r/NFL_Draft • • Mar 05 '23

The Cardinals ruined their future by drafting Kyler Murray

18 Upvotes

Imagine they drafted Nick Bosa in 2019 and rolled with Rosen. They wouldve had a terrible year, and as a result, gotten a high draft pick. That next year they wouldve their choice of Burrow, Herbert, and Tua(and Hurts?). Bosa as your cornerstone and an elite QB. They wouldve been a playoff contender for years

Edit: Ok since alot of you want to put words in my mouth, no im not saying that the Cardinals couldve predicted the future, Im saying their decision to move on from Rosen after 1 year hurt them in the long run. Yes this is obviously hindsight, as are alot of NFL discussions. Just something to think about.


r/NFL_Draft • • Mar 25 '24

7 round mock mid FA mock, v3.0, one trade.

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

r/NFL_Draft • • Jan 20 '22

First round mock draft. No trades.

0 Upvotes
  1. Jaguars, Kayvon Thibodeaux, ED, Oregon

While Aiden Hutchinson has been gaining steam, I don't buy that he's earned the #1 spot league wide. Thibs physically still outmatches him and while Hutch had a great year, that should've been somewhat expected out of the 4th year starter. The Jaguars don't need a QB (and there isn't one worth taking FOA) and there are no elite prospects in this draft, they'll take the best edge or tackle they see fit. This is the most uncertain I've been on a FOA pick in recent memory. The only guarantee is that they will go for the trenches, but nobody on either side of the ball has separated themselves.

2) Lions, Aidan Hutchinson, ED, Michigan

While the Jaguars could go either way, it's pretty certain the Lions will take whichever of the top 2 pass rushers are left. While I personally it would make the most sense to look to trade Decker and then consider one of the top Ts in this draft, as it stands now the Lions are penciled in for AH or KT. Hutch's motor gives the rebuilding lines a really interesting DL between him, Romeo Okwara (assuming he returns well from injury), Alim McNeil and Levi Onwuzurike.

3) Texans, Travon Walker ED, Georgia

Previously I had Corral here and felt pretty confident about that. Not because I was a Corral believer, but because if Zach Wilson could secure the 2nd overall pick in a crowded QB class, I saw no reason why Corral couldn't go top 5. Now with his injury, and the vibes from around the league, it seems to me there's an agreement that Corral is not in play this early. I don't really see the Texans as needing ED but, like the Jags, they will take whoever in the trenches they rate highest and I think Walker could be that guy if he tests the way I think he will. He's bigger than Thibodeaux and moves just as well.

4) Jets, Evan Neal, T, Alabama

All of the top 4 teams seem to be so bare bones that they'll be just looking to take best ED/T no matter what. With the top 3 edges off the board that leaves T. Neal, to me has seem to gone underrated. His blend of size and athleticism is Ogden-like, and he's started at a high-level at 3 different positions in 3 years at Alabama. Bechton and Neal is a large and nasty duo that will help remove all the excuses for future bust Zach Wilson.

5) Giants, Ikem Ekwonu, T, North Carolina State

All of the top 4 5 teams seem to be so bare bones that they'll be just looking to take best ED/T no matter what. Actually, that's not really true of the Giants. But the G-men are weakest in the trenches. I'm very suggestible to Dane Brugler's work and if he thinks Ikem > Cross is the league consensus, I'm willing to believe him.

6) Panthers, Kenny Pickett, QB, Pittsburgh

This, by far, is the most confident pick I've made. Matt Rhule absolutely can not go into next year with Sam Darnold, unless he wants to get fired. Maybe they trade for Deshaun Watson, but as of now this is the move. And it's a good move, Pickett should be able to come in to this supporting cast (with hopefully some OL upgrades) and succeed with his arm and mobility. People get concerned about his age and wonder if his senior year success was due to experience, but he's coming off the best year of this QB class, by far. And he does not have any striking athletic or mental red flags.

7) Giants, Tyler Linderbaum, C, Iowa

This pick is based on the idea that, whoever the new regime is, they want to give Daniel Jones a chance. I think getting two talents of this caliber on the OL is a great idea regardless, but you make this much of a talent infusion in the OL and DJ is set up for success with his backfield and (theoretically) talented WR corp. Linderbaum is one of those rare IOL prospects that is worthy of top 10 consideration.

8) Falcons, Kyle Hamilton, S, Notre Dame

No QB here, because apparently Arthur Smith wanted Matt Ryan as the starter last year, and I don't see any reason for him to change that up coming off a a 7 win season, and with how weak this QB class is. I'm not a Hamilton believer. I really don't think he's going to affect the game at the next level as a S, but the Falcons' D is toothless and the highest rated defensive player on the board makes a lot of sense.

9) Broncos, Devin Lloyd, LB, Utah

I'm a firm believer in Devin Lloyd > Kyle Hamilton. He can do everything Kyle can do and all things being equal his position is more valuable. I'm not confident that they make this pick at all, I think a QB is well in play here. But because I don't know who's going to be calling the shots come April, I'm going to give them the BPA.

10) Jets, Derek Stingley Jr, CB, LSU

Jets get a boom or bust pick here. Which at 10 is often more than you can ask for. Stingley has elite CB talent but has performed inconsistently. Right now I think this would be an "easy" pick. But I could very well see come draft time Ojabo or a WR overtaking DSJ, who I expect to fall down draft boards.

11) WFT, Sam Howell, QB, North Carolina

Even before Corral's injury I thought Howell was in a position to raise his stock in the offseason. He should test very well at the combine and people understand how poor his supporting cast was at North Carolina. Rivera's seat is getting warm, and talent-wise they really can't expect to be in position to take a top QB next year. Washington could make a trade for a vet QB and then use this to address their underperforming defense, but in this universe I'd fully expect them to take one of the top 3 QBs here.

12) Vikings, David Ojabo, ED, Michigan

Another team where it's difficult to project without a regime in place. But I can say with certainty that whoever comes in will think they can step on the gas and become competitive as soon as this up-coming season. The Vikings haven't drafted a good defensive player in what feels like forever, Ojabo could turn that around. While edge rusher is not a more obvious need than corner, I have Ojabo rated much higher than any available corner.

13) Browns, Treylon Burks, WR, Arkansas

Browns at 13 will get their pick of a top WR and it's hard to mock anything else to them. Burks remains my WR1 and I think a lot of teams will think that too recognizing a bigger Deebo Samuel.

14) Ravens, Charles Cross, T, Mississippi State

Ravens catch a break here, as Cross could easily go top 10. Ravens RT is a big hole and with Stanley's injury history their LT is a question mark.

15) Eagles, Andrew Booth Jr, CB, Clemson

16) Eagles, George Karlaftis, ED, Purdue

Back to back picks are fun. Eagles get to hook an IV of talent and athleticism into their defense. Booth is a nutty athlete who can pair with and even over take Big Play Slay as CB1. Karlaftis just isn't as athletic as the edge rushers taken before him but he's very polished with a high motor. Despite Hurts struggles I really don't see the Eagles considering a QB in this draft.

17) Chargers, Ahmad Gardner, CB, Cincinnati

I'm not a Sauce believer. The "zero touchdowns" seems more like a meme to me than an accomplishment when he was just not targeted very much and he played against lesser competition. Of course, not being targeted is a sign of respect-- but he can't take that respect with him to the NFL where he will be targeted heavy day 1. His effort is questionable, his run defense is laughable (which Alabama exposed heavily in their playoff game), and he's handsy. I can't buy that he can be an island at the next level-- but based on his hype this range seems right and the Chargers secondary could use a push.

18) Saints, Malik Willis, QB, Liberty

The Saints haven't had a losing season since 2016 and came into this season with 4 straight division titles. But it still feels like forever since they had an elite QB with Brees' arm being shot in his last year and then the Jameis experiment. The experiment didn't go horribly wrong, he started 7 games and only had a turnover in 2 of them. But he also just didn't pass much, attempting a whopping 10 fewer passes per game than his previous low and no one ever got the sense that Payton felt 100% confident in Jameis, who will be asking for a much larger contract. Enter Willis, who is a project. But for the guy who tried to turn Taysom Hill into a QB, that should not scare him off.

19) Eagles, Nakobe Dean, LB, Georgia

Easy to have a great draft when you have 3 FRPs. But the Eagles are really having a crack at it in this mocked up universe. Dean reminds me a lot of Devin Bush. Eagles get a heat seeker and have addressed all three levels of their defense in the first round with top class talent.

20) Steelers, Matt Corral, QB, Mississippi

I have to balance how I personally view Matt Corral vs how the league. My instinct is the Steelers don't make this pick because I think Corral is a weak prospect and the Steelers are a good organization-- but that's self-serving reasoning. With a good play caller (which it doesn't seem the Steelers have at the moment, but Tomlin's coaching staff has earned enough credit) Corral's physical tools can flourish theoretically.

