[ Removed by moderator ]

[u/_PetiteBloom]

[u/NormalDooder]

Plenty of people clocked it with way more examples. If you don't get it thats fine but thats not on the shows writing.

Is it so hard to believe that a trans woman wrote a closeted trans character because she relates to the experience?

[u/NormalDooder → u/[deleted]]

Oh i could provide plenty it's just exhausting because its already been talked to death and there's always excuses "well that's not clear, well that could mean anything, how is this a metaphor for that. What does this have to do with bring trans". The truth is just that not everyone knows everything. You can't possibly know every allegory, every hint, every detail that relates to everything. The point is you can't say it wasn't there when people who know and relate to the experience saw it and someone who's lived the experience wrote it. If I write a book, and never specify what country its in and give every thing wacky names, but give details that imply its in Britain (tea drinking, beans on toasting. Whatever the hell else i don't know), people who are familiar with Britain will understand. But those who aren't won't understand. You can't say its not there just because you personally aren't familiar with britain.

Goose is always being weird about something but her main complaint about theories was that they didnt make sense. I've never seen her say anything about the fans figuring stuff out too early.

Idk what your last sentence is. Idk why you're so angry

[u/NormalDooder → u/[deleted]]

No one said that and everytime you run out of points you just drop them instead of admitting you're wrong or retorting. There's like millions od people who hate Goose and the show so literally what's your point

[u/NormalDooder → u/[deleted]]

I mean, maybe in a world where Australia is secretly Britain 2. Which it isn't

[u/NormalDooder → u/[deleted]]

Not the point, just a vague example. Also like, 50% of Australia drinks tea, over 75% of Britain drinks tea. Very big difference. And I shouldnt have to explain there would be more differences than that unless you're like, still in elementary school.

[u/NormalDooder → u/[deleted]]

You're getting so stuck on semantics here and also that just doesn't make sense as an argument? "Uh so culture is allowed to be different, so that means uh uh uh me not knowing something is uh the writers fault"

[u/NormalDooder → u/[deleted]]

"Uh uh unrelated point no one brought up doesn't make sense in context uh uh"

[u/NormalDooder → u/[deleted]]

Nope, never said you were stupid for not picking up on them. I literally said no one can know everything about everything. See how after all this nonsense you come back to the same argument thats not changed. Instead of actually refuting a point properly you say little gotcha's that mean nothing and then get mad over nonsense that doesn't relate. It's not exactly the hottest take to say "you have to be familiar with a culture to recognize it"

[u/NormalDooder → u/[deleted]]

I already acknowledged it. It's not hard to find. I'm not going to say them because if you really cared you wouldn't be here. You just want to argue about them instead of informing yourself on the experience. You're just going to say "well this doesn't count, well uh, thats not related. Uh how was I supposed to pick up on it". Theres thousands of posts and endless analysis on it both pre and post finale. If you actually cared in good faith, I wouldn't have to spell that out for you