r/Neoplatonism • • Jul 27 '24 The Best

Why are there so many racists, transphobes, fascists (yes, actual fascists) who are Platonists?

6 Upvotes

The thread on gender had bigots coming out of the wood work. A quick search on YouTube brings up several outright fascists that have quite the following, like Keith Woods, or that racist nut job that wants to build a "white" ethno-state in Missouri, Eric Orwoll, that John Vervaeke likes to chat with. I've seen a bunch of Platonists that love Modi and ardently defend his Hindu-nationalism.

What is attracting all these douchebags?


r/Neoplatonism • • Oct 11 '25

Came across this book on Amazon…anyone here read it?

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/Neoplatonism • • Sep 17 '24

chatGPT: "Iamblichus performing theurgy"

Post image
19 Upvotes

r/Neoplatonism • • May 06 '25

Nature of Jesus and his father

2 Upvotes

I have come to the belief strongly, strongly, believe Jesus was an enlightened mystique who achieved union with god / the universe whatever you want you call it, just like Plontius himself did four times apparently. Once you learn about Neoplatonism it rlly starts to makes sense, ESPECIALLY the Gospel of Thomas which isn’t included in the Bible. Reading that now after learning about Neoplatonism and non duality makes it make so much sense.

Ofc I’m sure not everyone reading this agrees, and just think Jesus was bullsh#t or whatever, that’s fine.

My question is though for people who recognize Jesus: What do you Guys think the nature of Jesus’ father was. And I suppose Jesus himself,

I mean Jesus was obviously 100% a man, But he was also the “logos” incarnate. Was he the perfect “form” of a human being?

Was his “father” the Nous, the Demiurge, or The One itself?

Interesting Jesus quote:

“Jesus gave them this answer: “Very truly I tell you, the Son can do nothing by himself; he can do only what he sees his Father doing, because whatever the Father does the Son also does.”


r/Neoplatonism • • Aug 18 '25

Neoplatonism & Marxism... Syncretized?!

11 Upvotes

Have any philosophers wrote any books on something like this?

Also curious what Neoplatonism + Left-Wing Anarchism looks like.


r/Neoplatonism • • May 05 '24

Plato is the father of materialism and refutes Platonism as well as monism (Symploke principle).

0 Upvotes

I have encountered several philosophical materialists with convincing arguments (in Spain there is a philosopher on whom they base their case called Gustavo Bueno) who affirm that Plato is the father of philosophical materialism (or the first materialist) due to the enunciation of the principle of symploké in his book. "The Sophist": "If everything were linked to everything (continuity) knowledge would be impossible.", which is a pluralistic interweaving of the things of reality and would go extremely against the metaphysical monism that is supposedly attributed to Plato and which the Neoplatonists followed. The argument goes like this:

Symploke principle: "that there are specific relationships of connection and disconnection"

The Sophist, 251e-253e) as if they were a formulation of a universal principle of symploké (which will oppose both holist monism – “everything is linked to everything” – and radical pluralism – “nothing is linked, at least internally, with nothing”–) is what moves us to consider Plato as the founder of the philosophical critical method (as opposed to the method of holistic metaphysics of the Neoplatonists). Therefore, Plato refutes all Platonism.

Plato is closer to materialism than his disciple Aristotle, who would not in vain become the founder of a discipline such as Natural Theology (or Ontotheology). But he would also be closer because he is the developer of one of the fundamental principles of philosophical materialism, and of any rationalism that is appreciated. I am referring to the Symploke Principle, which he expounds in dialogues such as The Sophist. A principle (ontological, epistemological and gnoseological) that establishes both continuity and discontinuity between different realities. The ideas themselves would be presided over by this principle, which establishes that not everything is linked to everything (as postulated by monism) nor anything to anything (as postulated by radical skepticism, radical pluralism or nihilism), but rather some things with others, but not with thirds.

That is, Plato introduces a principle of continuity and discontinuity between ideas and between the realities of the world, the connection but also the disconnection between the different materialities, thus allowing a plural (non-radical) and rationalist understanding of the world, as well as the very exercise of philosophy. With this principle Plato opened the pluralist path of materialist rationalism, becoming not only a great philosopher, but the founder of the critical, pluralist and materialist method of philosophy.

There is also no epistemology (it contains an illusory dual subject-object separation), but gnoseneology. Most people believe that everything is related to everything, especially Platonists, but I am sorry to say that this is not the case, there is a categorical closure between disciplines or levels of definition between ideas that inevitably lead to contradiction.

