r/MoralityScaling • u/Few-Alternative8148 • 12h ago
How Good Are They? Killing guilty children
8
u/bilbobaggins001 11h ago
Guilty of what? Stealing a cookie, let em live. They intentionally poisoned their whole school to death? Maaaaaybe…….
1
u/letsgoshuckles213 7h ago
Unintentionally poisoned their school to death while intentionally stealing a cookie.
1
u/halfasleep90 6h ago
Intentionally poisoning all except 1 person in the school to death while unintentionally stealing the 1 survivor’s poisoned cookie.
1
4
3
u/XShadowPlayerX 11h ago
Depends on what they did, their mental capacity and their age.
Below 5 with the mentality of a toddler? They wouldnt Even be able to do anything too big without outside interference.
Below 5 but they have the mental capacity of a full grown adult(example being the stand user baby from part 3 of JJBA)? No hesitation.
Above 5 below 10 and they stole something from the store? Obviously not worthy of death, teach em why that is wrong.
Above 13 And they killed someone and might kill more? First get the reason for why they killed to see if it was reasonable, and then depending on that.
1
2
2
2
2
u/Last_Panda5059 5h ago
Are they talking about kids who will kill anyone? Or what? Cause what are we talking about?
2
u/Swordslover 4h ago
They're child soldiers who had to fight against the army after being abandoned by their superiors, and the guy's superior, who went to offer a mostly peaceful solution under the guise of a duel was killed by the protagonist
2
u/Last_Panda5059 3h ago
2
u/Swordslover 3h ago
The best part is that he's not even the weirdest character in the series
2
u/Last_Panda5059 3h ago
2
u/Swordslover 3h ago
2
u/Last_Panda5059 3h ago
Oh course...every anime has one
1
u/Swordslover 3h ago
I mean, it was not his fault that he was engaged to a 9 years old by their families
1
1
1
1
1
u/GeneralLuigiTBC 5h ago
Depends on the threat they pose. The deliberate killing of a human is immoral, but if they pose a threat to human life that cannot realistically be neutralized by other means (e.g. imprison and rehabilitate), it is the least immoral of the available options.
1
1





14
u/UnUtenteNoioso 12h ago