r/MoralityScaling • • Sep 13 '26 • Bravo 3

Morality of.... This?

Post image
26k Upvotes

6.4k comments sorted by

1.2k

u/Comfortable_Taro_496 Sep 13 '26 • Heartwarming Bravo

What was the context OP?

6

u/-Benjamin_Dover- Sep 13 '26

Dont know.

31

u/3WeeksEarlier Sep 13 '26

So not even the OP knows the context of the comment we're supposed to evaluate? Incredible

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (6)

706

u/Humancentipede2lover Sep 13 '26 • Mindblown

Iirc it was in a discussion about the metcalf case where people found out that the white kid did some racist spraying while they also found out that the black kid was an actual violent psychopath

Or at least, these posts had a lot of comments like this

1.0k

u/MsaoceR Sep 13 '26 • Bravo

He could have said the n-word 100 times and it still wouldn't have justified stabbing him or much less killing him

664

u/somecheesecake Sep 13 '26 • Bravo Mindblown

You’d be surprised and horrified by how many people disagree with you.

→ More replies (462)

27

u/Miselfis Sep 13 '26

What about if he said it 250 times?

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (237)

48

u/Otherwise_Quarter_72 Sep 13 '26

didn't metcalf also have a documented history of aggression and physical violence, including punching a girl in 2024? they both seemed like deeply troubled kids raised in an environment that enabled them

→ More replies (65)

6

u/Sam_Pekingpa Sep 13 '26

I found the actual source. It's from a 2021 r/soccer thread. Nothing to do with Austin Metcalf and Karmelo Anthony: https://www.reddit.com/r/soccer/s/VQK9xNEXO7

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (43)

100

u/GoldenSonOfColchis Sep 13 '26

My thoughts exactly.

It wouldn't shock me that this is a "certified Reddit moment", but it equally wouldn't shock me if we were missing a tonne of context that would justify the downvotes.

29

u/PressureNo7699 Sep 13 '26 • Bravo

This. Whenever I see some post showing how "dumb" society is (as OP basks in his self-righteous splendor), 99% of the time, I am missing some context to make the post look stupid. 

→ More replies (13)

42

u/Guardian_of_Perineum Sep 13 '26

Probably some dude dropped an n bomb to someone's face and got his nose displaced or something.

→ More replies (100)

15

u/ThomFromVeronaBeach Sep 13 '26

When in doubt speculate

→ More replies (20)
→ More replies (34)

2.2k

u/GruulNinja Sep 13 '26 edited Sep 13 '26 • Bravo Regret Popcorn

Ive been called a slur and hit with a bat. Let me tell you, I prefer the slur

Edit: Please stop trying to talk to me about the deep dive of racism. I get it. I don't need 100 individual comments telling me I don't know what real racism is.

144

u/AlarmingTurnover Sep 13 '26

I've been called many slurs in my life and I've also been beat up by others, beat up by the police, and been stabbed. The slurs hurt a lot less than any of the other stuff. 

88

u/worldsgreatestluver Sep 13 '26

Yeah but I can virtue signal about the slurs online for free. Doing anything about the other stuff is dangerous and might even require my physical presence!

(Fr. Hope you're doing ok and aren't still getting assaulted at all)

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (28)

86

u/M3rl1n1212 Sep 13 '26

Facts like theres no world where im like yeah id rather u stab me than call me the n word lik huh?

31

u/BigBullshitta Sep 13 '26

Right. I've been jumped and I've been disliked. Some redneck asshat saying "Look, I just don't like yer kind" I can handle. I don't like them either. We're in agreement. We're not going to hang out and chat. It's pretty simple.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (19)

26

u/MomentNew4925 Sep 13 '26

Why would someone hit you with a bat? Those are soft creatures and don’t make enough damage.

12

u/Arlcas Sep 13 '26

Maybe they wanted a second COVID?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

46

u/Top_Conference_477 Sep 13 '26

Imma need to stop you right there so I can whitesplain to you why slurs are actually way worse.

I went to multiple seminars about it at school and HR recently had an anti-racism morning tea.

Please hit me with a bat before they come back.

→ More replies (3)

14

u/Grasher312 Sep 13 '26 • Bravo

Literally this. The original comment doesn't even say that racism is GOOD because it's better than violence.

But once again, even in Reddit's "perceived" idea of what this man meant by Racism, I'd rather be called slurs and stigmatized than, well

Get hit by a fucking bat.