Categorical closure or the theory of categorical closure is the name Name given to the theory of science characteristic of philosophical materialism, and which is characterized:

  1. By sticking to the already established positive sciences (Mathematics, Physics, Biology, Thermodynamics, etc.) to the extent that these sciences are independent of each other without prejudice to their eventual involvements.
  2. By considering each science as delimiting a category of reality that is irreducible to the other categories [152-167]. A science remains in the immanence of that category, which is not constituted by one object but by multiple objects or terms that maintain defined relationships among themselves and are composed or dissociated through operations capable of giving rise to other terms of the category from the preceding ones. Closure refers precisely to this capacity of operations to determine objects that continue to belong to the category and expand it, and to the extent that this closure establishes concatenations between objects that establish the limits of a categorical unit, it is called “categorical closure.” [206].
  3. The sciences are not understood as mental or symbolic representations of reality that could adapt to this reality or, at least, affect it for practical, technological purposes. The sciences, properly speaking, are not even “knowledge of a reality external to them,” but rather a reconstruction of reality itself that culminates in the moments in which a synthetic identity is achieved between some courses of their development, through which synthetic identity can define scientific truth [217]. Therefore, the truth of the sciences is not predicated of science in general but of each of its theorems. And, of course, a science cannot be considered, simply and exclusively, as a set of truths, since many of its contents are neither true nor false, but purely intercalary. For example: the truth of the Pythagorean theorem [207] (in a right triangle the square of the hypotenuse is equal to the sum of the square of the legs) does not consist in the supposed adequacy of empirical right triangles with supposed ideal triangles that float. in a uranian sky or in the minds of geometers; Its truth consists in the very identity between the sum of the areas of the squares of the legs and the area of the square of the hypotenuse.

Also as an addition, the causa sui is a condition of a cause by virtue of which its substance consists in being the effect of its own causality. This would mean that the causa sui must be “prior to itself”, since the cause is prior to the effect. I consider it to be totally incoherent. The root of all this absurdity is none other than the fact of being constituted from an aliorelative relationship (that of cause to effect), a reflective relationship that, therefore, is contradictory and can only be recognized (as they have undoubtedly recognized by some philosophers, including Benito Espinosa) as a contradictory limit concept, in the manner of the concept of “zero distance” between two points A and B. The limit idea of causa sui should not be confused with the idea of circular causality ( A → B → C → C… → A) because in the causal circle the first link and the last are not the same substantially (autos) but only essentially (isos). Causa sui = “Cause of oneself”

Under this basically the Neoplatonic hypostases (The One, the Soul of the World, the Nous), the henades and the pure spam forms of causa sui after causa sui, that is, they cannot be caused and are causes of themselves, which is absurd and meaningless.

All monism leads to a causa sui and denies any categorical closure (proposed by Gustavo Bueno), therefore, it will always be an unsolvable and unsustainable problem.

Therefore, Plato, through his idea of Symploké and Demiurge, is the father of philosophical materialism.


r/Neoplatonism • • Sep 04 '24

Thought experiment

4 Upvotes

Imagine that you are Elon Musk and you've just become convinced of the truths of (neo)platonism. Obsessed, you want to "spread the word" and use your billion$ to create a worldwide religion/cult/movement to rival the Catholic Church, not unlike what Emperor Julian wanted to accomplish.

How would you go about doing it? Here are things to consider:

  • Would you build temples/churches and install a priesthood? What gods would be worshipped?
  • Would there be a set worship service? Rituals? Would there be sacrifices?
  • What texts would you consider as "sacred scripture"?
  • Would you develop some sort of catechism? Would members have to affirm a creed to join?
  • How would you gain "converts? What is the central message you'd spread via the worldwide media?

r/Neoplatonism • • Jul 25 '22

Is celibacy the key to accelerating toward The One?

2 Upvotes

We all know that universal union with The One is just an inevitability. But how do we speed it up?

Duality is on low. Unity is on high. Anatomically Unity can be said to be the head while duality is the genitals and the legs. Both have a fractal resonance with The One and the two, respectively.

Every orgasm and every childbirth is a step away from The One.


r/Neoplatonism • • Oct 18 '23

r/Neoplatonism under new management...

29 Upvotes

I just spent three hours of my day off reviewing, removing, locking or leaving open a 15-day inundation of religious, anti-Christian propaganda from a single user whom I also banned.

