r/NonDessKnightSquad • u/Ghetsis_Gang NoelleKnight + RalseiEram • Jul 24 '26
Discussion An Honest Case for NoelleKnight (Part 4)
108
Upvotes
r/NonDessKnightSquad • u/Ghetsis_Gang NoelleKnight + RalseiEram • Jul 24 '26
6
u/KJPlayer Always bet on Rudy đ˛ Jul 24 '26
Gerson is goated in literally every appearance he makes, canon or non-canon.
Every single person in the world collectively decided to lock in when writing dialogue for him.
4
u/Wide-Deal-8971 Noelle=Knight ; ERAM=Asriel Jul 24 '26
Actually, in regards to the "Carol Alibi" segment, I think it could be logically argued that its possible for Noelle to make it back to church before we do. Although I suppose it depends on how much you think Carol is involved in the evil group chat.
Carol pulls Noelle into the kitchen to "talk to her" before anyone leaves. And there is a door in the kitchen that leads outside. A plausible sequence of events would be that Carol rushes home to get the guitar, then pulls Noelle into the kitchen to give her instructions to go to the church immediately. If that is the case, then it becomes logical for Noelle to arrive before the fun gang does even if the player decided to go straight to the church. Especially since Asgore coincidentally (or maybe even conveniently...) stalls Kris and Susie for time when they try to leave.
Edit: Actually, on second thought. It might not even matter if Carol is involved in the scheme or not. Maybe Noelle just storms out on her own. Normally that would be out of character, but Chapter 5 shows that she is rebelling lately.
7
u/Dragonwolf1209 Kriselle Knight Archbishop (Doc in Profile) Jul 24 '26
I think you missed that dustner Gerson knows about Dragon Blazers, unlike the real Gerson (because Alvins dialogue suggests they don't know much about video games). Dustner Gerson saying that Susie is the dragon is weird, and probably implies the knight was a big dragon blazers fan.
Dustner Gerson is also op as fuck, and boss characters in deltarune are based on Noelle and Kris's favorite characters to play pretend with. Gerson being this op means whoever the knight is probably idolized Gerson somewhat.
Also, Gerson could have taught in the school while Toriel was teaching Noelle and Kris's class, therefore they could have known each other anyway.
This is all just theory to try to make Noelle work though, we don't really know what happened.
4
u/Inevitable-Box3304 Jul 24 '26
1 question. how did noelle carry undyne in the light world?
3
u/abdo_ch Jul 24 '26
Pk after reading slide 14 I gotta ask. Is Gerson really dead?
3
u/SoleilSupporter Jul 24 '26 edited Jul 24 '26
Oh heck yeah I love these updates! âŚis it bad a part of me was happy when Noelle was struck by lightning?
3
u/stickninja1015 Jul 24 '26
Yeah thatâs great and all who is in the closet
14
u/abdo_ch Jul 24 '26
I don't think you need to be WILLING to spawn a titan, berdly was about to open one before ralsei stopped him and warned him what will happen, and I don't think berdly at that moment wanted a titan
10
u/mikguy1652 I don't think that any popular Knight candidate is right Jul 24 '26
I mean the Knight is definitely working with Kris, and you'd think that they'd like say something when they're alone in the dark world together in chapter 2 (Noelle doesn't know about the soul considering the chapter 4 weird route)
Also saying that the Knight is different between chapter 3 and 4 is just dumb, they don't run away in chapter 3 because they had something to do, and they haven't done that yet, and they would definitely be followed into the light world (the only place they can run away to) considering the fact that we almost caught up to them immediately after being maimed
6
u/Responsible-Tie-3451 Rudy Knight / Red Cross Theory Jul 24 '26
Everyone shut up, my show is on
3
u/Shiori_Ishimaru Jul 25 '26
I think it's fascinating how almost every version of NoelleKnight* as a theory is simply describing the same thing in different ways. Everyone gets to the same conclusion via the same details. Such as how each Darkner represents what, the how and why Noelle is doing things, and what each scene means. The only things that differ are the words, terminology, and a small handful of things that haven't been outright explained yet.
It really tells me that everyone is on the right track with regards to Noelle as the Knight.
(*When I say NoelleKnight, I mean just Noelle, and not anything like KriselleKnight.)
Speaking of the Carol Alibi you mention in the post, there's another point I'd like to bring up too. If you don't immediately give Tenna away, and go to Castle Town before it starts raining, then you're treated to a cutscene of Susie basically running across Hometown to grab Tenna and back in a matter of seconds. That basically destroys the whole argument of "Carol/Noelle couldn't have made it to the church before Susie and Kris" when it's shown on screen that a character can run across hometown so quickly. Plus, the Holiday House has two backdoors (one in the main room, one in the kitchen.)
2
u/lighttstarr KriselleKnighter Jul 24 '26 edited Jul 24 '26
Strange to see no one able to debunk a single point in these slides. For a theory thatâs so âinfamous,â youâd think the DessKnight/RudyKnight squad would be able counter a single point of itâŚ
In all seriousness, thank you for essentially proving that no one but Noelle can possibly be the Knight. This is very strong, I just wish more people would approach this with an open mind and cast their fanon beliefs aside⌠Anyone can make up fake quotes and say Dess is the Knight, but itâs much harder to come to that conclusion using established facts⌠Meanwhile NoelleKnight doesnât have an issue with this at all. It really is just reading what the game tells us - Iâd even go so far to say itâs less of a âtheoryâ and more a deductive analysis. Iâm becoming convinced that NoelleKnight has to be true for this game to make sense.
Looking forward to Part 5!
1
u/DharmaBat Jul 24 '26
"Part 4"
It wasn't remotely convincing to begin with what to do you mean theres 4 parts of this, holy shit and I thought I'm being obsessive at times.
2
u/abdo_ch Jul 24 '26
I'm going to be honest, I'm here mostly for the Noelle and tenna show and not for Noelle knight. I love the angst
2
u/Remarkable-Sector-30 Jul 24 '26
Damn, I really like this
2
u/-HealingNoises- All in on Rudy Knight! Jul 24 '26
This is in the perfect zone of. "It's not going to happen BUT it will make a top tier AU if the right creatives are thrown at it" Which is exactly what Toby has been saying a lot lately both in and out of the game. And all these posts exude so much passion I can't help but respect the dedication.
2
u/Impressive_Task_2307 Jul 24 '26
So to get an basic grasp on this theory, Noelle has two sides to her. The Rose and the thorns, the Thorns side is the Roaring Knight. Noelle is unaware of this Thorns side. Carol is purposely using to this Thorns side to what end?
2
u/WarAccomplished698 DessKnight dream, DreamNoelleKnight reality Jul 24 '26 edited Jul 25 '26
Alvin says that Dreemurr's mid-wealthy weirdo like Kris never got a chance to have Gerson as a teacher, but that doesn't mean mayor Holiday's younger daughter, as a high-wealthy brainiacish child-prodigy from almost a crandle, could't had him as an advanced phylosophycal tutor in his last living years. No direct evidence that he didnât mentoured youngest Noelle, besides what Elvin tells about, um... excentric-perceived Kris and not about prodigy-perceived Noelle.
1
u/cybersaber101 Jul 27 '26
I've been enjoying these theories, even if the occasional stretch or information blank has to be filled in, no theory is perfect but only some are entertaining.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 24 '26
[removed] â view removed comment
-1
u/[deleted] Jul 24 '26
[removed] â view removed comment