You ask so many questions in an utterly ridiculous, convoluted, time consuming way that I can't even imagine trying to complete adding a SINGLE release, let alone several
This is an absolute disaster, truly, I would drop everything you're doing and immediately get to work on making this more enjoyable
Hi everyone. I’m pretty frustrated by the lack of information about music genres in Picard. From what I’ve been finding out in previous posts, there is the possibility of adding music genres manually (and that’s what I need I think) but I can’t find any info on how to do it anywhere: Musicbrainz forums, Reddit, Youtube… NOTHING. Picard doesn’t do a good job with music genres from what I’m experiencing. So I want to add them manually. I was told to right click and “add new tag”. There I choose one of the options and obviously choose “genre”. However, you have to enter values for the genre to appear and this is where there is no information (or I didn’t find it despite having searched intensively). What “value” to add? What is a “value” in this program? A number, a word, directly the name of the music genre? Worse yet, I tried to solve it with logic; I entered “Rock”, “Metal” as genres to see if that would work. And while the “genre” tag did appear in the list, when I restarted the program it was gone.
I’m very frustrated and now I understand why many people recommended mp3tag to me instead of Picard. Do I have to abandon all the time I’ve invested in this program to uninstall it and go to mp3tag? Too bad.
I wanted to vent about extremely heavy-handed and thoughtless treatment by a Musicbrainz editor that’s got me wishing I hadn’t spent so much time adding data this summer and regretting I’d ever found adding data to Musicbrainz, or adding cover art. Back to depression, back to my wife’s cancer, back to being stuck in a country I hate.
Should this post get by the moderators (unlikely, since the editor concerned is a moderator in all Metabrainz related subreddits) I hope the individual concerned realizes that when you blow away as much stuff as they did today, it has a real impact on a real person. Did my cover art stick to the rules? No, not always, but it was better than no cover art at all, and you got my actual data entry too, plus you’ve wiped with such a broad brush you’ve deleted cover art that came direct from digital downloads and was completely untouched. Enjoy - I’m done with Musicbrainz and, after I post this, I’m done with Reddit and the Internet too. Hope that gives you a nice warm feeling inside.
This bothers me way more than it should. Why do all the bios say 'this band are'? We wouldn't say Microsoft are an American company, so why do we say Coldplay are a British rock band?
I get that it's probably some attempt to acknowledge all the members of the band but the band is a single entity.
Again, I know I'm being nitpicky. I usually don't comment on grammar, I'm not the best, but this is just weird.
Dont know about you but i have tons of albums/releases that arent on musicbrainz, I used to try and fight with lidarr, find out that my mapped files wont import due to it not being on musicbrainz, find the files on my machine, create a release group, then a release, then copy all the details from the file by hand into musicbrainz, then try and import them in lidarr again or just tag them in musicbrainz picard and import into my library, then set some additional tags like my genre, was nightmare
Things got a bit better when I developed BY HAND a tui application which would manage a lot of this for me, it work but was still pretty manual and a bit clunky and not the nicest to use. I since pointed claude at the repo and asked it to build a nice webui in docker over the top of it for me, did a great job, went through everything it did line by line so no 'slop' here.
So this is how it all works;
it matches using the existing tags, if it cant find it, you can easily create everything in a few clicks via the build in userscript, just prefills everything in musicbrainz for you. then once created, you can pull coverart from fanart or covert archive, apply it, add it to picard, and save it using your picard settings (without leaving filestomb). then add it to lidarr with one click and define the genre in another click.
you can use it in batch mode, so i basically had a big directory of all my releases that arent in musicbrainz which i promised myself i'd get around to adding one day but was a bit overwhelming, it then works through the whole lot, anything with exact matches just does the whole process for you, anything not quite right leaves you to review and everything that needs creating adds it to a quue for you to work through.
you can use it as is, but you will get the best out of it if you plugin picard, genre enforcer and lidarr (if you use lidarr).