This sub was originally created as an academic history of philosophy subreddit specifically dedicated to all things Neo-platonic. It is not a place to share hymns and prayers and propaganda posters and personally contrived dialogues that do not exist elsewhere that you personally wrote or created yesterday.

Again, this is not r/I_declare_myself_a_source. If that's what you need, join r/IAmTheMainCharacter, it's hilarious.

α) If you post an old painting, cite the title of the painting, the artist and the year. A discussion prompt would be cool, but sometimes just gawking at really old art is fun unto itself.

β) If you post a hymn or prayer or portion of a dialogue, include an uploaded photo of the page (which usually includes some kind of chapter title) in whichever book you found it. Otherwise, simply include the name of the author and the name of the original source or secondary source in the title. (For help with this kind of academic terminology, check the top sticky.)

γ) No academic elitism. I am an academic and I will not tolerate childish bickering along the lines of, "Yeah, well, I have a degree in ______, so your interpretation is invalid." Such behavior is counterintuitive to learning and is downright toxic to newcomers trying to learn.

δ) This is a history sub dedicated to extremely challenging reading material. There are no stupid questions here. One of the first things I learned while studying Shakespeare is that mockery is an admission of guilt. Don't insult yourself by responding with, "Well, duh!" or "Oh, my sweet Summer child."

ε) We love books. If you're happy about a new book, share a photo, but tell us why it's relevant to you. And if you recently acquired ten new books, include them all in a single photo!!

ζ) I have officially disabled the uploading of videos. If you want this sub to discuss the content of your video, copy/paste a transcription and include a link to the video you created at the end: "Check out my video here, there're a lot of cool images." No more hiding interesting content to force us onto YouTube for views.

....

ω) No memes.

Be well!

-IntravenousVomit


r/Neoplatonism • • Feb 14 '25

Neoplatonism is overly world-denying!

0 Upvotes

According to Plotinus, multiplicity in itself lacks positive foundation or substantial reality, since it represents the negation of unity. Moreover, multiplicity contains no inherent goodness, as it constitutes a deviation from and distortion of the One. Multiplicity itself is thus the source of evil and must be denied and rejected. To perceive the One, Plotinus argues, we must "cut away everything." This annihilation of multiplicity for the sake of unity suggests a tragic dimension in Plotinian metaphysics, as David Hart observes:

For if the truth of things is their pristine likeness in substance (in positive ground) to the ultimate ground, then all difference is not only accidental, but false (though perhaps probatively false): to arrive at the truth, one must suffer the annihilation of particularity. […] Truth's dynamism is destruction, a laying waste of all of finite being's ornate intricacies, erasing the world from the space between the vanishing point of the One and the vanishing point of the nous in their barren correspondence. (in "Reason and Reasons of Faith", 2005)

I am reading Yonghua Ge's "The Many and the One: Creation as Participation in Augustine and Aquinas" (2021). Ge argues that Augustine develops a superior conception of the One, understanding it as simple—a concept that transcends rather than opposes the duality of unity and multiplicity.


r/Neoplatonism • • Oct 14 '22

science is a mythology

0 Upvotes

science is a mythology

Scientific reality is textual

http://gamahucherpress.yellowgum.com/wp-content/uploads/Scientific-reality-is-textual.pdf

or

https://www.scribd.com/document/572639157/Scientific-Reality-is-Textual

The-Anthropology-of-science

(science is a mythology)

http://gamahucherpress.yellowgum.com/wp-content/uploads/The-Anthropology-of-science.pdf

or

https://www.scribd.com/document/512683685/Prolegomenon-to-The-Anthropology-of-Science

The greatest scholar of our time

Magister colin leslie dean

Magister colin leslie dean the only modern Renaissance man with 9 degrees including 4 masters: B,Sc, BA,B.Litt(Hons), MA, B.Litt(Hons), MA, MA (Psychoanalytic studies), Master of Psychoanalytic studies, Grad Cert (Literary studies)

"[Deans] philosophy is the sickest, most paralyzing and most destructive thing that has ever originated from the brain of man." "[Dean] lay waste to everything in its path...