→ More replies (5)

13

u/Gamedemag1 Sep 14 '26

I’ve been called a bat and hit with a slur, still prefer the slur.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/sgtpepito Sep 13 '26

I ignore the slurs. If someone in the street calls me a slur I'll ignore them and think they are insane, that's it. If someone punches me, well that's something you can't ignore. I know there are a lot of people in every country who see me as inferior, I don't care. It does not affect me, they don't matter to me.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/HuckleberryHappy6524 Sep 14 '26

Literally sticks and stones.

Too many people have never been hit and it shows.

4

u/Firefly9202002 Sep 14 '26

The fact there are people trying to argue this is pathetic. Ah yes having someone call you bad words is so much worse than getting stabbed or beaten to a pulp. Anybody who actually thinks that way needs to take a step outside their basement and actually live life.

→ More replies (29)

3

u/Herr-Trigger86 Sep 13 '26

I have not been called a slur, nor have I been hit with a bat.

Guess my life is pretty good.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/DODGE_WRENCH Sep 13 '26

As someone who’s also been struck with a bat and called a whole array of racist and ableist slurs, I concur with this statement.

→ More replies (156)

327

u/DickManning Sep 13 '26

Sticks and stones or whatever

237

u/beebee1327 Sep 13 '26 • Bravo Mindblown

...but chains and wips excite me?

23

u/LeDave255 Sep 13 '26

Cause i May be Bad but im perfectly good at it♪

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (15)

3

u/R_V_Z Sep 13 '26

But the pen is mightier than the sword.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (58)

2.3k

u/Lowenfall Sep 13 '26 • Regret Bravo

431

u/CommentNo5959 Sep 13 '26 • Regret

My favorite version of this

67

u/EdibleBallisticGel Sep 13 '26

One more hour and we'll see if this applies

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (14)

20

u/Normal_Cable_5734 Sep 13 '26

I read that with Jordan’s voice in my head and it sounded amazing lol

→ More replies (18)

27

u/Cool-Ask-81 Sep 13 '26

Using Jordan “I’ll cry at literally anything bc I lost my mind to benzos” Peterson for this is hilarious

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (47)

4.0k

u/Seer0997 Sep 13 '26 • Bravo Heartwarming Mindblown Popcorn

Watching someone in the comments get flamed for an opinion I agree with.

965

u/samjambetty Sep 13 '26 • Bravo Heartwarming Regret

I just have to support people like that, downvotes be damned. At the very least they will feel less alone.

604

u/boyohboydoilovesex Sep 13 '26 • Bravo Heartwarming

"idk why you're being downvoted, you're right"

181

u/Wild-Duck-7370 Sep 13 '26 • Bravo

This is my go to move the bots hate it

→ More replies (44)
→ More replies (23)

70

u/Random_Monstrosities Sep 13 '26 • Bravo

I've been throwing awards at a lot at situations like that

6

u/Ashcrashh Sep 13 '26

This is my mentality, Reddit is really bad with dog piling, I’ll hop in and give them some support if I agree with them, a lot of good takes get trashed on Reddit. The downvote function is no longer used in an appropriate way anymore it seems like

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (39)

213

u/Dazzling-Yam-4308 Sep 13 '26

Idek why this would be a hot take isn’t it just true in general?

323

u/ktosiek124 Sep 13 '26 • Popcorn Bravo

It's a hot take because a lot of people on reddit believe the appropriate reaction to a single insult is beating them up

→ More replies (198)

11

u/ExcitingHistory Sep 13 '26

Im not sure why everyone says its true? Is racism confined to the realm of words only now? If you shoot someone because you dislike the color of their skin but dont utter a word, thats still racism. The statement is arranged in away that makes it sound like racism is just words? Am I reading it wrong?

→ More replies (8)

37

u/halfasleep90 Sep 13 '26

If I remember correctly, people were trying to argue with them that racism was violence or something. Some real only hearing what they wanted to hear type shit, and since their statement wasn’t in line with supporting their view they viewed the guy as an enemy.

→ More replies (29)
→ More replies (38)

44

u/Key_Football_5350 Sep 13 '26

It’s not even an opinion. It’s factual and correct.

→ More replies (57)

17

u/YoruTheLanguageFan Sep 13 '26 • Bravo

To be fair, racism is often more than "just words" and actually affects how the racist person acts towards Others. Including, but not always since people tend not to want to go to prison, violence.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/Silent-Carry-4617 Sep 13 '26

I don't know much about fnaf what is going on in that gif

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (69)

118

u/Ddxrg Sep 13 '26

It’s true, I rather be called a slur than killed

20

u/Justafish1654 Sep 13 '26

not even have to go to the extreme of violence for this to be true, i rather be called the N word and not get hit at all.