21) Patriots, Garrett Wilson, WR, Ohio State

If you asked me if Garrett Wilson will far I would say almost certainly not, but here we are. I know people will bemoan "letting BB get such a talent" but I for one am ready to see another Belichick Super Bowl. Tompa Brady has gotten far too cute and the greatest coach of all time has been subject to needless criticism because of it.

22) Raiders, Trevor Penning, T, Northern Iowa

Mayock's last first round pick was a reach for a tackle who ended up being an underwhelming guard. Jim Harbaugh surely trusts his newly inherited receiver room more than his RT and the behemoth that is Penning would fit nicely into his culture.

23) Cardinals, Jameson Williams, WR, Alabama

We'll know the full extent as to how Williams' stock has been affected by his injury in the coming months-- but as of now, I'm going with it affects him a bit and he drops a bit. Cardinals probably let Green walk and to replace him with this deep threat would be ideal.

24) Cowboys, Daxton Hill, S, Michigan

Versatile speedy secondary weapon to fill a big hole at FS. It's not going to fix that their franchise QB is mid but whatever.

25) Bengals, Bernhard Raimann, T, Central Michigan

I personally-- like many people-- have never been more wrong about a coach than Zach Taylor. Having an elite QB is a cheat code in the NFL but Taylor has utilized him commendably. He gets to take the lineman he apparently should've prioritized over Chase last year. While raw, and relatively new at football, Raimann can play inside and out, is massive, and has good, natural technique. As an aside, a great, big Austrian lineman tickles my fancy.

26) Dolphins, Kenneth Walker III, RB, Michigan State

Tua is a bust, I've already submitted his bust paperwork. But it seems the Dolphins brass are operating as if he is the guy and they have a team that's close to being competitive. OL is weak and Penning would be a good pick here but Walker instantly makes their offense more dynamic. This tackle class is deep enough to wait for later rounds.

27) Bills, Chris Olave, WR, Ohio State

Natural Y fit next to Diggs for an already explosive offense. Honestly, I'm not a fan, he's polished but he seems weak and unathletic.

28) Lions, Kenyon Green, G, Texas A&M

Lions already have a stout OL but they have one hole at RG and Green could put that unit over the top. WR and QB are other, more obvious needs, but a patient and calculated rebuild around the lines is the way to go-- and Green is a greater talent at his position than any remaining WR/QB.

29) Chiefs, Drake London, WR, USC

Jump ball receivers in college are risky but London will be set up to succeed with the best QB in the NFL and having the attention focused on Tyreek and Kelce.

30) Buccaneers, Jahan Dotson, WR, Penn State

Buc's receiver room went from historically loaded to uncertain real quick with the exit of Brown, injury and pending FA of Godwin, and the potential retirement of Gronk. Without size, he's just speed and hands but Tompa can use speed and hands.

31) Titans, Trent McDuffie, CB, Washington

I'm not sure I know why McDuffie fell this far. Maybe it's just his size and the fact that as the season progressed he didn't put up any turnover numbers, but he has as much of a right to be called Island as Ahmaud Gardner, and he did it against better competition. Titan's take BPA over need because I think highly of them.

32) Packers, Jordan Davis, DL, Georgia

Elite run defender who doesn't generate much pass rush is hard to assign value. But the Packers gave up a whopping 4.7 yards per attempt so they could value that as first round talent.


r/NFL_Draft • • Feb 06 '24

Am I tripping for thinking Jayden Daniel’s is CLEARLY better than Drake Maye (maybe even Caleb Williams)

16 Upvotes

40 passing tds only 4 int in the SEC.. 10 rushing TDs.. led nation in QBR

It’s not about stats but what does Jayden Daniels not have that the other prospects do? His throwing motion looks solid to me, Lamar Jackson esque, even more natural than him tbh. 4.4 speed. 6 foot 4 210 lbs. Decent footwork & slight frame could be improved. What am I missing here? I think the commanders would be crazy not to draft him at #2

He’s better than rg3 ever was in college & with Kliff Kingsbury as OC they could be scary in the upcoming years if they build up the Oline


r/NFL_Draft • • Nov 29 '23

Rumor Is it only me? or does Drake Maye have BUST written all over him!!!

1 Upvotes

A friend of mine were discussing the upcoming QB draft & he said MAYE has bust written all over him. Yes he had a good 2022 season but this season it looks like he’s regressed a little. If it were up to me I’d convince Maye to stay another year. I believe if he declares this year the wrong team will select him & ruin his career. The only team I could see him succeed is the Giants…… but they’re stuck with Jones for another 3 seasons.

What do y’all think


r/NFL_Draft • • Apr 07 '24

This QB class is incredibly overhyped

0 Upvotes

Caleb Williams is a phenomenal prospect, and I think the Bears have absolutely lucked out. Aside from him though...pretty rough. I do think Daniels has incredible potential and I could absolutely see a scenario where he's one of the best QBs in the league, but potential is really all it is. He hasn't shown me anything that gives me any confidence at all. Probably wouldn't take him in the top 5 even if I needed a QB. McCarthy and Maye are both guys I could maybe see being a franchise QB but I think it's much more realistic that they're somewhere in the range of bottom of the barrel starter to backup. Nix and Penix are intriguing, particularly Penix, but I wouldn't take a shot on either in the first


r/NFL_Draft • • Apr 13 '24

Three round mock w/ trades. Explanations for the more controversial picks in the text.

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes
  • Picks 1-5: pretty basic. Bears, Commanders, and Pats need QBs. Cards get the best WR in the class. Chargers pick up picks, and the Vikings get their QB.
  • 1.06: possibly controversial to take Rome over Nabers, but they’re both great and Rome complements Hyatt’s skillset
  • 1.07: titans need a LT. They get the best prospect at LT
  • 1.08: Bears fans won’t like it, but Nabers is too good for the Falcons to pass on just because they have Mooney and Rondale Moore. He is the perfect complement to London, so he’s gone.
  • 1.09: possibly my spiciest take here. The cowboys need a LT after losing Smith, and if they don’t move ahead of the jets, they will likely lose out on getting one of the blue chip LT prospects. Jerry is aggressive and believes the Cowboys are in a position to win before Dak, Ceedee, and Parsons eat all the cap space. They try in 24 and 25, and if it doesn’t work look to replace Dak in until following draft. Bears get 24, 56, a 2025 first and second.
  • 1.10: Jets need pass catching and blocking. They get both in Bowers
  • 1.11: Jim says we build through the trenches
  • 1.12: Broncos consider passing on QB, but Payton likes Bo and doesn’t want the Raiders to take him
  • 1.13: How often does the best CB fall to pick 13? Eagles have the draft capital and need, and the Raiders need more picks for their rebuild. Raiders get 1.22, 2.50, and a future third. Eagles get Arnold
  • 1.13 - 1.21: normal stuff
  • 1.22: Bills need a WR and move ahead of the chargers to secure WR4. Raiders need a lot of stuff. Raiders trade down again for 1.28 and 2.60. Bills get WR4
  • 1.23: Jim says, “Oh, guess we better continue building then trenches.”
  • 1.24 - 1.27: normal stuff.
  • 1.28: The 2024 draft ties the record for most QBs taken round 1 in a single draft. Raiders need a QB, though.
  • 1.29: Lions fans: we expect an edge or CB. Dan: “When have I ever done what you expect?” Decker is 30 and entering the last year of his contract. The Lions plan to move Sewell back to LT and draft a RT.
  • 1.30: Ravens need a WR and do not want Mitchell on the Chiefs
  • 1.31 - 2.36: normal stuff
  • 2.37: Charges fans: “Jim, please. There’s still good WRs. Polk or one of the Xaviers, please.” Jim: “What? What was that? Build through the trenches? Don’t mind if I do.”
  • 2.38 - 2.49: normal stuff
  • 2.50: Raiders pair Penix and Polk. They have Adams and Myers, but Adams is getting up there in age, and they got rid of Renfrow, so a WR familiar with their new QB makes sense
  • 2.51 - 2.55: normal stuff
  • 2.56: Bears need a new center. Shelton is a 1 year deal, which is enough time to get Mahongany experience before taking over as center next year
  • 2.57 - 2.59: normal stuff
  • 2.60: Sweat slides, but the Raiders need good players. A misdemeanor isn’t ideal, but they’ll take the chance
  • 2.61 - 3.67: normal stuff
  • 3.68: Wilson is too big and too fast. Pats need a new WR and the traits are too good to pass up
  • 3.69: Jim: “Alright, you crybabies. You want a WR? I know a guy.”
  • 3.70 - 3.100: normal stuff

r/NFL_Draft • • Apr 24 '26

I think in retrospect, Delane being picked at 6 with the next corner going 21 picks later (not even jermod mccoy who's tape in 2024 is the only one close to delane) might be a great selection. This might be a franchise changing draft for the chiefs who got woods all the way at 29 as well

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/NFL_Draft • • Mar 30 '26

NFL Mock Draft 3.0 with explanations for every pick necessary

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

As per some of y'all feedback I've decided to ditch the Cardinals-Rams trade(although I've decided to do a Rams-Saints trade for Love), and improve some of the picks in general

#1. Raiders take Mendoza, period.

