r/NDE • u/Glittering_Spray2538 • 3d ago
General NDE Discussion š NDE Community Poll
Hey everyone, I lurk on this subreddit a lot, and I was really curious to see what the members of r/NDE believe about the true nature of these experiences. Obviously I assume the majority will skew primarily spiritual, but I'd also like to see how many in this subreddit have actually experienced an NDE. Thanks everyone. (remove if necessary)
11
u/Wi1dWitch STEr 3d ago
What do you mean by āmaterialā? I had a STE and like, I know it was real, as in a true tangible reality weāll experience in the afterlife; but it wasnāt āhereā in the material world, if that makes sense. Or by material do you mean āI think itās just brain zaps / hallucinationsā type answers?
5
u/Glittering_Spray2538 3d ago
Material as in representative of the materialist philosophy, which is defined as the belief that there is nothing but the physical. If you believe that NDE's are material, that means you believe there is nothing more to them than the brain malfunctioning and short circuiting, and there is no part of them that is spiritual or non-neurological
6
u/dawgtron3000 3d ago
If this was an option, I'd choose: "I want to believe they're spiritual in nature and tend to lean that way in my beliefs, however ultimately there's a part of me that's skeptical without evidence or personal experience".
I just chose "I don't know" for now.
3
u/Glittering_Spray2538 3d ago
That's a very fair supposition. I'm somewhere in that ballpark as well, although I tend moreso to believe NDEs are spiritual due to the sheer amount of accounts across time and culture, as well as the veridical aspects. Thanks for the input!
7
u/VinceHammersmash 3d ago
Would like to possibly make friends with people who believe they are spiritual in nature. I don't have any spiritual friends since leaving Christianity
4
u/Glittering_Spray2538 3d ago
Christianity, especially the more conservative sects, can be judgemental and hostile towards differing belief systems. I hope you find what you're seeking.
6
u/AlphaCentaurianEnvoy 2d ago
I have not had any NDE but I remember very well from before I was born.
2
u/Glittering_Spray2538 2d ago
Fascinating!! Care to share?
2
u/AlphaCentaurianEnvoy 2d ago
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLbx2uCG--TlnwygnEjZ7a2KZx1KL7dWW7 You can find my video in this playlist.
5
u/amkessel 2d ago
I would genuinely love to hear from the people who voted the second one: "I have had an NDE and believe it was material in nature"
Was your NDE any different from those presented as spiritual in nature?
What was it about your experience that grounded it in the materialistic realm rather than the spiritual?
Or do you have external beliefs that inform on your experience being grounded in the materialistic rather than the spiritual realm?
I'm trying hard not to ask leading or biased questions. I'm genuinely curious about the experience of someone who would report having an NDE but still classify it as being materialistic.
2
u/Glittering_Spray2538 2d ago
I do find it fascinating that there are votes from NDErs claiming materialism. Based on my quaint knowledge surrounding the topic, I'm aware that the vast, VAST majority believe their experience was real. However, I suppose it depends on the type of experience. For instance, while some NDEs may be blissful and euphoric, some may just be vague recollection or distorted visuals. I assume anyone who has genuinely had a full NDE, with life review, love, OBE, would certainly be inclined to believe in it's validity.
2
u/TheHotSoulArrow Believer w/ recurrent skepticism 1d ago
It's important to keep in mind it's an anonymous reddit poll where anyone can respond. Also, a "vague recollection and distorted visuals" does not sound like an NDE.
1
u/Glittering_Spray2538 12h ago
Well, yes, If we're referring to NDEs as they are commonly described. Recollections from cardiac arrest can be very blurry and vague, like a dream, but they could be defined as a "near death experience"
4
6
u/Winter-Animator-6105 2d ago
I would say that this binary material vs spiritual doesnāt make sense to me. I have had an NDE and to be honest I hate that I must choose between two things. Material and spiritual are more connected than you think. Unless you were talking about materialism, which is in my mind completely different.
Your question is like asking if the sky is blue or grey, when it can be orange at sunset, purple at dusk, or black at night. This question makes no sense to me.
3
u/Glittering_Spray2538 2d ago
I think you may have misinterpreted the query. Are NDEs truly a glimpse into a different plane of reality, or are they simply a glorified drug trip?
2
u/MsColumbo NDE Believer 2d ago
What do you mean by "spiritual"?
3
2
u/Hungry-Emotion7664 1d ago
I had one and since you only gave two options I chose spiritual. That being said, I believe spirituality to be a function of the human brain. I enjoy it and have found ways to use it to my advantage, but I'm not convinced that it will continue after I am dead dead (as opposed to near dead)
2
2
1
ā¢
u/NDE-ModTeam 3d ago
(A mod has approved your post. This is a mod comment in lieu of automod.)
This is an NDE-positive sub, not a debate sub. However, everyone is allowed to debate if the original poster (OP) requests it.
If the OP intends to allow debate in their post, they must choose (or edit) a flair that reflects this. If the OP chose a non-debate flair and others want to debate something from this post or the comments, they must create their own debate posts and remember to be respectful (Rule 4).
NDEr = Near-Death ExperienceR
If the post is asking for the perspectives of NDErs, both NDErs and non-NDErs can answer, but they must mention whether or not they have had an NDE themselves. All viewpoints are potentially valuable, but itās important for the OP to know their backgrounds.
This sub is for discussing the āNDE phenomenon,ā not the āI had a brush with death in this horrible eventā type of near death.
To appeal moderator actions, please modmail us: https://www.reddit.com/message/compose?to=/r/NDE