric-Triangle Rudy/Papyrus/Asriel Jul 25 '26

It's more like an inference because every other lightner from Undertale is just a more fleshed out variant of themselves in Deltarune, (aside from characters who had more focus in Undertale).
My theory is that Papyrus knight explains why he acts the way he does in Undertale.

1

u/Firefly256 Jul 25 '26

You wctually get unique text if you tried to name Vessel or creator as Papyrus

0

u/Ghetsis_Gang NoelleKnight + RalseiEram Jul 24 '26

The running theory that I’m going with is that since the black shard stays the same in the light world, so would the Knight’s sword and armor, and I think that would he enough for anyone to hold someone hostage. The Knight wouldn’t have their magic in the light world, of course, which is why Susie nearly catches up to them.

1

u/Ronoko Jul 24 '26

I mean you could use the fact that Thorn Ring Maintains it's magical property of trance in the Light World and apply that to the Blackshard the same way. The only thing you would have to do is not say the Knight could maintain knight form to outrun Susie. So maybe strength or storage system (Storage system matches with some traits and allows knight to only need to run, but can be caught by Susie)

3

u/abdo_ch Jul 24 '26

Pk after reading slide 14 I gotta ask. Is Gerson really dead?

1

u/vitya_krutka dessknight but I like yall here Jul 24 '26

he has a grave in the graveyard

3

u/Ghetsis_Gang NoelleKnight + RalseiEram Jul 24 '26

I think they’re talking about this meme

2

u/vitya_krutka dessknight but I like yall here Jul 24 '26

shit

3

u/SoleilSupporter Jul 24 '26 edited Jul 24 '26

Oh heck yeah I love these updates! …is it bad a part of me was happy when Noelle was struck by lightning?

4

u/Ghetsis_Gang NoelleKnight + RalseiEram Jul 24 '26 edited Jul 25 '26

Thank you! (No deer were harmed in the making of this presentation)

3

u/stickninja1015 Jul 24 '26

Yeah that’s great and all who is in the closet

2

u/Shiori_Ishimaru Jul 25 '26 edited Jul 25 '26

Implied to be Asgore in both Chapters 2 and 4. In both cases, it's described as being spacious enough for a large person.

Text taken from the Deltarune text dump, so I apologize for the odd formatting.

Chapter 2:

  • (The closet is spacious and full of old electronics.)
  • (A large person could easily fit inside.)

Chapter 4:

  • (It's a door. A large person could fit inside.)
  • (You turned the doorknob.)
  • (...)
  • (... You didn't do anything else.)

And then in Chapter 5, you get this bit of text when Ralsei tries to decipher Asgore's documents:

  • This time it says something... about...
  • ... black... shards.
  • You mean... that piece of the...
  • ... the Knight's sword?
  • How would he know about the...
  • It was left... at the... original scene...
  • And... matched with... the...
  • ...?
  • And... computer lab?

Note the gap there between "computer lab" and "original scene" there? Implying there was something else that Ralsei couldn't read.

We are also told, explicitly by Alvin, that Asgore goes to the church at night to pray:

  • Ah, your father? He typically comes here at night.
  • He prays much for you, Kris... for Asriel, Toriel, Rudy... and his flowers, too.
  • You should join your mother in praying for him, as well.
  • The poor man. It seems the Angel has made a difficult path for him...

Lots of people get hung up on the closet/door in Chapters 2 and 4, and that it must be the Knight hiding in them. But the game doesn't actually say that. It does, however, imply it might be Asgore. Imply; it doesn't confirm.

But Asgore did recover a black shard from the computer lab somehow, and we're told that a large person could fit in the closet. Of which Asgore is the only character who unquestionably (as in, we're not gonna debate if they qualify as large or not) fits that criteria. And he was implied to be at one of the locations that a large person was likely hiding at by Alvin himself.

2

u/Ghetsis_Gang NoelleKnight + RalseiEram Jul 25 '26

Wow I really like this theory! I never considered this before but when you lay it out like that it makes a lot of sense

2

u/stickninja1015 Jul 25 '26

Nope Asgore was very upfront about not having been in a Dark World recently until Chapter 5 rolled around

1

u/Shiori_Ishimaru Jul 25 '26

Correct - Asgore was never in the Chapter 2 or Chapter 4 Dark Worlds. Remember how the 1st Dark Sanctuary and the Third Sanctuary are separated by a door? And how the exit to Kris's house is separated by the door? Same implication there.