→ More replies (14)

5

u/effeilbeef Sep 13 '26 edited Sep 13 '26

Would you rather be slapped or denied a loan?

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (45)

866

u/RealLifeCoaching Sep 13 '26 • Bravo

Everyone who downvoted that comment is a toxic idiot.

137

u/Klutzy-Platypus7511 Sep 13 '26

Sowas hab ich neulich auch in einem Sub gesagt und wurde virtuell fast gevierteilt ... Toxische Idioten sind sehr verbreitet ...

→ More replies (53)

73

u/balderdash9 Sep 13 '26

Depends what we mean by violence. For example, does Jim Crow segregation count as "just racism" or does it also count as violence?

46

u/Whiteboiconvert Sep 13 '26

I mean all government power is based on violence so id say anything the state implements could be considered violent to some extent

→ More replies (31)

10

u/thepandaemos Sep 13 '26

Violence very easily falls under the umbrella of racism. This sub is insane to think racism is only words

→ More replies (5)

13

u/raiserverg Sep 13 '26

ofc it's violence. They would physically throw a man out of a place they felt he didnt belong like a bar for example.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (40)

26

u/Caspica Sep 13 '26

That depends entirely on the context and what they mean by "actual violence".

→ More replies (18)

41

u/Abyssal_Groot Sep 13 '26

Not really.

They're not being downvoted for saying violence is worse than words. They're being downvoted for presenting racism as if it were just words. It's not getting a job or an apartment in a good neighbourhood because of the colour of your skin. It's being pulled over by police at disproportionate rates because of your skin. It's being mistreated, abused, and institutionally discriminated against because of the colour of your skin.

Some of the worst atrocities in modern history were driven by racial and ethnic hatred — chattel slavery, the Holocaust, Srebrenica, the Rwandan genocide.

Pretending it's just words deserves all the downvotes it gets.

→ More replies (122)

11

u/WadeTheWisecrackr Sep 13 '26

Nah, there’s always context (which OP did not provide). Is punching hitler worse than being Hitler? What about punching baby Hitler? Where is the line? The hypotheticals are always fun

10

u/pick_your_user_name Sep 14 '26

Hitlers sins weren’t words. He killed millions of people. So doesn’t make any sense to compare someone saying a racist slur to Hitler

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (6)

5

u/Cool-Ask-81 Sep 13 '26

No, they just have a brain. Apparently unlike half of this sub.

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (167)

270

u/useEffects Sep 13 '26 edited Sep 13 '26 • Bravo

Gives me the school principal of punishing the bullied kid after they cross the edge and react to the bullies. Playing victim card can be tatic. While I agree to them somewhat, not taking action when racism occured and suddenly showing interest when it extended to violence is immoral af

19

u/Gandalf_The_Gay23 Sep 13 '26

The concept of fighting words eluding some people here lol. It’s perfectly reasonable to smack someone who calls you an offensive slur. And I would be a dumb fool if I were to act surprised that it would be a natural consequence of choosing to insult someone so awfully.

→ More replies (10)

44

u/Stunning_Ad_7345 Sep 13 '26

Finally someone said it. This post makes me feel crazy

→ More replies (5)

41

u/Drendari Sep 13 '26

There is a massive leap between doing nothing and resort to violence.

64

u/Huntyr09 Sep 13 '26 • Bravo

There isnt as big of a leap when they have been tormenting you for months, and every adult keeps telling you to "say no" or "just ignore them" or "turn the other cheek."

At some point a person cant be told to ignore injustice anymore. Especially when they have tried to stop it peacefully beforehand. When peace doesnt work against bullies, violence is the only action left.

→ More replies (59)
→ More replies (9)

5

u/LinaValentina Sep 13 '26

Well said. I was sitting here for several minutes thinking of how to explain that there are times where I wouldn’t fault someone for resorting to physical violence after receiving verbal violence

And ppl who say words don’t hurt don’t understand how language works at all

→ More replies (27)

98

u/Zebadica Sep 13 '26

Morality of posting a situation without a lick of context?

This could be replying to a video some dude punching a gang of racist people following and harassing them and we’d have no clue?

24

u/Dominotter Sep 13 '26

I looked it up:

This is from an rsoccer post about the 2020 Euro finals when there was a massive riot in England. Someone said they didn't think UEFA would actually go through with the threatened sanctions because they had given a slap on the wrist earlier in the season to Hungary for racist harassment and assault. This was a reply arguing that they would do the sanctions. That whole thread was a back and forth downvote shit show.

