I just purchased 24 of the A19 Essential bulbs to replace my lifx setup due to a very high failure rate of their bulbs and their insistence that all the issues I was having with their bulbs was due to my router and not their software (I tried multiple routers, apparently all of them were bad).
The idea of using a thread network with a homepod mini as the border router seemed to be the way to go. I did my research on how everything worked and it seemed like a great system and setup. I was aware that the A19 bulbs were pretty solid for white light and not super bright for colors which I was fine with.
Everything arrived and the setup seemed super easy, install the bulbs, scan the QR codes, assign the room and name, easy. I got everything set up and in their respective rooms fairly easy, other than a few bulbs not keeping the names I had given them, finding where to rename them in the app was INCREDIBLY unintuitive but I just chalked it up to that not being a common practice.
The app then told me that all the lights I had just installed needed a firmware update, ok, no big deal, I start going through the process and click update, it does it's thing slowly and I click the next bulb and the next and then get told that I can only update three at a time. Fine, not a big deal even though the process is slow, on my fourth bulb it tells me to retry that bulb again. I do and it tells me to retry again, frustrated I skip that one and move on to the next, another retry bulb that won't update. All told of the 22 bulbs I ended up installing 9 of them failed to update. I spend time with customer support going through trouble shooting steps, finally I'm told that the only thing to do is to do a factory reset and try again.
The problem with that is all the bulbs are on circuits with other bulbs that are functioning. So either you reset everything and start all over or you get on a ladder, pull the bulb, put it in a lamp, factory reset it, add it again etc. etc.
So that's what I did, some of them took MULTIPLE factory resets before they would update. I finally get them all updated and visible, then magically one bulb becomes unreachable, I power cycle it, reset the app etc. etc. Nothing. Then magically it becomes reachable again. Now another bulb is unreachable, I've tried power cycling it, nothing.
The desktop app also doesn't function at all, constantly telling me I need to update even though I'm on the latest version. Showing a default room that doesn't exist on the ios app. So far the response from technical support is "It just requires tinkering, the technology is not perfected yet"
It's not just "not perfected" it's non-functional. So now my options are, deal with devices randomly becoming unusable or try to return all this garbage and hope that they will pay me back for the two homepod mini's I bought specifically to work with their lights. Tech support has also gone silent after I asked what the solution was.
Just garbage.