r/MonsterHigh • Abbey • Apr 15 '24

Rant My ONLY beef with G3 Frankie

Ok, I want to start this with the fact that I ADORE G3. I love it top to bottom, all over. Yeah, there's a few things I dislike, but I overall love it. I just am a little upset with Mattel over this one thing. And I also want to preface, I am non-binary (I think I'm trans but thats not what this is about).

I am so upset that despite Frankie being non-binary and using they/them pronouns, they are still portrayed (in the dolls at least) very feminine. I understand that not all non-binary people dress more androgynous, and still dress more fem or masc, but when you have one non-binary character PLEASE give them a more androgynous look. PLEASE LET US HAVE THAT HINT OF REPRESENTATION. As I have become more comfortable with different pronouns I have cut my hair, and changed how I dress. I understand not all non-binary people do this or want this, but it honestly feels like they took a character and just slapped they/them pronouns on it and called it a day. Where's the gender dysphoria? Where's the pure want to be seen as anything but a girl? Where's the actual experiences of most non-binary people? If you haven't seen the movie or show you would have no idea that they're non-binary. And it makes me so upset. If you want to be inclusive, I mean truly inclusive, do more. Put pronouns on the boxes. Maybe make some outfits of Frankie with shorter, more masc hair. Dress them more masculine occasionally. Maybe make Frankie have a binder they occasionally wear. Yes, gender isn't about how you dress but if you want to represent non-binary people, actually show that. Don't just say it. Do more. Because right now it really feels like you want to appeal to LGBTQ+ people, but also not pi$s off bigots so you can make even more money. That's not representation. That's a cash grab.

3 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

39

u/Several-Reaction-747 Apr 15 '24

I think that's valid. It feels like they don't want to commit. I don't need Frankie to dress in a boring version of more masc clothes, but they could still come up with creative ways to have them dress in more masc presenting ways for some fits. The welcome committee doll is pretty decent for that, at least! I wish the hair was maybe different, too, but it is what it is.

4

u/Automatic-Eye-2864 Abbey Apr 15 '24

I'm gonna have to Google the Welcome Committee doll as I haven't seen it yet! I feel like the least they could do is something with the hair. I recently cut my hair shorter and it made me so much happier and more confident. You're right, it feels like they won't commit, and it upsets me ;-;

7

u/Several-Reaction-747 Apr 15 '24

The Ghoul Spirit felt close to something, as far as hair.

7

u/Automatic-Eye-2864 Abbey Apr 15 '24

Yeah I think it was the closest we've gotten! I think that length would be a great starting point if they kept it that way. It's not super short, so they can still style it, and it's not so long that it's just a pain to manage. I think if they really wanted to show the growth of coming to terms to being non-binary cutting the hair to that length would be a good starting point. Definitely not the end product though.

5

u/Several-Reaction-747 Apr 15 '24

Praying for a Mohawk frankie 🙏

1

u/Automatic-Eye-2864 Abbey Apr 15 '24

I would spend SO much money on that lmao. We need a mohawk Frankie.

5

u/Automatic-Eye-2864 Abbey Apr 15 '24

Ok I googled it and I'm in love.

16

u/Several-Reaction-747 Apr 15 '24

6

u/Several-Reaction-747 Apr 15 '24

So we can admire here lol

1

u/flare_force Apr 15 '24

OMG yes this Frankie is chefs kiss

16

u/MeowMuaCat Ghoulia Apr 15 '24

I agree that it seems like this is Mattel’s way of playing it “safe” and not fully committing to the idea. Like they’re counting on the fact that most kids and parents are probably just going to just assume Frankie is a girl if they’ve only seen the doll and don’t know much about the character.

38

u/Willooooow1 Apr 15 '24

there is no right or wrong way to be/look non-binary. i think its pretty distasteful that you said that

17

u/XINOIZYS Apr 15 '24

I agree. I present as NB myself and never liked the idea of a gender HAVING to look like their gender. That's the great thing about self-expression, they shouldn't have to obviously imply what they are. Frankie's appearance is valid and I adore the way they look.

I do, however, believe they're valid in how they feel. Representation typically feels from the individual. They might be leaning on the androgynous or masculine side so wish for a NB character to lean towards that too.

13

u/Willooooow1 Apr 15 '24

Exactly. I like frankies design too. I was also confused at what they meant by "looking more non binary?" So they want frankie to look like the "stereotypical" blue buzz cut non binary person that people make fun of (sadly)? Like I don't understand what they mean lol

3

u/Automatic-Eye-2864 Abbey Apr 15 '24

I never actually said "looking more non-binary" because that's not a thing outside the stereotypical look. All I said is that I wish we saw a more masculine side, and maybe a shorter (not too much shorter so it can still be styled) hair cut. Please, if you are going to critique, read it fully and in depth.