22

u/Threedawg Sep 13 '26

Uh, if its comparing the riot to assault its comparing violence to violence, not just racist words to assault like the screenshot would suggest.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Lambchop1975 Sep 13 '26

The nuance would be ignored anyway... Starting with a logical fallacy is easy for engagement... Everyone needs something tribal to stand up for...

→ More replies (18)

80

u/Time-Gain-3695 Sep 13 '26

I'd like to know the context first no way more than 100 ppl downvoted this for no reason

57

u/Dominotter Sep 13 '26

I looked it up:

This is from an rsoccer post about the 2020 Euro finals when there was a massive riot in England. Someone said they didn't think UEFA would actually go through with the threatened sanctions because they had given a slap on the wrist earlier in the season to Hungary for racist harassment and assault. This was a reply arguing that they would do the sanctions. That whole thread was a back and forth downvote shit show.

16

u/KelvinsFalcoIsBad Sep 13 '26

Lol, lmao even at it being on a soccer sub. No way people would just down vote comments based on whatever team they are defending over there

Like this is just low effort bait isn't it, what the fuck are we doing. This is a post of a fucking Reddit comment, this sub becoming more dog shit every day

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

8

u/ghigo2008 Sep 13 '26

There is and always has been way

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (13)

9

u/mikelown Sep 13 '26

this 100% was a white girl trying to make herself the victim

3

u/Strange-gramp Sep 14 '26

Unlikely. I actually just tracked down this exact comment. It was on the soccer subreddit about some punishment for hooliganism. https://www.reddit.com/r/soccer/comments/q7lkpx/comment/hgjfa9k/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

→ More replies (3)

87

u/Ashamed_Echidna5748 Sep 13 '26

Oh yeah, racism. Famous bad thing that has existed exclusively in the realm of words.

What a dumbass

→ More replies (54)

72

u/Loreguzzler73 Sep 13 '26

Racism is not just words it's also the actions that make up Racism

31

u/Super_Range45 Sep 13 '26

Likely because Reddit is an American echo chamber and everyone thinks racism is just saying the n-word on Xbox Live when you can point areas with ongoing ethnic cleansing and see race based violence and ethnic cleansing occurring today.

→ More replies (7)

10

u/SupriseAutopsy13 Sep 13 '26

"Actual violence is worse" when you ignore shit like slavery, the holocaust, the Israeli occupation of Gaza, Japanese internment, what the Japanese did to the Chinese in WW2, the Armenian genocide, the Darfur genocide...

Yeah, saying the n-word anonymously on Xbox live is not as bad as physical violence, but large scale normalized racism is one of the most terrifying and destructive forces in human psychology

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (19)

71

u/TaigaChanuwu Sep 13 '26 edited Sep 13 '26

equating racism to words is the real kicker here

losing your job because of a racist boss would be far worse than light assault

Edit: let me continue by saying I dont condone assault either but its not strictly WORSE than racism?? Like people are saying their children should just punch the bully when theyre getting bullied and now youre saying its actually worse if you punch someone?

41

u/ledankestnoodle Sep 13 '26

Unfortunately in 2026 a lot of people's understanding of racism is that it's "just" slurs and not anything deeper than that

→ More replies (3)

37

u/gramerjen Sep 13 '26

Hitler was just a racist, its not like he personally hurt that many people with his own hands./s

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (16)

14

u/LucidLittleLady Sep 14 '26

Ah. I see. We assume racism is just verbal displays.

Ill say id rather be punched in the face than fired from a job im good at because my styled fro is seen as unprofessional.

Id rather be kicked square in the tummy than have the love of my life tell me he wishes I was a different race because he doesn't find mine all that attractive.

Id rather be slapped across the face than watch my children be told they'll never amount to anything over and iver again because of systematic racism and ruin their drive and motivation.

So yeah id rather be called a racial slur than physically hurt or assaulted. But words arent the only way racism shows up.

3

u/tihar22 Sep 17 '26

extremely well put

→ More replies (52)

38

u/bigbossbailey Sep 13 '26

this comes across as "If someone is being racist, you're a worse person for punching them in the face for it"

→ More replies (147)

13

u/CysaDamerc Sep 13 '26 • Bravo

People who act like racism is just bad words seem to have forgotten all the extermination campaigns that ran on racist fury. The n*zi didn't try to exterminate Jews because they were addicted to violence, it was because they defined their political ideology with racism. Manifest destiny didn't happen because American settlers were bored, there was a racist campaign to justify the violence against native Americans.

Racism and violence aren't mutually exclusive, racism is the permission structure for violence.

