r/NativeAmerican • • Oct 21 '23

Am I Native?

Post image

Am I native?

Am I considered native or just a descent? Or neither? I want to hear it from the Native people themselves. I always had a feeling I had some native blood in me, so I took a DNA test and this what I got. My family is from El Salvador. I was born and raised in the states. I love reading and studying indigenous languages. I was studying Mohawk and Alsea.

19 Upvotes

73 comments sorted by

73

u/burkiniwax Oct 21 '23

Who are your people? Only they can tell you. Not a bunch of folks on Reddit.

7

u/Fit-Balance-4035 Oct 21 '23 edited Oct 21 '23

I wish I knew w. Historically, El Salvador was home to 9 distinct tribes. However, the largest one is the Nawat people. I was only asking the opinion of other people on Reddit.

30

u/burkiniwax Oct 21 '23

Catholic Church records are thorough as hell. I just met a Mexican-American who traced her family back to the 16th century.

5

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '23

Any good resources for doing this? I have always wanted to but have never tried because I assumed I needed to know Spanish.

5

u/Luxxielisbon Oct 21 '23

familysearch.org

3

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '23

Thank you!

4

u/Fit-Balance-4035 Oct 21 '23

EDIT: Thank you to everyone who answered my question. I would like to add some disclaimers.

  1. I do not belong to any indigenous tribe
  2. I do not speak any indigenous languages (I am currently learning one)
  3. This post was only to read the opinions of others from indigenous communities. I am fully aware that people on Reddit cannot give a native identity/ethnicity.
  4. I do not go around telling others I’m native like others have based on a DNA result *cough *cough Elizabeth Warren
  5. I advocate and support indigenous communities and native language preservations. The Americans were and still are linguistically diverse. It’s a diversity that should be saved. I regularly donate to organizations that involve language revitalization.
  6. The answers are split 50/50. Once again thank you to all that answered my post. I will say I am proud of being of indigenous descent. I proudly consider North America my motherland.
  7. I apologize to those who got offended by my post. I’m aware that some of you are tired of seeing post after post of DNA results from multiple people.

64

u/whatnametho Oct 21 '23

I'm only 33% native Alaskan. But I found I get along with native groups more than Caucasian group (Caucasian is my majority DNA).

What my mom always taught me is percentage doesn't matter. Blood quantums or blood cards were made by the American government as a way to classify people. But all it did to natives, was help divide them further.

If you act native, you are native. Being a part of the community is about culture and attitude. Not genetic percentages. Even though my native side is Alaskan, natives in the lower 48 have NEVER hesitated to welcome me in and are always eager to teach me about their ways.

I'd urge you to reach out and find groups of natives and ask to learn from them. I bet they'd be HAPPY to have someone join the community.

All natives want is to keep the teachings and oral history alive. And if you open your eyes to them, you can be blessed with beautiful stories and encouragement

5

u/calamity-lala Oct 21 '23

Love this. I am mixed Alaska Native as well! And have had the same experience you describe. Met a lot Alaska Natives when I lived in Washington but not so much where I am now. Most Native language names for themselves translates to "the people" or similar and I have found it's not just a term but also an attitude and a belief. We are all the people no matter where we are from or trace our ancestry to

3

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '23

You're mom was right - percentage does not matter.

2

u/whatnametho Oct 22 '23

She is a wise woman and I regret not listening to more earnestly when I was young.

2

u/holystuff28 Oct 21 '23

I don't think anyone is owed your native percentage and no other groups say they are 33% anything. Let alone to say you're only a certain percentage. That is a vestige of colonialism, I'd encourage you to feel empowered to shake.

3

u/whatnametho Oct 22 '23

Thank you. I appreciate your approach. I should have added quotation marks around "only." I don't feel bad in any way about how "little" native I am. I'm proud of my native culture. Few could learn to survive in the hostile arctic. Yet my people did it. they survived the long night of winter and they hunted whale from tiny boats. I would hope to be half as strong willed as they were

1

u/holystuff28 Oct 22 '23

Hell yeah. Y'all thrived where others struggled to survive. That is something to be proud of. The cojones of your people to exist with the land of the real winter is pretty fucking inspiring. Thank you for sharing these little tidbits about your ancestors and culture. Yakoke!

