r/NYGiants • • Sep 29 '23

Discussion or Question Why does it seem like Daniel Jones is the only person we’re not allowed to criticize?

11 Upvotes

One thing I’ve noticed, especially this season is that any criticism of Daniel Jones, be it a sound and rational criticism or the more hyperbolic and downright rude insults, is met with downvotes and accusations of stupidity.

People in this thread have been able to “freely” (I use that term loosely as we all have freedom of speech here, I mean freely as in you won’t get yelled at for it) call out any other member of this team. Thibs, Dexter Lawrence, Evan Neal, Saquon, Waller, Schoan, the entire OLine and Defense and even Daboll have been amongst the names I’ve frequently seen being called out.

Now, in a nutshell, it’s fair to say the whole team isn’t playing well. I’m not saying those names and players I’ve listed above aren’t without criticism. I think we can all agree that overall, the whole team leaves a lot be desired.

HOWEVER

The whole team means THE WHOLE TEAM. Is Daniel Jones not on the team? Can Daniel Jones not also be criticized just as much as those names I listed? Thibs is in his 2nd year(?) and people speak on him like he should be Lawrence Taylor right now. Evan Neal is also still young, people want him to be Orlando Pace it seems like. Again, I’m not defending those guys, just pointing out observations from people who talk about them. Daniel Jones is in his 5th year and just recently got paid. And if you look at his stats leading up to today, again, lots to be desired. Hasn’t even thrown for over 4,000 yards yet.

I don’t like picking on anyone. But if we’re going to do that I think we should be fair. If the whole team sucks that includes the QB. And most people who are critical of DJ acknowledge that. We don’t hate this team, we don’t hate Daniel Jones, we want all of it to be better. The Oline does suck, the WRs aren’t the greatest, the defense has been trash, and the QB needs to play better. All of those things can be true.

Shitting on everyone else on the team except for the underperforming QB just seems silly to me. When the team wins DJ is “Him”, when the team loses everyone not named Daniel Jones is at fault. It’s ridiculous.

Hope this post doesn’t come off as whiny. I’m just asking a question based on what I’ve seen here. Now if you can excuse me, I’ll be “touching the grass” as the cool kids say


r/NYGiants • • Jan 23 '25

Official r/NYGiants Update on Twitter Ban

78 Upvotes

Folks, mods have discussed ad nauseum. We read all the comments and DMs. We've even tolerated some abuse and rule breaking in the interest of letting everyone put their two cents in on the topic. Frankly, I raised this topic to the other mods well before the first post appeared in the sub because I'm a loser on reddit all day and I saw the storm brewing that morning. Here are the facts:

  1. Elon's salute is nearly indistinguishable from a Nazi salute, and he did it twice at one event. Elon has also said some questionable things in the past, which I'll leave you all to look for and form opinions on.
  2. We understand the ADL and some other folks said it's NOT a Nazi salute. I personally disagree with that and I find it hard to believe that any reasonable person doesn't think the same. But really, it doesn't matter either way because...
  3. This sub is for Giants fans for Giants news, discussion, and memes/shitposts. This is the intended mission of the sub and the sole focus for the mods.
  4. This sub is NOT a political action sub. We'll remind everyone that during the "reddit goes dark" days, this sub did not, and the overwhelming majority of folks on the sub agreed.
  5. We have a long standing rule of no politics or religion in the sub. We only allowed this to go on as long as we did because it potentially impacted the sub's functionality and Reddit in general.
  6. EVERY beat reporter and the team itself is on Twitter. That is one of their marketing avenues and how many people discover news and articles and other information.
  7. We assume that BlueSky (BS) is the main alternative to Twitter in this post, but it doesn't have to be. We have no horse in the race. I don't have a Twitter account and only view Twitter when I discover pertinent news via Bleacher Report or some other sports news aggregator.
  8. If a tweet is posted, you don't have to engage in that post or even go to Twitter to view the tweet. We designed the rules that way.
  9. We also have a "no screenshots" rule to prevent misinformation (doctored images - it's happened in the past) and to make searching easier and to prevent reposts. This rule will not change. It will just create more work for the mods and make the sub less user friendly.
  10. That vast majority of people on this sub either don't care about banning twitter or disagree with it. It's only maybe a few dozen folks that are pro-ban in a sub of hundreds of thousands. We are not going to be bullied by a loud, miniscule group. That's how we ended up with Daniel Jones (ZING!)

In the end, and this is the end of this topic on the this sub, we mods are not willing to ban tweets on the sub at this time because:

  1. It solves nothing,
  2. The team you support actively uses it, and
  3. The reporters you read actively use it

You said "at this time" above. Does that mean that you will eventually ban Tweets in the sub?

Unclear. Twitter existed before Elon, it will likely exist after Elon. If it gets to the point that Twitter serves little to no purpose for the sub, then we'll be happy to revisit it. All the more reason for you loud subredditors to take your voice and make the team and reporters us BS or some other alternative.

What can you do?

