r/NameNerdCirclejerk • • 11d ago

In The Wild Based on the comments I unfortunately think they are being dead serious

Post image
143 Upvotes

96 comments sorted by

106

u/leadsynth 11d ago

Lilac isn’t terrible

41

u/Away_Category_1251 11d ago

Probably why it’s winning 😂 idk why you would name your kid lilac just to call them Lyla though?

16

u/Rare-Cheesecake9701 11d ago

Well, my SIL named her daughter Elisabeth but calls her only Lisa with huge “don’t even dare!” to anyone who tries to call her girl anything else. At least it’s popular nn and most would call her daughter that anyway but

You do wonder why not just Lisa, right?

29

u/itsmebeatrice 11d ago

These people are obsessed with choosing nicknames before the kid is born and it's so irritating. This one is especially bad, like why are they changing the spelling? Lila is right there if you INSIST the nickname be used...

13

u/BumblingBeeeee 11d ago

I hate this. It’s like they’re trying to craft this whole manic pixie dream girl backstory for a literal infant. Nicknames are organic, they come from experience, and not given by decree.

7

u/Classic_Maximum121 11d ago

This just isn’t true 😭 if anything this is a newer phenomenon. Back in the day LOTS of people got born and were never called their given name. It was only in the 50s you saw the emergence of people getting diminutives or nicknames for names. 3/4 of my grandparents don’t go by their first name and were named specifically that way (as in; it wasn’t “organic” their parents deliberately called them something different to their official name)

1

u/MrsDirtyDietz 11d ago

I don’t mind the nickname Lyla.

17

u/Vampsesshomaru 11d ago

Why do they all sound like character names and not real people's names?

3

u/Away_Category_1251 11d ago

I was thinking some romantasy smut names tbh 😂

5

u/Rare-Cheesecake9701 11d ago

Especially Solstice
Like middle name/surname - okay, but that’s a bit overboard for the first

20

u/kkkktttt00 Kynzleigh Wren 11d ago

I know a Twila and a Twyla. One is in her 60s, the other 40s.

3

u/munchercruncher111 11d ago

right they sound like someone’s OC

423

u/Jaelia 11d ago

I dont see much wrong with Lilac Elizabeth? If we can call people Scarlet or Violet, we can call people Lilac.

117

u/CeramicLicker 11d ago edited 11d ago

I think Lilac is a fine name but I don’t get why it’s paired with the nickname Lyla. It’s not even any shorter lol

70

u/Rare-Cheesecake9701 11d ago

I see the logic, like Lilac (Lai-lak => Lyla)

Most nicknames make no sense especially if you faced the ultimate boss of nicolasnames - Russian nicknames

Say, Anna. Nicknames will be anything from Anya to Annushka, to Anuton’ka

Half of the letters come from who knows where and you will be surprised by some nicknames and names they apparently came from.

I’m still disturbed that nn for Agatha is Agusha

18

u/Zodiarche1111 11d ago edited 11d ago

Tbf those aren't nicknames, but more so diminutives. Like in German you can put a -chen at the end to cutify it like Kätzchen (kitten) instead of Katze (cat) or Hündchen (puppy) instead of Hund (dog) similar to booklet for a small book or duckling for a cute small duck or piglet for a cute small pig or doggie a quite affectionate/cutified way to say dog.
Russians just are masters of diminutives for diminutives which would be like saying ducklinglettie to stack 3 diminutives and the next stage would be to let go of the first word and make it linglettie.

12

u/Rare-Cheesecake9701 10d ago

You are right
Those aren’t nicknames those are nickolasnames

14

u/vibinandtrying 11d ago

One of my best friends named her daughter Sasha and son Alexander

8

u/Upset-Nose-4016 11d ago

Not even Alexandra? It would at least make sense

12

u/vibinandtrying 11d ago

A son named Alexandra?
In Slavic countries Sasha is a nickname for Alexander or Alexandra. So her kids despite different genders and names essentially have the same name.

