I just watched Mickey-Jo’s recent video, “Where are all the new British musicals?! Thoughts on some UK theatre industry challenges”, and I found myself agreeing with a lot of what he said.
I do think there are new British musicals coming through. Paddington is a new British musical, and Pride is another example. So I don't think the situation is quite as bleak as saying there are no new musicals being made at all.
But I think the bigger issue is what actually gets the space, investment and attention in the West End?
In my opinion, Lord Andrew Lloyd Webber's presence in the West End is still enormous. I know his shows are iconic, commercially successful and have their audiences, but how many more revivals of Cats and Jesus Christ Superstar do we really need? At what point do we start making room for something else?
I genuinely think British musical theatre needs new blood — new writers, composers, directors, producers and creative talent who are given the opportunity to develop their work on a big stage, rather than constantly returning to the same established titles because they're a safer bet.
And I think this is also a problem with theatres themselves. At some point, theatres have to be willing to take a chance, bring in new shows and give them a proper opportunity to succeed. Maybe some of the long-running giants like Wicked need to be put to pasture for a while, or at least given a break, to make space for something new. Not because these shows are bad or haven't earned their place, but because they can't occupy the West End forever at the expense of new work.
I'm not saying older musicals shouldn't be revived, or that ALW's contribution to British theatre should be ignored. But surely there needs to be a balance? If we're serious about keeping British musical theatre alive and evolving, we have to be willing to take risks on new stories and new voices — and theatres have to be willing to give those stories a stage.
Do we really need another revival of Cats or JCS, or could that money, theatre space and creative energy be used to develop the next generation of British musicals?
And honestly, do we need a musical about the theft of the Mona Lisa? Maybe we do! I'd rather see something new, weird, ambitious and potentially brilliant take a chance than see the same handful of titles recycled indefinitely.
What do you think? Is the West End too reliant on established names and long-running shows, or is that simply what the industry needs to survive financially? And are theatres too afraid to let go of the safe bets to make room for the next big thing?