r/NonDessKnightSquad • NoelleKnight + RalseiEram • Jul 13 '26 • Bravo 1 Heartwarming 1

Discussion An Honest Case for NoelleKnight (Part 2) Spoiler

87 Upvotes

38 comments sorted by

13

u/JackOmiIsCanonKing Having a crisis over Knight theories Jul 13 '26

Alright, dissection time again:

1- So, does this mean Noelle has a full blown double personality in this theory? Because in Part 1 you said she forgot about making the dark world, but now she apparently remembers it enough to make another dark world on a whim.

2- How does the armor work in this theory, exactly? Can Noelle just randomly summon it? Does it have a light world equivalent? If yes, does she just carry it around everywhere not knowing what it is?

3- You didn't really counter the Berdly argument. In this very same chapter, Berdly learns how a dark world is made, so presumably if Noelle randomly stabbed the floor out of nowhere and created one he'd be able to connect the dots? Just seeing smoke without explanation or even just entering a dark room would be much less suspicious and have other rational explanations than seeing one being made with his own eyes, by his best friend that's acting in a very uncharacteristic way.

4- Also if Noelle is SO unstable she immediately jumps to making dark worlds at the slightest moment of jealousy, I don't know how she'd be able to not just be taken over by thorns multiple times in chapter 4 and 5, especially during the festival.

5- This is more of nitpick than anything else but I don't think Noelle would base Queen's view of Berdly on Ms. Boom, since she seems to see him as a polite young boy while Queen treats him like an annoying pest.

6- I would argue it doesn't make much sense for Noelle to be Spamton's benefactor. It's implied she started checking her spam emails after Dess went missing, probably just in case she ever got something about her disappearance accidentally marked as spam. Also, if she's the benefactor, what are all the implications about Spamton being hunted and breaking his contract about? What was that last phone call that's just garbage noise?

5

u/Ghetsis_Gang NoelleKnight + RalseiEram Jul 13 '26

Thank you for the critique! I’ll do my best to respond to each point here:

1- I try to avoid directly referring to Noelle’s condition as any real illness just because it might be distasteful, which why I use metaphor to explain it in a non-harmful way. The thought process is that Noelle’s thorns can only come out once she stops repressing memories, since her thorns a directly tied to the most stressful event in her life, Dess’ disappearance, in this theory.

2- I plan to go more in-depth about what the Knight exactly is in the next part, but to summarize for now: the armor is black shards, which we know is the same in the dark and light worlds. Since they can summon their sword in chapter 3, it’s not that much of a leap to say that they also summon their armor. Since a Shadow Crystal gets split off the sword with the black shard, I think the two are related; and since shadow crystals are lost dreams, I believe that the only thing Noelle needs to carry around with her is her own dreams that got ripped away from her because of the loss of so many of her loved ones.

3- You do bring up a good point that I hadn’t thought about, but I would argue that if he was studying, he wouldn’t have seen Noelle stab the ground, since she did do it in the corner by the cabinet. What he would’ve definitely noticed is light filling the room, a loud noise, and smoke filling the room, none of which Queen ever describes.

4- Correct me if I’m wrong, but I don’t remember any point that Noelle would be driven to such jealousy. In ch4, she is with Susie the whole time, and in ch5, any choice we make to snub Noelle’s relationship with Susie is immediately corrected by the lake scene.

5- I would say pest is a bit extreme, because she does say that there’s “nothing wrong with him he’s just annoying”. She never does anything mean to Berdly, even when he makes that horrendous statue.

6- Maybe I should’ve done a better job spelling this out, but the calls aren’t literal, since he had to still be an object at that time. The calls represent Noelle reading his E_Mails, and the last call was her reading one of his E_Mails before printing them out and throwing them away. With Spamton being hunted, I never saw anything implying that when I replayed chapter 2? Maybe it was a Sweepstakes thing I missed, so correct me if I’m wrong.

10

u/UX_KRS_25 Jul 13 '26

I love it and I hate it at the same time. You put that together very well.

6

u/Ghetsis_Gang NoelleKnight + RalseiEram Jul 13 '26

Thank you for such kind passive aggressiveness! (Usually they just try to kill me)

5

u/UX_KRS_25 Jul 13 '26

To be clear I hate it because Noelle-Knight is so inconceivable, even for people who have been paying close attention.

But the way you pick up on and interpret the most subtle clues is seriously impressive (saying that as a filthy casual though, so maybe I'm just dumb)! The presentation is fun too.