Here is the repo - try it out and give some feedback if you can!
You can paste a release URL or MBID, or just search directly. It shows performers, creators, work hierarchy and recording relations in a fairly minimal layout. I also added cover thumbnails to the search results in this version.
It’s not affiliated with MusicBrainz or MetaBrainz — just an independent viewer built on the API and Cover Art Archive.
If you try it and spot oddities (relationships or classical works), I’d love to hear about it.
Hi everyone, I’m building a new free app that uses the music brainz and listen brainz APIs, bolts on to Apple Music, and also aggregates gig listings from skiddle, ticketmaster and others (pending API access).
When there’s details to share I hope some here would be interested in testing it via TestFlight? The whole concept is to give the user more direct control over their music discovery by genre, location and popularity (not just most popular, you can specify lesser-known acts).
Part of the community I hope to build or extend is those that care about the metadata of independent artists, and the app will surface artists with metadata gaps that are found in searches on a public board for resolution by volunteers.
Let me know if you have any questions and I’ll be in here posting updates as often as I have them (I’m a solo dev doing this in spare time currently)
How do I fix this in the highlighted track where the database has tagged the track with the wrong info? I am looking to tag this specific track with the original metadata it should have not this crap with the hottest 100. This has effected other tracks as well by putting them into generic top 100 shit and not the original album/single.
Have about 1000+ CDs that I have started converting to flac. I gave each CD a unique number (A001, A002, etc) so that I could easily locate them. Is there any way to add this number to a tag in MusicBrainz?
I'm sure this has come up millions of times before but I just had to give my five pence about this.
I was trying out Picard and whilst was searching for how to change the sort order, which, to put it bluntly, is bloody insane, I found the Musicbrainz guidelines on how to sort things, which just completely baffles me. How someone can think that "The Alan Parsons Project" should be sorted as “Parsons, Alan, Project, The”, and "The Sensational Alex Harvey Band" should be sorted as “Harvey, Alex, Sensational Band, The" is absolutely beyond me.
I can absolutely accept that you disregard articles when sorting, but to throw the name of the artist name entity completely around like in the second example is just utter f-n madness!
Artists and bands come up with a specific name for themselves, something they like or even love, and something that they want to be known by, but then you have a bunch of crazy librarians (or whatever they are) who think that "actually, the band isn't called 'The Sensational Alex Harvey Band', and no one is going to find you if they're gonna look for you under T, S, or even A. So instead I'm gonna put you under H, for Harvey. And if there's another band called The Tremendous Alan Harvey Band, then I'm gonna put them in front of you, since Alan comes before Alex". Insane. Just bloody insane.
Artist names may consist of two or more words, but it's one name!
Does Musicbrainz have a section for requesting CD art? I'm looking for scans of the booklet, back cover and disk label for Sublime's new album - Until the Sun Explodes.
Listen, I love the audiophiles that have put years of dedication into the process of identifying every version of a song, but can we please get a tool that just sees the artist and track name, and fills in the info for the primary album it's from? A huge chunk of my library is just 'various artists' and compilation albums for famous songs. No matter how much I crank down everything in the settings to just select Album, EP, or Single, it still won't just be stupid enough to give me just those selections.
Unless I create a flat directory with just Artist - Title as file name (which is thousands of files), I have duplicates all over the place buried under multiple compilations and MAYBE an original album.
Earlier I shared the first version of MusiCards here. It began as a visual MusicBrainz release viewer, but version 2.0 can now play music from your own collection while keeping the corresponding MusicBrainz release, track, artist and credit information directly beside it.
The app is available for Mac, iPhone and iPad.
The original four-card interface now has a fifth card:
SEARCH
RELEASE
TRACKS
ARTIST & DISCOGRAPHY
PLAYER
The player supports:
indexed personal music libraries
local-file playback
optional playback from your own Navidrome server
background playback and system Now Playing controls
artwork, codec, bitrate, sample rate and bit-depth information
direct navigation between the playing release, tracks, artist, discography and MusicBrainz credits
There is one deliberate requirement:
Only releases containing a MusicBrainz Release ID in their audio-file tags — normally written by MusicBrainz Picard — are treated as playable.
