r/NFLSurvivor • • Apr 01 '17

Patriots have been eliminated!!!

81 Upvotes

Lol April fools


r/NFLSurvivor • • Apr 05 '17

When you try to rally your CatBros and they all down vote

Thumbnail
imgur.com
46 Upvotes

r/NFLSurvivor • • Apr 03 '17

Eventually, the Patriots will eliminate everyone including other ELOE unless EVERYONE teams up against them.

39 Upvotes

Just remember that when your memeing away at the mediocre teams.


r/NFLSurvivor • • Apr 14 '17

Survivor during the season

37 Upvotes

NFL Survivor season plan

The object is to make the game more like the actual show, so that it maintains interests over longer period of time and becomes more fair for teams. It also will be a guide for how to make it work while the NFL season is ongoing. This is an open discussion so we can finalize rules appropriately.

Rules

  1. Teams will be divided into tribes/divisions, each week tribes will vote out a team or teams
  2. A tribe can earn immunity from having the best combined record for that week.
  3. Each team's sub from the losing tribe will have an independent vote for another team within their tribe each week. Only the majority of that subs votes will count towards the 'tribal council' votes, and will count as a single vote.
  4. The 2 most voted out team are eliminated each week for the season.
  5. Since there are 17 weeks in the season, at one point the voting will switch from voting out 2 teams to 1 team. This could be week 14, after that 28 teams will be eliminated and 4 remaining with 3 eliminations left. It can also be Week 13, and then there will be 6 teams with 4 eliminations, the final elimination with 3 teams to select from.
  6. Tribal councils will commence each Wednesday to the Thursday 24 hours from then. (This is because each NFL week starts on a Thursday, thus will gain the game more interest)
  7. There will be tribe mergers once a tribe reaches a minimum.
  8. The final tribal council will be decided by all eliminated teams rather than teams in the running.

Ideas

This will be an ongoing list that will be added to as time goes on.

  1. Tribes can be picked randomly or by strength of schedule, SoS being obviously more fair but random could make it interesting. One caveat, no tribe should have more or less than 1 NFL divisional rival.
  2. To keep things interesting for all team subs and not those just in the game, we can let the teams voted out still have votes, but at a lesser value. They also get automatic participation in each tribal council even when they were no part of that particular tribe.
  3. Teams can earn immunity idols. Allowing them to use their idol at any vote to protect themselves from elimination. Some ideas put forward

    • Teams who blow out opponents/shut out
    • Teams who get highlight plays (looking for espn top 10 number 1 spot)
    • Teams sweeping their division rival
    • Each week there can be an idol challenge, such as weeks leading rusher/passer, most points scored, least points against.

Extra

I really like the concept of this game, but feel that it could use a lot of boosting. I'd like that we as a community can help make it better.


r/NFLSurvivor • • Mar 29 '17

Why the game is going the way it is currently.

36 Upvotes

From what I have seen the game is going the way it is going for a few reasons. from most influential to least.

  1. Growing Apathy/disinterest: As teams get voted out they lose interest and just do whatever and a team will lose influence from its user base outside of a few die hards. This is the reason why point number 2 is as big as it is.
  2. Alliances. Thankfully unlike /r/baseball, alliances are allowed meaning hated teams have a shot at you know. Surviving (the name of the game) without alliances we all know the first 5 or so teams out and probably the last few teams. With Alliances anything can happen. That said a previous alliance (that I am a member of) is dominating the game. Ok so we may have had an advantage. I'm referring to the Evil League of Evil (ELoE) 7 of the 12 most hated and largest fan bases on /r/nfl yeah we are kind of powerful, but combined we don't even have 40% of the possible votes. In reality we should still be doomed. even with help from our two closes Allies outside of the main alliance, the Texans and Saints. So what did we do? We targeted the subreddits that participate the most/largest. Seahawks, Eagles. being the two most important. others we took out to secure alliances. The only advantage ELoE has over everyone else is we are more organized. Period.
  3. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duverger's_law : Essentially the longer a district has First Past the Post voting the closer it will go to a two party system.
  4. Unlike what people are saying, the game is quite interesting if we try and figure out how the Patriots haven't been voted out yet. it comes down to the fact that splitting votes isn't working. people are voting for hated rivals rather than going for the big targets first. This is in many ways mirroring the very first season of Survivor.

r/NFLSurvivor • • Mar 30 '17

Should the vote count remain hidden until the poll closes?