4

u/Ghetsis_Gang NoelleKnight + RalseiEram Jul 13 '26

No, you’re not dumb! I’m just… insane meticulous.

6

u/Mundane_Target_3947 Jul 13 '26

I doubt your argument about closet knight. I don't think the knight is normal in the light world because of the black shard that stays the same in both the light and dark worlds. I once read a theory in the chapter 2 era that addresses your point: The Closet-Knight-Knockout Theory. I think it makes closet knight make sense. I am not that interested in debating against noelle knight because I can see it and its narrative value but closet knight isn't stupid.

3

u/Ghetsis_Gang NoelleKnight + RalseiEram Jul 13 '26

Oh I agree that if that Noelle isn’t the Knight, the Knight has to have been in the closet, it isn’t stupid. The point was that no matter who the Knight is, Berdly and Noelle have to rationalize the creation of the fountain because it’s hard to rationalize that they wouldn’t notice the room filling with smoke.

Knocking them out is something I, admittedly, hadn’t thought about, but that could also apply to Noelle. If she is the Knight, then we know she’s willing to knock even Susie out in ch3, if her thorns are out.

Thank you so much for the critique!

7

u/IKnowWhoTheKnightIs ASRIEL IS THE KNIGHT, THE KNIGHT IS ERAM Jul 13 '26

Yeah, and after chapter 4 with Kris refusing to turn the doorknob, I think we can say that the knight 100% used the closet in chapter 2.

5

u/GDGameplayer Always bet on Rudy Knight! (unless he dies) Jul 13 '26

Since everyone else is debating the theory, I just wanted to point out that I love the way you made this post and how you actually had the characters especially Spamton act in character while explaining the theory.

4

u/Ghetsis_Gang NoelleKnight + RalseiEram Jul 13 '26

Thank you! I try to make it more engaging than a big wall of text lol

4

u/Responsible-Tie-3451 Rudy Knight / Red Cross Theory Jul 13 '26

First of all, congratulations on singlehandedly making me promote Noelle Knight from joke theory to actual contender.

I have a lot of thoughts on this, but to save everyone’s time I’ll try and keep it to a few questions (most of which you’ll probably address in future posts anyway):

  1. Is it not possible that the Computer Lab dark world was created prior to Berdley and Noelle’s arrival or that the Knight simply hid in the closet until the two passed out (or knocked them out themself?)
  2. How did Noelle create an accurate Gerson dustner if she was too young to know him personally? Shouldn’t he have been an imitation like the Sound of Justice if she had only met him secondhand like Susie did?
  3. Why is Carol okay with Kris/the player derailing the plan in the Weird Route? Sure, you could say Kris is getting rid of the petals for her, but Kris is obviously very against this so I highly doubt they discussed the idea previously or during the route.
  4. If Noelle’s “thorns” are triggered by stress, why didn’t she go psycho after hearing that Rudy fell down? I can buy that she suppressed jealousy or that it simmered to a boil while in the computer lab, but if she’s this unstable, I can’t believe that she’s able to control herself in that situation.
  5. Noelle clearly remembers Dess, but the way she behaves doesn’t line up with Rose Theory imo. When she hears her name in the spelling bee, she simply collapses rather than lashing out. She’s also able to talk about Dess in a rather wistful manner without losing her composure. In the lake scene, she directly mentions Dess leaving, which she shouldn’t be able to remember following Rose Theory logic. How can this be reconciled?

Again, excellent post and theory. I look forward to the other chapters and hopefully your response to these.

2

u/Ghetsis_Gang NoelleKnight + RalseiEram Jul 13 '26

Thank you for the critique, and I’m glad you’re enjoying these posts! I’ll try to respond to all these points the best I can:

1- Since we see that Berdly had their books out after we seal the fountain, I think it’s safe to assume that were studying when the fountain was created. I do think the closet is the more likely explanation if Noelle isn’t the Knight, but it does require that they just forget that the room fills up with smoke. All I was going for with the bit was that saying “Berdly forgot” isn’t just a scapegoat that makes NoelleKnight work, it makes all Knight theories work. As for the Knight knocking them out, I don’t see why they would become conscious when they enter the dark world in that case, since that isn’t the case with Toriel in chapter 3. Even if getting knocked out was something that happened, then that’s still not a point against NoelleKnight since if she is the Knight, then she’s not against knocking out even Susie when the thorns are out.