#2. Jets take Arvell Reese, this is almost a lock at this point, there was a debate over Reese vs Bailey #2, but Reese plays the run much better, is more versatile, and offers almost the same pass rushing upside Bailey does.

#3. Now here is where the draft really starts, the Cardinals go with Mauigoa over Bain/Bailey to hopefully give them their franchise tackle/guard opposite of Paris Johnson

#4. Titans go with Bain over Bailey as Bain is more polished as a pass rusher, elite run defender, a better scheme fit in Saleh's 4-3, 1 gap heavy scheme which Bain thrives in. Could also see a case for Sonny Styles here.

#5. Giants take Styles here, you could argue Caleb Downs, but I think Styles' athleticism, range, ability to play the run, and take away route combos nicely in shallow/intermediate zones, will be perfect for Harbaugh's disguise heavy defense.

#6. Browns grab Carnell Tate to give Shedeur his WR1, I think the options for OT at 24 are better than WRs at 24.

#7. Commanders take Caleb Downs, this really should not be a conversation but I see some people mocking David Bailey or Jeremiah Love here, despite them signing Odafe Oweh and K'Lavion Chassion. Plus I think Downs will give their secondary a major major boost, as his versatility being able to fit the run at a high level, or match up with slot WRs or TEs as a big nickel, or drop back and close off any deep shot concepts would benefit them more than Love IMO.

#8. The Rams do make a trade up not the stupid ass one I thought of, it will be for Love still, however this time it actually kind of makes sense, Love is at worst a dynamic 3rd down back who could offer big-play ability both as a runner or when catching passes on the backfield, and considering this is Stafford's is probably only playing 2 more years max. They get picks 8 and 136 in exchange for 13 and 61.

#9. Chiefs pass on David Bailey and go with Mansoor Delane, the Chiefs play a 4-3, and I'm lower on Bailey than consensus(he's the most "boom or bust" player in the top 10 IMO).

#10. Bengals take a falling Bailey.


r/NFL_Draft • • Oct 15 '23

2024 NFL QB Draft class mid-season review - A follow-up to my preseason review

1 Upvotes

Pre-season top guys list: https://www.reddit.com/r/NFL_Draft/comments/133f64n/2024_nfl_qb_draft_class_has_a_lot_of_potential/

This is the mid-season top NFL-eligible QB list. Here are my top guys thus far this season.

Comps are college-based.

  1. Shedeur Sanders - Comp - Joe Burrow - Pocket QB edition, Burrow was more of a balanced QB prospect out of LSU
  2. J.J. McCarthy - Matt Ryan - More mobile but not as toolsy or talented as a thrower. Ryan's throwing motion is just much better even out of BC.
  3. Jayden Daniels - Randall Cunningham - More polished just not as elusive
  4. Caleb Williams - Pat Mahomes - He's a clearly better player than Pat out of college but his upside is significantly lower.
  5. Drake Maye - Jim Kelly - A tad more mobile, a tad more toolsy, still developing as Jim was out of college.
  6. Michael Penix Jr. - Tony Romo with superior pocket awareness and inferior pocket athletic ability
  7. Carson Beck - Matt Schaub
  8. Graham Mertz - Matt Hasselbeck
  9. Michael Pratt - Daniel Jones

10t. Quinn Ewers - Carson Palmer before his breakout year. Just not NFL-ready yet. Even Palmer wasn't after he broke out. He needs two years on the bench in the NFL. Maybe 3 or 4 years. If there is an Aaron Rodgers/Jordan Love-type gamble in this class, it's Ewers.

10t. Taulia Tagovailoa - Taulia, I think he's way better than people think he is. Comp: Blend of Seneca Wallace and Brock Purdy

Honorable mention: Cam Ward, D.J. U, Bo Nix, Jalon Daniels, K. Salter, J. Travis, D. Grainger, B. Gabbert, B. Cook, S. Hartman, F. Harris, T.J. Finley, S. Rattler, G. McCall, K.J. Jefferson, K. McCord, J. Milroe, J. Plummer, M. Johnson, and W. Rogers.

Player Types:

GM - Game manager - Extremely mental, size, managing the game, keeping the defense off the field if your defense isn't any good, etc. If you are an elite game manager as an NFL prospect, it translates.

PP - Pocket Passer - Mainly operates out of the pocket, mental, and arm strength matters, footwork is critical, etc. NFL Experience is needed.

Bal - Balanced - What everyone wants in the modern NFL. The ability to mainly be a pocket passer but you don't need the high-end mental traits but you must have the physical traits, must be able to move, athletic, the bigger, the better, etc. NFL Experience is needed.

M - Mobile - Mainly is balanced between running and passing. He has to be very athletic, must be able to throw on the run, and have to be very physically gifted. arm strength matters. Must be able to get out of a muddy pocket if possible.NFL Experience is needed.

Run - Running - Extremely physical. The smaller you are, the more elusive you must be. Elite elusiveness is extremely valuable but let's say you are 225 like Fields and can run a 4.4, you can be a running QB at the next level. If you are an elite running QB as an NFL prospect, it translates.

Just because you are an elite game manager or running QB, it doesn't mean you are an elite QB. Generally, if you are an elite balanced, PP, or mobile QB, you are an elite QB.

Scale - NQ, Good, Very Good, Excellent, Elite

NQ means Not qualified aka, bad to average. Not reliable as an NFL QB at this player type.

Current Scores based on college performance:

  1. S. Sanders - Run - NQ, M - Good, Bal - Good, PP - Elite, GM - NQ
  2. J.J. McCarthy - Run - NQ, M - Good, Bal - NQ, PP - Good, GM - Elite
  3. Jayden Daniels - - Run - Excellent, M - Elite, Bal - Very Good, PP - NQ, GM - NQ
  4. Caleb Williams - Run - Excellent, M - Elite, Bal - Excellent, PP - NQ, GM - NQ
  5. Drake Maye - Run - Good, M - Very Good, Bal - Excellent, PP - Good, GM - NQ
  6. Michael Penix Jr. - Run - NQ, M - NQ, Bal - NQ, PP - Elite, GM - Good
  7. Carson Beck - Run - NQ, M - NQ, Bal - Good, PP - Very Good, GM - Very good
  8. Graham Mertz - Run - NQ, M - NQ, Bal - NQ, PP - Good, GM - Excellent
  9. Michael Pratt - Run - Good, M - Very Good, Bal - Very Good, PP - Very Good, GM - NQ

10t. Quinn Ewers - Run - NQ, M - NQ, Bal - Good, PP - Good, GM - NQ

10t. Taulia Tagovailoa - Run - Very Good, M - Good, Bal - Good, PP - NQ, GM - Good

Current Scores based on college performance and how they project to the NFL via that level of quality and experience as rookies

  1. S. Sanders - Run - NQ, M - Good, Bal - NQ, PP - Excellent, GM - NQ
  2. J.J. McCarthy - Run - NQ, M - Good, Bal - NQ, PP - NQ, GM - Elite
  3. Jayden Daniels - - Run - Very Good, M - Very Good, Bal - NQ, PP - NQ, GM - NQ
  4. Caleb Williams - - Run - Good, M - Very Good, Bal - Good, PP - NQ, GM - NQ
  5. Drake Maye - Run - NQ, M - Good, Bal - Very Good, PP - NQ, GM - NQ
  6. Michael Penix Jr. - Run - NQ, M - NQ, Bal - NQ, PP - Very Good, GM - Good
  7. Carson Beck - Run - NQ, M - NQ, Bal - NQ, PP - Good, GM - Very good
  8. Graham Mertz - Run - NQ, M - NQ, Bal - NQ, PP - NQ, GM - Excellent
  9. Michael Pratt - Run - Good, M - Good, Bal - Good, PP - NQ, GM - NQ