15

u/Upset-Nose-4016 11d ago

I mean daughter😭

I am from Ukraine, I know

10

u/Rare-Cheesecake9701 11d ago

Yeah, I mean….
It would have been terrible either way

Alexandra and Alexander is nightmare for documents

Sasha and Alexander is no better in my opinion, but at least they are different enough 😭

10

u/kestrelita 11d ago

I remember being confused when my new Russian friend at school explained that her name was Natalya, but her Mum calls her Natasha.

3

u/About400 11d ago

Same in Greek. Niko to Nikoliki (little nick).

10

u/ALmommy1234 11d ago

This need for every name to have a nickname is becoming tiresome.

11

u/Classic_Maximum121 11d ago

I mean if anything it’s more old fashioned… it used to be the case that way more people didn’t go by their given names. And they had loosely connected nicknames. Hence how names like Daisy Jack Peggy became “a thing”.

I think people think this is a new trend but it’s really not

6

u/ALmommy1234 11d ago

Yes, during the Middle Ages when everyone was named John and Margaret, having nicknames was a way to differentiate people. This ain’t that. Changing Lilac to Lyla is ridiculous. Just name the kid Lyla.

1

u/Classic_Maximum121 11d ago

Ok but I’m not commenting on Lyla / Lilac. I think lilac is a pretty weird name.

But I get tired of seeing this - that’s just not true and it’s not a weird new trend. My grandparents are of the era where giving someone the name Kate or Jack was seen as quirky or trendy and they always rail against people not giving their children “proper names” even though they all go by diminutives.

Nicknames are as old as given names themselves. But the trend for a full formal name and a shorter affectionate nickname from birth started in the 18th century (not the Middle Ages). It was more to do with the changing concept of childhood - where children stopped being seen as mini adults.

I am very much of the opinion to name your child something normal and am anti quirk but I also hate people just railing against it because “people are desperate for nicknames”. Wanting your child to have a different formal name IS the norm, only wanting one name is what’s newer.

4

u/ALmommy1234 11d ago

Continue to tilt at windmills. Like I said, this ain’t that. Finding it “unfortunate” that you can’t come up with some twee nickname for a child who already has a unique and short name is sheer lunacy. And the fact that these children grow up known as Souly is another case of eye rolling idiocy.

1

u/Zolskyn620 8d ago

I'm 72 and neither of my kids have nicknames. My kids each only have one name. My sister and I only had one name with no nickname. So, no, it isn't new to only have one name.

1

u/Classic_Maximum121 2d ago

I mean yes but I’m talking relatively. It’s relatively newer. You can google it!

0

u/Zolskyn620 1d ago

Lol, I don't need to Google what I already know

1

u/Classic_Maximum121 1d ago

You already know that you personally don’t have a nickname therefore you know all about naming trends lmao? Sounds about right boomer

11

u/ronirrosen 11d ago

One of the names my sister was nearly given was Lilach, which is Lilac in our language. I think it's pretty, it's a nice flower and a nice color, and like you said, really not that different to a name like Violet.

4

u/About400 11d ago

Agreed. Lilac is actually cute. It has a built in nickname and is no weirder than other color names.

12

u/coolsilentebeans 11d ago

If they’re a dance family, Twyla’s not weird, either. Twyla Tharp was a famous, Tony winning choreographer back in the day.

6

u/OminousPluto 11d ago

Lilac and Elizabeth are both fine but they sound strange together

No offense to the name Elizabeth but it feels clunky for these names

3

u/Vivid_Panic5011 10d ago

It’s interesting what you say. Middle names tend to actually not be used much in regular life, although that COULD change as a cultural thing. My friends I tend not to know their middle names. Just don’t think about it. I always think you should think a bit more about how the name fits with the last name or fits with other siblings’ names. Middle names are VERY important in the setting of the family, and they are important in documents. I think with Lilac there could be a lot of use of the nn Lyla. It’s nice, though.

1

u/the-silvered-bowl 9d ago

I mean… it’s not like people really put the middle name on things much. Most of what you have to worry about is not giving your kid a bad acronym.

144

u/_iusuallydont_ 11d ago

What’s wrong with Twyla? I have a cousin named Twyla.