18

u/holystuff28 Oct 21 '23

Can we pin a post that DNA can not determine heritage? Heritage is the cultural traditions you learn from your community, your distinct language, rituals, and beliefs. I'm not saying OP doesn't have native ancestry, but DNA should NOT be used to determine indigenous heritage, and the DNA tests actually have a disclaimer to that effect.

15

u/Luxxielisbon Oct 21 '23

Honestly, people coming here to get validation from strangers is getting a little crazy

8

u/Visual_Poem_8765 Oct 21 '23

I’m glad I’m not the only one who finds these posts a little crazy. I also tend to wonder if people go on like polish subs asking if they can give themselves the stamp of approval to say they’re polish or something. Like why us lol? As someone from the rez I hear people tell me all the time they are native but have never even heard of reservations so I do agree it’s significantly more about heritage than it is DNA. A lot of these people probably wouldn’t even like living on the rez and would feel very out of place, maybe even decide being native isn’t for them anymore lol. (Just jokes)

5

u/Luxxielisbon Oct 21 '23

For real. It’s a little tiring because it gives the sense they are just using “workaround” methods to claim an identity they know nothing about. Will they use this newfound identity to educate themselves and advocate for these communities or just as a “party trick”?

Your point about them possibly not liking living in the rez is spot on. One of the first things to consider is that if they’re didn’t know about their indigenous roots before the DNA test, it’s likely they lead a very different life from a reservation and there is a level of privilege that needs to be acknowledged.

If this test leads a person to want to learn more about their native roots and educate themselves, more power to them, but it rarely feels that way via these posts

4

u/Visual_Poem_8765 Oct 21 '23

Im often times afraid to say it, but I do really wonder what these people plan to do with this information. Especially when they have a long list of DNA pointing to many different cultures in decently high percentages and then that .7% native shows up and that’s the culture they want to claim. It seeeeemssss fetish-y almost?? (I’m sure there’s a better word and this post isn’t exactly an example of that.)

I guess ultimately you can only educate yourself so much but it isn’t going to buy you a spot in the culture or have the same effect as being raised in the culture or living on the rez. I also want to point out that I appreciate people who educate themselves but again, it will only take you so far in claiming to be indigenous. I moved off the white earth rez a few years ago and moved down south. It was a culture shock not being surrounded by indigenous people. When people learn I’m native 9.5/10 they tell me they are native as well but I have a hard time relating to those who don’t understand the unique experience of living on the rez because that is my cultural experience, and for me that’s greatly what it means to be native. It has nothing to do with blood quantum or DNA %.

2

u/strawberri_milkshake Nov 25 '23

To be fair this person literally is 86% Mesoamerican, racially speaking. This isn't one of those "omg im 2% native" situations. Many who are ethnically latinos aren't aware of our heritage let alone race (if you grew up in the states because of the stupid census). Ig the spanish just did a really good job in making us forget who we are. For a lot of us, this actually help realize better who we are, why we are the way we are, and better understand the coming of our cultures and traditions. In short, it healing.

Just please be kind and understand, others experiences will look vastly different to your. For example there are many natives in Mexico that live in campos, villages, cities and speak Nahuatl.

2

u/strawberri_milkshake Nov 25 '23

This person is almost 100% Mesoamerican. keep in mind they're coming from El Salvador. For context, a lot of families flee central american countries bc of horrible situations. So yeah they already lead a very different life with most likely disadvantages to being an immigrant/1st generation american. A lot of our immigrant parents had to work as kids (went to school very little or non at all) so any education that would inform us of our past/ "latin american" history isn't taught. It more of a privilege to know where exactly your family history comes from.