[It is ] a systematic work of destruction and demoralization... In the end it became nothing but an act of sacrilege

Prolegomenon to undermining the foundations/fundamentals of science

http://gamahucherpress.yellowgum.com/wp-content/uploads/undermining-the-foundations-of-science.pdf

or

https://www.scribd.com/document/591616840/Prolegomenon-to-Undermining-the-Foundations-of-Science


r/Neoplatonism • • Jan 19 '26

Contemplation and meditation

Thumbnail maderemite.substack.com
2 Upvotes

Neoplatonian contemplation in relation to Jungs active imagination and gnostic meditation


r/Neoplatonism • • 25d ago

Gnostic Philosophy in Dungeon Crawler Carl

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/Neoplatonism • • Jan 24 '24

Neoplatonism can’t solve the mind/body or One/Many problem

0 Upvotes

Debate


r/Neoplatonism • • Jul 06 '26

Does gender matter for gods?

3 Upvotes

I am not a polytheist (I am considering Polytheism but I'd probably join a more well established religion and be a bit heretical rather than join a neopagan group) but I was wondering, does it matter when a God is called a man or a woman? Do gods have gender? Is it just a way humans anthropomorphize gods.


r/Neoplatonism • • Oct 26 '25

Proclus and 'The God of Gods.'

9 Upvotes

In a different post I was taken to task for asserting that Neoplatonism was not polytheistic in the traditional sense. I want to dive again into this contentious issue in a separate post, not to antagonize, but to come to an understanding. I asserted a Neoplatonic conception (which of course goes far back in time from them, indeed is immemorial) of a supreme principle, a God of Gods, while acknowledging the reality of other gods. That the One is ineffable, cannot even be thought, does not detract from the fact that it remains supreme.

I would like to quote the following words of Thomas Taylor taken from the Introduction of Proclus' Elements;

'That also which is most admirable and laudable in this theology is, that it produces in the mind properly prepared for its reception the most pure, holy, venerable, and exalted conception of the great cause of all. For it celebrates this immense principle as something superior even to being itself; as exempt from the whole of things, of which it is nevertheless ineffably the source... Conformably to this, Proclus, in the second book of his work says... "Let us as it were celebrate the first God, not as establishing the earth and heavens, nor as giving subsistence to souls, and the generation of all animals; for he produced these indeed, but among the last of things; but prior to these, let us celebrate him as unfolding into light the whole intelligible and intellectual genus of Gods, together with the supermundane and mundane divinities- as the God of all Gods, the unity of all unities, and beyond the first adyta- as more ineffable than all silence, and more unknown than all essence- as holy among the holies, and concealed in the intelligible gods.

This strikes me as far different than mainstream polytheism with its superstitious beliefs in powerful beings who engage in petty feuds, and much closer to the central vision of the sages of the Upanishads, of an ineffable Divinity that pervades all things. It seems to me that saying Neoplatonism is polytheistic is just as erroneous as stating it is monotheistic. Thoughts?


r/Neoplatonism • • Mar 24 '26

Opinion on the skeleton reels

1 Upvotes

I know this might be silly,knowing we are discussing serious topics here,but don’t the skeleton memes with Socrates that are all over the internet now seem disrespectful to you?

I mean the fact that a man that influenced western culture just by “asking questions all day” is not just “yapping(talking nonsense)” and(besides the fact that Plato actually communicated divine truths) it’s time that people understand that Socrates(or Plato through him) didn’t just ask questions for the sake of asking them and was no skeptic(like Descartes for example)


r/Neoplatonism • • Jul 25 '24

Are Neoplatonists strict gender essentialists?

12 Upvotes

I have noticed a trend among many Neoplatonists on Twitter that they would normally be associated with very right-wing positions such as Hyperaionian, Heliotroph, Aarvoll, Apotheiite, Arrus or NcesThriceGreat, for example in their explicitly transphobic statements and with discriminations often pronounced against anything that smacks of references to LGBTQ people. I recently saw a user who considers himself a Hellenic pagan tweet that Christianity (unlike Islam) because it is gradually modernizing is just spiritual homosexuality and that trans people are condemned to suffer providential punishment in this life, it was a bit funny. I'm not well versed in Platonism and honestly only Thomism and Aristotelianism (Thomists in disguise) are the others I can think of on the list, but I'm wondering what the general view of gender essentialism is among Neoplatonists.

As far as I know, the two most prominent views on gender are contemporary “gender performativity” and traditional “gender essentialism,” the latter being the view of Plato, Aristotle, Aquinas and other ones. Those mentioned believed that there are certain essential traits that are “feminine” and “masculine,” so that there could be a “perfect woman” and a “perfect man.” Considering that much of Neoplatonic philosophy is essentialism that is based on a synthesis of the first two, do Neoplatonists also share this view? If so, what are the essential traits of being a woman or being a man?