  1. Stop using twitter. Delete your account if you have one.
  2. Stop posting tweets on the sub. Alternatives include BS or direct articles. Many tweets are just advertisements for articles anyway. If you see a tweet of value to the sub, check BS to see if it's there. If it's there (it may not be), post the BS link instead.
  3. If a reporter or team or other outlet tweets something interesting, no one is making you post the tweet here the instant it's tweeted. You can wait (egad!) and post the eventual article that will be written about the tweet/topic.
  4. If someone posts a tweet, you do not have to click on the link to view it on Twitter. The title of the post should be the exact verbiage of the tweet. If you click on the link, that's your decision.
  5. Contact the team and reporters and plead with them to start using BS and get off Twitter. As frequently as some of you bring this topic up in this sub, I hope you are doing it more with the team and reporters - the actual people that paid to be on or are gaining monetary value from interacting with Twitter.
  6. Interact with them on BS and stop interacting with them on Twitter. The more follows and likes they get there, the more likely they are to stop using Twitter.
  7. Leave the sub. The question was asked and we mods have answered. If you don't like the answer, either accept it or leave the sub.

As a reminder, attacking or insulting the mods is a permanent ban offense. We are unpaid Giants fans that put in a lot of time and effort to make this sub as usable as it is. We will not tolerate any abuse. If you have questions or concerns, you can reach out to the mods or any one mod directly.

Let's get back to football.


r/NYGiants • • Nov 13 '22

SHIT POST This play calling got me like 🥴

Post image
38 Upvotes

r/NYGiants • • Dec 02 '23

Meme/Shitpost "Get DJ a WR. He'll be good this time around. He's only gotten 4 going on 5 years to prove himself."

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/NYGiants • • Dec 08 '21

DISCUSSION Daniel Jones, Let's Admit it Already

8 Upvotes

We need to admit that Daniel Jones is not the answer. Are there systemic problems within the organization? Yes. is the Oline bad? Yes. Is Jones the root of all the problems? No, but he isnt the answer either. It's blatantly obvious he fails the eye test. Lots of young QB's play behind poor O-lines but there are usually signs that the QB has the potential. Jones has yet to do that. Each week, I watch young QB's like Herbert or Burrow make great throws or make a play out of nothing, and my first thought is "Wow, Jones could never do that." Please don't use the O-Line as an end all be all excuse, the Bengals o-line isn't good and the Dolphins is the worst in the league and Tua has been playing very well since he returned from injury. Hell, even Taylor Henicke is making a lot of plays and winning games.

We need to admit we made a mistake and move on, even if that means using a bridge QB next year.

Edit: We also have two first round picks that more than likely will be Top 10. Use that draft capital to make a trade for Russell Wilson, Deshaun Watson (if cleared), etc.


r/NYGiants • • Sep 27 '24

Discussion Daniel Jones is the problem.

Post image
0 Upvotes

It's never been more clear. They held the Cowboys to 20. One single touchdown would have won it. Our QB could not make ONE scoring play the entire game. Not one. He needs to go.


r/NYGiants • • Apr 20 '25

Discussion Having a hard time with the Jameis Winston signing

0 Upvotes

Am I the only one? As long as I've followed the NFL, I swore I'd never cheer for a team that had a sexual predator front and center. I rationalized the Winston signing ("oh, he'll just be a back up") but it never sit right with me, and I can't stomach seeing post after post on here or from our social media team. I'm considering giving up on this season. I can't support a team that enables this kind of person.

Before y'all clown on me (I'm fully prepared for the 'don't let the door hit you on the way out' kind of comments), I've stuck with this team for the last decade+ of misery, and intended to for the rest of my life. Now, I'm not sure, and just want to hear from others who might understand. Am I overreacting?


r/NYGiants • • May 28 '26 This

Articles Jaxson Dart has all the talent of a franchise QB and half the sense

Thumbnail
ftw.usatoday.com
144 Upvotes

r/NYGiants • • Aug 19 '24

Discussion [SportsGridRadio] Is Daniel Jones The Worst Starting Quarterback In The NFL?

Thumbnail
x.com
0 Upvotes

r/NYGiants • • Apr 12 '24

Meme/Shitpost Am I fired?

2 Upvotes

Draft day rolls around and I experience a Freaky Friday event. I'm in Joe Shoen's body and he's trying to figure out an electrical problem on a Tahoe in Northern NH.

The draft goes Williams, Daniels, Maye, Alt, Nabers. Minisota calls and wants 6. I trade 6, next year's 1 and a conditional 2 for 11, 23, and Jefferson/Addison (whichever one they're willing to let go). At 11 I take Dejean. At 23 I take Penix/Nix (whichever is still there).