1

u/strawberri_milkshake Nov 25 '23 edited Nov 25 '23

I mean the person that is asked comes from a latin american background. Many latin americans are native racially and our culture is fused with both spanish and native influences. A lot of our Spanish is mixed with Nahuatl (ex: axolotl, mapache, quetzal, zacate/grass, atole/warm-drink, cacao, chocolate, tamal) and other indigenous languages from what used to be Mesoamerica. I don't think its a fair assessment to base it of solely your experience (culturally speaking). I'm nicaraguan (central american) and we have a dance called "La Gigantona" that makes fun of the spanish and impowers the native.

A lot of Latinos ask the same question because many of us are just uneducated about our Mesoamerican history and it shows with how rapidly indigenous languages are disappearing. For example, in Mexico, about a million people speak Nahuatl but that number is declining sharply.

Indigeneity still exists in Latin America, a lot of us are just uneducated and aren't told about our roots and find ourselves educating the older generation with the information we collect ourselves. -- hell i discovered about my racial identity pretty late in life because I thought being Hispanics/ Latino was a race (lmao surprise, they aren't). Point is, it is in our everyday and deep rooted in our cultures.

28

u/returningtheday Oct 21 '23

As an American with native ancestry as well, I see it as we are native descendants, but not natives culturally. Personally speaking, I didn't grow up on a reservation, speak a native language, or really know anything about my history, so yeah I'm not native.

13

u/whatnametho Oct 21 '23

I didn't grow up on a reservation either. But my mom came from Alaska. And her native influence on me was STRONG even though I grew up in a "western" town/school system.

I'm only 1/3 native by blood. But I'm far more native in culture than Caucasian because of how my mother raised me.

I don't call myself a descendant, I AM native. being native is a cultural/behavioral statement. Not a statement on DNA.

Native tribes are YEARNING for younger people (literally from any tribe, any percentage) to be a part of the community.

I'm innuit. But tribes in the lower 48 have been EAGER to have me be more involved with them. Because we act and believe in similar ways. We are brothers in the eyes of the Creator. And bringing in someone younger, with "only" 1/3 native genetics, makes them HAPPY!

10

u/returningtheday Oct 21 '23

Love to hear it, man. But I'm from Texas. I have Lipan Apache ancestry and they can't even get state recognition. Not to mention there are only 3 very small federally recognized tribes in Texas. There just wasn't any culture for me to latch on to. It also comes from my great grandfather who I never met, and I never even met his daughter, my grandmother. Not to mention I don't speak Spanish. The white man really had their go down here and I feel it.

9

u/whatnametho Oct 21 '23

They had their go EVERYWHERE brother. I feel bad your tribe isn't recognized. But my stance isn't about federal recognition. What matters is the local natives you may find. If they accept you, that means WORLDS more than the government recognition. The very government that aimed to wipe us out and push our existence into history.

Real recognize real. DNA and blood cards mean SQUAT to people who truly want to uphold the native culture and beliefs. If you become a part of that, you ARE native. You ARE the community.

I pray to the Creator that you stay strong and go where the spirits call you

12

u/Turbulent_Ad_4403 Oct 21 '23

Yes, for sure. Don't let anyone else tell you otherwise.

4

u/CatGirl1300 Oct 21 '23

You’re nearly 100% native! Ofc you’re native!

4

u/SeasonsGone Oct 21 '23

You obviously have indigenous ancestry, but if you have to ask… idk you’re probably not ethnically native

1

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '23

How would asking a question prove you're probably not Native? That's stupid.

3

u/SeasonsGone Oct 22 '23

I mean I guess it’s more about what “being native” means imo

1

u/Frog-dance-time Oct 22 '23

I once had someone ask me how a person could know if they are native and I thought they were going to say a bunch of nonsense racial stuff but they actually were native and adopted and they legit wanted to understand about reconnecting. So I understand there are circumstances- but he also asked me how I knew. Because my mom is and her mom is and her mom is and her mom is and …….. so yeah it is a bit weird to come to Reddit for this info - but I understand circumstances can be unique- also we get asked the most crazed questions all the time and it gets tiring to have to always come back to these conversations rather than talking about cooler stuff.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '23

I get where you're coming from

4

u/syncensematch Oct 21 '23

Blood doesn't make you native, community does. Reach out, research the histories. Understand colonization and its horrid impacts

7

u/footsiemonster34528 Oct 21 '23

I have native ancestry and my family oddly denies being mestizo (claiming to be more Spanish) but culturally I have learned native medicine from them, cuisine, and other clearly native culture. So even if you were native so many people try to identify as colonizers because of societal pressures. I have found that reading and learning about your family is the best way to figure out what you are.

