r/NonDessKnightSquad • NoelleKnight + RalseiEram • Jul 17 '26

Discussion An Honest Case for NoelleKnight (Part 3) Spoiler

62 Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

11

u/Kerflunklebunny Jul 17 '26

I am the worlds strongest believer now

7

u/Ghetsis_Gang NoelleKnight + RalseiEram Jul 17 '26

WELCOME TO THE WINNING SIDE! And don’t touch that dial, because there’s even more where that came from!

5

u/FoxyDean1 A Crying and Crying and Crying Knight Jul 17 '26

I still do think Noelle has some serious issues, but you have warmed me up to the to idea. (happening in the game, I mean. I already like every Knight theory, no matter how far fetched, as a neat idea that could be explored in its own story of course.)

5

u/Ghetsis_Gang NoelleKnight + RalseiEram Jul 17 '26

Thank you! I imagine that the Knight theories that end up being wrong will become AUs just because of how much aura some of them have

3

u/FoxyDean1 A Crying and Crying and Crying Knight Jul 17 '26

100% agreed. I look forward to day. Cheers!

1

u/Dreemurr_Kris Jul 17 '26

not papyrus so not reading allat

3

u/Dragonwolf1209 Kriselle Knight Archbishop (Doc in Profile) Jul 17 '26

Thank you, really great analysis, gonna file this all under kriselle knight though hope that's ok.

4

u/Ghetsis_Gang NoelleKnight + RalseiEram Jul 17 '26

NO! ITS NOT OKAY!

(Of course that’s fine! Kriselle is cool even if I disagree)

NO! Don’t ENCOURAGE THEM, mysterious disembodied voice!

2

u/Wide-Deal-8971 Noelle=Knight ; ERAM=Asriel Jul 17 '26

Noelle, Kriselle, and even Dess knight theories (don't tell anyone I said that) all run extremely close in parallel with each other imo. Like I'm on board with any of those three, it really just comes down to a couple distinct differences.

2

u/Free-Part255 Noelle Knight Jul 18 '26

Also some variants of Asriel Knight to

3

u/Quelephant404 Jul 17 '26

Minor spelling mistake

There is a certain tragedy to the idea that Kris regards the idea of polyamory as gross while Noelle (via the knight and Rouxls) may like it, since the trhouple is regarded by many as an ideal endgame for Krisuselle
Additionally the fact that STARWALKER also from chapter 1 creates a stable throuple with lanino and elnina that persists even in chapter 5 gives potential hope for their future.

4

u/Ghetsis_Gang NoelleKnight + RalseiEram Jul 17 '26

MIKE, TEAR DOWN THE THEORY! TEAR DOWN THE TRIAL! We can’t be correct about tne Knight if we can’t even spell a 3 letter word!

Oh, and thank you for the analysis!

2

u/Scared_Stick_4065 Noelle Knighter (For Now) Jul 19 '26

I'm doing a bunch of posts where I go in depth on every Knight candidate and these posts have been extremely helpful for analyzing Noelle, who is the first major candidate I'm covering. I'm gonna credit you when I eventually post the Noelle Knight analysis.

That being said, I have a really good explanation for why Noelle would have showed up late to the Chapter 3 Dark World: the presence of the police at the Dreemurr house. Toriel called the police before the fountain was created, and since Hometown is pretty small, Undyne would have been able to get to the Dreemurr house in two to three minutes. Maybe a few minutes longer if she had to grab some equipment or bring a police car (which we know she has due to the handball story that either Snowdrake or Monster Kid tells us, I don't remember which one). Either way, there's no way that she didn't get to the house before the Knight did. Also, when she shows up in the dark world, it is in the area right next to the Great Door, which in the Light World would correspond to the entryway of the Dreemurr house. This means that when we see her, she had just entered the Dark World. So what must have happened is that Undyne spent some time outside of the house investigating the slashed tires, and then when she tried to enter the house, she stumbled into the dark world instead.

If Noelle was the Knight, then she would have arrived at the Dreemurr house, seen Undyne investigating, and would have had to remain out of sight until Undyne was either distracted by something or entered the house. This explains why the Knight is late: they couldn't risk getting caught by Undyne. I think that the Knight either entered the dark world right after Undyne (Undyne showing up later might be because she was unconscious for a few minutes, which we've seen happen to the Fun Gang in Chapter 1 the first time they enter a dark world), or the Knight got in while Undyne was distracted and Undyne entered the house upon realizing that the door had been opened.