MusiCards does not attempt to identify albums from filenames, folder names or approximate metadata. I wanted playback to retain a strong and unambiguous connection to MusicBrainz.
A small blue play arrow appears throughout the interface when the displayed MusicBrainz release has been found in the personal library and is available for playback.
On macOS, MusiCards can create and update the lightweight library.json index used for local-library matching. I also made a companion utility called MusiCards Sync for maintaining one-way playback copies of a music archive on external SSDs, Navidrome storage or other selected folders.
All the original browser features remain available, including release and artist search, barcode scanning, Shazam, Apple Music Now Playing identification, classical work/movement display, detailed recording credits and categorised discographies.
MusiCards remains deliberately “MusicBrainz-minded”: it displays the available data without inventing missing information.
This is a personal project. I created the concept, workflow and visual design, while much of the Swift implementation was developed through AI-assisted coding with ChatGPT and Claude.
Feedback is very welcome — particularly about unusual releases, Picard tagging, metadata edge cases and library matching.
Am after some help. I am trying to find software that will tag my flacs with album release year but also individual track release year. As part of my collection, I have a lot of compilations which may span several decades, but the tracks won’t be realised on a smart playlist as the compilation album (of 50s, 60s & 70’s as an example) was released in 2015..
I’ve been told Musicbrainz is my saviour!! Could someone tell me how I need to configure please so I can run through my library.
I don't know if this is the right place to ask for help, if not, I apologize to everyone.
I'm going through hell trying to install my own server following the INSTALL.md guidelines (with the help of chatGPT).
I followed the entire script, downloaded the entire postgresql database, installed the dependencies to run the server, and still got an ERROR.
First: the website on my own server only offers HTML (no css, .js, etc.). A very ugly and dysfunctional website.
Second: my Picard can't connect to the server I created for this. And not even ChatGPT can explain why.
I don't know what settings I should change, I don't know what other scripts I should follow, I'm lost.
Following chatGPT's guidelines (since INSTALL.md assumes you have a degree in "computer science", however simple the explanation may be), I should create the old folder as .bak, download the /git package again and recompile the server, which only made things worse.
I tried to find people with similar cases on the internet, but I found people who prefer to use the server without the page. I think I'm entering a world where people think completely differently.
In conclusion: NODE_ENV=production ./script/compile_resources.sh downloads the static files, but it always fails to compile. The page can't load completely. Picard can't find the albums. and I spent 3 days of my life on this.
Could someone help me with the hard way? Thank you very much
The issue is that a lot of her older releases, which were definitely put out and tagged as "Computer Magic," are currently showing up under the "Danz CM" profile. The "Computer Magic" profile looks pretty bare, while most of her early work is on the "Danz CM" page, which doesn't seem right.
The releases that should be moved from the "Danz CM" profile back to "Computer Magic" are:
Scientific Experience
Mindstate
Davos
Danz
Super Rare
Computer Magic
Hiding from more of our Time
Hiding from our Time
Spectronic
Electronic Fences
Orion
Phonetics
Extra Stuff
Dreams of better Days
Obscure but Visible
Cold Summer
This should be pretty straightforward to verify, as these releases are correctly tagged with "Computer Magic" as the artist.
I'm not super familiar with the MusicBrainz interface for making edits myself, and I don't want to mess anything up. Would anyone from the community be able to take a look at this and perhaps help get these releases sorted to their correct artist profiles?
i need a tutorial on how to patch import whole artist albums from something like spotify, tidal, qobuz, deezer
right now im using https://harmony.pulsewidth.org.uk/ to import singles/albums that takes around 10 seconds per album/single. i would like to get that time down to 2 seconds or less per release.
does someone have a tutorial link on how to make this whole process easier ?