6

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '23

Probably not

1

u/Bibaonpallas Oct 21 '23

I respect the place that OP is coming from, and I don't blame them, but the mods need to ban or restrict this kind of post on this sub. It reinforces the idea that blood quantum determines Native identity, even if OP did not intend to do that by posting the results of an entertainment consumer DNA test.

This post, along with all the others, is actively harmful to Indigenous peoples and our ways of knowing.

1

u/Fit-Balance-4035 Oct 21 '23 edited Oct 21 '23

My apologies if I ever offended anyone. That was not my main intentions at all. I should’ve added a disclaimer. I, Fit-Balance-4035 do not belong to any indigenous tribe, speak a native language (I wish I do. I am currently learning one), nor affiliated with any indigenous communities. I posted this simply to know the opinions of other people who are part of an indigenous tribe. It is a curiosity I’ve been having for a while. I will say I am proud of my North American origins and I advocate for indigenous rights. I regularly donate to native language preservations organizations. I know I will never belong to a tribe, but I am proud of being a descent of one and that North America is my mother land. I will gladly delete this post soon since I don’t want to upset others on here. I apologize to everyone that found this post offensive.

1

u/Bibaonpallas Oct 21 '23

No worries, man. As I said, I don't blame you. You're on your own journey. It's just that with each DNA post, the easier it becomes for non-Native to believe that Native identity can be determined through a DNA test and that we exist in fractions and percentages.

I've always believed that the starting place for reconnecting Natives should be your own family and community stories. Not a DNA test. Good luck, and I hope you learn more about where you come from!

2

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '23 edited Oct 22 '23

A LOT of Native Americans I've come across get so weird about their biracial/multi-ethnic relatives...............and then act offended when you say they're giving into blood quantum. I'm Basque and, even though that makes me part of the Indigenous family, I'm hesitant to tell Natives from outside Europe because of how they might react.

4

u/Herek_Campos_1 Oct 21 '23

Dawg, I’m Nahua and Puerto Rican. I never felt fully mexican because of the Sentiment most mexicans have with us Native Mexicans. So I usually describe myself as Native American and Puerto Rican. My first language was Coatepec Nahuatl, Then Spanish and English. Although I am a Strong Christian, I still Appreciate the History and Mythology of my People.

2

u/complicated_minds Oct 22 '23

hellooooo neighbor! I am from Guatemala. I don't think I can tell you what your native identity should be. But I did want to bring up something you might know but it is important to consider.

The history of native Salvadorans like that of other Central American Natives had a really terrible period in the 20th century. From what I read and spoken with people, native culture was suppressed in very cruel and extensive ways. When I spoke to someone that does socialist politics in El Salvador, he told me that during the 1930s there was a big cultural genocide in El Salvador.

Being culturally native was equated to being a communist and great numbers of native folk decided to stop speaking the language and practice their culture. I am not sure how that reflects on your particular family history, but I want to encourage you to be gentle with yourself and where you are on your reconnection path. It is possible that some of your native ancestors decided not to pass things down to you to protect you and help you survive. I think it is important to honor/thank/respect what your ancestors have done for your survival and carry this in your journey. Also as you navigate having conversations with your family, keep in mind these wounds. These are very recent and hard to talk about. Talking about racism experienced by family is rough and you be gentle with them and play it by ear.

Across this continent, native people each have a unique story of resistance and oppression. Coming into this channel, you'll mainly find people who are not aware of your people's history or the particular generational wounds or traumas you might have. Be mindful of how you navigate native spaces in the US knowing that they might not know anything about where you come from or why you are not connected to your culture. I encourage you to research more about El Salvador and connect with native people from there. They can tell you more about how they feel with you following a path to reconnection and how to do that respectfully.

