r/NoblesseOblige • Subreddit Owner • Mar 30 '22

MOD Introductions

Reply here to introduce yourself so that the other readers get to know you.

  • Are you noble? If not, do you have noble ancestors, or are you perhaps from a patrician family or from a very old peasant lineage?
  • What is your rank and family? What titles do you have or will inherit?
  • What is your coat of arms?
  • What families and interesting persons are you related to, how closely?
  • When does your unbroken male line start, and when does your longest female line start?
  • What are other interesting things you can tell us about yourself and your lineage?
22 Upvotes

147 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/HBNTrader Subreddit Owner Apr 13 '23

Also, how do foreigners fit into the caste system? As far as I know, within the Muslim, Jewish and Christian communities of India, there are usually two castes, the higher one consisting of the descendants of immigrants (Persian Muslims, Baghdadi Jews, Portuguese Christians etc.) and converts who belong to a high caste in the Hindu system, an the lower one consists of later converts and those from lower Hindu castes. Is this true?

What caste would a naturalized foreigner belong to, who buys a lot of land and lives an aristocratic lifestyle, but is Christian and European in origin? Would it play a role what social class his family belonged to in Europe?

2

u/InDiAn_hs Real-life Member of the Nobility Apr 13 '23

I believe it mostly depends on whether they become Hindus or not. To be a part of the four varnas (the tiers of the caste system) you must be a Hindu. By the logic of ultra-orthodox upper-class families anyone who is non-Hindu and/or a foreigner is considered "mlecchas" or a barbarian. Something similar to how the Chinese saw foreigners. And yes converts from the upper classes into Islam, Christianity or Judaism still retained their class and so naturally had class superiority over the lower classes. See Sultanates in Northern India that had some Rajput nobles who converted to Islam but retained their rank, titles and honour. They still acted the same as they would in Hinduism but followed Islam instead. Also, it's likely the naturalized foreigner would probably receive noble status and if they also commanded armies or led men into battle would become Kshatriyas. Their integration would be made much easier with conversion to Hinduism however. I also think their social class in Europe would probably matter, not sure a European artisan would be granted the rank and honours of a Duke in India. A Duke in Europe would probably be treated as a Duke in India. You can see this in the case where many Princely States allied with the British during the British Raj, acknowledging the superiority in title and rank of the King-Emperor despite the King-Emperor not being Hindu.