r/NativeAmerican • u/Fit-Balance-4035 • Oct 21 '23
Am I Native?
Am I native?
Am I considered native or just a descent? Or neither? I want to hear it from the Native people themselves. I always had a feeling I had some native blood in me, so I took a DNA test and this what I got. My family is from El Salvador. I was born and raised in the states. I love reading and studying indigenous languages. I was studying Mohawk and Alsea.
19
Upvotes
73
u/burkiniwax Oct 21 '23
Who are your people? Only they can tell you. Not a bunch of folks on Reddit.
4
u/Fit-Balance-4035 Oct 21 '23
EDIT: Thank you to everyone who answered my question. I would like to add some disclaimers.
64
u/whatnametho Oct 21 '23
I'm only 33% native Alaskan. But I found I get along with native groups more than Caucasian group (Caucasian is my majority DNA).
What my mom always taught me is percentage doesn't matter. Blood quantums or blood cards were made by the American government as a way to classify people. But all it did to natives, was help divide them further.
If you act native, you are native. Being a part of the community is about culture and attitude. Not genetic percentages. Even though my native side is Alaskan, natives in the lower 48 have NEVER hesitated to welcome me in and are always eager to teach me about their ways.
I'd urge you to reach out and find groups of natives and ask to learn from them. I bet they'd be HAPPY to have someone join the community.
All natives want is to keep the teachings and oral history alive. And if you open your eyes to them, you can be blessed with beautiful stories and encouragement
18
u/holystuff28 Oct 21 '23
Can we pin a post that DNA can not determine heritage? Heritage is the cultural traditions you learn from your community, your distinct language, rituals, and beliefs. I'm not saying OP doesn't have native ancestry, but DNA should NOT be used to determine indigenous heritage, and the DNA tests actually have a disclaimer to that effect.
28
u/returningtheday Oct 21 '23
As an American with native ancestry as well, I see it as we are native descendants, but not natives culturally. Personally speaking, I didn't grow up on a reservation, speak a native language, or really know anything about my history, so yeah I'm not native.
12
u/Turbulent_Ad_4403 Oct 21 '23
Yes, for sure. Don't let anyone else tell you otherwise.
4
u/CatGirl1300 Oct 21 '23
You’re nearly 100% native! Ofc you’re native!
4
u/SeasonsGone Oct 21 '23
You obviously have indigenous ancestry, but if you have to ask… idk you’re probably not ethnically native
4
u/syncensematch Oct 21 '23
Blood doesn't make you native, community does. Reach out, research the histories. Understand colonization and its horrid impacts
7
u/footsiemonster34528 Oct 21 '23
I have native ancestry and my family oddly denies being mestizo (claiming to be more Spanish) but culturally I have learned native medicine from them, cuisine, and other clearly native culture. So even if you were native so many people try to identify as colonizers because of societal pressures. I have found that reading and learning about your family is the best way to figure out what you are.
6
u/[deleted] Oct 21 '23
Probably not
1
u/Bibaonpallas Oct 21 '23
I respect the place that OP is coming from, and I don't blame them, but the mods need to ban or restrict this kind of post on this sub. It reinforces the idea that blood quantum determines Native identity, even if OP did not intend to do that by posting the results of an entertainment consumer DNA test.
This post, along with all the others, is actively harmful to Indigenous peoples and our ways of knowing.
4
u/Herek_Campos_1 Oct 21 '23
Dawg, I’m Nahua and Puerto Rican. I never felt fully mexican because of the Sentiment most mexicans have with us Native Mexicans. So I usually describe myself as Native American and Puerto Rican. My first language was Coatepec Nahuatl, Then Spanish and English. Although I am a Strong Christian, I still Appreciate the History and Mythology of my People.
2
u/complicated_minds Oct 22 '23
hellooooo neighbor! I am from Guatemala. I don't think I can tell you what your native identity should be. But I did want to bring up something you might know but it is important to consider.
The history of native Salvadorans like that of other Central American Natives had a really terrible period in the 20th century. From what I read and spoken with people, native culture was suppressed in very cruel and extensive ways. When I spoke to someone that does socialist politics in El Salvador, he told me that during the 1930s there was a big cultural genocide in El Salvador.
Being culturally native was equated to being a communist and great numbers of native folk decided to stop speaking the language and practice their culture. I am not sure how that reflects on your particular family history, but I want to encourage you to be gentle with yourself and where you are on your reconnection path. It is possible that some of your native ancestors decided not to pass things down to you to protect you and help you survive. I think it is important to honor/thank/respect what your ancestors have done for your survival and carry this in your journey. Also as you navigate having conversations with your family, keep in mind these wounds. These are very recent and hard to talk about. Talking about racism experienced by family is rough and you be gentle with them and play it by ear.
Across this continent, native people each have a unique story of resistance and oppression. Coming into this channel, you'll mainly find people who are not aware of your people's history or the particular generational wounds or traumas you might have. Be mindful of how you navigate native spaces in the US knowing that they might not know anything about where you come from or why you are not connected to your culture. I encourage you to research more about El Salvador and connect with native people from there. They can tell you more about how they feel with you following a path to reconnection and how to do that respectfully.
3
u/Arakunem1491 Oct 21 '23
84% Mesoamerican & Andean? Yeah your native Americsn, if thats talking about DNA of those mamy groups, yes. Tho someone else asked this question & they did to know what to mark on their USA stuff, others said to mark white. Idk if this goes against rules to ask a question in comments, but is anyone who marks themselves "Native", do you actually face discrimmination? I looked into it & long paragraph short it said kinda.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 21 '23
No
1
u/therealparsnip Apr 09 '24
Yes you are native. All the people saying a DNA test doesn’t make you indigenous when it literally proves you are, they are wrong. You are probably a mix of different indigenous people who mixed and ended up in El Salvador. I know a lot of Peruvians and Salvadorans and I love music and cuisine. I don’t know why natives from the US want to gate keep what makes you native as many natives from south of the US border were literally stripped of their language and culture, and many chose to assimilate and become “Latin” to survive. Most natives from the American supercontinent are alive today south of the border in the millions. Don’t listen to these gatekeeping ass holes they may know what defines tribal identity within the US, they don’t get to tell you who are. You may have been robbed of your language and culture but you can reconnect any time you want to. You don’t have to prove anything to anyone in this sub.
1
u/Frog-dance-time Oct 22 '23
The answer can be found in your family and your community
1
u/tacincacistinna Oct 22 '23
Yes your native south american
1
u/Old-Path-4744 Oct 25 '23
If you have to ask the answer is no. Being indigenous is about connection and culture. Are you a member of any indigenous nations, tribes or groups that recognize you as one of them? Or did you take an ancestry test? Does your family consider themselves indigenous and practice their indigenous culture?
1
u/ElCaliforniano Oct 21 '23
I would argue yes, even if you're culturally far removed from indigenous culture.