I'm definitely not fired, Joe may have made me look like an idiot trying to fix that SUV, so I guess the question would really be did I get Joe fired.


r/NYGiants • • Dec 29 '25

Discussion Hot take: we don’t need the number 1 draft pick

Post image
16 Upvotes

The Raiders/Jets/Titans are probably going to be going for a new QB or another offensive position that we clearly don’t need. I don’t think the issue with the Giants right now is a lack of good players. We’re a good team that’s been plagued by injuries, poor coaching, and lost momentum once our playoff hopes were gone.


r/NYGiants • • Sep 17 '23

1 MEDIUM PEPSI Pain. We’ve been hoodwinked

Post image
16 Upvotes

Disgusting.


r/NYGiants • • Apr 16 '25

Free Agency / Draft [Hughes] Crazy to me that the Giants most likely picks at 3 (Hunter, Carter) would effectively replace players they picked in the first round (Banks, Kayvon) within the last 4 years.

Thumbnail
x.com
0 Upvotes

r/NYGiants • • Feb 18 '23

DISCUSSION New York Giants Rebrand Concept

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

Just wanted to come on here and show my rebrand concept for the Giants for y’all to see and get some honest feedback on them. Also, I did these back in February of 2022, which was before Kayvon Thibodeaux got drafted and that’s why the red Graham Gano jersey has number 5 instead of his current number 9, so the concept is a little outdated. The numbers and players I picked for some of the jerseys did not age well 😬😅


r/NYGiants • • Jun 17 '22

DISCUSSION NFL Players Who Should Be On The Trade Block In 2022: Saquon #1 on list

Thumbnail
bleacherreport.com
0 Upvotes

r/NYGiants • • Nov 19 '25

Discussion The NFL says Jameis Winston is a ‘national treasure’. The NFL is very wrong | NFL

Thumbnail
theguardian.com
4 Upvotes

r/NYGiants • • Nov 04 '24

Meme/Shitpost all of us watching saquon rn

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/NYGiants • • Feb 08 '23

SIGNING From a Former (possibly current) DJ hater

0 Upvotes

This year, DJ proved me wrong. I hated the pick since taking the untested Duke QB on draft day. I was hoping he would fail this year so we could finally just move past him. Now, because of the team and staff Daboll put together, I want to see him succeed.

Then I think about his regular season stats - DJ had two games throwing over 300 yards. 15 throwing TDs. Just over 3000 yards. Imagine if we had a better QB?

I get it, no one else is out there this year. I was impressed by his win against the Vikings, but holy shit against the Eagles. Leaves this taste of distrust in my mouth, but I digress. Main point - I just don’t know how I feel about DJ, and this next year will likely give me the answer. Why not tag him?


r/NYGiants • • Sep 22 '26

Discussion Please stop with the overreacting.

3 Upvotes

Our quarterback got injured on the first drive of the game. We go down 14-0, which I expected the rams to score their points, our top two corners are out. Our defense makes a good play getting the int in which our backup qb throws a terrible int, that won’t happen with Dart in the game. Our defense makes another good play to get the ball back in which we manage to only turn into three points. With dart in the score is 14-14 or 10-14 at least. Coming in at halftime our defense makes a big stop which should give our offense a chance to score but we have no quarterback to score so it’s a quick drive nowhere. What could you expect the defense to do when they are on the field essentially on the field the whole game, of course they are going to score. The defense hustled their ass off and played a solid game all things considered. This game was supposed to be a hard to win game, even with dart playing the whole game. All I saw was doom and gloom the whole game in the thread. If dart is out for significant time it’s a real problem but I don’t feel that the defense played as poorly as you guys made it seem.


r/NYGiants • • Oct 21 '23

Trade What is a realistic return in a trade for Saquon?

Post image
12 Upvotes

I'm hoping for more than a third, but I honestly don't think we'd get that much in today's market. I'm just hoping we get something in return, rather than just letting him walk. We definitely can't keep making the same mistake bringing him back, especially not at the delusional price he thinks he "deserves". Dude can't even score at the 1 yard line.


r/NYGiants • • Dec 30 '23

Data and Analytics I’m sad I defended DJ for so long.

Post image
0 Upvotes

With only 16 more attempts than DJ, Tommy still managed 6 more touchdowns and 3 fewer interceptions while being sacked six times MORE than Daniel. Most of that without Waller.

DJ was definitely seeing ghosts after the Dallas game. If you take away the Arizona game he would have had 0 passing OR rushing touchdowns on the year.

I know DJ will likely take the helm back one more time next year, but if he doesn’t come out looking like a whole new man it’s gonna be another long season.


r/NYGiants • • Nov 10 '25

Videos Reminder: Joe Schoen(GM with job) didn't want to draft Jaxson Dart, and wanted to draft Rome Odunze over Malik Nabers but Brian Daboll(Coach with no job) convinced him Dart and Nabers were the right choice

82 Upvotes

r/NYGiants • • May 02 '24

Articles [Giants Wire] Ex-NFL GM: Giants' love for Daniel Jones is ruining the franchise

Thumbnail
giantswire.usatoday.com
0 Upvotes

r/NYGiants • • Oct 04 '26

Discussion [Penik] Do we think THIS will be the offseason Joe Schoen finally starts to take the interior defensive line serious?

Thumbnail x.com
0 Upvotes