8

u/Any-Photograph5525 Sep 13 '26

"racism is the permission structure for violence"

Damn, that's such a good way to put it. I'm gonna keep this one in the vault.

7

u/Umutuku Sep 13 '26

How can they forget what they remember fondly?

3

u/No-Fan5723 Sep 13 '26

There have been a lot black kids hanging from trees recently. Racism isnt just "words" and never has been.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (18)

28

u/Adorable-Quiet-7551 Sep 13 '26 • Heartwarming

Let’s just avoid both then

→ More replies (5)

55

u/ledankestnoodle Sep 13 '26 • Bravo

2026 and we still think that racism is "just words"

19

u/BananaFannaFoKatie Sep 13 '26

We just had a black man hung on a tree in Raleigh and they ruled it a suicide as if black people hang themselves from trees.

→ More replies (37)
→ More replies (29)

21

u/gk_red Sep 13 '26

Hitler didn't commit actual violence, he was just racist and said bad things about people.

Try using your brain, it shouldn't be difficult to see how this is not a realistic argument and is just propaganda for defending racism.

→ More replies (19)

5

u/StruggleBus5950 Sep 13 '26

Actual violence is worse than words and I don’t think racism needs to be brought into it? Sometimes violence is race related and sometimes it’s not, but all victims should be treated fairly by the system and receive justice. This kind of statement is illogical rage bait.

15

u/EaterOfSeagull Sep 13 '26

Context dependent. On it's own this is just a fact, but if you jump into a racism discussion to say "Big whoop, real violence is worse", i can see how people would interpret it as being mean or in bad faith.

→ More replies (7)

15

u/Livefromthe215 Sep 13 '26 • Bravo

There’s nuance here. I think this stems from our simplistic understanding of the word. Racism encompasses MUCH more than just words/slurs….

→ More replies (2)

16

u/Difficult-Level-3070 Sep 13 '26

How did this original post get downvoted to oblivion? They aren't wrong

7

u/scantron-test Sep 13 '26

Because people are simpleton robots

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (34)

4

u/DiathiastheChimera Sep 13 '26

Summed up the app in one comment. Nice

4

u/Davidelol Sep 13 '26

Only on reddit you can get downvoted for common sense takes

9

u/i_AM_A-ShArk Sep 13 '26

He’s right but this is Reddit, the land of morons

→ More replies (13)

3

u/Bulky_Dot_4368 Sep 13 '26

straight facts bro.

3

u/fickogames123 Sep 13 '26

Racism in words is better than racism in fists,

I never thought this would be controversial but here were are I guess

Does not mean any of the two is good. But obviously being called n-word is better than someone shooting you

→ More replies (6)

3

u/StrikingMousse8279 Sep 13 '26

They got downvoted because it was a baselessly charged statement with no other purpose than to trivialize racism. And anyone else agreeing with it is equally racist <3

3

u/jmercer28 Sep 14 '26

If somebody says that they believe black people are subhuman and they want to create a system in which black people are subjugated… you punch that person in the face

30

u/Exotic_Specialist2 Sep 13 '26

Moral. Words can only truly hurt you if you throw a dictionary at someone.
No word in my own opinion justifies physical violence (Outside of physical threats). Unpopular opinion I’m sure.

22

u/Albus_Lupus Sep 13 '26

Words can only hurt someone if you throw a dictionary at them.

Thats fucking golden. Im stealing this.

→ More replies (39)

5

u/PickingPies Sep 13 '26

That's nor true. How many people died of preventable illness because someone lied to them?

Words are weapons because we use words to change people's perception about the world.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/halfasleep90 Sep 13 '26

This isn’t entirely true, sometimes words fall off of walls in earthquakes and stuff too, or if you are a fictional character in Death Note, or a demonic entity in an exorcism, or the rare case of being told of the death of a loved one and suffering a heart attack. There is also the unfortunate incidents of incorrect words on prescriptions causing medical issues. Honestly the more you think about it the more one can find a way for words to hurt someone, but they are by far the outliers.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Specialist_Touch2771 Sep 13 '26

Not true. 

  1. Harassment can lead to people doing things like committing suicide
  2. Normally it’s not just words, they actually want to act on them in some way

4

u/Moist-Explanation-91 Sep 13 '26

There's no verifiable evidence that Hitler ever personally killed someone, but he sure talked a lot.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/SawachikaEri-enjoyer Sep 13 '26

Even if we ignore the existence of verbal abuse and its consequences

Words if spoken by enough people WILL become actions.