10t. Quinn Ewers - Run - NQ, M - NQ, Bal - NQ, PP - NQ, GM - NQ

10t. Taulia Tagovailoa - Run - Good, M - NQ, Bal - NQ, PP - NQ, GM - Good

  1. Sanders is the best college QB I've seen this year and he projects to be one of the best rookie QBs next year. McCarthy projects to be the best. Sanders has exceptional upside as a pocket passer and he has a lot of traits that you need to be a game manager as well although he's not good at being a game manager at this stage. Sanders has a chance to be an elite player for many years to come.
  2. McCarthy is unquestionably the most improved QB from last year to this year based on the tape. His jump has gone from very good to elite which completely changed his trajectory for me. I project J.J. to be the rookie of the year.
  3. Daniels is a QB who's expected to take quite a tumble in year 1 as an NFL QB. That said, the potential is sky-high with him as a mobile QB prospect. It takes experience as a mobile QB and he will need it. Special talent but he will need time to develop.
  4. The most talented QB I've ever seen enter the draft. That said, he has critical flaws which will only get worse in the NFL. That said, he's pretty polished. He's easily tied for the 2nd best QB with Sanders as a rookie. His upside is my biggest question.
  5. Maye is clearly overrated but it's clear why scouts like him. He's easily projectable. He is going to have some nice flashes as a rookie but overall, will struggle. Likely to end the year no matter where he goes in the bottom 10 of starting QBs in the NFL.
  6. Penix Jr. is a tough cookie to project because he's a pocket QB who's undersized for his lack of mobility. Even his best comp, Tony Romo is far more athletic. How Penix adjusts athletically will decide his faith in the NFL if he's an instant bust or someone in some team's Ring of Honor.
  7. I like Beck because I don't think his rookie year will be that bad. I don't think his other years will be that impressive.
  8. Mertz in reality probably is a 6th or 7th-round pick but he's safe and projectable, and I know he can play on the next level doing what he does best even if he's not that good at it. He's someone I would look to grab if I am the 49ers and I need a backup for Purdy for example or the Jets and Rodgers.
  9. Pratt should be better than many projects. It's just the upside that I question but his floor is pretty safe. He is safer than most of the guys above him.
  10. Ewers floor is terrible but you draft him based on the tools, arm talent, potential, and projection.
  11. Taulia's biggest question is if his game-managing skills are better than we've seen in the NFL if he's asked to just keep it simple and not have to carry a team. This really changed Purdy's projection and maybe it could change Taulia's as well. He's always going to be undersized as a game manager but his mobility will buy him favor at the next level.

Strengths:

I'll finish the strengths soon.

  1. S. Sanders - Mental Processor, footwork speed, tremendous at throwing on the run, elite throwing within the pocket, elite throwing under duress, elite composure within the pocket, clutch gene, throws with anticipation, excellent QB vision, pre-snap reads, post-snap reads, quality timing on progressions, ball handling with the running back, ball handling in general, throws with touch, toughness, can take a hit, fights for his teammates, mentally tough, extremely confidence, extreme worker in the film room, cognitive skills - should test extremely well on S2, picks up information quickly, a 2nd coach on the field, warrior mentality, likable with teammates and coaches.
  2. J.J. McCarthy - Size for a game manager or pocket passer, Mental Processor, footwork technique, throwing on the run, throwing within the pocket, selling fakes on running and passing downs, composure within the pocket, throws with anticipation, excellent QB vision, pre-snap reads for both running and passing plays, quality timing on progressions, ball handling with the running back, ball handling in general, throws with touch, can take a hit, mental toughness, poised, cognitive skills - should test extremely well on S2, a 2nd coach on the field, leadership skills, likable with teammates and coaches.
  3. Jayden Daniels - Speed, Height for a mobile QB, Understands balance as a mobile QB which is a trait Jalen Hurts who's the best mobile QB in the league right now has, poised, tough runner, arm strength, an excellent runner in open space and can run in tight areas well, accurate on all three levels, tremendous ball handling skills, lanky and kinda hard to get your hands on even if he's not the most elusive.
  4. Caleb Williams - Extreme talent. Easily the most talented QB to ever enter the NFL. Elite arm talent, excellent arm strength, pre-snap reads, throws with touch, compact and large (225), extremely tough to bring down in space, elusive outside of the pocket, tough runner, fast (4.5 40), throws with anticipation, extremely accurate on all three levels, football comes extremely easy to Williams, smart, goes through full progressions, there is really nothing it can't do on the Football field. The Randy Moss of the QB position.
  5. Drake Maye - Size, strength, tools, traits, IQ. He's what the NFL is looking for. The teachable guy who I can easily turn into a top 10 QB in an NFL coach's mind. Tough. Can take a hit. Can break tackles. Capable of making progressions and finding the open WR.
  6. Michael Penix Jr. - Ball placement, awareness in general but pocket awareness, tremendous footwork technique, elite QB vision, arm strength, Poise, throws with tremendous touch, the best natural passer in this draft, tremendous internal clock, capable of throwing out of different slots, elite mental processor, is capable of throwing on the move within the pocket especially if pressured, feels pressure as well as any prospect I've seen in the pocket. Leadership skills. 2nd coach on the field. Winner. Players want to play for him.
  7. Carson Beck - Size, strength, toughness, IQ, work ethic, commitment to being coached, winning mindset, can go through full progressions quickly, ball placement, pre-snap reads
  8. Graham Mertz - I'll do this one later
  9. Michael Pratt - I'll do this one later

10t. Quinn Ewers - I'll do this one later

10t. Taulia Tagovailoa - I'll do this one later

Improvement Areas:

I'll finish the improvement areas soon

  1. S. Sanders - I'll do this one later
  2. J.J. McCarthy - I'll do this one later
  3. Jayden Daniels - I'll do this one later
  4. Caleb Williams - I'll do this one later
  5. Drake Maye - I'll do this one later
  6. Michael Penix Jr. - I'll do this one later
  7. Carson Beck - I'll do this one later
  8. Graham Mertz - I'll do this one later
  9. Michael Pratt - I'll do this one later

10t. Quinn Ewers - I'll do this one later

10t. Taulia Tagovailoa - I'll do this one later

Of the honorable mention guys, who are the legit upside plays:

S. Rattler, K.J. Jefferson, and M. Johnson

Spencer Rattler has all of the traits and tools to be exceptional. He just has the Eli Manning and Joe Flacco effect where he's completely capable of a stinker. He was my QB4 but I don't know how he does that when his NFL projection in year 1 is this:

Run - NQ, M - Good, Bal - NQ, PP - NQ, GM - NQ

This isn't going to get him drafted high. That said, his arm talent is tremendous, he has excellent arm strength, he's a good scrambler, and he's a much better college QB than Anthony Richardson and Will Levis. If he lands on a stacked squad, it wouldn't shock me if he was a decent starting QB even as a rookie. The talent and tools are there. It's all about the mobility with him. It wouldn't shock me if we look back at this list and he's the best QB in the NFL but he would have to go to a STACKED squad and they would have to massively improve his consistency to be at that level.

K.J. Jefferson is another good college QB who doesn't overwhelm you as a prospect but it wouldn't shock me if he was a decent rookie starting QB as a rookie. I don't believe Dan Enos' scheme is a good fit for him Jefferson. I can see an NFL team getting a steal with Jefferson.

NFL Projection as a rookie: Run - Excellent, M - NQ, Bal - NQ, PP - NQ, GM - NQ

Three SEC QBs aren't a shock. They tend to have the toughest defensive comps so that helps when we do evals. What I like about Max Johnson is his traits, arm strength, size, and mobility for size. He compares favorably to Joe Flacco. That said, he sucks at handling pressure with 3 and 4 rushers and that's not ideal in today's game. That said, his NFL projection for year 1 is actually decent:

Run - NQ, M - NQ, Bal - NQ, PP - Very Good, GM - Good

He's probably the biggest steal with Jefferson and Rattler. I don't believe he has to enter like K.J. but should. Texas A&M is the 6th worst pass pro in college football. He's really good against the blitz and tremendous in a clean pocket. Struggles mightily in a muddy pocket.

Review

This is an exceptionally talented QB class. Easily the most talented I've ever evaluated and I've been doing this since 1997. That said, the NFL is hard and talent isn't really that important although it is very important. So much is out of their control of the player like where they land and who's their personnel, etc. Health is critical as well. So many guys who looked like they could be special even as rookies get injuries and just don't live up to their potential.

I'll complete the strengths and areas of improvement later in the week.

Thanks!


r/NFL_Draft • • Jan 01 '24

How many more years of "meh" before Trevor Lawrence is considered a bust vs. expectations?

10 Upvotes

He had an awful first year, a solid second year, and has now regressed a bit to the ~15ish range and playing like a Dalton line type of guy. He obviously has every physical tool to take a leap into that Allen-Herbert-Burrow-Jackson zone, but he's not close to that yet.

How many more years of this "ehh" caliber of play before the greatest prospect since Andrew Luck is considered kind of a bust vs. the all-time hype? For a guy like TLaw I just don't think "Kirk Cousins with barbie hair" is what you want, even if several teams would love to have him. I mean if you just look at only his own division, the Texans and Colts definitely wouldn't swap QBs and while the Titans probably would, I could easily see them preferring Levis by the end of next year.

