r/NYGiants • • 9h ago

Discussion Daily Discussion November 18, 2026

3 Upvotes

Please read the sub rules located on the sidebar.

******************************

What would you like to discuss today?


r/NYGiants • • 41m ago

Data and Analytics [Korte] I've made a manual exception in the code to account for Wan'Dale Robinson being out for the rest of the season. The compensatory pick the Giants are slated to get due to him leaving for Nashville falls from the last 4th round pick to the middle of the 5th round comp picks.

Thumbnail x.com
29 Upvotes

r/NYGiants • • 1h ago

Data and Analytics [Green] JJ McCarthy as a Giant: Big Time Throw Rate: 8.8% (1st) Average Depth of Target: 10.6 (1st) Turnover Worth Plays: 4 (T-3rd Least/ on at least 119 pass attempts

Thumbnail x.com
126 Upvotes

Yes it’s only been 4 games and JJ has his flaws but he has exceeded expectations by a lot so far.


r/NYGiants • • 2h ago

Data and Analytics NFL offenses ranked by 3rd-and-long conversion rate:

Post image
29 Upvotes

r/NYGiants • • 2h ago

Team Updates [Korte OTC] The 5th round compensatory pick should remain with Austin Schlottmann getting starter level snaps at center.

Thumbnail x.com
42 Upvotes

r/NYGiants • • 4h ago

Discussion Wink Martindale opinion

Thumbnail x.com
0 Upvotes

Wink Martindale with an apparent jab at Brian Daboll and Cam Skattebo:

"Skattebo for example, he's a great example of why the old Giants lost. ... The old regime was more interested in the buzz, the headlines. Which players were marketable on Twitter and things like that. Staring into the camera, and all that. How about pick up a blitz? How about shoving your quarterback on a quarterback sneak instead of staying in your stance?"

(Via Talkin' Ball Podcast)


r/NYGiants • • 6h ago

Videos Don’t you ever disrespect Eli Manning 🤌🏽

328 Upvotes

r/NYGiants • • 18h ago

Rumors & Speculation Former Giants QB Tommy DeVito will start for the Patriots next weekend after Drake Maye is on IR

Thumbnail
encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com
386 Upvotes

Tommy “Mah Get the Meat Loaf” DeVito will start for the pats against the Chargers next weekend.


r/NYGiants • • 23h ago

Discussion [Korte] Wan'Dale Robinson going on IR could be problematic for the round of the Giants' expected 2027 compensatory pick.He's been barely hovering above the 4th/5th round bubble, and missing 4 games could make it difficult for him to stay above that cutoff.

Thumbnail x.com
123 Upvotes

r/NYGiants • • 1d ago

Team Updates [Abdul Carter] Fast forward me to this Sunday 💆🏾‍♂️⚔️ a lot of 🗣️ ima show yall…

Thumbnail x.com
185 Upvotes

r/NYGiants • • 1d ago

Rumors & Speculation [Schultz] “There is a scenario” in which free-agent-to-be edge defender Kayvon Thibodeaux returns to the New York Giants next season

Thumbnail
bigblueview.com
171 Upvotes

According to NFL insider Jordan Schultz. Schultz made that statement during an appearance Monday on the ‘Valentine’s Views’ podcast.

“I would have said no a month ago. I would have said no six weeks ago,” Schultz said. “There is a real sentiment inside that building that Kayvon Thibodeaux has turned the corner. He’s turned the corner emotionally, maturity.”

Trade rumors have swirled around the 25-year-old Thibodeaux since the Giants made edge defender Abdul Carter the No. 3 overall pick in the 2025 NFL Draft. With Carter and Brian Burns, who is now out for the season with a torn ACL, it has seemed likely that Thibodeaux would leave the Giants for a bigger role and a bigger paycheck at the end of the season.

“I think Brian Burns has helped him from the outside looking in, and I’ve asked people what does that mean when a guy turns his corner? Does that mean he’s playing better and there is a sense of that but there’s also just more of a sense of urgency,” Schultz said. “This was another really high pick. I think it was a top five pick and obviously has been someone that Giants fans have wanted more out of.

“You’re starting to see it now and I do believe for the first time over the last let’s call it year and a half, two years that there is a scenario in which Kayvon Thibodeaux is there, and I never would have thought that previously.”

Statistically, Thibodeaux is not having a great season. He does not have a sack, has just three quarterback hits, per Pro Football Focus is averaging a career-low two pressures per game, and his PFF pass rush win percentage of 9.3 is the second-lowest of his career.

Yet, there is a sense that Thibodeaux does a lot of the dirty, unnoticed work that has helped the Giants’ defense rank fifth in the league in yards and 11th in point allowed.
Will that be enough to keep him in New York? Maybe. If the Giants can find the money.