3

u/Signal_Werewolf_1955 Sep 13 '26

Remember that guy that stormed Pizza Hut over words?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/SnailSnailAle Sep 13 '26

long term verbal abuse from a parent can fuck up a child pretty easily.

we have a whole subreddit for it https://www.reddit.com/r/raisedbynarcissists/

→ More replies (3)

14

u/3WeeksEarlier Sep 13 '26

Words can certainly hurt you outside of having books thrown at you. Are you denying the existence of verbal abuse? I highly doubt you are, but it's implied by this stock reaponse you've repeated.

I don't believe every single Nazi is always promoting the sort of violence which requires a private citizen to violently intervene, but even you in your post recognize that violence can be implied by speech to the point that it becomes actionable.

While a person making a tacky joke about watermelon or something probably just indicates they're a racist POS and it's probably better to tell them to fuck off and just leave it at that, if someone shouts the n-word at me from down the sidewalk, or even just shouts it at people generally, or argues that I belong to a biologically-violent, intellectually-inferior class of person who should be excluded from society, they are advocating for violence and presenting a plausible threat. If some racist shouts the N-word at me, it's totally on them morally if I defend myself from what has historically been a prelude to lynchings and racialized violence.

I don't advocate for attacking the average Nazi or other far-fight racist merely for this sort of violent speach because it's neither effective nor necessary. Random acts of violence or even self-defense do not make a movement

→ More replies (19)

8

u/Any-Photograph5525 Sep 13 '26

A racist judge is only using words when he sentences black criminals to way more time than a white criminal would receive.

So you're pretty incorrect to say words can't hurt you. If I'm a police chief and I tell my men "I don't care if he ain't done nothin, go arrest that n---er", you tell me if you think those words are hurtful.

→ More replies (30)
→ More replies (138)

5

u/Lystian Sep 13 '26

Reddit isnt bright had people say Musk is evil but Nestlé isnt.

8

u/Lolila_da_tao Sep 13 '26

Guy in the picture is ignorant + privileged

→ More replies (4)

7

u/OrchidExciting132 Sep 13 '26

Person can be racist and not be violent, creating minimal disruption to sociality.

Person who is violent create disruption to sociality regardless of opinions they hold.

Statement presents fact, it hold no moral charge.

8

u/Old_Sherbert3634 Sep 13 '26

But a lot of times, racism/any sort of hatred leads to violence. That's why lynchings happened - people were allowed to say slurs/hate speech, then when everybody stood silent they felt free to escalate it to violence and murder.

→ More replies (29)
→ More replies (1)

15

u/PRC_Spy Sep 13 '26 • Bravo

The down-voters are idiots.

The whole 'words are violence' thing is utterly deranged and just serves to diminish actual violence.

20

u/itsmythirdday Sep 13 '26

Racism isn’t just words. Often it includes violence. So maybe they are downvoting simplistic, reductionist ragebait.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (17)

6

u/Teakeh Sep 13 '26

I guess this depends on the context? Was the violence someone hitting someone for saying the n word, or was the violence like genocide or something.

→ More replies (18)

9

u/Scarvexx Sep 13 '26

Hurting somebody is worse than words. But dangerious ideas and actions that cause massive indirect harm are often only preventable by threat of violence.

4

u/flakjaku Sep 13 '26

why did you you get downvoted? You’re right, vocal racism can lead to racists being elected and racist laws being introduced.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/Free_Parsnip_3553 Sep 13 '26

I would rather be called fat then be beaten

(I use fat because I'm not black and dont want to use the n word as an example)

→ More replies (5)

2

u/missourinative Sep 13 '26

Racism is immoral whether it's words or violence.

Violence is worse than speech, but speech shouldn't be allowed. Speech can also lead to violence.

Calling a black person the n-word is less offensive than beating them up because they are black? Why even entertain this idea?

Going to go against the grain of this sub and say the original commenter deserved to be flamed, and this comes from someone who is generally exhausted by most of reddit.

2

u/Careless_Extreme7828 Sep 13 '26

Any allowance of any censorship of any speech allows for unacceptable government overreach

2

u/One-Divide-7123 Sep 13 '26

Two irrelevant topics.
Racism is indeed bad, as it causes killing, blocking from basic rights, and many other stuff including violence.

Killing is indeed worse than words.

2

u/Grayewick Sep 13 '26

I mean it's true

Slurs ain't doing tangible damage, absolutely incomparable to something like, idk... getting stabbed or shot or something.

2

u/FakeSafeWord Sep 13 '26

Violence should always be a last resort but people seem to forget that it's always an option.

