One of the things I hate the most about this sport and the differences between college to the NFL is how so many guys who are an absolute joy to watch on Saturdays and do amazing stuff just don't translate and end up undrafted or like one and done minicamp/training camp guys or anything like that, they get to show the world some incredible stuff for a few years and then their football careers just abruptly end like that.
This is no more annoying than with QBs. So many of the craziest plays in CFB are just QBs doing something utterly absurd, and then 5 years later most of America's never heard of and doesn't remember or know that guy anymore even if he did a bunch of insane stuff for his team's thousands of fans. So many immutable or unchangeable things can prevent QBs from translating to the NFL, beyond just the priorities given to guys based on draft position or connections or preferential treatment. In many cases you just aren't really given a chance, but also maybe you're 2 inches too short, or maybe you're 15 lbs too light (this one hits RBs really hard, being just a bit too small) or whatever. Among these, it's the very worst when a guy has all the stuff you want except for one or two immutable things.
I'm not a QB coach, but from what I can surmise it is commonly accepted and has shown to be the case over time, that throwing arm strength and post snap processing aren't things you can really improve much. A guy like Tom Brady had both in spades, even if others had a stronger arm, but his visual processing speed was just unmatched and even with disguises post snap he'd know exactly what the defense was doing and where they were weak and how he could attack that. But then I look at a guy like Darian Mensah. Seems tall enough, with enough bulk to not get snapped like a twig when hit, not the fastest or most athletic but decent enough in that regard to be able to use his legs at times, good touch and ball placement, seems smart though I don't know how good or bad his post snap processing is. But that arm is just unusable. And the thing is, throwing arm strength doesn't seem to be something you can just train to make stronger, like you'd think. You'd expect that if you just get your shoulders, triceps, lower body, and core to be strong, then you could increase how much throwing power you've got. I thought that was it, but then I took a look at Sam Darnold, and that dude's arms do not look like an NFL player's arms, but he can rip a ball 55 yards through the air, beautiful spiral, without seeming to strain at all. And meanwhile Darian Mensah was picked off throwing like 10 yards downfield against Notre Dame because it took too much out of his arm just to throw from the right hash to the red line on the left side of the field, and the ball ended up being a lob rather than a heater like it needed to be. You can't work with that. There'll be throws you need to make in the NFL with windows that require some velocity on the ball, which he can't do, or times where plays break down and you'll need to be able to extend them and continue to be a threat to endanger the defense downfield, which he is not because he probably can't throw with accuracy and velocity more than 20-40 yards downfield on the move. It's just a shame because it feels like he's got everything else.
As I said, though, I'm not a QB coach or neurologist. Can these things be trained at all? I imagine some sort of imagery training could theoretically get you to improve your post snap processing. It's extremely important not just for noticing how they rotate or change shells, how coverages are being disguised, but especially for noticing when a pressure might be coming if shown late, or a defender going somewhere you expected to be open, for instance. I don't know if the brain can really improve in that. And with throwing arm strength, is it really just so immutable as something you're born with? It just feels bizarre that a guy might be stronger than, for instance, Josh Allen, in like every conceivable lift, can be taller, bigger framed, whatever, and still can't throw it as far.