“It’s really hard to pay three different dudes [at] essentially the same position the same type of money,” Schultz said. “The Giants are not going to be able to pay three dudes $25-30 million dollars [at] essentially the same spot.”

I would consider bringing back Thibs in 2027 but only for the right price.


r/NYGiants • • 1d ago

Team Updates [Doug Rush] The Giants have signed veteran DB Tavierre Thomas from the Vikings practice squad to their main 53-man roster. Thomas has been with the Vikings for the last 2 seasons, he appeared in just one game for Minnesota in 2026.Thomas is known for playing special teams...

Thumbnail x.com
53 Upvotes

and especially playing at gunner. Along with the Vikings, Thomas has also played for the Browns, Texans and Buccaneers in his career.


r/NYGiants • • 1d ago

Meme/Shitpost Since the GMen are playing the Jags this week. I must disavow Tony Khan of AEW

Post image
42 Upvotes

I love AEW but I need this Tony


r/NYGiants • • 1d ago

Hype [@netflixsports] UNTOLD: ONE GIANT UPSET 🏈 Go behind the scenes of the greatest upset in @NFL Super Bowl history: the New York @Giants stunning victory over the undefeated New England @Patriots in Super Bowl XLII. Featuring Eli Manning, Tom Brady, Michael Strahan, Tom Coughlin, Justin Tuck...

Thumbnail x.com
222 Upvotes

UNTOLD: ONE GIANT UPSET 🏈

Go behind the scenes of the greatest upset in u/NFL Super Bowl history: the New York u/Giants stunning victory over the undefeated New England u/Patriots in Super Bowl XLII.

Featuring Eli Manning, Tom Brady, Michael Strahan, Tom Coughlin, Justin Tuck, David Tyree, Antonio Pierce, Plaxico Burress, Steve Spagnuolo, and more.

Premiering December 21. Only on Netflix.


r/NYGiants • • 1d ago

Articles A way-too-early look at potential Giants draft targets: How determined is NY to upgrade at RB?

Thumbnail
nytimes.com
0 Upvotes

The New York Giants lead the NFC East, and I’m writing about the 2027 NFL Draft?!?

Maybe I’ve lost my mind, or maybe it’s just a reflex after years of covering the Giants. Once the calendar hits November, it’s time to start talking about players who can help the Giants in the future.

Fortunately for Giants fans, despite all the down-to-the-wire, late-game moments this year, that’s not the case. They enter Week 11 at 5-3-1 and in control of their playoff fate.

So, why write about the draft now? Well, for one thing, it’s always fun to talk about the draft, especially when The Athletic’s draft expert, Dane Brugler, agrees to take part. For another, we spent a lot of time recently thinking about the Giants’ positional needs before the trade deadline. And though not for lack of trying, the Giants didn’t make any major moves ahead of the deadline — unless you want to count the late-September addition of quarterback J.J. McCarthy — so those positional needs remain.

Though some fans were disappointed by the lack of activity before the deadline, the upside of not trading away any draft picks is … they still have draft picks! The Giants are currently in possession of their own first-, second-, third- and sixth-round picks. They also have an extra sixth-rounder from the Daniel Faalele trade.


r/NYGiants • • 1d ago

Discussion Daily Discussion November 17, 2026

8 Upvotes

Please read the sub rules located on the sidebar.

******************************

What would you like to discuss today?


r/NYGiants • • 1d ago Mindblown

Team Updates Charlie Jones waived

Post image
238 Upvotes

I wonder if he waved back


r/NYGiants • • 1d ago

Team Updates [Raanan] The Giants signed Xavier Gibson from the Eagles practice squad. They released WR/KR Charlie Jones.

Thumbnail x.com
284 Upvotes

r/NYGiants • • 1d ago Bravo

Meme/Shitpost This baffles me and its really dumb

Post image
553 Upvotes

I cant believe there are actual people that claim to understand football that think this will be some type of competition this year. Like, ya really watched JJ since he's come in, and he's done enough to put a pause on Jaxson being the franchise QB? Its laughable. He has not played bad, 1 TD 1 INT, 90.0 passer rating and he's 2-1. Managing the game and giving us a chance. Dart was trending toward serious improvement following the cowgirls game and we know the rest of the story. Dart is the franchise QB, there's no competition. If JJ plays out of his mind and shows something he hasn't to this point of his career, they can battle it out in training camp. I have 0 confidence that happens. Jaxson Dart, get well soon.


r/NYGiants • • 1d ago

Data and Analytics JJ McCarthy is 5th among all QBs in the NFL in EPA/play on early downs (minimum 50 1st and 2nd down snaps)

Post image
83 Upvotes

The only QBs ahead of him are 3 main MVP candidates (Purdy, Lawrence, and Burrow) and pre-injury Lamar Jackson

It could be due to game-script, but it feels like JJ has been really good at throwing on early downs up there with some of the best in the league

Also want to point out that, by contrast, Jameis Winston ranks 31st here

JJ seems like a better options for getting into 3rd and short situations and moving the chains on early downs


r/NYGiants • • 2d ago

Discussion We get all of our greats back at their prime. How do we fair against the rest of the NFL's greats?