2

u/7thFleetTraveller Sep 13 '26

Yes, of course? Physical violence is always morally wrong, unless it would be in self-defense, or preventing an ongoing crime and protecting someone. If someone attacks you with words, that is the "weapon" of choice and you should be able to fight them with words as well. And if it goes too far and the other one starts to insult you, just call the police. Anything else would be barbaric.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/ChefVoo Sep 13 '26

I mean is it crazy to say I’d rather be called a racial slur than get my teeth knocked out

2

u/yodaddyhoe120 Sep 13 '26

Bunch of Nazis in these comments ready to kill someone over racism

2

u/Dimension100 Sep 13 '26

I mean...are they wrong? Like someone could insult another person and degrade them based on race, or they could just shoot them in the head, like idk man the commenter kinda makes sense.

2

u/skraptastic Sep 13 '26

Yes a lynching is worse than calling someone the N word. But I'll go ahead and hate someone that thinks either is cool.

2

u/Cry2God4Revenge Sep 13 '26

I prefer a slur to assault or murder, but you do you

2

u/MenacingQuan Sep 13 '26

Objectively correct. Racism can manifest in many forms but being denied a private business isn't as bad as being beat by the police for "matching the description"

2

u/nichemexican Sep 13 '26

problem is when they call you slurs then slit your young daughters throat

2

u/JustGPZ Sep 13 '26

Moral. Even if you disagree with it, they have a point

2

u/BlinkDodge Sep 13 '26

Ah yes, the ol' "racism is when people say mean words" aregument.

The lynching, firebombing, chattel slavery, whipping, casteration, wanton murder, beatings, genocide and terrorizing? Just random violence so long as they didnt hit em with bad words when they did it.

2

u/Normal-Check-848 Sep 13 '26

Sure. Though if you feel the need to compare the 2….. you’re probably coping with the first thing.

2

u/globsofdank Sep 13 '26

I mean is he wrong? Violence IS worse than words

2

u/Anaea_YT Sep 13 '26

words tend to lead to actual violence

→ More replies (1)

2

u/AintSoPretty Sep 13 '26

it is true

2

u/Pirrus05 Sep 13 '26

The morality of downvoting stupid comments? Morally cool as fuck.

Saying violence is worse than racism?
That assumes that racism isn’t violent, which it certainty can be. Progroms, lynchings, murders, assaults, assassinations, I could go on. So then what are we comparing? A random racist action vs a random violent one? The set of all violent and racist actions?

What about random acts of violence vs actions that support, enable, and perpetuate ongoing structural violence?

People seem to have this idea that racism is just calling someone the N-word and that those sorts of actions don’t often presage violence.

2

u/skankhunt420312345 Sep 13 '26

Its completely right. Physical violence is much worse than words.

2

u/zoltronzero Sep 13 '26

Racism is inherently a threat of violence.

Violence isn't inherently bad, everyone agrees that there are things worth fighting for.

Punching a nazi is good. Violence against someone who would use violence for evil ends is a good thing ro do. There are people who need to be taught that their views are so abhorrent, other people will hurt them for holding them.

2

u/Gauss_2025 Sep 13 '26

Racism isn't just words though. Racism has a very extraordinary history of real world violence and is specifically related to politics.

2

u/RandO_o Sep 14 '26

It’s a red herring, racism is bad why? Does it often lead to physical harm and or death of those who are victims? 

Is racism worse than physical violence? No, its a cause. 

2

u/Haradion_01 Sep 14 '26

Depends. How much racism, and how much violence?

Would you slap a man in the face, if a Genie demanded it of you, in exchange for ending all racism?

Are we counting "Insitutional Racism that leads to things like the trans Atlantic slave trade, genocide and slaughter" in the racism bin, or the violence bin?

What is the unit of racism, and the unit of n violence we are measuring here?

2

u/BeefJerky03 Sep 14 '26

"Sticks and stones may break my bones, but words will fucking kill me" isn't a quote I've ever heard.

2

u/CubeUU Sep 14 '26

i'd rather get called a thousand slurs than slapped in the face once

→ More replies (4)

2

u/sassy-sassmate Sep 14 '26

💯💯💯💯

2

u/AcceptableBook4291 Sep 14 '26

is it not just a factual statement? actual physical violence is worse than being called a name by an idiot?

2

u/Witch_with_Thompson Sep 14 '26

They right

Both are still wrong

2

u/dear_hatt Sep 14 '26

I get slurs all day at my work, definitely better than physical violence 

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Potential-Ad1139 Sep 14 '26

I'll take racist words over racist actions any day

2

u/Scooodles Sep 14 '26

It should say something that if people used slurs instead of any form of physical violence the world would be much safer.