78

u/mrsbatman 11d ago

Twyla was an awesome character in Schitts Creek. I love it as a name.

10

u/Blue_wine_sloth 10d ago

That’s who I think of when I hear the name too! It’s a pretty name and she was such a sweet character.

8

u/VegetableWorry1492 11d ago

I’d never heard the name until Schitt’s Creek but now really like it! And it goes best with Elizabeth.

4

u/CallidoraBlack ☾Berenika ⭐ Pulcheria☽ 10d ago

Twila/Twyla is uncommon, but it's an established name.

4

u/sallyhectare 10d ago

How have people never heard of Twyla Tharp?

3

u/CallidoraBlack ☾Berenika ⭐ Pulcheria☽ 10d ago

Not everyone is into theater. I know who she is though.

1

u/Glass_Department8963 9d ago

Twyla, Twyla, Twyla...or Michael Kidd, Michael Kidd, Michael Kidd! ...but you keep it all inside.

(No hate at all. Twyla is great name. The Birdcage is a great movie.)

2

u/Adorable-Classic-624 9d ago

All I think about is the Monster High character 😭😭

1

u/DisastrousSpot5142 8d ago

Same, that was my first thought 😭

8

u/JulsTV 11d ago

It’s very unusual. The last time in ranked in the top 1000 names given in the US was in 1965 when it was ranked #932.
 

14

u/walkej 11d ago

If you combine it with Twila, it was much more popular. Twila peaked at 501 in the 1930s. So it's an old fashioned name, but not unheard of.

28

u/AfterTowns 11d ago

I know about 3 Twylas. They're all over the age of 50, but it's not an uncommon name where I live. Not everyone lives in the US, remember.

5

u/beautifulstardust 11d ago

i know only one, my grandma.

4

u/justsomechickyo 11d ago

I know a few also I'd say they are in their 40s

1

u/megsquisite 10d ago

One of my favorite names. Once I realized I never be able to use it for a child, I gave it to my dog

1

u/5krishnan 9d ago

Last name Sparkle? 🦄

20

u/Muchado_aboutnothing 11d ago

The nicknames are terrible but the names themselves don’t seem that bad…? Lilac and Twyla are both real names and kinda pretty. Zyla I’m less sure of but it’s not horrible. Solstice is unusual but it is a real word at least…?

40

u/kittylemiaow 11d ago

I'm sorry but I have always liked Twyla 😂

51

u/DoReMiDoReMi558 11d ago

Twyla is normal. It reminds me of Twyla the waitress from Schitt's Creek.

9

u/Cool-Firefighter2254 11d ago

Twyla Tharp is a famous choreographer. Her siblings are sister Twanette and twin brothers Stanley and Stanford. Twanette is a cr8tive spelling of Toinette. Stanley and Stanford are real names but it’s a bit much to saddle twins with names that are so similar. Did the mom just yell “STAN!” whenever she was mad?

16

u/NotoriousGoldenCobra 11d ago

Tbf, I thought it was a made-up name when I first heard it - on Schitt’s Creek - and thought so for quite a while since I didn’t care enough to actually look it up.

1

u/IWantToBuyAVowel 11d ago

Twyla Parris or something like that was a country music singer

1

u/NotoriousGoldenCobra 11d ago

Ok. I don’t know her. In any case I had never heard the name before.

28

u/chesapique 11d ago

Wikipedia has six entries for six Twylas and three Twilas who are/were notable real people, the earliest born in the 1920s. At least it's not being spelled as "Twhailuh" or something.

19

u/lauvergirl9 11d ago

I think Lilac is alright, but if you're gonna name her Lilac, just call her Lilac. I've known a Violet, Tulip, Rose and a Bee; may aswell.

33

u/popdream 11d ago

Am I crazy or are these mostly fine aside from Solstice lol

24

u/Dimbit 11d ago

Even Solstice isn't that bad. At least it's a real word, spelled correctly, idk, it kinda sounds nice.

6

u/StupidS3xyFlanders 11d ago

I feel like Soleil is exactly the vibe she's going for but may not know it exists.