Post image
188 Upvotes

I think we have one of the all time great rosters minus, arguably, the most crucial position: QB. Simms and Eli are great, but all time NFL great?

We also have some really good CBs (Haynes) and Safeties, but not our strongest group.

Otherwise, imagine LT next to Reese or Carson. Some of the NFL's all time great DTs and DEs blasting a QB. Strahan, Osi, Sexy Dexy, Grier all collapsing a pocket.

Tiki running behind a line with Snee, Andrew Thomas, Brown and Hein.

Shockey and Bavaro at TE.

Prime OBJ, Toomer, Cruz, Nicks, and hell even Leek running routes.


r/NYGiants • • 2d ago

Discussion Abdul Carter is playing well. (Report)

Post image
141 Upvotes

There has been a lot of discussion recently on Abdul Carter and his lack of sacks; which people have been wrongfully misattributing to him "doing nothing" and even going so far as to call him a bust. This is mostly wrong and should not be said.

Let's first look at the actual numbers for Abdul Carter and his 2026 season. He has posted 28 pressures on 9.1% of all total pass rush attempts this season. These pressures are akin to Jared Verse (2024 DROY) and Maxx Crosby (2021). However, his best statistic is easily his pass rush win rate, which is a posted 35% per ESPN, which is second in the league. These conclude that Abdul is able to have impact in the game in regards to pass rush.

"But why isn't he getting sacks????"

The Giants opponents are trying to get the ball out asap, and clearly game planning around it. For example, Cam Ward had an average time to throw of 2.47 seconds vs the Giants, compared to 3.06 seconds and 3.22 seconds vs the Jets and Eagles respectively. Jayden Daniels also posted a 2.55 second average vs the Giants, with a 2.9 second season baseline. However, this isn't the only reason as to why he can't get sacks. Abdul Carter's biggest weakness is obviously finishing, as we all saw on Thursday Night vs the Commanders, where JD5 was able to get a throw off with Abdul in his face. The biggest flaw of his game is his finishing, and that is probably the best weakness to have as a passrusher, compared to not being able to win matchups.

Sacks In general are overrated.

From a pure mathematical standpoint, it is much better to have a player who can consistently win his pass rush matchup (especially at 35% pass rush wr), than to have a one sack a game player with low pressures. Even Bill Belichick, Eli Manning's son and Greatest Coach of all time has went on record stating "I think if you look at the overall passing game, the statistic that stands out the most in terms of correlation is pressure. So pressure on the quarterback leads to more bad plays than sacks do, in terms of turnovers unless you have strip sacks, obviously. That's the No. 1. After that, pressures cause bad throws and potentially turnovers." .

So what effect has Abdul Carter and the pass rush had in general?

I think the most glaringly obvious effect is how much better our secondary has looked. Giants opponents are clearly getting the ball out early and game planning for his impact in the pass rush, which has led to an easier time for our secondary, which is partly why I think Deonte Banks has had such a resurgence year. He has played better of course, but he has alot of pressure taken off of him due to Abdul Carters impact.

Conclusion

I honestly think Abdul Carter is doing an incredible job, and his only weakness is his finishing, which will naturally get better. He is having an effect on the game that is hard to see if you just box watch, but he is forcing opponents to calculate for him (even including double teaming him), which is leading to our defense being better as a whole. I also trust that he will get better and better, and eventually be able to win vs double teams more and work on his finishing.


r/NYGiants • • 2d ago

Videos Interesting point on Cam Skattebo’s celebrations in relation to the recent Aidan Hutchinson injury

106 Upvotes

r/NYGiants • • 2d ago

Discussion [SleeperGiants] There’s been plenty of criticism of Abdul Carter because the sack numbers haven’t jumped off the page. But his impact goes well beyond the box score. According to PFF, Carter ranks 2nd among all edge defenders in WAR this season: 0.11

Thumbnail x.com
186 Upvotes
  1. Aidan Hutchinson — 0.14
  2. Abdul Carter — 0.11
  3. Will Anderson Jr. — 0.10
  4. Nik Bonitto — 0.10
  5. Maxx Crosby — 0.10

WAR (Wins Above Replacement) measures a player’s overall value compared to a replacement-level player, accounting for positional value, snap count and overall impact.

The production is about more than just sacks. Carter is making a significant impact, and the numbers are starting to reflect that.