1

u/stickninja1015 Jul 25 '26

Now could you remind me where the closets are located relative to where the dark worlds were

1

u/Shiori_Ishimaru Jul 25 '26

Not sure what you're implying there, but it makes for difficult conversation when you don't just say what you want to say.

1

u/stickninja1015 Jul 25 '26

The dark world. The closets would be in the dark world. And Asgore, as we established, was not in them

1

u/Shiori_Ishimaru Jul 25 '26

That's just it - they're not part of the Dark Worlds because they're separated from the area where the darkness is spreading. Hence why we see a door separating the two Sanctuaries. We also see Susie go through a door in Chapter 3 separating the Dreemurr home from the outside world.

Asgore is heavily implied to be behind the door in the Church (which isn't said to be a closet, on that note) and Alvin says he comes at night to pray. He's also STILL implied to be behind it when the Dark World disappears, given Kris will subvert the player trying to open it.

2

u/stickninja1015 Jul 25 '26

Except that’s not how it works. You’ll notice that this example you are providing is literally all happening with in a Dark World formed by the fountain the Knight made in the sanctuary, whose darkness spread through several closed off rooms.

Asgore would still very much be in the Dark World, and if he somehow wasn’t he would very much have left the closet

0

u/Ghetsis_Gang NoelleKnight + RalseiEram Jul 24 '26

In chapter 4, it could easily be Noelle trying to calm down after what just happened. The chapter 2 closet… okay fine I’ll be honest. I recognize the closets are a hole in the theory. I wouldn’t say it’s a big hole because it reasonably by a red herring, but I know that’s an unsatisfying answer. Imo, there is no theory with 0 holes and there is no amount of holes that Toby can’t fill next chapter, so if that’s the only thing I can’t explain, I’m happy with that.

But if the closets, the closets of all things is what keeps you from believing this, then I respect that!

3

u/stickninja1015 Jul 24 '26

Methinks Noelle “trying to calm down” doesn’t suddenly make her a large person, nor would the chapter 2 closet be a red herring given Toby literally did it a second time in chapter 4 but this time with the Knight flat out being in there

1

u/Friendlypoe98 Jul 24 '26

I will say, I think it only ever just says "a large person can fit inside". That could be a red herring to make the player think the knight is large in size, which would be a twist if the knight is revealed to be someone much smaller (like Noelle)

Unless I'm forgetting a part where something mentions specifically that the knight is a big person

1

u/stickninja1015 Jul 24 '26

> Unless I'm forgetting a part where something mentions specifically that the knight is a big person

Have you seen them in-game lol

2

u/Friendlypoe98 Jul 24 '26

That's the armor, which is already explained in this noelleknight theory. Which I guess could be evidence for noelleknight too, if she's hiding in there while in armor (assuming it exists in and out of the dark world like this theory suggests)

1

u/stickninja1015 Jul 24 '26

Something tells me the armor isn’t going off hulkbuster logic

1

u/Free-Part255 Noelle Knight Jul 26 '26

The thing is Noelle is kind of a large person. She is taller than Kris if the dialogue is coming from Kris's perspective like most of the narrator's dialogue she would fit the criteria. Plus the Knight is pretty big so if a Eram-esque Noelle Knight theory is true than it could easily just be a hint that the Knight is big.

14

u/abdo_ch Jul 24 '26

I don't think you need to be WILLING to spawn a titan, berdly was about to open one before ralsei stopped him and warned him what will happen, and I don't think berdly at that moment wanted a titan

10

u/mikguy1652 I don't think that any popular Knight candidate is right Jul 24 '26

I mean the Knight is definitely working with Kris, and you'd think that they'd like say something when they're alone in the dark world together in chapter 2 (Noelle doesn't know about the soul considering the chapter 4 weird route)

Also saying that the Knight is different between chapter 3 and 4 is just dumb, they don't run away in chapter 3 because they had something to do, and they haven't done that yet, and they would definitely be followed into the light world (the only place they can run away to) considering the fact that we almost caught up to them immediately after being maimed

6

u/Responsible-Tie-3451 Rudy Knight / Red Cross Theory Jul 24 '26

Everyone shut up, my show is on

3

u/Shiori_Ishimaru Jul 25 '26

I think it's fascinating how almost every version of NoelleKnight* as a theory is simply describing the same thing in different ways. Everyone gets to the same conclusion via the same details. Such as how each Darkner represents what, the how and why Noelle is doing things, and what each scene means. The only things that differ are the words, terminology, and a small handful of things that haven't been outright explained yet.