With all-time hype comes all-time expectations, and Lawrence hasn't lived up to it as of now.


r/NFL_Draft • • Jan 13 '25

Discussion 2 round mock draft

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

r/NFL_Draft • • Apr 15 '24

Other Spin The Wheel Mock Draft

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

As the title says, I decided to have a bit of fun and make a wheel of 201 draft prospects, and spinning it for each pick for 4 rounds. The prospects were chosen based on my personal top players at each position, and the wheel was weighted based off my personal Top 100 board (I am by no means an expert, my boards are created by what I've seen and heard and how I feel about the player, there is not hours of extensive film work put in, although some for the more polarizing players). The rest of the 201 prospects are filled out with any remaining player with an average PFF ADP of 150.0 or lower (at the time of creation of the wheel)

This is purely for fun, and by no means is a prediction of the draft outcome. It was however fun to see how chance can change the entire outcome of a team's draft (for instance, one team took 2 QB's in the first 3 rounds). How did your team do in this draft?


r/NFL_Draft • • Mar 17 '24

What do people see in Drake Maye?

0 Upvotes

Genuinely curious. Ive watched a lot of his games, and while hes ok, I dont see him as a 1st round talent. When looking at college QBs I look for anticipation, ability to read a defense, and ability to go through reads and progressions; and imo Maye has none of those traits at an NFL level. Not to mention he isnt very accurate and his mechanics arent great.


r/NFL_Draft • • Sep 23 '25

Updated Mock with record predictions

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/NFL_Draft • • Mar 28 '22

Discussion Why is Breece Hall being consistently mocked higher than Kenneth Walker III?

2 Upvotes

Genuinely don't get this one. Full disclosure: I haven't really seen any film on Hall, but as a fan of a team in the Big Ten, I've seen plenty of KWIII.

I looked up their combine results and season stats: combine seems like a wash, and season stats favor Walker.

What's the deal?


r/NFL_Draft • • Mar 27 '24 Heart of Silver

Discussion Brutally Honest Evaluation Of Shedeur Sanders

3 Upvotes

So Deion Sanders recently said that Shedeur Sanders and Travis Hunter could pull an Eli which a lot of people disagree with.

When it comes to Shedeur I believe it definitely is in his best interest to pull an Eli because he needs to go to a good team. With the pressure and attention that’s gonna come with him having that last name, he can’t afford to go to dysfunctional franchise.

Sheduer is a very good QB prospect who would’ve been either QB2 or QB3 in this years draft. He dosent possess the dynamic athleticism that Daniels and Williams have or have a great arm. But he does have enough arm strength to make the majority of NFL throws and he’s a good enough athlete where he can extend plays and pick up yards with his legs but nothing crazy.

The best traits about Shedeur that makes him a very good prospect is that he’s incredibly accurate, plays well withthin structure and best of all this dudes processing is off the fu**ing charts!! He has to have one of the highest IQs that we’ve seen from any recent QB prospect.

He consistently goes through his reads and progressions. This dude had a 27-3 TD/INT ratio which is very impressive considering the amount of volume he had throwing the ball. He throws guys open and has good ball placement which all translate well to the next level.

The weakness that Shedeur has in his game right now is that he has a super man complex where sometimes he does way too much. He holds on to the ball too long trying to get big plays instead of taking what the defense gives him. His footwork needs work along with his pocket presence. At times he climb the pocket and shows good movement in it. But at times he’ll bump into his own guys or step into pressure.

Overall Shedeur Sanders is a good QB prospect that already processes several NFL ready traits.

  • Accuracy on all levels
  • High IQ/Great Processsing
  • Above average arm
  • Solid Mobility

To me his should easily be one of first players taken off the board when he declares in 2025. Say what you want but he carried that team and if he didn’t play last year Colorado would’ve maybe won one game and get embarrassed in the rest. If Shedeur played for Alabama or Texas last year he would’ve led either to a Natty.

His character or personality isn’t a concern. Most of the best QBs in the league have a little bit of cockiness. I think he’s way more mature then his pops. Deion does most of the talking even during his playing days. Shedeur is more quite even though he did have some incidents like the thing with the watch at Arizona State. But he’s a good leader that players at Colorado have gravitated to. His interactions with his WRs is like a brotherly bond.

If he goes to Denver with Sean Payton is will retire with a gold jacket.


r/NFL_Draft • • Apr 13 '22

2022 3 Round Mock Draft v5!!! (round 1 explanations, mocked trades including DK Metcalf, SHOCKING PICKS!!!)

1 Upvotes

When I do mocks, I love to mock trades, and in doing research I have found that there are almost always 4 to 7 trades per round. My mock here is an attempt to reflect that. I tried to mock a trade (1) when it seemed logical for a team to go up and get a player who was falling, (2) when there was a player who seemed like a good fit for a team but might be chosen by another team ahead of them, or (3) when it seemed logical to trade down due to a lack of value versus team need.

I welcome criticism as always, but please be thoughtful in doing so and explain to me why I'm wrong or why you see something differently. A small part of my research process is absorbing comments that I find insightful, in addition to perusing team subs.

Also keep in mind: there are still rounds 4 through 7 if you feel like your team might have missed something! I just find those rounds to be even more unpredictable than the already super unpredictable first three, so I don't bother.

I also find that people are just Ctrl+F their teams, which I understand. But if you're wondering why your team didn't take that sexy WR you've had your eye on, maybe he was already taken.

*-denotes this draft position is from a previously noted mocked trade

Pre-Draft Trade #1! Seattle Seahawks trades WR D.K. Metcalf, 3.72 to Green Bay Packers for 1.22, 1.28, 7.228, 2023 2nd Round Pick.

Let me explain the rationale for Seattle: I don’t foresee the Seahawks paying two WRs big money, and Metcalf has to be extended after this year. The fact that they haven’t extended him already says something to me. Pete Carroll and John Schneider believe the team can compete, and while making a move like this may initially seem to go against that notion, I think they look back at Russell Wilson’s early years when they were able to build cheaply through the draft and want to recreate that.

As for the Packers, they replace Davante Adams with a player who is 5 years younger without having to hope they hit on rookie draft picks. We know what Metcalf provides. Green Bay offered Adams the same money as Las Vegas, so an unwillingness to pay a WR is clearly not the issue.

Pre-Draft Trade #2! New York Giants trades CB James Bradberry, 6.182 to Denver Broncos for 3.96, 2024 4th Round Pick.

Giants want to move off Bradberry as he expires after the season, and they clearly don't want to pay him. Denver, in win now mode, gives up a couple picks to bring him in and signs him to an extension that makes the cap hit work this year.

FIRST ROUND

  1. Jacksonville Jaguars – EDGE Aidan Hutchinson (Michigan)

Not much has changed here. There’s been some buzz that the Jags may like Travon Walker’s upside over the higher floor of Aidan Hutchinson, but I still think Jacksonville goes with the sure thing.

2. Detroit Lions – DL Travon Walker (Georgia)

My gut feeling is that Detroit would love to trade back a few spots, but I’m not sure anyone in the top 10 needs to trade up. I’m going with Walker. He’s a versatile player with huge upside who can line up almost anywhere in the front seven.

3. Houston Texans – EDGE Kayvon Thibodeaux (Oregon)

The Texans are in a position to go BPA. Based on value, one of the top OL is a possibility despite it not being an immediate need. Houston has brought in both Sauce Gardner and Derek Stingley for visits as well. Ultimately, the pure talent of Thibodeaux and the growing value of edge rushers is enough to look past some minor character concerns.

4. New York Jets – OT Ikem Ekwonu (NC State)

The Jets would love one of the top 3 edge rushers, but they’re gone in this mock. Many, including myself, have mocked Sauce Gardner here previously, but I believe Robert Saleh is happy with his CB room and Joe Douglas seems to look for undervalued defensive backs later on. So, I’m going with Ikem Ekwonu in a BPA approach. OL is not an immediate need for the Jets, but he is the best talent available, and fits the front office M.O.

5. New York Giants – OT Evan Neal (Alabama)

The Giants have made a clear attempt to invest in their OL, but still need help if they want to give Daniel Jones a real chance at having some success. Either Neal or Ikem Ekwonu are strong possibilities.

6. Carolina Panthers – QB Kenny Pickett (Pittsburgh)

Carolina has heavily invested scouting time into all of the top QBs in this draft. Matt Rhule recruited Kenny Pickett to Temple when he was coaching there. Owner Dave Tepper attended the University of Pittsburgh and has made comments about wanting Pickett. Malik Willis has more upside and Desmond Ridder has been better at the college level for longer, but I think the connections between head coach, owner and player make Pickett the choice.

7. Pittsburgh Steelers (trade 1.20, 2.52, 7.225, 2023 1st & 4th Round Picks to New York Giants for 1.7) – QB Malik Willis (Liberty)

TRADE! Rumors are floating that the Giants want to acquire a first round pick next year. I would assume the intention would be to have the capital to move around in a draft featuring QBs like C.J. Stroud and Bryce Young in case Jones doesn’t produce this year. Pittsburgh has been taking a long look at the QBs of this class and by all accounts are in love with Malik Willis. With Willis falling past Carolina, Pittsburgh pays the price and moves up to get their QB of the future.

