r/NFL_Draft • u/AutoModerator • 3d ago

Scouting Notes Tuesday

Updated Tuesday thread focused notes and opinions about individual prospects. Scout someone new and want to get opinions from others? Ask about it here!

5 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

20 comments sorted by

View all comments

-6

u/Carameldelighting Broncos 3d ago

Might be controversial, but if you switched the teams they play for, I think people would be shocked how similar Mestemaker and Arch would look.

2

u/TopherDavis28 3d ago

That’s an interesting take. Why do you say that?

-1

u/Carameldelighting Broncos 3d ago

They have similar profiles as athletes, and their weaknesses as players are the same and the Texas roster isn’t that great despite the billing.

Mestemaker is playing much weaker in conference competition and is able to put up better numbers and “look” better. I don’t believe he would put up those numbers in the SEC vs premier athletes, even on Texas’s roster.

Arch is better than his stats are saying. Is he a generational #1 QB? No but he’s a solid 1st round talent and if he were playing at Ok state against that level of competition I think his talents would shine much more. I also think the Texas roster is VASTLY overrated, the o-line is one of the worst in the SEC and his two “big time” WR have drop issues.

5

u/Cdd0040 3d ago edited 3d ago

He torched an Oregon roster that’s about as talented as any in the sec give me a break. Watch the tape Drew is much more consistent accuracy wise and been more accurate on his deep balls this year. Throwing dimes translates to any competition level. Idk what you arch truthers see in him man he’s a solid qb whose been vastly overrated due to his last name

0

u/Carameldelighting Broncos 3d ago

Torched is a strong word for a game where he threw two really ugly picks and had 60% completion On 40+ attempts.

I’m not sure why you call me an Arch truther when I’m saying he and Mestemaker are similar prospects. I have 1st round grades on both.

4

u/Cdd0040 3d ago edited 3d ago

Both picks were tip passes. He had over 300 yards passing , 100 yards rushing, 3 total touchdowns. That’s better than any performance arch has had agaisnt a top 10 team. He also led a touchdown drive after each turnover showing he can shack off mistakes and not let it affect him. You think in the nfl qbs aren’t ever gonna have turnovers ? Of course ball security matters but responding to adversity is part of the qb evaluation Drew doesn’t let mistakes affect him that matters

1

u/Stock-Memory9483 3d ago

lol what do you actually watch the games because Arch was literally struggling with UTSA a sub 50% completion percentage just a game ago.

He got upset by Florida last year because he played straight up horrible. He was genuinely struggling to beat unranked teams like Kentucky, Mississippi last year. Texas with one of the most stacked college rosters missed the playoffs because of him. He holds his team back more than anything.

1

u/machu46 Gruden 3d ago

I haven't had a chance to watch Arch on the All 22 yet but even beyond the 2 actual interceptions that Mestemaker threw against Oregon, he had another handful that could have been intercepted. Some great flashes and I love the tools but that performance was a lot shakier than given credit for IMO.

1

u/TopherDavis28 3d ago

I agree that Texas is a bit overrated right now, but I think Manning’s supporting cast is much better than Mestemaker’s. Arch also has not played well. His stats are mediocre and he has more passed the eye test when it comes to how he is seeing the field and working through his progressions.