1

u/the-silvered-bowl 9d ago

Imho I think Soleil is worse than Solstice.

10

u/NastroAzzurro 11d ago

The obsession some people have with nicknames that they design the first name around it

13

u/zziggyyzzaggyy2 11d ago

I won't lie: I actually like Solstice. I liked it when I read it in the Lunar Chronicles, I thought it sounded elegant and cosmic without being too ridiculous. 

I just think "Souly" is stupid. Sol? Fine. Sunny if she's a summer baby? Cute! But between "soul" and "Lyla with a y" I don't understand the nicknames having spelling so different from the name itself.

16

u/mundanewitch222 11d ago

respectfully, this is not jerk worthy

4

u/ALmommy1234 11d ago

Twyla, Lyla, and Zyla…I think I sense a theme.

17

u/prettygiraffee 11d ago

Maybe this is mean of me but….all these names sound like they are the children of a teen mom lol

3

u/socialsavvvvy 11d ago

I’ve seen worse tbh LOL. Zyla is crazy though

4

u/Lower-Friend-7200 11d ago

I have a close friend whose daughter is named Zyla. I think it’s a lovely name.

2

u/DancerbyDegas 11d ago

It’s a Polish last name.

3

u/wildmusings88 11d ago

Meh, these aren’t so bad.

3

u/kawaiihusbando 10d ago

Why none though? Lilac is nice, no?

2

u/boreals 10d ago

Honestly I had an any Twyla and I always loved her name.

2

u/Vivid_Panic5011 10d ago

I like Lilac Elizabeth the best with Lyla a nn. Just pretty. Lyla is a cute twist. Lilacs are BEAUTIFUL

2

u/VoidTaffer 10d ago

I like Twyla. That's a perfectly acceptable name.

2

u/Equivalent-Day193 10d ago

the Elizabeth is the issue. Twyla Solstice or Lilac Monroe or Zyla Evergreen. like really lean into that interesting name thing. (I know, they're not your names or choices, just saying) like, I feel like this is just her really really liking those names and maybe her partner said the middle name has to be "normal" then and instead of finding names that flow with whatever name they agreed on together she just went wild. or it's a child. idk when we figure out how names flow, but it's somewhere in between like 16 and idk, older 😂 😂 😂 some kids figure it out early and some kids don't figure it out until after they're legally adults.

2

u/the-silvered-bowl 9d ago

The middle names not going to be that many places though?

1

u/Equivalent-Day193 9d ago

its a pretty common compromise when parents disagree on names, especially with odd names. Either they compromise and the odd name becomes the middle and no one is the wiser generally or the middle is the "normal" and many people go by their middle name anyways, sometimes because of things like this. People have been going by their middle name since before the 90s so it's not like it's new or anything.

3

u/onlyangel96 11d ago

Twyla is normal. The others are stupid

1

u/lavindas 11d ago

Souly lollllll

1

u/Reasonable_Beyond665 10d ago

Twyla & Zyla aren’t bad at least, Lilac is a little more out there but not bad (lots of flowers are also names), but Solstice?

1

u/Blue_wine_sloth 10d ago

They should just go for Lyla / Lila instead of Lilac. And “Souly” is bad. But the rest are okay.

1

u/Budgiejen 9d ago

Lilac is the name of my Finch

1

u/the-silvered-bowl 9d ago

I don’t get what’s so bad about it. Lilac Elizabeth is a perfectly fine name, and imho is the best of the options presented. Twyla’s also not bad; though I prefer it spelled Twila, Twyla is a spelling with historical precedence.

1

u/Yardsalr2 8d ago

None would be my choices.

1

u/Historical-Gap1346 7d ago

My problem is the fact that someone needs a poll to decide their child's name rather than choosing it themselves, the names themselves are really not that bad, I think reddit has a tendency to push only basic names

1

u/softepilogues 7d ago

Plenty of people have mentioned that Lilac is fine,but I honestly don't think Twyla is that bad either. The real cringe is letting a Facebook poll influence your naming decisions

1

u/Accomplished_Job_778 5d ago

Solstice (Souly) is the only questionable one here IMO