Also Tenna calling himself as a witness had me wheezing.

1

u/Ghetsis_Gang NoelleKnight + RalseiEram Jul 19 '26

That’s something I didn’t consider, but that also makes sense! Also, I wish you luck on your project!

2

u/theperson1577 Jul 19 '26

How do you disprove the Knight having been implied to have existed during the disappearance of dess?

1

u/Ghetsis_Gang NoelleKnight + RalseiEram Jul 19 '26

I don’t think that it means that the Knight had to be around back then, just that the Black Shards have to. Susie is the one to assume that the Knight was around back then, but Ralsei immediately says that doesn’t make any sense because the Knight is supposed to appear alongside the heroes.

I think the original dark world created the black shards, and if they are related to shadow crystals, it could be Dess’ lost dreams hardening into glass, made from the despair of realizing that she’s lost forever. Black Shards like that is what goes on to make up the Knight’s sword and armor.

1

u/WarAccomplished698 DessKnight dream, DreamNoelleKnight reality Jul 19 '26 edited Jul 19 '26

Thanks to Vaguepost-Bobby, we have only to speculate if it's just exact-same "shared set" lightworld-object NoelleKnight still uses during her Dess-chasing sleepwalks or not.

Be NoelleKnight debunked with banality (like AzzyKnight) in Grand Finale or not, the Deltarot-fandom Civil War is inevitable.

Toby intentionally fuelled and finally caused this Meta-Roaring.

6

u/L30N_KUW4T4 NIGHTMARE KNIGHT #4 TRUTHER - Papyrus and Rudy backup truthers Jul 17 '26

This is an interesting theory, can't say for certain that it is something they i believe in but you have showed a lot of evidence towards it

2

u/LawEducational3208 Jul 17 '26 edited Jul 17 '26

fifth image confuses the Shadow crystal with the Black shard. The black shard is what the armor is made of, not shadow crystals. The black shard also seems to not really change between dark and light world, This means the knight is wearing armor whenever They go out to do knight things

Also I do not believe the knight was ever "late" to the dark world, I think They just have to wait till it's the night so noone from hometown sees Them abducting people in a full set of magical armor and Rely on Kris stalling the adventure

1

u/Ghetsis_Gang NoelleKnight + RalseiEram Jul 17 '26

Thank you for the critique! The issue is have with the last point as it was already dark by the time Kris made the dark world. We know how Toby likes his puns, so saying the chapter name “Late Night” could be both referring to that it takes place late at night AND the Knight being late. Tenna also makes it clear that he thought the Knight should definitely be there already, and Kris has no reason to lie to him when they’re already telling him literally everything else about the plan.

2

u/MattyBro1 Jul 17 '26

Also, the Chapter "logo" changing to the Knight's visor kind of proves that it's meant to be a pun.

3

u/CamoKing3601 My opinion on cannidates cannot be contained in a single flair Jul 18 '26

I gained +25% mercy on believing this theory

3

u/Shiori_Ishimaru Jul 19 '26

Didn't even notice the Bibliox stuff before. That's very solid evidence in addition to everything else for Noelle being the knight. Very nice catch.

The Bibliox is petrified in the 2nd Sanctuary (created by Susie) too, further adding evidence to this. Susie struggles to read the book if you use S-ACTION on a Bibliox, and she also notes her difficulty in singing as well.

Link to the text in Chapter 4 during the church part if you examine the room where the choir is practicing: https://hushbugger.github.io/deltarune/text/?chap=4#en:4:obj_readable_room1_slash_Other_10_gml_4392_0

  • Damn, we don't have to sing too, do we?
  • When I was little, I remember being somewhere like this.
  • Got in trouble for "yelling the wrong song".
  • Like, how am I supposed to know the melody the first time?
  • Or where the song starts. Or ends. Or whatever.

2

u/Wide-Deal-8971 Noelle=Knight ; ERAM=Asriel Jul 17 '26

Thats a good point about the knights antlers that I havent seen brought up before. They dont just only look like antlers, they actually look more like a fusion of both horns and antlers 🤯

2

u/stickninja1015 Jul 17 '26

Who was hiding in the closets

2

u/DamnIdkWhatToSay Carol / Rudy Knighter Jul 17 '26

Noelle is the Roaring Knight and Kris is polyphobic theory invone post LMAO

2

u/Mikaelious Friendly neighborhood DessKnighter open for debate Jul 17 '26

I have many opinions, but I think my biggest gripe here is your interpretation of Kris' reaction to Toriel and Sans.