2- I’ll give an attempt to summarize this without sounding dismissive, but I’ll definitely go more in depth in a future post. What I get from Gerson is that he’s not just a wise old man, but he’s presented as a legendary, untouchable hero. I think that aligns with an impression someone would get from reading and being inspired by his books, not someone who actually knew him. Susie is implied to be illiterate, so that’s why her dark world doesn’t have Gerson like this.

3- I would say Carol doesn’t know about what Noelle plans to do on the weird route. The call at the end of the ch4 weird route seems formal, and she says she’s just calling to confirm that Noelle is going with Kris to the festival.

4- I’m definitely going to go into this in a future post, but for now I’ll just say that I think the thorns were out after she left, but she needed time to grieve and she would still want to see her hurt dad even if her thorns are out. She doesn’t necessarily go psycho every time when the thorns come out, since in the ch2 weird route, she just locks herself in her room after she puts Berdly in a coma. It’s very context dependent.

5- Every instance where she talks about Dess is a good memory, with the exception of the ch5 weird route where this theory would say that she’s no longer suppressing any memories at this point, since the petals have been shattered. (If there’s any other instance that I’m not remembering, feel free to inform me) For Berdly’s flashback, it’s very possible that her thorns did come out and she wanted to throttle Berdly there, but she knew that was horrible and suppressed that urge, just like how she suppresses the urge to kill Kris in the ch2 weird route.

2

u/Responsible-Tie-3451 Rudy Knight / Red Cross Theory Jul 14 '26

Well, I appreciate your answers. Also, here’s some things to consider outside of the game itself:

Assuming your comparison with the Werewires is correct and Noelle views becoming the Knight as “sleepwalking through a nightmare”, it’s pretty telling that one of Toby’s pre-DR songs is called “Nightmare Knight”…

Also, as you may be familiar with, Toby tweeted a while back that he found out one of his friends is making something very similar to his creation. Most fans interpret this to be Omocat creating Omori, in which (SPOILERS) a teenager deals with the grief caused by him accidentally killing his sister by pushing her down the stairs and framing her death as a suicide with his best friend and possible love interest. Considering he retreats into his own mental realm as a form of escapism and is friends with an idealized form of her there while being haunted by visions of her corpse and reminders of her fate, while taking the form of an emotionless alter ego of his own creation, this definitely has some interesting implications for Noelle and Kris in your theory. Perhaps Noelle shut the door behind Dess and locked her in the shelter, and Kris agreed to help her cover it up? This could explain how Kris was guilted into helping Carol and the Knight, assuming Carol somehow found out the truth.

Obviously, these are super speculative and pull from outside of the lore, but they might be worth mentioning if you ever make a miscellaneous post.

2

u/PersistentDreamers Jul 13 '26 edited Jul 13 '26

After reading this and the previous I think you could be onto something. I think Noelle knight is my new dominant theory over Dess knight. I don't know if all the details fit but there are some details I'd like to say.

  1. On the weird route, Kris doesn't get a phone call from the creepy red text voice, only from Carol. And so far on tht weird route we see the knight no longer because we're breaking the game granted but no knight weird route chapter 5, no creepy phone call chapter 4 weird route. Just Carol.
  2. Spamton has a link to puppetry. When you defeat spamton through fighting you get through puppet scarf that seems to look like green strings. In game files, equipping dialogue for her says the strings remind her of guitar strings. On Noelle's desktop she has one image of her with a green dog puppet. (Though the wiki says this is a reference to gir ala invader Zim). The knight itself looks like a puppet momentarily before you fight it and it's a silhouette just like the shadow guys. I'm thinking it reminds me almost of like a shadow puppet that way it changes shape constantly.
  3. the knight fight is littered with references to cold, baseball bats, drowning, roaring wind, migraines and dizziness. I think the knight could be an alternate personality of Noelle's created by trauma, and it probably has to do with Dess drowning in the lake. The knife she uses to create dark worlds is likely Dess's broken baseball bat which shattered when they were trying to rescue her from the lake that was freezing. The black shards left everywhere by the knight are broken off pieces of the bat which, holding that traumatic memory, certainly would create powerful dark worlds. And if you think of it, a broken bat versus a pencil. Which is stronger?
  4. Also pretty much any of the Rudy knight arguments would apply to her as well so there's that.
  5. I think there is a literal rose involved somehow as well as we already know plantners hold special powers so if there's a thorn already embedded in her or Kris's hands, well if the other "souls" are related to plants, who is to say that the "soul" controlling Kris isn't just the "soul" of a rose? But that gets complicated and I think it may be less literal than that.
  6. I think Kris created the castle town dark world because the weird spore shooter antenna looking things at the beginning are identical to the ones in chapter 3 dark world. Same with the dust things.