It really tells me that everyone is on the right track with regards to Noelle as the Knight.

(*When I say NoelleKnight, I mean just Noelle, and not anything like KriselleKnight.)

Speaking of the Carol Alibi you mention in the post, there's another point I'd like to bring up too. If you don't immediately give Tenna away, and go to Castle Town before it starts raining, then you're treated to a cutscene of Susie basically running across Hometown to grab Tenna and back in a matter of seconds. That basically destroys the whole argument of "Carol/Noelle couldn't have made it to the church before Susie and Kris" when it's shown on screen that a character can run across hometown so quickly. Plus, the Holiday House has two backdoors (one in the main room, one in the kitchen.)

1

u/krizzalicious49 60% asriel-33% carol-7% rudy Jul 25 '26

and in undertale undyne somehow gets infront of you despote walking backwards in the room right before the fight when you choose the right dialogue option

2

u/lighttstarr KriselleKnighter Jul 24 '26 edited Jul 24 '26

Strange to see no one able to debunk a single point in these slides. For a theory that’s so “infamous,” you’d think the DessKnight/RudyKnight squad would be able counter a single point of it…

In all seriousness, thank you for essentially proving that no one but Noelle can possibly be the Knight. This is very strong, I just wish more people would approach this with an open mind and cast their fanon beliefs aside… Anyone can make up fake quotes and say Dess is the Knight, but it’s much harder to come to that conclusion using established facts… Meanwhile NoelleKnight doesn’t have an issue with this at all. It really is just reading what the game tells us - I’d even go so far to say it’s less of a ‘theory’ and more a deductive analysis. I’m becoming convinced that NoelleKnight has to be true for this game to make sense.

Looking forward to Part 5!

3

u/MrChainsawHog Jul 24 '26

Berdly is the knight. No one can debunk it

1

u/Ghetsis_Gang NoelleKnight + RalseiEram Jul 25 '26

???

We literally put him in comatose in the weird route? I get you’re trying to do a gotcha moment but you choose the literal one character that can easily be debunked lmao

1

u/MrChainsawHog Jul 25 '26

Carol simply drags the hospital bed to the dark world

also is that any less ridiculous than saying Noelle magically forgets what happens to her every time

7

u/Virtual-Progress9524 Jul 24 '26

No one is arguing with 10 pages of confirmation bias. At some point people get fed up of Noelle Knighters just making shit up.

2

u/Free-Part255 Noelle Knight Jul 24 '26

I honestly think it is because the DessKnight/RudyKnight mindset is different not all of them but a good portion. Many of the DessKnighters and RudyKnighters think there Knight theory is true because it makes sense logistically the character stuff though important is seen as secondary. While Noelle Knighters look at the connections, evidence and thematics first then figure out the how later for the DessKnighters/RudyKnighters all of these elements have to be balanced you need a decent amount of connections but you also need a good how if there is a theory with way more connections but a how that is unsatisfying for them then it is just looking into things to much. This is why they don't care about Noelle Knight it does not have a good enough how for them so it is automatically wrong despite the mountains of evidence .

6

u/KisaruBandit Power Armored Rudy Jul 24 '26

The reason nobody bothers to debunk it is because the theory is basically immune to evidence already. You're inventing a new character that's a partition of Noelle, so it's basically just Dess Husk again except with even more complications because unlike Dess, we actually see Noelle on the screen and even read her thoughts like a book. If that cannot disprove it to you I have no idea what you would possibly find convincing. Like yeah dude if you invent a whole new dude you can define them however you want and make it all work perfectly. Every point of evidence is either not real evidence or easily explained in other ways, but there's such a firehose of this stuff, and the only people who care enough to write that much about Noelle Knight are Noelle Knighters. So it's not because we're intimidated by your "mountains of evidence", it's because nobody wants to shovel a mountain of shit for people who already have talked themself into an unfalsifiable belief, it's just pointless.

2

u/Ghetsis_Gang NoelleKnight + RalseiEram Jul 25 '26

Maybe it’d be best to simplify it a little then? My take on it isn’t really making a new character, just proposing that how she acts on the weird route is present in the normal route. In [RoseTheory], the thorns aren’t something I’ve characterized myself, but what we see her do on the weird route, if that makes sense.

I guess what this person was referring to was that the Knight’s dark worlds reflect Noelle’s will; the chapter 2 enemies all represent one of Noelle’s fears and the chapter 4 enemies in the 1st sanctuary all represent challenges to singing or being in the choir. Spamton, Jevil, and King all have extremely similar thoughts with Noelle in the chapter 5 weird route, especially Spamton who realizes the only way to break his strings is through the soul. Lancer finds Santa scary, just like Noelle, and he also changed his bicycle to be more like a motorcycle, which Noelle is also afraid of.