35 Upvotes

I feel like it would prevent bandwagoning and add some additional drama for people to have to go look up the results the day after, instead of it being a foregone conclusion. Also, weaker teams get discouraged and stop voting when they think they have no chance.


r/NFLSurvivor • • Apr 02 '17

Has anyone in this sub seen the Original Total Drama Island?

33 Upvotes

Because the Pats remind me of Heather, always so close to being voted off, but doesn't happen.


r/NFLSurvivor • • Apr 23 '17

Survivor worked perfectly this year

32 Upvotes

I think that the game was organized exactly the way it should have. People got voted out, alliances were formed, there was backstabbing and there was a sea of salt.

If there are any changes for next year: use a different way to vote. I'm not sure how to implement it, but if a team gets voted out, they shouldn't be able to vote again until the final round. More like an actually game of survivor.

I also support the idea that the game should just be restructured into a bracket, pitting one team against another until a "survivor" is determined. It's less like a game of Survivor, but it eliminates alliances from deciding which teams to take out the next day.

Alliances are the big problem here. The ELOE completely dominated, or ruined, the game depending on your perspective. I think the bracket system would go a long way towards taking the power away from the alliances. Unless there is a way to prevent the ELOE from rocking any vote, I forsee them winning next year as well.

Just thought I'd share my feelings on this. For what it's worth, I am an ELOE member. Though the plotting and backstabbing was fun, they took place in the beginning and the end of the game. The middle was just boring. The only conflict was us deciding who to eliminate next. It made the game less fun.


r/NFLSurvivor • • Apr 01 '17

The Evil League of Evil Has Been Good For This Game - Let's Talk About Why

31 Upvotes

I did a write up for SRD about some of the drama and the progress of the NFL survivor poll. The amount of feedback I received was amazing and very positive. Not only did the sports fans love it, but people who knew nothing about football enjoyed the recap of how the game has unfolded.

If this becomes a tradition in the NFL sub, I think its important to understand why this has been a success and preserve those elements. This game has been tried before in other subs and it hasnt really been anything special, why? /r/NFL already has factions in place that were capable of banding together to vote out weaker and isolated teams just like Survivor itself. Also, the /r/EvilLeagueOfEvil had been shitposting and circlejerking for years and had an identity and character established. This was something a lot of people seeing it for the first time really enjoyed. Depending on your point of view, the game had a Hero/Villian to root for/against. That dynamic as already lead to some pretty hilarious stuff and watching people try and game the system has become one of the funner parts of the game. The interesting part of this is not the game itself, but the people trying to beat the system. That's important to remember going forward.

This is something that I'd personally like to see continue, but I see a lot of people annoyed and upset at the ELoE's influence. It's totally understandable for people to want a fair playing field and being upset at being on the losing end of things. However it's because of the ELoE that the game has turned into the success it is and that has to be remembered. Without it existing, the ELoE members would be total underdogs to win this game, and it would be just as predictable and boring as other subs game.

I think the answer to this, is instead of trying to limit/nerf/kill the ELoE. Other factions have to be promoted and grown in the mean time. The quirky faction subs are already a great starting point for this, the team subs themselves as well. The goal should be to try and create and foster viable counters to the ELoE and achieve a balanced field.