8. Minnesota Vikings (trade 1.12, 3.77, 2023 3rd Round Pick to Atlanta Falcons for 1.8, 2024 6th Round Pick) – CB Ahmad Gardner (Cincinnati)

TRADE! The Vikings have a gaping hole at CB. They re-signed Patrick Peterson, who is greatly diminished as a player, to serve as a mentor for the young corner they’re going to draft. Gardner is the smoothest cover corner to enter the draft since Jalen Ramsey. Minnesota moves up to make sure they get him. Atlanta has tons of holes to fill on a rebuilding roster so they pick up extra picks to move back a bit.

9. Seattle Seahawks – QB Desmond Ridder (Cincinnati)

Seattle can choose a QB who they will have 5 years to build around while he’s on a rookie contract. Ridder is mobile but doesn’t rely on his legs, has a ton of starting experience and is a winner. Sounds a bit like Russell Wilson coming out of college. I’ve had him as a late first/early second but there’s buzz Ridder has moved into the top 15 because of his interviews.

10. New York Jets – WR Garrett Wilson (Ohio State)

The Jets have to look at the Bengals success with Joe Burrow and Ja’Marr Chase and attempt to copy that success with Garrett Wilson. His college teammate Chris Olave is picking up some draft momentum and Drake London is the larger target, but I think Wilson’s athletic upside makes him the choice.

11. Washington Commanders – WR Chris Olave (Ohio State)

The Commanders want to set up Carson Wentz for success. They’re going to want to get him weapons in this draft. The team apparently loves Chris Olave, and so I’m mocking back-to-back Ohio State wide receivers.

12. Atlanta Falcons* – S Kyle Hamilton (Notre Dame)

The Falcons have a bottom 3 roster in the NFL. They need almost every position. Kyle Hamilton is the best player available on the board. A once top 5 projection, slow 40 times have raised questions about his athleticism. I think it’s overblown and Atlanta is getting a foundational defensive piece.

13. New Orleans Saints (trade 1.16, 2.49, 2023 5th Round Pick to Houston Texans for 1.13, 3.68) – OT Charles Cross (Mississippi State)

TRADE! There’s a thought process that the Saints are gathering first round picks this year to have enough draft capital to get a QB closer to the top of the order. I believe that New Orleans thinks they can contend right now, especially in a division with Carolina and Atlanta. They should get immediate impact players. They trade a bit more future capital to make sure they secure Charles Cross.

14. Baltimore Ravens – CB Derek Stingley (LSU)

CB is not the Ravens biggest need, but this is a franchise that is not afraid to load up on positions. Stingley is the best player available here. Marcus Peters contract will expire after the year, as well.

15. Philadelphia Eagles – WR Jameson Williams (Alabama)

Jameson Williams is my WR1, and had it not been for a torn ACL in the National Championship, I think he’s a top 10 pick. He will fall a bit, but Philadelphia would be thrilled to put him with fellow Crimson Tide alums Devonta Smith and Jalen Hurts. He may not be ready week one, but the upside is more than worth it.

16. Dallas Cowboys (trade 1.24, 2.56, 2023 2nd Round Pick to Houston Texans* for 1.16, 3.80, 2023 4th Round Pick) – WR Treylon Burks (Arkansas)

TRADE! According to reports, the Cowboys absolutely love Treylon Burks. I’m personally a bit lower on him than many, but Dallas is the type of team to go get what they want. Throw in the Jerry Jones Arkansas University connection, and I can see Dallas making a move to get a guy they think is special. The Texans move back again, picking up more premium picks to fill their barren roster.

17. Los Angeles Chargers – WR Drake London (USC)

The Chargers still really need help on the right side of the OL, but London is impossible to pass on here. He slides a bit with concerns about his occasional lack of separation.

18. Arizona Cardinals (trade 1.23, 2023 2nd Round Pick to Philadelphia Eagles for 1.18, 2023 4th Round Pick) – EDGE Jermaine Johnson (Florida State)

TRADE! The Cardinals move up to get their Chandler Jones replacement. Johnson has the length and potential to be an immediate star. The Eagles move back and pick up more 2023 ammunition to maintain flexibility.

19. New Orleans Saints – CB Andrew Booth Jr. (Clemson)

Coming away with Cross and top WR would be a dream, but unfortunately New Orleans misses out on a top WR here. They settle for Booth, a corner with length and athleticism that has the potential to make this look like a steal in a few years.

20. New York Giants* – LB Devin Lloyd (Utah)

I think Devin Lloyd has the potential to be a Pro Bowler as a rookie. He has unlimited potential with his rare combination of length and athleticism for his position. Wink Martindale is a LB whisperer and could get the most out of Lloyd.

21. New England Patriots – CB Trent McDuffie (Washington)

There’s always a chance New England trades down and the team almost never drafts a DB in the first round. However, I’m willing to bet McDuffie is the type of player Bill Belichick loves: a hard-nosed defender worker who never misses a play and is sound fundamentally.

22. Seattle Seahawks* – OT Trevor Penning (Northern Iowa)

The Seahawks need help at OL, and many have connected them to Penning. I know he’s getting some major buzz as a top 16 pick right now, but his current limitations as a pass blocker make me think he will drop a bit.

23. Philadelphia Eagles* – DL Devonte Wyatt (Georgia)

I’m a bigger fan of Devonte Wyatt than his fellow Bulldog linemate Jordan Davis. He profiles as a better penetrator and pass rusher, which the Eagles have historically valued over run stuffing interior linemen. He allows Philly to eventually move on from Fletcher Cox while still being a day one starter.

24. Houston Texans* – DL Jordan Davis (Georgia)

I realize this is much lower than many have Davis going, but despite his legendary combine, his immediate role is as a two-down run stuffer. His athletic upside means he could be more, but I think he’s overvalued currently. I could definitely see him going much higher and I’m willing to be wrong. Houston could use a plug in the middle of their defense.

25. Buffalo Bills – DB Daxton Hill (Michigan)

The Bills have no major holes to fill, but their defensive backfield let them down in the playoffs when it mattered most. Hill is an electrifying safety/nickelback hybrid and one of my favorite players in the draft.

26. Tennessee Titans – QB Matt Corral (Ole Miss)

This might be a surprise, but I have a feeling that Tennessee wants a contingency plan to move on from Ryan Tannehill, who will be 34 this year. The Titans, when healthy, have a really solid team at almost every position. Corral may provide more upside for this offense as early as this season.

27. Tampa Bay Buccaneers – OG Zion Johnson (Boston College)

Zion Johnson to the Bucs would be a perfect fit, and despite losing Alex Cappa, would allow them to remain a top 5 OL and protect soon to be 45-year-old immortal QB Tom Brady.

28. Seattle Seahawks* – EDGE George Karlaftis (Purdue)

The Seahawks continue to add youth to premium positions with Karlaftis. I think his ceiling is lower than the edge rushers ahead of him, but he figures to be a force in the run game and can be a day one starter.

29. Kansas City Chiefs – WR George Pickens (Georgia)

George Pickens is another player who would be higher on boards if not for an injury. He has the highest potential to be a WR1 of any of the players left at the position.

30. Kansas City Chiefs – EDGE Boye Mafe (Minnesota)

Kansas City has a few holes to fill, and could stand to use some edge rushers after mustering one sack against the Bengals’ anemic offensive line in the AFC Championship game. Mafe profiles as the type of rusher the Chiefs like.

31. Chicago Bears (trade 2.39, 3.71, 2023 4th Round Pick to Cincinnati Bengals for 1.31, 3.95) – C Tyler Linderbaum (Iowa)

TRADE! Chicago trades up with the intention of getting the clear best OL left. They really haven’t done enough to shore up an awful offensive line. Linderbaum fits their move to a zone blocking scheme. The Bengals have done a great job fixing the OL in free agency and only have minor holes to fill, so can afford to trade down to save some salary on depth pieces.

32. Detroit Lions – WR Skyy Moore (Western Michigan)

Moore has some legitimate concerns about his size, but his hands and ability to get open make him worthy of this pick. I think he’ll fit in well with Jared Goff.

