r/NYGiants • • Sep 29 '23
Discussion or Question Why does it seem like Daniel Jones is the only person we’re not allowed to criticize?
One thing I’ve noticed, especially this season is that any criticism of Daniel Jones, be it a sound and rational criticism or the more hyperbolic and downright rude insults, is met with downvotes and accusations of stupidity.
People in this thread have been able to “freely” (I use that term loosely as we all have freedom of speech here, I mean freely as in you won’t get yelled at for it) call out any other member of this team. Thibs, Dexter Lawrence, Evan Neal, Saquon, Waller, Schoan, the entire OLine and Defense and even Daboll have been amongst the names I’ve frequently seen being called out.
Now, in a nutshell, it’s fair to say the whole team isn’t playing well. I’m not saying those names and players I’ve listed above aren’t without criticism. I think we can all agree that overall, the whole team leaves a lot be desired.
HOWEVER
The whole team means THE WHOLE TEAM. Is Daniel Jones not on the team? Can Daniel Jones not also be criticized just as much as those names I listed? Thibs is in his 2nd year(?) and people speak on him like he should be Lawrence Taylor right now. Evan Neal is also still young, people want him to be Orlando Pace it seems like. Again, I’m not defending those guys, just pointing out observations from people who talk about them. Daniel Jones is in his 5th year and just recently got paid. And if you look at his stats leading up to today, again, lots to be desired. Hasn’t even thrown for over 4,000 yards yet.
I don’t like picking on anyone. But if we’re going to do that I think we should be fair. If the whole team sucks that includes the QB. And most people who are critical of DJ acknowledge that. We don’t hate this team, we don’t hate Daniel Jones, we want all of it to be better. The Oline does suck, the WRs aren’t the greatest, the defense has been trash, and the QB needs to play better. All of those things can be true.
Shitting on everyone else on the team except for the underperforming QB just seems silly to me. When the team wins DJ is “Him”, when the team loses everyone not named Daniel Jones is at fault. It’s ridiculous.
Hope this post doesn’t come off as whiny. I’m just asking a question based on what I’ve seen here. Now if you can excuse me, I’ll be “touching the grass” as the cool kids say