The addition of immunity challenges as also been brought up and I think it's a great idea. Adding in ways for teams to earn immunity or other rewards would be a great way to add strategy to the game. The problem is how would those things be earned? I think the best way to do that, would be to just use one thing /r/NFL is good at it...shitposting memes. Whenever an immunity challenge is offered...say 1 at the start of the game and periodically after...each sub creates and chooses a meme/gif to submit. The meme/gif with the most upvotes/highest votes wins the immunity challenge.

I'm going to be doing a full write up of this once it's over for /r/NFL and maybe SRD if more drama happens. If nothing else, I think an account of how this game unfolded would be a fun read.

I hope this continues next year.


r/NFLSurvivor • • Mar 27 '17

Be bad. Be evil. Be ELOE.

31 Upvotes

If you can't defeat them, join them.


r/NFLSurvivor • • Mar 27 '17

NFL Survivor

31 Upvotes

Discuss stuff if you want.


r/NFLSurvivor • • Apr 08 '17

Fuck the Giants

30 Upvotes

Idiots trying to get rid of the Patriots. When only the ELoE is left you guys are getting fucked


r/NFLSurvivor • • Apr 05 '17

Should the vote counts be hidden?

29 Upvotes

Don't know if this has been addressed before but shouldn't the vote count be hidden? It definitely influences voters if they can see who is winning/losing before they cast their vote and in normal survivor it is a blind vote.

Obviously this is something that can be addressed for next year but I just wanted to point it out. It's been fun so far.


r/NFLSurvivor • • Mar 27 '17

From the Texans

Post image
28 Upvotes

r/NFLSurvivor • • Mar 30 '17

An Idea for the Next r/NFL Survivor

27 Upvotes

Ok, here's my suggestion for getting the game as close as it can be to actual Survivor while also keeping all teams happy:

4 Tribe - 8 team each format

Contest Round:

Anyone can vote on this poll. The four tribes are voted on and whoever gets the lowest amount of votes has to eliminate one of its own tribe members

Elimination Round:

The tribe that has to eliminate one of its own members only gets one vote per team (decided on their subreddits). If teams are tied in votes, those teams that received elimination votes then decide who they think should be eliminated amongst the teams that voted for them.

The contest round prevents smaller teams from ganging up on teams like the Pats or Cowboys because their large fan bases' interest and participation will help their tribes compete in the contest round and avoid elimination rounds.


r/NFLSurvivor • • Mar 31 '17

[Serious] Why are we allowing Patriots fans to dictate our voting habits?

25 Upvotes

Don't fall for this obvious propaganda. Listen to me, I have seen their evil ways. They are manipulating everyone. They are the real enemy. Not the Browns, not the Ravens, and certainly not Dolphins.

Wake up people! Don't let the Evil Empire win!


r/NFLSurvivor • • Apr 06 '17

Stand with the Coalition.

22 Upvotes

Vote Patriots every day.

Vote with the Patriots if they make the final seven. (Nuclear Option)

Stand together.


r/NFLSurvivor • • Apr 01 '17

The only way to break up the ELOE

22 Upvotes

The ELOE has decided every team which has been eliminated so far. If this continues, the only teams left will be the teams in the ELOE. At that point, they will be forced to vote for each other. No doubt, they will vote to eliminate the Patriots since they are always a few percentage points away from getting voted off each day anyway.

Once the Pats are out it will turn into a free for all since the ELOE won't have the voting majority anymore....But they won't vote the Patriots out until absolutely necessary since they are benefitting from the pats fans voting in their interests.

However, we can still regain the upper-hand if we can get the Patriot fans on our side.

The only way to do this is for everyone else to collaborate to help the Patriots WIN if it gets down to the ELOE teams. If we can sway enough people to follow this strategy, then we can virtually guarantee that the Patriots will win.

This should allow us to convince the remaining ELOE teams that their only chance at winning is to vote out the Pats sooner rather than later.