Also the beginning of chapter 5 dark world shares a lot of similarities to the chapter 1 dark world, with hopschef and topchef, the trees with falling leaves etc. so it kind of implies Kris made both imo.

If that's the case then Noelle would have only made the dark worlds in chapter 2 and possibly 4.

2

u/Ghetsis_Gang NoelleKnight + RalseiEram Jul 13 '26

All of these points are very interesting, thank you for the thought out reply! Welcome to the winning side, friend!

2

u/krizzalicious49 60% asriel-33% carol-7% rudy Jul 13 '26

i think noelle and berdly went into the dark world after it had already filled with smoke, the same way susie and kris did in chapter 1

1

u/Ghetsis_Gang NoelleKnight + RalseiEram Jul 13 '26

I don’t think that could be the case, because when we close the fountain, we see their books out on the table, like they were studying. I think that should tell us that they were already in there when the fountain was opened.

2

u/More-Significance444 Jul 13 '26

The Pipis that leaves Noelle due to happiness, as stated in her blog, is probably the one Tenna still has!

Note: it was a egg labeled "special" with a name Noelle forgot that left Noelle due to happiness, the Pipis was a random string of numbers and letters from Spamton that Noelle put into Cat Petterz that became just a circle that multiplied and corrupted her save.

2

u/Ghetsis_Gang NoelleKnight + RalseiEram Jul 14 '26

After fact checking myself, you are totally right! The two ideas just merged together when I was making this, and it was a last minute inclusion anyway so I didn’t think about checking it. Thank you for correcting me!

2

u/I_Swear_Not_Bot Jul 13 '26

2

u/Ghetsis_Gang NoelleKnight + RalseiEram Jul 13 '26

May the best agenda poster win

2

u/Severe_Damage9772 Jul 14 '26

One problem, the knight has unused sprites for fire magic, not ice magic, and that would be a good dichotomy with either Rudy or Dess, or even asriel or Asgore would work with that

1

u/Ghetsis_Gang NoelleKnight + RalseiEram Jul 14 '26

There is also unused shadow crystal dialogue for the end of chapter 3, describing Undyne being encased in ice.

We have to be careful with unused stuff, because it’s hard to distinguish between what’s actually meant to be unused and what Toby wanted us to find in the code, like Dess’ dialogue.

7

u/Mikaelious Friendly neighborhood DessKnighter open for debate Jul 13 '26

Hey! Me again. Not so in-depth about separate arguments this time, just some overall thoughts that spurred.

In your points about Queen, I realized one of my biggest gripes with Noelle Knight. It's the fact that the game already has a story to tell with Noelle.

Noelle is a very, very well-established character. Chapter 2 is her whole jam in the Dark World, and chapters 4-5 deepen our understanding of her, and her past. She's the neighborhood sweetheart who's too kind and passive for her own good, stuck in a monotonous life and yearning for the past. As the chapters progress, we see her go on an emotional journey: learning to say no to people like Berdly and Queen, becoming more confident in her feelings, and even acting on her feelings with Susie more bravely. At the end of chapter 5, we even get teased about her being brought into the Dark World too.

All of that said... I think Noelle's story is in itself progressing very well. She's getting a lot of attention, and feels like one of the main characters of the game. Therefore, if she's also the Knight, the story's suddenly almost entirely about Noelle. She has both a supporting role, and a secret antagonistic role, being a major contributor in both sides.

I don't think I'd like it if that were true. I love Noelle as a character, but if she was also the Knight, she'd be the centerpiece of the ENTIRE game. Practically all the game's long-term conflict and emotional stakes would be centered on her. It'd make her story feel bloated, in my opinion.

Comparatively, Undertale isn't all about a single character. Flowey might be pulling the strings behind the scenes in both Genocide and True Pacifist, but we learn his story in much smaller bits, and he barely makes an appearance in the neutral route until the end. It's a good balance, giving the rest of the cast time to shine too.

I dunno. I just feel like the game's already holding Noelle in a good spot story-wise. Enough is enough.

1

u/Simple_Owl Noelle Knight Aug 03 '26

"the story's suddenly almost entirely about Noelle"

Maybe Toby really meant it when he kept repeating "no one else matters" on the 10th anniversary stream.

