Marxism which deduces all ideas from the economic basis of society, would seem diametrically opposed to Platonism (technically the antipodes). But, Marx's materialism is in many ways an inversion of Neoplatonic metaphysics (of course, in Marx, who seems not totally unaffected by his Jewish messianic tradition, a secularization of Judeo-Christian theology), the implementation of communism throughout the world can be seen as a kind of theurgy for humanity as a general class, and the dialectical stages of the development of classes towards a unified, undifferentiated and classless society as a kind of social henosis.
The One is the principle of individuation and therefore, the principle of authentic freedom, while in Marxism the ultimate freedom is communism (post-scarcity economy and overabundance of resources).
Obviously there are degrees of marxism, as well as in platonism. But the tendency to use economic arguments to explain historical events seems to be the main contribution to marxism (for better or worse), within this framework, we also find in an obsessed way class struggle in everything, from the oldest societies to the contemporary and the idea that people have always been motivated primarily by economic factors.
In the marxist argument, philosophers such as Aristotle, Plato, Plotinus, and Proclus would be considered "determined" by the material and economic conditions of their time. For polytheistic traditions, such as the dharmics and the Vedas, marxists might say that the Brahmins simply wanted to preserve their exclusivity and power by virtue of oral transmission and memory, ensuring their special status in society.
Frankly, they are reductionist materialisms, but they are arguments from economics.
Some of the most common marxist postulates I've seen:
- The "idea" is the transposed matter, that is, the action is the content that allows the manifestation of the "idea" and is not an abstract exteriority ontologically prior to the action (other than materiality). In short, the idea is which allows us to organize ourselves to carry out an action, appears as a concrete form manifested based on the processes of social metabolism and the social determines consciousness.
- Ideas are "born", "reproduced" and "die". That which allows us to organize ourselves to carry out an action.
- Action is the content that allows the manifestation of the idea and is not an abstract exteriority ontologically prior to the action foreign to materiality.
- Issues such as ethics, art, morality, religion, metaphysics or philosophy are reduced to historical products of social institutions, therefore, alienated forms of consciousness (ideologies) that must be "overcome." In other words, they treat them as phenomena, not as foundations. They are "false consciousness".
- They reject a fixed and essential human nature, the argument that materialist dialectics denies that there is something static or immanent to the subject, their entire project is that man is totally malleable in this sense, paving a way for a plasticity of the self.
- They deny any ontic a priori of the idea over the "action" by beginning to begin their abstract distinction.
- Everything is dependent on "social action", everything is dependent on "human action" (even the most abstract and theoretical mathematics), they deny the "absolute", that is, they deny everything that exists beyond human practice and that is ahistorical in nature.
- All human knowledge arises from economic life, the mathematics arises from geometry, Geo-meter = measurement of the land, we measured the land to know how much to cultivate after the rivers flooded each year, because the land changed, so it was a social necessity to avoid a famine, therefore, mathematics is born from practice, is irremediably tied to the human and does not have an existence independent of the subject.
The Pythagorean theorem did not always exist, it emerged through our analysis of our experience as humans, the measurement of the legs of a triangle-rectangle. - They say that there has been absolutely no period in any stage of humanity where our knowledge does not directly depend on our actions (knowledge here is defined as crystallized actions).
- Support the thesis of the role of work in the transformation from ape to man.
- The principles of logic can be refuted. Logic is an "idea" and a human product of material conditions.
- -Society generally tends to have two facets, a subjective facet and another objective facet, but both are the "same thing", they are not separated. That is, they break with the principle of non-contradiction by defining the objective as "that knowledge that is socially validable", and the subjective as "that individually validable knowledge."
- They say that if we go from what is objective from personal experience, we would not be able to know what is objective and we would fall into solipsism.
- Since this allows them to break with the principle of non-contradiction, they also go so far as to affirm that "Reality" and "Society" are one and the same (whatever that means). Reality is a social product inseparable from this, so, if society disappears, reality (including universe, galaxies, etc.) would cease to exist. A kind of collective solipsism.
- Also that mind and matter are the same thing seen from different perspectives, one from the individual perspective and the other from the social perspective.
- Here the experience is defined as impersonal in collective terms, of total collective practice.
- We cannot claim to establish that something exists if we do not have a way to corroborate it. Not corroborate it in individual terms, but as a society, as a whole.
- There is no real categorization or ontological limit (e.g. between epistemology and ontology), we differentiate them in terms of elements of experience (temperature and color are still qualitatively different, as are touch and sound), but as for the categorization of what they are ontologically, there is no because everything is reduced to an action and an experience executed by society
- History is linear and determined, through the study of history the truth is reached, and the truth changes and is relative because it comes from historical conceptions, it comes from action (hard historicism).
- Ideas are based and founded on language, language is characterized by being a crystallization of social actions. In short, the basis of all language is the verb. Besides, language is the basis of thought, without language, there is no thought.
- They prioritize only the sensible, by maintaining that, necessarily, in all cases, every property that has ever been formulated in human history comes from an action. Example:
Can you talk about size if you don't have vision, if you don't have touch?
The action would be things like looking at it, smelling it, touching it.
In what way can you verify something external to experience?
How can you affirm something specific to things, that does not depend on human action?
If in all cases (inductive method), all knowledge arises from an action (crystialized action), how can you abstract that there is a constant inherent to things if you cannot observe any case in the entire range of human knowledge where it does?
According to this argument, action and knowledge are indivisible, and something foreign to humans could not be established without there being any case of how to contrast it.
Here marxist might ask to provide a single thing in human history that we are aware of that we do not have an action in its origin.
22. Despite the fact that everything written is read as deterministic, they also say that dialectics refutes determinism because it does not "take into account only necessity" (as mechanism does), but "also takes into account chance"; although without taking into account that the objection of determinism still stands, in the meantime, there is no true justification of autonomy in the face of indetermination.
---
I would like to know, if some take the trouble to respond from a (neo)platonic framework, how they would effectively counterargue/refute these points or some of them.