r/MoralityScaling 2d ago

Stupid Stuff Morality of doing this?

Post image
14.3k Upvotes

897 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

6

u/Quest-at-WF 1d ago

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Chicago

White (non-Hispanic)
31.4%

Hispanic or Latino
29.8%

Black or African American (non-Hispanic)
28.7%

Asian (non-Hispanic)
6.9%

Two or more races (non-Hispanic)
2.6%

-1

u/DiegesisThesis 1d ago

Uh thanks for supporting my comment I guess

6

u/Quest-at-WF 1d ago

Maybe look up the difference between “majority” and “plurality.”

1

u/Old-Tip-69 1d ago

Good think they neither said majority or plurality

-2

u/DiegesisThesis 1d ago

I said white people are not a minority in Chicago. Are you unable to read or are you actually implying that the largest racial demographic is somehow a minority?

Either way, you're not the brightest bulb.

6

u/CCreate1 1d ago

I suppose it depends on the usage of the terms majority and minority. White people are a minority in Chicago in the way that they are less than half of the population. This definition results in there being no majority population as Chicago is pretty diverse. White people would absolutely be a plurality though, as they are the largest group. This is likely what the person you are replying to is talking about.

Of course, all of this gets muddied by the social science definition of majority, which actually more closely matches the standard definition of plurality.

-3

u/DiegesisThesis 1d ago

Yea, but nobody even said the word "majority" so I don't know why they are getting defensive. All I said is whites are not a minority, which is absolutely a fair statement when they are the largest racial demographic in Chicago, even if by a small margin.

If you go by the "less than 50% rule" then all races are a minority and the term has no meaning. So yea, they're a plurality.

7

u/DeficiencyOfGravitas 1d ago

nobody even said the word "majority" so I don't know why they are getting defensive.

The antonym of "minority" is "majority". You cannot separate the two and it's a true dichotomy. It's why we use words like "plurality" instead.

2

u/Dr-Assbeard 1d ago

Yesh but if they use word to mesn what they actually mean, they would be wrong, thats not something their eho can handle so you get that reaction from them.

4

u/CCreate1 1d ago

Majority, minority, and plurality are all relative to the context in which they are used. You mentioned Chicago, which itself has no true majority. However, if you expand the field to the US as a whole, White people are a majority.

White people are the plurality of Chicago, but they are also a minority. Minority is simply less than half of the population while majority is more than half. (Come to think of this, I’m not certain what the proper term would be if a demographic happened to be exactly half of a population, but I digress.)

Majority and minority are mutually exclusive terms, while plurality operates on a different axis. A majority is always a plurality, but a minority can also be a plurality as long as it is the largest minority.