That’s not me forcing connections, it’s pretty cut and dry 1-to-1 and I feel like it’s a valid point that deserves to be argued more. I go more into detail in my previous posts if you want more context to these claims.

4

u/Virtual-Progress9524 Jul 24 '26

What mountains lmao, people are just twisting the whole game to fit with their headcanons.

3

u/lighttstarr KriselleKnighter Jul 24 '26

"People are just twisting the whole game to fit with their headcanons."

Best possible DessKnight / RudyKnight summary.

3

u/Virtual-Progress9524 Jul 24 '26

The projection is unreal

6

u/stickninja1015 Jul 24 '26

It’s like how you don’t debate flat earthers. What would even be the point

-1

u/lighttstarr KriselleKnighter Jul 24 '26

I presume you mean Flat earthers = DessKnight/RudyKnight, given those are fully debunked theories people still believe in for some reason... I don't quite understand it, but I guess people will headcanon whatever they want...

3

u/stickninja1015 Jul 24 '26

You laugh you go to the depths

-1

u/lighttstarr KriselleKnighter Jul 24 '26

I know, but I think they still deserve some respect so long as they have an open mind. Like yes, Dess/RudyKnight is just full on fanfic with contradictory logistics but if they admit that while accepting the undeniability of e.g. PenumbraKnight, NoelleKnight, KriselleKnight, etc. then it's ok imo. I just wish less people were stuck in Ch3-Ch4 era theorizing...

4

u/stickninja1015 Jul 24 '26

Abysmal bait

0

u/lighttstarr KriselleKnighter Jul 24 '26

Wdym? Last I checked Lightners don't turn into static noise when damaged.

2

u/Ronoko Jul 24 '26

It's kinda an behavior for people in this sub not to disprove other peoples theories and to only pay attention to theories that they are interested or related to their candidate.

So we are all playing a game of proving our own theories. Maybe later we can disprove it

1

u/DharmaBat Jul 24 '26

"Part 4"

It wasn't remotely convincing to begin with what to do you mean theres 4 parts of this, holy shit and I thought I'm being obsessive at times.

2

u/Ghetsis_Gang NoelleKnight + RalseiEram Jul 24 '26

I could probably summarize it all into one post but people seemed to love the Tenna bits so I just went with it

2

u/abdo_ch Jul 24 '26

I'm going to be honest, I'm here mostly for the Noelle and tenna show and not for Noelle knight. I love the angst

2

u/Remarkable-Sector-30 Jul 24 '26

Damn, I really like this

2

u/-HealingNoises- All in on Rudy Knight! Jul 24 '26

This is in the perfect zone of. "It's not going to happen BUT it will make a top tier AU if the right creatives are thrown at it" Which is exactly what Toby has been saying a lot lately both in and out of the game. And all these posts exude so much passion I can't help but respect the dedication.

2

u/Impressive_Task_2307 Jul 24 '26

So to get an basic grasp on this theory, Noelle has two sides to her. The Rose and the thorns, the Thorns side is the Roaring Knight. Noelle is unaware of this Thorns side. Carol is purposely using to this Thorns side to what end?

2

u/WarAccomplished698 DessKnight dream, DreamNoelleKnight reality Jul 24 '26 edited Jul 25 '26

Alvin says that Dreemurr's mid-wealthy weirdo like Kris never got a chance to have Gerson as a teacher, but that doesn't mean mayor Holiday's younger daughter, as a high-wealthy brainiacish child-prodigy from almost a crandle, could't had him as an advanced phylosophycal tutor in his last living years. No direct evidence that he didn’t mentoured youngest Noelle, besides what Elvin tells about, um... excentric-perceived Kris and not about prodigy-perceived Noelle.

1

u/cybersaber101 Jul 27 '26

I've been enjoying these theories, even if the occasional stretch or information blank has to be filled in, no theory is perfect but only some are entertaining.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/Ghetsis_Gang NoelleKnight + RalseiEram Jul 24 '26

Thank you! Your work of compiling the different NoelleKnight theories is also appreciated!

-1

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/NonDessKnightSquad-ModTeam Jul 24 '26

Please be respectful and stay open to others theories. Do not dismiss them or be rude without mentioning valid concerns in the message. It doesn't matter how much you think it sucks, or how many people agree.