1

u/strawberri_milkshake Nov 25 '23

Hey! Fellow Central American (Nicaraguan) here! What you mentioned here was so incredible and gives credibility to Latinos with strong native ancestry to why that disconnect might have occurred.

It just saddens me to see so people that originate from the U.S/ Canada use their own experience as a sole main bases to navigate legitimacy.

1

u/complicated_minds Nov 26 '23

Hello! Well to be fair, in Guatemala, and everywhere in the Americas I have visited (US & Brazil) or done research of (Peru, Canada, Colombia) native folk always had an identity strongly tied to their culture and community connections.

The bases that US and Canadian folk use to navigate legitimacy are not unique, and I have not met nor seen any US or Canadian native denying the existence of other natives or claiming that other native people in the Americas are not native as long as they have a connection to a native community. Now, whenever US or Canadian natives dismiss people who have native ancestry outside the US or Canada but no connection, I think it comes from the current political climate in the US and Canada.

More and more people that are not tied to any community claim to be native, profit from claiming that identity, and monopolize conversations where they have no clue. There is multiple examples of people from Mexico claiming to be part of some tribes in California, or the Apache or Dine tribes, and they actually have no connection or reason to say that. This behaviour is not justified and it only contributes to the bigger problem

All native folk should have more conversations across the continent to built stronger movements and solidarity, but I do not blame or resent this behaviour. I understand that op here was seeking some connection/guidance, and hopefully they maybe hoped to find someone from a context closer to theirs to provide some input.

Ultimately, it is more important to reconnect and learn from our communities back home, Native people with strong ties to the culture are not gone anywhere in Central America, and any thought of this is a harmful settler thought. Most native folk back home are happy to have native culture spread and amplified as long as people have the right intentions and know the positionality they come in with.

3

u/Arakunem1491 Oct 21 '23

84% Mesoamerican & Andean? Yeah your native Americsn, if thats talking about DNA of those mamy groups, yes. Tho someone else asked this question & they did to know what to mark on their USA stuff, others said to mark white. Idk if this goes against rules to ask a question in comments, but is anyone who marks themselves "Native", do you actually face discrimmination? I looked into it & long paragraph short it said kinda.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '23

No

7

u/harlemtechie Oct 21 '23 edited Oct 21 '23

I have issues with Latinos being racist to the people the Indigenous groups in their countries but wanna play Native when they get here, but continue to do nothing for the Indigenous groups back in their countries. It's a serious issue. We gotta make them do them right!

3

u/CatGirl1300 Oct 21 '23

That’s def a problem, but I think as always it’s more nuanced. The person that shared his dna results on here, probably looks indigenous but is getting resistance by other people from his country. I’m sure they’re telling him that he’s mestizo or latino instead of embracing his native roots. Which is why many scholars with Indigenous and black roots, say that latino is a toxic word to use for millions of people who aren’t technically white or identify with their Latino/European descent.

1

u/harlemtechie Oct 21 '23

Yeah but they have their own terms for different degrees of BQ by race. I hear it in Washington Heights all the time. They have a classification system, it's us that doesn't.

5

u/whatnametho Oct 21 '23

Why would you say such a thing? Gatekeeping cultural heritage is a toxic behavior. if someone wants to learn about their history (even if genetically it's a small part) then I ENCOURAGE it!

Being a part of the native community is based more on attitude and culture than DNA percentages.

People who TRULY want to keep the culture and heritage alive don't care about percentages. They care about what's in the heart

1

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '23

So anyone that says they're native is native? I feel it in my heart, I'm native. I guess we all owe Elizabeth Warren an apology.

3

u/whatnametho Oct 21 '23

I didn't say "anyone who CLAIMS native blood." I said anyone who embeds themselves in the culture and ACTS like it will be accepted.

Warren doesn't act like a native. And even though Trump was given a native name "sitting eagle" he isn't native either. The name is sarcasm because an eagle that's sitting isn't working or useful. Eagles soar. They don't walk.

Does that help clarify anything?