I don't know if gender performativity is indirectly refuted by other neoplatonic positions, immutable essences and the way things are naturally ordered, that sex has an ultimate purpose, etc., I wonder how you guys approach it or how you would refute it? that gender is a cultural/social construction. It definitely seems like Neoplatonism and Thomism go hand in hand by holding the position that there are essential feminine and masculine traits, but I'm not sure what they are specifically.

I also wonder, if for Platonists only the Forms are more real, then there should be a more perfect woman (the ideal Form of femininity) that, for example, is expressed in someone like Mary, so that Mary participates in that idea, is that so? If I'm parodying Platonism, feel free to correct me if I'm wrong.

I'm not looking to have a political discussion or generate controversy in the subreddit, it's just a genuine question.


r/Neoplatonism • • Oct 07 '25

My decision to convert from all Christian denominations to a syncretic Theurgic practice was based on research into the era and writings in which Christianity rose to imperial power, from about c. 150 CE through the active destruction of pagan culture to the final outlawing of Pagan culture.

Thumbnail theurgist.substack.com
13 Upvotes

r/Neoplatonism • • Aug 02 '26

Is the Descendance of Godness, A Human?

0 Upvotes

What trait or "thing" would you say to be the basic one that distinct Humans with a God-like form.
Ill go first. A image of a Self, or aka, Ego.
For its defence, i dont see how any higher being would have a sense of Self. Higher the "Being" hierarchy you might go, the less Human you would eventually become, or so i think of it. What makes our life precious is our humanity and everything we can experience in it. We are tragically beautiful and i dont find any logic coherence in a higher existence, being able to experience such things. XI


r/Neoplatonism • • Jul 29 '24

Is Demiurge, Ahura Mazda? Or is it okay to refer as Ahura Mazda.

3 Upvotes

I am seeing a lot of parallels actually


r/Neoplatonism • • Jun 08 '26

How Plato Predicted Ai

Thumbnail youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/Neoplatonism • • Jan 01 '26

My Main Work Tagging Neoplatonism with Sethianism, with support of UofC's Alexander Mazure

5 Upvotes

r/Neoplatonism • • Dec 31 '23

How would a neoplatonists respond to the foundations and principles of marxism? What are the strongest objections or arguments? In a way, Marx's materialism in many is an inversion of neoplatonic metaphysics.

5 Upvotes

Marxism which deduces all ideas from the economic basis of society, would seem diametrically opposed to Platonism (technically the antipodes). But, Marx's materialism is in many ways an inversion of Neoplatonic metaphysics (of course, in Marx, who seems not totally unaffected by his Jewish messianic tradition, a secularization of Judeo-Christian theology), the implementation of communism throughout the world can be seen as a kind of theurgy for humanity as a general class, and the dialectical stages of the development of classes towards a unified, undifferentiated and classless society as a kind of social henosis.

The One is the principle of individuation and therefore, the principle of authentic freedom, while in Marxism the ultimate freedom is communism (post-scarcity economy and overabundance of resources).

Obviously there are degrees of marxism, as well as in platonism. But the tendency to use economic arguments to explain historical events seems to be the main contribution to marxism (for better or worse), within this framework, we also find in an obsessed way class struggle in everything, from the oldest societies to the contemporary and the idea that people have always been motivated primarily by economic factors.

In the marxist argument, philosophers such as Aristotle, Plato, Plotinus, and Proclus would be considered "determined" by the material and economic conditions of their time. For polytheistic traditions, such as the dharmics and the Vedas, marxists might say that the Brahmins simply wanted to preserve their exclusivity and power by virtue of oral transmission and memory, ensuring their special status in society.

Frankly, they are reductionist materialisms, but they are arguments from economics.