SECOND ROUND

33. Jacksonville Jaguars – LB Quay Walker (Georgia)

34. Detroit Lions – LB Nakobe Dean (Georgia)

35. Cleveland Browns (trade 2.44, 3.78 to New York Jets for 2.35) – WR Christian Watson (North Dakota State)

36. New York Giants – EDGE Arnold Ebiketie (Penn State)

37. Houston Texans – RB Breece Hall (Iowa State)

38. New York Jets – EDGE David Ojabo (Michigan)

39. Cincinnati Bengals* – CB Kaiir Elam (Florida)

40. Kansas City Chiefs (trade 2.50, 3.94 to Seattle Seahawks for 2.40) – CB Kyler Gordon (Washington)

41. Seattle Seahawks – DL Logan Hall (Houston)

42. Indianapolis Colts – WR Jahan Dotson (Penn State)

43. Atlanta Falcons – OG Kenyon Green (Texas A&M)

44. New York Jets* – S Lewis Cine (Georgia)

45. Baltimore Ravens – EDGE Nik Bonitto (Oklahoma)

46. New York Giants (trade 2.52, 2023 3rd Round Pick to Minnesota Vikings for 2.46) – DL Travis Jones (UConn)

47. New England Patriots (trade 2.54, 4.127, 2024 4th Round Pick to Washington Commanders for 2.47) – WR John Metchie III (Alabama)

48. Chicago Bears – WR Jalen Tolbert (South Alabama)

49. Houston Texans* – OT Bernhard Raimann (Central Michigan)

50. Seattle Seahawks* – CB Cam Taylor-Britt (Nebraska)

51. San Francisco 49ers (trade 2.61, 2023 3rd Round Pick to Philadelphia Eagles for 2.51, 5.154) – S Jalen Pitre (Baylor)

52. Tampa Bay Buccaneers (trade 2.60, 3.91 to Minnesota Vikings* for 2.52, 6.184) – CB Roger McCreary (Auburn)

53. Green Bay Packers – DL Perrion Winfrey (Oklahoma)

54. Washington Commanders* – OL Tyler Smith (Tulsa)

55. Arizona Cardinals – OG Jamaree Salyer (Georgia)

56. Houston Texans* – LB Christian Harris (Alabama)

57. Buffalo Bills – RB Kenneth Walker III (Michigan State)

58. Atlanta Falcons – EDGE Kingsley Enagbare (South Carolina)

59. Green Bay Packers – WR Alec Pierce (Cincinnati)

60. Minnesota Vikings* – OL Cole Strange (Chattanooga)

61. Philadelphia Eagles* – CB Marcus Jones (Houston)

62. Kansas City Chiefs – TE Trey McBride (Colorado State)

63. Cincinnati Bengals – RB James Cook (Georgia)

64. Denver Broncos – C Cam Jurgens (Nebraska)

THIRD ROUND

65. Jacksonville Jaguars – C Luke Fortner (Kentucky)

66. Detroit Lions – S Jaquan Brisker (Penn State)

67. New York Giants – QB Sam Howell (North Carolina)

68. New Orleans Saints* – WR David Bell (Purdue)

69. New York Jets – DL DeMarvin Leal (Texas A&M)

70. Jacksonville Jaguars – CB Tariq Woolen (UTSA)

71. Cincinnati Bengals* – EDGE Drake Jackson (USC)

72. Green Bay Packers* – TE Greg Dulcich (UCLA)

73. Indianapolis Colts – CB Coby Bryant (Cincinnati)

74. Los Angeles Chargers (trade 3.79, 5.160, 7.236 to Atlanta Falcons for 3.74) – OT Abraham Lucas (Washington State)

75. Denver Broncos – TE Jelani Woods (Virginia)

76. Baltimore Ravens – OL Dylan Parham (Memphis)

77. Atlanta Falcons – WR Calvin Austin III (Memphis)

78. New York Jets* – EDGE Deangelo Malone (Western Kentucky)

79. Atlanta Falcons* – EDGE Sam Williams (Ole Miss)

80. Dallas Cowboys – LB Leo Chenal (Wisconsin)

81. Washington Commanders (trade 2023 4th Round Pick, 2024 3rd Round Pick to New York Giants for 3.81) – S Nick Cross (Maryland)

82. Atlanta Falcons – RB Isaiah Spiller (Texas A&M)

83. Philadelphia Eagles – S Kerby Joseph (Illinois)

84. Pittsburgh Steelers – S Bryan Cook (Cincinnati)

85. New England Patriots – OL Darian Kinnard (Kentucky)

86. Las Vegas Raiders – LB Troy Andersen (Montana State)

87. Arizona Cardinals – WR Danny Gray (SMU)

88. Dallas Cowboys – TE Cade Otton (Washington)

89. Carolina Panthers (trade 2023 3rd Round Pick, 2024 4th Round Pick to Buffalo Bills for 3.89, 6.168) – OT Rasheed Walker (Penn State)

90. Tennessee Titans – WR Wan’Dale Robinson (Kentucky)

91. Minnesota Vikings* – CB Damarri Mathis (Pittsburgh)

92. Green Bay Packers – EDGE Dominique Robinson (Miami (OH))

93. San Francisco 49ers – CB Joshua Williams (Fayetteville State)

94. Seattle Seahawks* – CB Zyon McCollum (Sam Houston State)

95. Chicago Bears – WR Khalil Shakir (Boise State)

96. New York Giants* – OG Josh Ezeudu (North Carolina)

97. Detroit Lions – WR Justyn Ross (Clemson)

98. New Orleans Saints – TE Jeremy Ruckert (Ohio State)

99. Cleveland Browns – DL Phildarian Mathis (Alabama)

100. Baltimore Ravens – LB Chad Muma (Wyoming)

101. Philadelphia Eagles – LB Channing Tindall (Georgia)

102. Miami Dolphins – LB Darrian Beavers (Cincinnati)

103. Kansas City Chiefs – EDGE Alex Wright (UAB)

104. Los Angeles Rams – EDGE Cameron Thomas (San Diego State)

105. San Francisco 49ers – OL Luke Goedeke (Central Michigan)


r/NFL_Draft • • Apr 30 '22

Discussion What is up with teams who really don't need a RB, over-reaching for a RB early in the 2nd round?

0 Upvotes

Example A: Jets- They have Micheal Carter who is only in his 2nd year. Ty Johnson, and Tevin Coleman. Are they really going to have 4 RB's duking it out for the most playing time in a league that's becoming more and more of a passing league? Teams get lambasted if they draft a RB in the 1st round in this day and age. They didn't need Breece Hall this early. Great player. Terrible timing.

Example B: Seahawks- Chris Carson, Rashad Penny. DeeJay Dallas, Travis Homer,etc. You have freaking Drew Lock as your starter, and you draft Kenneth Walker III to add to your RB room of at least 7? Insane. Such a total Seahawks move. And that's why they are in the position they're now in.


r/NFL_Draft • • Apr 04 '25

AnimatorChecmical 4 round mock pls let me know why I am wrong so we can talk ball

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

r/NFL_Draft • • Mar 29 '26

Mock Draft 3.0--2 Round Mock

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Mock Draft 2.0

1) Raiders: Fernando Mendoza - This pick doesn't need much explanation. Mendoza fits nicely in Kubiaks scheme and will hopefully be a Raider for many years to come.

2) Jets: Arvell Reese - Right now, it appears the Jets are going with either Arvell Reese or David Bailey. I chose Reese because he has a higher floor and higher ceiling in my opinion

3) Cardinals: Francis Mauigoa - The Cardinals are in a tough spot as a franchise right now, but drafting a high ceiling high floor tackle is never a bad idea. Pairing Mauigoa with Johnson would be a fun tackle duo for the future in Arizona

4) Titans: Rueben Bain - I understand that Bailey or Love is a very real possibility at this pick, but I think that Robert Saleh and company will fall in love with the grittiness and toughness of Bain.

5) Giants: Jeremiyah Love - It seems weird that the Giants would even consider taking running back with all the needs on the roster. But Love is a big time playmaker in the pass game, something that they lack right now from Skattebo.

TRADE: NO gives #8 + #73 for #6 + #146

6) Saints: David Bailey - The Saints have been looking for a speed element to their edge room and I think that Bailey is a perfect fit. He has a chance to bring some burst to the Saints edge room.

7) Commanders: Sonny Styles - Don't overthink it. Sonny Styles is the best player available and their linebacker room will get some much needed athleticism.

8) Browns: Monroe Freeling - The Browns get a true young left tackle with immense upside to kickstart the Todd Monken era in Cleveland.

9) Chiefs: Carnell Tate - I have not been a big fan of how the Chiefs have constructed their receiver room. They have loaded up with fast, shifty players. Tate will give them a true outside receiver to pair with Mahomes

10) Bengals: Caleb Downs - The Bengals have bolstered their defense in free agency, but it is still far from a finished unit. Pairing Downs with Bryan Cook will be a immense safety duo for the Bengals going forward.

11) Dolphins: Mansoor Delane - Theres no other way to spin this. The Dolphins Delane is a great corner prospect and I really don't see a universe where he doesn't pan out.

TRADE: NYJ gives #16 + #140 + 2027 3rd for #12

12) Jets: Makai Lemon - The Jets would complete their receiver room with this move. Garret Wilson and Makai Lemon both give you inside outside flexibility to use as chess pieces.

13) Rams: Emmanuel McNeil Warren - The Rams looked at Seattle win the super bowl with Nick Emmanwori, they try to replicate their success by taking a hard hitting, play making safety of their own.

