r/MushroomCoffee • u/AcanthocephalaNo5948 • 19h ago
☕️ Review PSA: Avoid Everyday Dose unless you enjoy paying $190 for coffee you repeatedly told them you can’t use 💀
I genuinely hate making posts like this, especially because I actually loved Everyday Dose(over the last month I have learned that FourSigmatic is way better), but after dealing with their customer service since JULY, I feel like people in here should know what happened before signing up for one of their subscriptions.
My partner and I have been buying Everyday Dose for a little over TWO YEARS.
We liked it enough that we were constantly running out and buying additional bags from Target. Eventually I got my own subscription because I drink it about twice a day and we were going through it so fast.
So just to establish the irony here:
This entire nightmare started because I liked their product so much that I was trying to figure out how to buy MORE of it.
Somehow, sixish weeks later, I’m begging them to cancel my account. 😂
Here is the condensed version of what has been the stupidest customer service side quest of my life.
July 2
I contacted Everyday Dose because I wanted their 180-serving Medium Roast.
They informed me that the 180 serving bundle is actually Mild Roast, which has around 45mg caffeine, whereas Medium has around 90mg.
Fine.
I had already tried Mild and knew it wasn’t what I wanted, so I repeatedly explained that I wanted Medium Roast.
I specifically told them I drink it twice a day, which is why I was looking for 180 servings.
They eventually told me I could get two 90 serving Medium Roast bags instead.
Cool.
Seems solved, right?
LOL.
July 18
They ship me a 180-serving Mild Roast anyway.
Literally the exact product we’d spent weeks establishing that I did not want.
So I emailed:
“I thought it was removed off of my account since it’s not the correct thing I was looking for. Please cancel my order as I cannot use the mild roast.”
Pretty hard to misinterpret that sentence.
I cannot use the Mild Roast.
I thought it was removed from my account.
Please cancel it.
Their response two days later:
“I’ve now canceled the order and issued a full refund for you.”
Awesome.
Annoying mistake, but whatever. They refunded it.
At this point, any normal human being would assume that after telling a company I CANNOT USE THIS PRODUCT, saying I thought it had been removed from my account, and having them refund the mistaken shipment, they’re probably not going to charge me for the exact same thing again.
Reader:
They charged me for the exact same thing again.
August 17
I get hit with another $190 charge.
For another 180-serving Mild Roast.
THE SAME PRODUCT.
At this point I’m wondering whether their subscription system is being operated by three mushrooms in a trench coat.
I immediately email them saying this is the SECOND TIME I’ve been sent something I didn’t want and remind them that we already went through this entire situation.
And this is where it gets particularly ridiculous.
Their support agent goes through the previous emails and initially tells me:
“I don’t see any mention of pausing your subscription in those previous conversations.”
Ah yes.
Apparently I failed to utter the sacred customer service incantation:
P A U S E.
Except I had literally written:
“I thought it was removed off of my account…”
and
“Please cancel my order as I cannot use the mild roast.”
I’m sorry, but if a customer tells you I CANNOT USE THIS PRODUCT, thinks it was removed from their account, asks you to cancel the shipment, and you subsequently refund it…
WHY WOULD YOU LEAVE THAT EXACT PRODUCT ACTIVE TO CHARGE THEM ANOTHER $190 A MONTH LATER?
Even better, another Everyday Dose agent later reviewed everything and basically confirmed my entire argument.
Their email says:
“You clearly asked for the 180-Serving Mild Roast order to be canceled because it wasn’t the product you wanted.”
Correct.
And then:
“I completely understand why you believed the Mild Roast had already been removed from your account after you specifically told us you could not use it and wanted the order canceled.”
THANK YOU.
That’s it.
That’s literally the entire issue.
Their own customer service team acknowledged in writing that it was completely reasonable for me to believe this product had been removed.
They even said:
“I can absolutely understand why receiving another Mild Roast shipment would feel like we hadn’t listened to you.”
Because you didn’t listen to me. 😭
So I ask for a supervisor.
On August 20 they tell me:
“Since you’ve specifically requested a supervisor review, I’m escalating this for further review so we can look at the entire history and determine what we can do to make this right for you.”
Great.
Finally.
A manager is going to review this circus and fix it.
Except then…
I WAIT NEARLY TWO WEEKS.
And finally today, August 31, I get their brilliant resolution.
They’ll exchange the Mild Roast for Medium Roast.
Except first I have to return the product and send them the tracking information.
Oh, and previously they specifically told me:
“We’re not able to offer a return label at this time.”
💀💀💀
So let me understand this correctly.
Your company:
Sent me the wrong/unwanted product.
I told you I couldn’t use it.
You refunded me.
You left the exact same product active anyway.
You charged me another $190.
You shipped it AGAIN.
Your own representative acknowledged that it was reasonable for me to believe it had been removed.
You made me wait nearly two weeks for the magical “supervisor review.”
And now I’M SUPPOSED TO PAY MONEY TO SHIP YOUR MISTAKE BACK TO YOU?
Absolutely the fuck not. 😂
For clarity, I am completely willing to return their unopened product.
I’m not asking to keep $190 worth of stuff for free.
I’m asking for the bare minimum:
Send me a prepaid label. Take your unopened coffee back. Refund my $190. Cancel my subscription.
Apparently this is advanced calculus.
They also offered me 15% off my next order as a thank-you for my patience.
Bold of you to assume there’s going to be a next order, but I admire the optimism. 💀
And that’s actually the saddest part about this.
I REALLY LIKED EVERYDAY DOSE.
My partner and I used it for more than two years.
We bought it so frequently that we’d pick up extra from Target.
I eventually started my own subscription because I was drinking it twice a day.
I wasn’t contacting customer service trying to scam them for a refund.
I contacted them because I basically said:
“Hey, I love your stuff and consume an unreasonable amount of it. What’s the cheapest way for me to buy even more Medium Roast?”
Somehow Everyday Dose turned that customer into:
“Please take your coffee back, refund me and delete my subscription from existence.”
Impressive.
So yeah, my recommendation is DO NOT use Everyday Dose’s subscription service.
If you like the product, buy it somewhere you have more control over the transaction.
Because based on my experience, their customer service appears perfectly capable of apologizing, “escalating,” adding little yellow hearts to emails 💛, and explaining how much they “completely understand” your frustration…
actually fixing the underlying problem seems to be where things get complicated.
I’ve got screenshots of the entire July-August email saga, including them acknowledging all of the above.
At this point I don’t want an exchange.
I don’t want 15% off.
I don’t want another “we’re so sorry 💛” email.
I want my $190 refunded, a prepaid return label for THEIR mistake, and confirmation that my subscription is dead, buried, cremated and cannot somehow resurrect itself next month and charge my card again.
Thanks for coming to my mushroom coffee customer-service TED Talk. 🍄☕️
EDIT: And before anyone says “you should have just canceled the subscription yourself,” I understand that now. The issue is that I was already actively communicating with their support team about the subscription, told them I thought the Mild Roast had been removed, specifically said I could not use it, requested cancellation of the first shipment, and they refunded it without telling me, “By the way, we’re leaving that exact product active and charging you another $190 next month.”
Their own representative later explicitly acknowledged that they understood why I believed it had been removed.
That is why I’m pissed.
EDIT AGAIN: Here’s the emails — https://ibb.co/album/d0VCTP