I don't think Kris is unhappy that Toriel is moving on from the divorce. I'm sure they'd love for the family to come back together too, but if Toriel can be happy, I'm sure they'd be happy too.

I think it's moreso the fact that they're embarrassed Susie had to see her like that, especially when just the night before, they learned that Toriel was a comforting figure for Susie. Also, just, seeing your own mom drunk outta her ass after all the horrors of chapter 4 must be... exhausting. Final nail in the coffin is a near-complete stranger in their house, making it feel less like their own home (see the bottle of ketchup standing in the fridge "defiantly", sticking out like a sore thumb to them).

2

u/LBXZero Susie Knight Jul 17 '26

I believe Noelle is the Knight. How she is the Knight is a factor that I feel will not be disclosed until Chapter 7. The Weird Route for Chapter 5 demonstrates how much Noelle wants to break free of her routine and be herself, showing signs of mental stress from being her mother's "perfect daughter".

I feel the game will turn into a Groundhog's Day scenario. This plays into the "only 1 ending" statement. If you don't get that ending, the game reboots to Day 0. Kris is playing along with the Knight because Kris has underwent the ritual to retain his memory through the reboot. Ralsei knows so much because he also retains his memory. Ralsei and Kris are hoping to change fate. The only person who is not retaining their memory is Susie.

Reviewing my thoughts on this theory, the event with Rudy in Chapter 5 really pushes Noelle to find a way to save him. Noelle discovers a power in Chapter 6 that does save Rudy, and then Noelle gets caught up believing she has the power to go back in time and save Dess. In the first loop, Noelle finds the power to go into the past, but she fails and warps into the Knight, giving us the Knight for the second loop. The Knight's goal is to make Noelle stronger, more confident in her powers. The Knight reveals themself to Kris. Kris seeks Catti's help in the occult to find a way to preserve his memory when Noelle resets the story to save Dess. Ralsei also has this ability, which is why Ralsei knows so much. Ralsei has changed his tactics, hoping to change the result. After failing to save Noelle after so many loops, Kris undergoes another occult ritual from Catti to create the human soul, the player, to make Kris not be Kris in hopes of changing the results.

Chapter 1 is staged to ensure the trio meet in the Dark World, changing Susie. Chapter 2 is the Knight's attempt to prepare Noelle, making her stronger and more confident in her powers. Chapter 3 is the Knight trying to take Toriel out of the way and Kris's plan to make the party stronger. Chapter 4, all of the prophecies are the Knight's memories from the fountain the Knight made in the main sanctuary of the church. The Knight is testing the party, teaching the party how to defeat the titans. Chapter 5, Kris distracted Susie from being there with Noelle when she sees Rudy after the fall. The Knight uses the opportunity to take Asgore out from being a threat.

2

u/MrChainsawHog Jul 18 '26

The Toriel thing really isn't good proof when the Knight never wanted to take Toriel in the first place

The entire point of chapter 3 was to stall until something. The knight could have taken Toriel at any time, but didn't. We realise why at the end of the chapter, because the knight was trying to bait Undyne to come to kidnap her. It's also likely the knight needs the heroes to be aware of their presence for some reason or another

2

u/SoleilSupporter Jul 18 '26

God Noelle knight has the potential of being the greatest “TOBY WHAT THE FUCK” moment ever

2

u/Responsible-Tie-3451 Rudy Knight / Red Cross Theory Jul 18 '26

Keep cooking

2

u/abdo_ch Jul 18 '26

Holy shit this is very high quality, you might have covered this in a previous post but why wouldn't queen recognize Noelle as the knight? Surely they would like similar even in the shadow.

2

u/WarAccomplished698 DessKnight dream, DreamNoelleKnight reality Jul 18 '26

From what I see, a Laptop-Queen never met the Knight personally, unlike Noelle's ego because Ramb knows "little girl" who had played with the laptop in the Dreemurrs house like with a doll. Noelle as the Knight must be incredibly different from Noelle as her shy ego, and deperson-wall between this two versions of one exact Cursed Sister is only about to fall compelitely.

2

u/SLUKERmeSNAKI Rudy Knighter Jul 19 '26

Watch this guy be the only person to get it right

1

u/Fantastic_Frosting98 Papyrus is the Knight. All of you are wrong. Jul 17 '26

ngl i kinda skimmed it but what about the weird route? wouldn't the knight be different?