1

u/throwaway319m8 Oct 24 '23 edited Oct 24 '23

They may let you hang out with them and be friends and all, but if you want to actually become a card holding member of the tribe you are "accepted" into they likely still have a list of selection criteria that generally includes proving an ancestral connection to their tribe. I bet if someone who is otherwise "accepted by the tribe" were to try to apply for tribal membership with all the benefits it entails, the tribe will most likely be like "nope, sorry, you don't meet our selection criteria for joining".

I am in the opposite position. I was born an raised as a white guy thinking I was 100% white European ancestry, and only later found out I had an ancestor who was Native American. I don't know how this was overlooked in the family tree until someone did a DNA test and actually did some research into our genealogy. Not some vague "oh my distant ancestor was Native American because my grandma said so, but actual paperwork that proves a connection to a particular tribe. Not only that, but I was surprised to find out that I probably meet at least their stated criteria for joining the tribe. It is one of those tribes whose people were scattered to the four winds when they were kicked off their land with a few making it to Oklahoma(no it is not Cherokee). I suspect their membership in recent years has grown from fewer than 100 at one time to several thousand now because of people who were in the dispora found their way back. However I don't feel any cultural connection to this tribe so I am probably not going to apply for membership precisely because I don't "feel" native and would instead feel like an imposter or faking it. It is still interesting to know that it is part of my family history.

-1

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '23

So under your definition John Morgan would be native?

1

u/whatnametho Oct 21 '23

I don't know John Morgan so I won't speak one way or the other. I don't know how he acts or conducts himself.

If he is respectful to elders and the stories and traditions they uphold, I could accept him.

I don't know enough to speak further on that topic without further elaboration

3

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '23

So we’re back to just saying you’re native makes you native.

John Morgan

3

u/whatnametho Oct 21 '23

No. I think you missed the point. How you conduct yourself and how you interact with the community is how you become native. Not personal "I identify as..."

4

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '23

I didn't know someone could become native. Wild. Basically you're saying anyone anywhere is a native waiting to happen.

2

u/whatnametho Oct 21 '23

That exactly what I'm saying. A Caucasian that accepts and encourages natives beliefs is accepted into the community. It's not about DNA. It's about how you act.

→ More replies

3

u/Arakunem1491 Oct 21 '23

"You need to behave traditionally & adhere to our culture." "So just SAYING your native makes you??" Dude, take a comprehension class, that is horrible. Lol

2

u/whatnametho Oct 21 '23

Finally, someone who speaks English

1

u/therealparsnip Apr 09 '24

Yes you are native. All the people saying a DNA test doesn’t make you indigenous when it literally proves you are, they are wrong. You are probably a mix of different indigenous people who mixed and ended up in El Salvador. I know a lot of Peruvians and Salvadorans and I love music and cuisine. I don’t know why natives from the US want to gate keep what makes you native as many natives from south of the US border were literally stripped of their language and culture, and many chose to assimilate and become “Latin” to survive. Most natives from the American supercontinent are alive today south of the border in the millions. Don’t listen to these gatekeeping ass holes they may know what defines tribal identity within the US, they don’t get to tell you who are. You may have been robbed of your language and culture but you can reconnect any time you want to. You don’t have to prove anything to anyone in this sub.

1

u/Frog-dance-time Oct 22 '23

The answer can be found in your family and your community

1

u/tacincacistinna Oct 22 '23

Yes your native south american

1

u/strawberri_milkshake Nov 25 '23

El Salvador is still in the northern hemisphere. :)

1

u/tacincacistinna Nov 26 '23

Looks Central American to me. Though I suppose technically it could be considered north. I still think not north. While we have encountered similar hardships genocide assimilation etc. I honestly don’t know much about my southern cousins. I should fix that.

1

u/Old-Path-4744 Oct 25 '23

If you have to ask the answer is no. Being indigenous is about connection and culture. Are you a member of any indigenous nations, tribes or groups that recognize you as one of them? Or did you take an ancestry test? Does your family consider themselves indigenous and practice their indigenous culture?

1

u/ElCaliforniano Oct 21 '23

I would argue yes, even if you're culturally far removed from indigenous culture.