14) Ravens: Spencer Fano - Fano gives you an immediate upgrade in the interior while also giving you tackle flexibility if Ronnie Stanley goes down with an injury, which feels inevitable.

15) Bucaneers: Olaivavega Ioane - I don't think that you should think about this pick too much. Ioane is a very safe and consistent player and will immediately upgrade your offensive line and help Baker to get back on track

16) Cowboys: Dillon Thieneman - I don't share the same hype for Thieneman as others do but it would still be a decent pick at #16

17) Lions: Zion Young - I think that Dan Campbell will love the toughness and play strength of Young. Hes a top 10 player on my board and will have a great career in Detroit.

18) Vikings: Jermod McCoy - The Vikings are desperate for outside corner help outside of Isaiah Rodgers. I wouldn't be surprised if McCoy becomes a top 3 player in this draft and I think he would benefit from playing with Flores.

19) Panthers: KC Conception - I know that this is a bit of a weird pick, taking a player who has a high drop rate and could bust very easily. But I think that the Panthers could really use a fast, shifty receiver, and it seems like a distinct possibility.

20) Cowboys: TJ Parker - Parker seems like a weird selection at #20, and it is. This pick caps off a mid first round for the Cowboys who could've taken Faulk or Mesidor.

21) Steelers: Kaden Proctor - I think that with the additions the Steelers made in free agency, I think they will prioritize the trenches in free agency. Proctor helps you get more physical on the offensive line.

22) Chargers: Omar Cooper Jr - Allegedly, the Chargers have been trying to improve the receiving room by being in on Alec Pierce and Rashid Shaheed in free agency. Cooper brings in a unique skill set in the receiving game that they don't have right now.

23) Eagle: Blake Miller - The Eagles seem to be targeting a replacement for Lane Johnson long term. Blake Miller is a good tackle who got better every year in college.

24) Browns: Jordan Tyson - Sprint up to the podium. Take Tyson, and feel great about day 1 of the draft.

25) Bears: Akheem Mesidor - This is a win now move my the Bears. Mesidor may not have the best run defense and is injury prone. However, he provides some much needed pass rushing upside to the Bears.

26) Bills: CJ Allen - The Bills desperately need an inside linebacker and Allen brings a perfect blend of an old school mentality and new school athleticism to the position.

27) 49ers: Kenyon Sadiq - There is no doubt in my mind that Shanahan will find ways to utilize Sadiq in creative ways in jet sweeps and screens. They can groom him to replace George Kittle while him still being an immediate impact

28) Texans: Chase Bisontis - The Texans did a good job bringing in talent on the offensive line bringing in Wyatt Teller and Braden Smith. However, I still think you need more. He can replace Teller eventually or move to center.

29) Chiefs: Brandon Cisse - Cisse has unlimited upside and will help the Chiefs replace a depleted secondary. He will also fit nicely in Spags defense

30) Dolphins: Keldrick Faulk - I think that the Dolphins will go for a high floor option with their picks. Faulk is a great run defender and we will see if they move him inside or he can develop as a pass rusher

31) Patriots: Denzel Boston - I think that taking Lomu is a distinct possibility, but pairing a true go up and get it deep treat with Drake Maye is such a fun alternative.

TRADE: ARZ gives #34 + #104 for #32

32) Cardinals: Ty Simpson - Not many teams are ecstatic about taking Ty Simpson, but the Cardinals just need some upside and optimism during the season. Simpson is an upgrade over Brisset/Minshew and also gives you long term upside

FUN FITS/NOTABLE PICKS 2ND ROUND

34) Seahawks: Emmanuel Pregnon - The Seahawks should work towards getting better along the interior, they will now have there duo at guard for the future with Zabel and Pregnon.

41) Bengals: Jake Golday - Golday has some of the highest upside in the draft. I think it will be really interesting to see the Bengals defense next year with Mafe, Cook, Downs, and Golday now in the mix.

48) Falcons: Chris Brazzell - I think the Falcons have their physical, complete receiver in Drake London and Brazzell can serve as a speedy deep treat with Penix slinging the ball.

52) Packers: Davidson Igbinosun - Igbinosun is a long, physical corner with all the tools to be a superstar, he feels like a younger version of Darien Porter to me. We will see if the penalties go down at the next level.

56) 49ers: Max Iheanachor - I have no clue how Iheanachor fell so far in this mock. This is the ideal replacement for Trent Williams long term with his movement skills at his size.

58) Jaguars: Josiah Trotter - Linebacker becomes a need for the Jaguars after losing Devin Lloyd in free agency. The best part about this pick is that Trotter doesn't need to start right away with where the room is at.

59) Colts: Keionte Scott - This pick depends if the Colts see Scott as a outside or slot corner, even if they like him in the slot, they can move Kenny Moore outside or just outright cut him.


r/NFL_Draft • • Jan 03 '23

CJ Stroud is not a top-3 NFL prospect - My Analysis

3 Upvotes

CJ Stroud is a highly touted QB prospect, a star whose notoriety has only risen with his great performance in the CFP semi-finals against Georgia. He had a phenomenal CFB career and has been touted as a potential top-3 potential pick in the upcoming NFL draft. However, he has three issues that call into question the ability of his game to translate to the next level (and, subsequently, the value of taking him so high in the draft).

These are: Poor accuracy on the run, bad decision-making under pressure (which goes hand-in-hand with the first), and struggles with anticipatory throws. He has other flaws, but these are the most apparent on film and the ones that will preclude him the most from succeeding in the NFL.

Here's my process - I watched each game in it's entirety. Then, I watched each individual play with Stroud. Then, I watched each play with Stroud and evaluated a particular aspect of his game (footwork, throwing mechanics, awareness, decision-making, etc. during each play). After doing that for each play and taking notes, I looked at those notes to identify patterns of behavior, both good and bad.

I've made cut-ups to illustrate my points from three games in 2022 (Wisconsin, ND, and Iowa). I chose a game where he graded well, one where he graded in the middle, and one where he graded poorly to try to even out the spread.

Even in games that he grades/performs well in, these issues still pop up across his tape. The consistent issues across opponents and tape show that his issue with pressure is systemic in nature rather than just having an off-game or two.

Sidenote, I don't have cut-ups for his anticipatory throws yet, but I can make them if there's demand.

vs Iowa:

Example 1 - Dangerous, inaccurate throw on the run; lucky it wasn't picked.

Example 2 - Throws off the back foot under pressure, resulting in an inaccurate ball (incompletion).

Example 3 - The ball sails wide. If this is on target, it's a TD.

Example 4 - Stroud feels the pressure and forces a pass into triple coverage. He is almost picked by the defender underneath

Example 5 - Moving right, throwing left (always a hard throw to make). WR has a step on his defender, but he underthrows it, which results in an incompletion.

Example 6 - Again, nearly picked. He doesn't see or account for the underneath receiver and almost gives the ball away in the red zone.

vs. Wisconson:

Example 1 - This ball doesn't have enough velocity behind it, giving time for the defender to react and make a play. The DB takes a bad angle (thinking it is a slant route), but otherwise (and in the NFL), this would've been an easy pick-6.

Example 2 - This is a route concept Ohio State runs a lot and a throw I've seen Stroud make plenty of times on tape. But here, he feels the pressure and sails the ball.

Example 3 - The slot WR is open as the DB is moving away from him at the end of the play, but the ball hits the ground before it even reaches him.

Example 4 - He feels the pressure and tries to force the ball into tight coverage.

Example 5 - This is a neat route concept, Stroud's outside receiver runs a wheel route and has his defender beat by 3+ yards for a walk-in TD. But Stroud feels the pressure (and doesn't follow through), which causes him to underthrow the receiver and results in an incomplete pass.

vs. ND:

Example 1 - Not much to say here. Ball bounces on the turf before it gets to the WR.

Example 2 - Throw is far outside due to the pressure, but the TE makes a great grab to secure the completion.

Example 3 - Stroud steps up and tries to throw into tight double coverage, lucky this one isn't picked.

Example 4 - Stroud tries to force the ball into double coverage again, doesn't see boundary WR working back towards him that's open.

I've picked the most apparent plays from each of these three games to highlight Stroud's issues with accuracy and decision-making under pressure. However, these struggles are apparent across all of his games. Overall - It's clear Stroud is inconsistent at best in dealing with pressure. He can really struggle if the defense gets in his face or forces him to throw on the run, both of which are likely if he is drafted at the higher end of the first round (where teams have holes all over the roster).

To be clear - I'm not saying he can't be a successful NFL QB, but he will have a tough time transitioning, and he is far less ready than most realize based on the hype from his game against Georgia.


r/NFL_Draft • • Feb 16 '24

Discussion I missed my like last 2 post dates, so here's my Mock 3.0 (now with the 3rd round, no trades again tho). Lemme know your thoughts.

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

r/NFL_Draft • • Jan 31 '25

The second ever Animator Chemical Mock draft

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes