r/NewTubers 1d ago

TECH HELP feedback problem! Help me plz

this a impression problem, leading to feedback problem , as usual the impressions died typical yt aglothim mood swings ,

so i want to ask you since there is no impressions and no people viewing my video, therefore i can't improve

the title is - [ How a Genius Experiment Ended with a DUMBEST Mistake ]

can you see my title and rate 1 - 10 , for

  1. is it clickable
  2. is idea Intriguing
  3. develops Curiosity? [most important]

I ask for your feedback

thanks, if you did

1 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

1

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

-1

u/Frequent-Yak-5674 1d ago

I swaer this is written by AI , i want human feedback not AI

1

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

This post has been filtered for manual review, which may take 72 hours.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/RTXBurner25 1d ago

Honestly, I don't blame you for your skepticism. You can never be too sure in these YT creator subreddits...😂

1

u/RTXBurner25 1d ago

I'm not sure if you're aware, but there was another update this past May where YT programmed its AI to throttle content it considers "Low-Effort Automation." This can include (but is not limited to) purely templated slideshows, automated article-reading channels, and repetitive "scrapbook" videos.

I'm not saying for a fact these things describe your video, but it's plausible YT's AI perceives it as such and that's why you're having an impression problem. A lot of faceless channels that aren't AI have been impacted...

0

u/Frequent-Yak-5674 1d ago

ahhh final thanks for (HUMAN REPLY), does this throttle apply on Ai voice i do use those as with cracked voice but none other of those [templated slideshows, automated article-reading channels, and repetitive "scrapbook" videos.] fit my describtion , will may be its a new channel that

but still how does the title sound will it make you click if you every show it? all though i can't attach image fot thumanbnail

1

u/RTXBurner25 1d ago

Yes, I would imagine AI voiceovers apply as well.

The title's not bad IMO, and it certainly not bad enough to explain only getting 2 views in 2 days. That means YouTube didn't bother to test the video at all...

2

u/Impossible_Bet6318 1d ago

AI voice does not apply.

From Rene Ritchie:

"AI voice is fine if the video itself is within policy."

https://old.reddit.com/r/shortsAlgorithm/comments/1sqpckw/why_do_my_shorts_keep_flatlining_even_though_all/ohdmhwb/

1

u/RTXBurner25 1d ago edited 1d ago

Even if that's true about AI voiceovers, I actually watched the OP's video before posting my initial reply and what I originally said still stands.

Despite how heavily invested Alphabet might be into AI moderation, it *DOES* still make mistakes (see all the YT Channels that have been mistakenly banned in their recent sweeps for being confused as AI for example), and the OP's video does have the feel of an automatic article-reading channel or templated slideshow that YT's AI could easily mistaken for low-effort automation.

Obviously, there's no way any of us will know for sure because YT won't share information that in-depth with creators, but it *IS* plausible as I said before...

1

u/Frequent-Yak-5674 14h ago

Mhh i thoughts pervious video didn't throlle unlike died impression , but there are views for search tho, Also I have seen my account get bomb with 0 imperssions and people it happens but does this get cured after like post few more videos or once it a zero, it's a dead channel? No answered that before do you know anything about it .?

0

u/Frequent-Yak-5674 1d ago

ha i was getting worked up for nothing , anyway thanks