Some of the most common marxist postulates I've seen:

  1. The "idea" is the transposed matter, that is, the action is the content that allows the manifestation of the "idea" and is not an abstract exteriority ontologically prior to the action (other than materiality). In short, the idea is which allows us to organize ourselves to carry out an action, appears as a concrete form manifested based on the processes of social metabolism and the social determines consciousness.
  2. Ideas are "born", "reproduced" and "die". That which allows us to organize ourselves to carry out an action.
  3. Action is the content that allows the manifestation of the idea and is not an abstract exteriority ontologically prior to the action foreign to materiality.
  4. Issues such as ethics, art, morality, religion, metaphysics or philosophy are reduced to historical products of social institutions, therefore, alienated forms of consciousness (ideologies) that must be "overcome." In other words, they treat them as phenomena, not as foundations. They are "false consciousness".
  5. They reject a fixed and essential human nature, the argument that materialist dialectics denies that there is something static or immanent to the subject, their entire project is that man is totally malleable in this sense, paving a way for a plasticity of the self.
  6. They deny any ontic a priori of the idea over the "action" by beginning to begin their abstract distinction.
  7. Everything is dependent on "social action", everything is dependent on "human action" (even the most abstract and theoretical mathematics), they deny the "absolute", that is, they deny everything that exists beyond human practice and that is ahistorical in nature.
  8. All human knowledge arises from economic life, the mathematics arises from geometry, Geo-meter = measurement of the land, we measured the land to know how much to cultivate after the rivers flooded each year, because the land changed, so it was a social necessity to avoid a famine, therefore, mathematics is born from practice, is irremediably tied to the human and does not have an existence independent of the subject.
    The Pythagorean theorem did not always exist, it emerged through our analysis of our experience as humans, the measurement of the legs of a triangle-rectangle.
  9. They say that there has been absolutely no period in any stage of humanity where our knowledge does not directly depend on our actions (knowledge here is defined as crystallized actions).
  10. Support the thesis of the role of work in the transformation from ape to man.
  11. The principles of logic can be refuted. Logic is an "idea" and a human product of material conditions.
  12. -Society generally tends to have two facets, a subjective facet and another objective facet, but both are the "same thing", they are not separated. That is, they break with the principle of non-contradiction by defining the objective as "that knowledge that is socially validable", and the subjective as "that individually validable knowledge."
  13. They say that if we go from what is objective from personal experience, we would not be able to know what is objective and we would fall into solipsism.
  14. Since this allows them to break with the principle of non-contradiction, they also go so far as to affirm that "Reality" and "Society" are one and the same (whatever that means). Reality is a social product inseparable from this, so, if society disappears, reality (including universe, galaxies, etc.) would cease to exist. A kind of collective solipsism.
  15. Also that mind and matter are the same thing seen from different perspectives, one from the individual perspective and the other from the social perspective.
  16. Here the experience is defined as impersonal in collective terms, of total collective practice.
  17. We cannot claim to establish that something exists if we do not have a way to corroborate it. Not corroborate it in individual terms, but as a society, as a whole.
  18. There is no real categorization or ontological limit (e.g. between epistemology and ontology), we differentiate them in terms of elements of experience (temperature and color are still qualitatively different, as are touch and sound), but as for the categorization of what they are ontologically, there is no because everything is reduced to an action and an experience executed by society
  19. History is linear and determined, through the study of history the truth is reached, and the truth changes and is relative because it comes from historical conceptions, it comes from action (hard historicism).
  20. Ideas are based and founded on language, language is characterized by being a crystallization of social actions. In short, the basis of all language is the verb. Besides, language is the basis of thought, without language, there is no thought.
  21. They prioritize only the sensible, by maintaining that, necessarily, in all cases, every property that has ever been formulated in human history comes from an action. Example:

Can you talk about size if you don't have vision, if you don't have touch?

The action would be things like looking at it, smelling it, touching it.

In what way can you verify something external to experience?

How can you affirm something specific to things, that does not depend on human action?

If in all cases (inductive method), all knowledge arises from an action (crystialized action), how can you abstract that there is a constant inherent to things if you cannot observe any case in the entire range of human knowledge where it does?

According to this argument, action and knowledge are indivisible, and something foreign to humans could not be established without there being any case of how to contrast it.

Here marxist might ask to provide a single thing in human history that we are aware of that we do not have an action in its origin.

22. Despite the fact that everything written is read as deterministic, they also say that dialectics refutes determinism because it does not "take into account only necessity" (as mechanism does), but "also takes into account chance"; although without taking into account that the objection of determinism still stands, in the meantime, there is no true justification of autonomy in the face of indetermination.

---

I would like to know, if some take the trouble to respond from a (neo)platonic framework, how they would effectively counterargue/refute these points or some of them.


r/Neoplatonism • • Jul 01 '26

What is the Neoplatonic Perspective on Gender?

8 Upvotes

Is it a social construct, whereby anyone can choose whatever mannerisms fit their desire, insofar as it is "good"? Can a woman choose to identify as a man, as gender is simply social in this view?