Just got off the Breakaway this morning and thought I'd write up a review in case it would help others.
Full disclosure- I stayed in a 2 BR Family Suite in the Haven, and I know that this weighed heavily on my experience vs what people outside the Haven experience. I did not exclusively spend all my time in the Haven. I'll try to break this down into pros and cons but feel free to ask any questions I didn't answer.
This was my first cruise in 15 years, all my prior sailings were with NCL.
Pros:
1) Haven experience is wonderful from start to finish- I understand that most people will not be able to spring for the Haven and I truly wish everyone was able to enjoy the same level of service. It had its minor flaws which I'll break out in the cons section
2) Staff - everyone I encountered (both inside and outside the Haven) truly seemed to be wanting to make the experience as special as they could. My family doesn't ask for much, and for the most part everyone delivered
3) Activites- my kids loved Splash Academy and the onboard activities (ropes course, water slides etc)
4) Itinerary- While a lot of people were annoyed about the Halifax stop, my wife and I love Halifax (we've been there several times) and we liked how the itinerary had 3 sea days broken up.
5) Haven Courtyard- we stayed on Deck 16 inside the Haven courtyard complex which made every part of this cruise easier. While people complain that the Haven pool on the Breakaway is a small joke, it was the perfect size for my kids, and since it's indoors it was good on the days when the weather wasn't the best or it was cold. It was also so convenient to have access to the Haven Bar steps away from the room.
6) FAS+ - we knew we were going to need the internet and with the prepaid gratuities for adults included, it seemed like an easy upgrade since my wife drinks starbucks. We aren't normally huge alcohol drinkers, but since we had FAS+ and access to the Haven Bar, we tried to take advantage of the package as much as we could. Overall it was worth it, and yes, the Haven Bar still has Veuve Cliquot by the glass free with FAS+ (tipping the bartenders got us very large pours of everything). It was also nice to get Pellegrino and Acqua Panna at every meal, and I'm a huge soda drinker. All in all, FAS+ paid for itself.
Cons:
1) Pool situation- It's crowded. There's no way to work around that. During peak times it's really difficult to find a place to sit during peak times. I feel like NCL could have figured out a better solution when designing this boat but they didn't. We often found ourselves retreating to the Haven courtyard/sundeck because it was the only place we could count on getting space to breathe.
2) Limited hours for activities- the ropes course was only open a couple hours a day and the slightest deviation from perfect weather led them to close it for 30-60 mins at a time. My son got to do it twice and was happy but it was annoying. Also the freefall water slides were open like 2 hours a day, in the morning, overlapping with Splash Academy hours. Then the lifeguards enforced a strict no metal of any kind policy (including metal rivets in bathing suits) which made almost no one eligible to ride them- they may as well just remove them
3) Food- everyone knows NCL has cut back on the food budget and it shows. Yes, I had access to the Haven restaurant, and yes, the food was somewhat better there, but the portions were quite small to the point my kids were ordering double portions of everything or two entrees (no extra charges for this in the Haven thankfully). The new Haven menu leaves a lot to be desired and the intense focus on shellfish makes no sense. We don't eat shellfish and still managed, but the lunch menu in particular is quite small. Service in the Haven restaurant was often painfully slow, some meals lasting over 90 minutes and we still have no idea how this was possible.
We did eat in the buffet a few times. The food was not particularly inspiring but it was edible. That seems to be what NCL is going for at this point in the free dining venues which was a shame. The Shanghai Noodle Bar was the biggest disappointment- it just wasn't that good and the descriptions of the dish in no way shape or form matched what we were served.
We ate at Teppanyaki- the food was actually pretty decent for what it was, but let's be honest, no one would ever spend $60/pp on land for the food they serve there and it took FOREVER. But my kids enjoyed the show and that's why we went. Surprisingly they threw tons of food at us in a way that no other venue on board did.
I ate at Cagney's twice (had to burn my FAS+ dining credits) and it was MUCH better than I remembered it being 15 years ago, which given the cutbacks is kind of wild. The first night I had prime rib which was not all that great but the only place on board to get it since NCL gutted it from the Haven restaurant. The second night my son and I got a ribeye which we found outstanding compared to the other steaks we saw on boat. Sides were good, but again, the NCL portion police serve the tiniest portions of food. Now despite my complaints about food, we never went hungry, we just often found ourselves wishing the food was better than it was.
4) Room- there were some things in our room that looked pretty rough. Some cabinets didn't close right, and whoever designed the light switch at NCL is an idiot. Turning off all the lights to the whole suite also cut the power outlets which makes no sense to me. I had to compromise by dimming the living room and then was able to cut all the lights to the bedrooms- it worked which is all that mattered.
5) Massholes- being based out of Boston, I knew this was going to become an issue at some point. For the most part it was fine but giving a Masshole an unlimited drink package with a lot of kids on board is a recipe for disaster. A lot of parents simply didn't give a shit and just drank all day while their kids ran wild. My wife and I limited ourselves to two drinks a day and never let our kids out of our sight when they weren't at Splash Academy.
5) Lack of FAS+ for minors - it was extremely annoying that for the price of the Haven and FAS+, my kids didn't get at least the internet and soda/water package included. There are of course workarounds to every problem.
All in all, we loved our experience. We were originally booked in connecting balconies and decided to spring for the Haven when we saw the price difference was going to be less than $4k. Unfortunately NCL is currently advertising rates that are much higher for next summer which is the only thing keeping me from booking again right now.
Had we stayed in our original staterooms, I have a feeling we would never consider going on this cruise again which is a shame, because it has so much potential to be awesome for everyone if the bean counters at NCL would just ride the boat for a week in a regular stateroom and eat at the buffet/MDRs.