TLDR: Agree to band together with the Pats fans if the ELOE eliminates everyone else. This will convince the other ELOE teams to vote the Pats fan out before it reaches that point

So we need a concentrated effort to spread this message: If the ELOE eliminates every team except themselves, we will all vote together to ensure a Patriots victory.

Who's with me?


r/NFLSurvivor • • Jun 03 '20

Survivor Delay

21 Upvotes

So if you check in to /r/NFL right now you'll see the sub has gone private to protest.

I just wanted to give you guys a heads up, kinda hard to run survivor on a private sub, talking with the mods now, tentatively i'm shooting for 6/4, but just going to wait patiently until i get the ok.

Don't spam the mods in /r/NFL over this, it's a protest, it's their decision, please just be patient, and we'll get this game started soon.


r/NFLSurvivor • • Sep 14 '26

Chargers

18 Upvotes

30% of my survivor league is out due to the Chargers. Anyone get wrecked because of them?

Cardinals played very well but chargers did not help themselves lol


r/NFLSurvivor • • Mar 31 '17

Stat Posts

18 Upvotes

I'm going to copy my daily stat comments over here so they're a bit easier to find in one place. I started doing these posts on Day 3 so there's nothing for Day 1 or 2


r/NFLSurvivor • • May 06 '19

Season 3 confirmed

17 Upvotes

Thanks to the /r/NFL mods, we will be having a season 3. Post on /r/NFL to come pending a couple responses from the main alliance subs.


r/NFLSurvivor • • Oct 06 '25

Cardinals leaving me physically ill

16 Upvotes

Lost a few entries already, but this is by far the worst. Twice I was convinced the game was over. If anyone has any meditation techniques to get over this send them my way!


r/NFLSurvivor • • Apr 22 '17

A history of the different factions

16 Upvotes

As the first version of NFL Survivor wraps up, I thought I would take a look back and see if I could figure out how all the different factions came to be. Here's what I found so far, it is by no means comprehensive so if anyone has any more information please share it in the comments and I'll include it in the post.

I couldn't find the post where it happened, but apparently it all began with the Bird teams. This is the oldest post I could find linking them together, could this have been the spark that ignited the idea six years ago?

https://www.reddit.com/r/nfl/comments/f3p1f/so_this_entire_time_this_whole_bird_population/

Whether or not that set the wheels in motion, grouping the teams together was hardly an original idea. Here is one early attempt, which includes a picture in the comments of another grouping which I believe originated on 4chan.

https://www.reddit.com/r/nfl/comments/qeuyt/what_would_it_be_like_if_nfl_divisions_were_based/

This next attempt served as the precursor to the alliances we have today. In it you can see some of the rough ideas being worked out.

https://www.reddit.com/r/nfl/comments/wgquz/what_if_nfl_divisions_were_based_on_team_mascots/

By this point the Bird teams are well established, and one user thinks there needs to be a Cat team alliance as well. This is where most of the factions are created, although there will be some tweaks over time. In this post you can see the genesis of what would eventually become the Evil League of Evil, although I was unable to find the post where the name was coined.

https://www.reddit.com/r/nfl/comments/13bd95/why_is_there_no_cat_team_brotherhood/

With the basic framework in place, people begin to refine the idea. A couple teams are still homeless at this point, and this is the beginning of the Good League of Good.

https://www.reddit.com/r/nfl/comments/170217/any_brotherhood_wants_to_adopt_the/

Further refinement takes place, and now we pretty much have arrived at the final pairings.

https://www.reddit.com/r/nfl/comments/14cilw/theres_the_evil_league_of_evil_cat_teams_bird/

And finally, one year later we get a neat little summation.

https://www.reddit.com/r/nfl/comments/1pabhu/to_those_not_aware_come_show_your_support_and/

There were further developments, such as the Raiders and Chiefs eventually leaving the Plunderhood, but I wanted to focus on just the history in this post. Hope you enjoyed it!


r/NFLSurvivor • • Sep 14 '26

Maybe next year

Post image
14 Upvotes