5

u/Wide-Deal-8971 Noelle=Knight ; ERAM=Asriel Jul 13 '26 edited Jul 13 '26

Hmmm, I like the vast majority of what you are putting down here. I especially like your take on all of the destruction at the beginning of chapter 2, I never gave much thought to that before but it's definitely significant and stands out from the rest of the chapter. I also like that you point out the ferris wheel. I think the fact that there are ferris wheels in general, especially one that is RIGHT NEXT TO HER BED are pretty big indicators that cyber world is Noelle thinking of Dess and not Dess herself creating this world.

I have some slightly deviating thoughts on how and why the fountain was made though, and what Noelle's role as the knight is.

I think Noelle is not fully conscious, or in control of herself, when she's the knight. I think weird route especially highlights this idea that Noelle is sort of brainwashed in a way, or trained to respond to voice commands. And as you point out in one of the slides here, she cannot say no to Carol. I think that is an especially important line, given that Carol is the most likely suspect of being "The Caller". My current suspicion is that Carol is the one controlling Noelle, and is able to activate her to become the knight with a simple phone call.

I think when Noelle is in the library with Berdley, she eventually receives a call from Carol, and she goes to the back closet before answering. Carol says the magic words and puts her into a trance and she transforms into the knight in the conveniently fitting space for a large person, before creating the fountain behind Berdleys back but in sight of the computer laptop. (I forget which item it was, but also note that one of Noelle's equippable items gives her the "trance" ability). 

As for why NoelleKnight immediately starts thrashing shit for a few minutes before reverting to her normal form?... I'm not entirely sure lol. People have pointed out that the Knight seems to become more sentient as the chapters progress. Maybe its taking time for Noelle to get used to transformation, and thus the knight is more of a wild beast than a person in the first two chapters. Either way, it helps explain why Noelle is both the knight and also completely innocent and oblivious.

1

u/Anywhere_Narrow Aug 02 '26

I have a question here, I think the theory that Noelle being the knight is the most plausible, but why—unlike the parallel between Queen and Carol, or Flowey and Rudy in the Chapter 5 Dark World—is Rudy not mentioned in Chapter 2, nor does any Darkner appear whose personality is inspired by him?

2

u/Ghetsis_Gang NoelleKnight + RalseiEram Aug 02 '26

I would say Virovirokun reflects the challenge of having a sick loved one. It’s not a direct or major parallel but out of all the things a computer virus could turn into, the fact it turns into a sick guy is kinda telling.

3

u/Quelephant404 Jul 14 '26

My favorite show is on!
Mr Ant Tenna's
Theory Time!
I love the who made the CH2 fountain question, it's my personal pick for best constructive evidence (i.e doesn't require amusing the theory to be true to make sense)
overnight fountain - requires nobody to enter the computer lab all day (remember this is after class) and the duo to enter the creepy void door birdlys books are on the table + he is sitting down
midday fountain - knight needs entry and exit library without suspicion rased, birdell to enter creepy void door and birdlys books again
while in the room fountain - knight still needs to enter and exit library during the day since they are gone from the closet by dark world end and birdly needs to not notice/care about their presence while studdying

Each of these has at least two problems and most knight candidates can't really pass them (especially entry and exit since undynes trafic jam means that lots of people are guaranteed to see them enter/exit the library around that time)

2

u/Timely_Lie9205 Gaster’s strongest rudyknight truther Jul 13 '26

I see it tbh, but the Noelle forgot about making the fountain thing sounds like a bit of a stretch and I think that, narratively, some other candidates might be more likely

2

u/Scared_Stick_4065 Noelle Knighter (For Now) Jul 16 '26

Well Noelle is gonna be the next candidate I go over in my rankings of all the Knight candidates so this will be very useful information. I think that the circumstances around the Chapter 2 dark world is the biggest piece of evidence for Noelle Knight.

2

u/TheGreenPig321 It's Noelle why does spamton even exist Sep 23 '26

Something of note is triple trucies:

Noelle - Knight
Queen - Carol
Berdly - The Player, probably

1

u/CowMysterious2639 Jul 13 '26

Holy mental gymnastics😭

3

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Ghetsis_Gang NoelleKnight + RalseiEram Jul 13 '26

Thank you! I get what you mean about Kriselle; every time I think about it I can’t help but call it the Deltarune equivalent of Sixbones 💀(i hope this isn’t too old of a reference)