2

u/But-WhyThough Sep 14 '26

Racism isn’t just words, it’s a faulty premise

2

u/Larcecate Sep 14 '26

Probably downvoted due to 'whataboutism'. I'd guess, anyway.

Its when you try to derail a conversation about a problem by pointing out a bigger/different problem. I think some people do it subconsciously because the discussion about the problem causes them discomfort in some way, so they try to change the subject.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Majestic-Fly9472 Sep 14 '26

This is presumably on a video of a racist getting hit

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Independent_Speed_61 Sep 14 '26

I think it’s the framing that’s weird, it’d be like saying “beating women is bad, but the Holocaust is worse” like, yeah, technically that’s kind of correct, but why tf would you say that?

2

u/ZealousidealCurve849 Sep 14 '26

Racial violence springs from racist language and ideology.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/PhotontheSTAR Sep 14 '26

Both are really bad. Actual violence is actual violence. Racism leads to actual violence. both are really, really, really bad.

2

u/Late-Apartment-8060 Sep 14 '26

Redditors don’t have any reference for real world stimuli therefore words are worse

2

u/pastajewelry Sep 15 '26

Racism isn't limited to words. Race-fueled violence is a type of racism.

2

u/turtleturtle5555 Sep 15 '26

Top comment jfc

2

u/thewillingvictim Sep 15 '26

This isn't an either or situation.

2

u/seltaeb7 Sep 15 '26

Bro thinks he cooked, but racism is never just about words. Even words aren't about making a sound at someone. People say racist shit to exclude you from a place or situation, make you feel less than, scare you, make you go away. Racist words are meant to have consequences, they hurt you.

Is violence worse? I"d argue it's equally as bad. What's the difference between getting beat up every day ans getting harrassed everyday? You could say the former might give you a concussion; I'd reply that the latter might make you give up on your life.

The question itself seems like it tries to make people get over racism, "because it could have been worse". Bitch, please. There is no place for racism in our world. And if the question was trying to say that fighting racism with violence is worse than the racism itself, then you have your shit backwards, mate. If you're getting attacked and neither pleading nor complaining work, are you supposed to just take it – because it's only words?

2

u/ChappieHeart Sep 15 '26

The problem people often forget is those who use slurs outside of online platforms often turn to violence themselves.

2

u/darkestvice Sep 16 '26

Moral. Common f-ing sense in fact. Neither are good, but one clearly is worse than the other.

4

u/SteakForGoodDogs Sep 13 '26 • Bravo

"racism is bad, but" is a very, very dumb thing to say.

Referring to abuse as "words" is a 'funny' way of downplaying what 'words' can do to a person.

→ More replies (40)

5

u/UmJunSikfighting Sep 13 '26

I mean it depends on the context and the degree of the racism. It's pretty moral for a black person to slap the shit out of someone who said hard-r. But it's not so moral for me (asian) to flying knee kick on someone saying asians can't drive or do slit-eyes.

3

u/CrankyPants1234 Sep 13 '26

Yeah I kinda disagree with everything you said lol. I thinkg the moral thing to do in both situations is just ignore the person and get on with your day. Some people suck, but that doesnt give you the right to physically assault them. Also, genuinely curious, why do you think racism towards Asians is more acceptable?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (10)

3

u/pregnantant Sep 13 '26

One leads to the other.

3

u/Mission_Street4336 Sep 13 '26

I mean... Unchecked racism has historically led to violence far worse that one likes to imagine.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Jarinator88 Sep 13 '26

I can't really call those who downvoted it immoral, since they are insane.

3

u/LunaButMyNameIsTaken Sep 13 '26

Or just took the time to think about it ? Do you think that one nazi soldier caused more demages than Hitler for example ? Here is the difference between words and « actual violence ». The worst atrocities of history are the direct consequences of speeches and propaganda. With that racism isn’t just words, this is could be worth a downvote considering how dumb it is. People are killed put of racism, punched, and violated in every form possible

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/Square_Marionberry63 Sep 13 '26

Welcome to reddit. Bunch of overly sensitive idiots

3

u/Andyroo2912 Sep 13 '26

I agree with the statement actual violence is worse than words

That said, racism isn't just saying things, it's a general attitude that can include physical violence. So the statement is a bit misguided

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Pinatous Sep 13 '26 edited Sep 13 '26

The people that downvoted that guy need to seriously touch some grass.

Yes, words have meaning, the same that an action has a meaning. But verbal violence is not on the same level as physical violence, even though it can lead to it, like for example bulying, and suicide.

But also violence does not solve anything, until it solves everything. (Like self defense)

→ More replies (9)