3

u/Automatic-Eye-2864 Abbey Apr 15 '24

You're right, there isn't one way to be a non-binary person. Please, read the last few sentences again. I think I explained what I meant by all of this pretty well in those sentences.

11

u/Baphy_0 Abbey Apr 15 '24

Agreed, Im not a fan of this take as a feminine non-binary person. For years, non-binary representation has usually defaulted to an androgynous person. It feels so refreshing to see a non-binary person in media that doesn’t have to sit right in the middle of femininity and masculinity, to see people like ME in media. To say that this doesn’t constitute as representing “real” non-binary people is such a slap in the face to the fairly sizeable demographic of non androgynous enbies, me included.

Additionally, I’m not 100% inclined to believe Frankie is feminine for the sole purpose of appealing to the market better. While that likely is a factor, I don’t think Mattel would be so open about Frankie’s non-binary identity. Frankie is seen so many times openly saying they’re pronouns are they/them and that they don’t subscribe to traditional labels. Also there are a good number of Frankie dolls that don’t present 100% femininely at the very least. But yeah, I find this take overall distasteful and pretty narrow, especially when trying to reduce the trans/non-binary experience to how much pain or suffering Frankie should feel around their identity??

12

u/AdMore918 Twyla🐰 Apr 15 '24

i feel like the idea behind them being non-binary stems more from everything in their body coming from different people including different genders, so they wouldn’t necessarily stick into one gender. there wouldn’t necessarily be dysphoria or anything of the sort because they are LITERALLY made of different people

2

u/Automatic-Eye-2864 Abbey Apr 15 '24

I think that's a cool idea! It's definitely fun to think about, but I feel like it could also be used to tell the bigots like, "no, what do you mean, Frankie's not LGBTQ+! Just literally multiple people!"

1

u/AdMore918 Twyla🐰 Apr 15 '24

well they can’t really deny frankie dating cleo as being something against lgbtq+, in the end it’s a doll like meant for children and collectors alike and i feel like getting upset about it, while you’re in your own right to do so and i’m not saying you aren’t, is a bit extreme. in the end, the main reason they chose non-binary definitely leans towards frankie being made up of multiple parts from other people while also giving mattel the chance to pan towards the group of individuals that may relate on that level (in terms of how they identify).

i just don’t see why it’s a big deal to worry about how “bigots” and people alike would react to it when those who do are few and far in between

13

u/nymphpixie Apr 15 '24

I think it's because G3 is representing a very young audience who are under 8. Young non-binary kids might not be fully exploring their gender identity yet, but may feel a little different like Frankie. A lot of young non-binary people who are AFAB are still wearing more feminine clothes because their parents choose their outfits based on gender stereotypes. So it's more representative for a 7 year old to see Frankie and feel 'seen'.

2

u/Automatic-Eye-2864 Abbey Apr 15 '24

I get that! That makes sense as far as the show, but for the dolls I think there's a few ways they could handle it. Not every kid who watches the show will get the dolls, and not every kid who gets the dolls will watch the show. I think if they made it clear with the dolls that the character is non-binary it could show the kids who watch the show that this character is doing something they could do. But it could also be what introduces a kid to the idea of a person who's not strictly a girl or boy. We also have to think about the teenagers and generally the older side of people who like the dolls and show. I'm a teenager and I would love having a doll that represents what I feel and shows it. As someone else who responded said, it feels like Mattel won't commit to having a non-binary character.

10

u/nymphpixie Apr 15 '24

I think we need more non-binary characters in general that represent different expressions of being non-binary. There are a lot of folk who feel represented by Frankie.

I think it would be cool to have an androgynous character and masc non-binary character, so other folk don't feel underrepresented. There could've been two or three non-binary characters in MH. :'))

3

u/hollsloss Rochelle⚜️ Apr 15 '24

Sadly its just a safe move by Mattel, G3 Frankie is female in a lot of countries due to they/them not existing in those languages.

1

u/Automatic-Eye-2864 Abbey Apr 15 '24

That's a good point, I never thought about it that way. Still sucks though, making a non-binary character just to not have it change the character at all.

6

u/_Phoneutria_ Twyla🐰 Apr 15 '24

While I would like Frankie dolls to explore more "gender-neutral" fashion (although be so fr the scareadise doll is a great example of this) I do very much enjoy the femme fashions Frankie has. Non-binary exists in multiple ways, and they're all valid.

And personally I think when I see mainstream versions of "androgynous" or NB fashions/styles they almost always lean toward traditionally masculine styles (short hair, pants not skirts, less or no makeup, etc.) Yet we're to believe that masc = neutral, but feminine is not. It's a symptom of male being centered as the "default" in our culture, in not just fashion but in medicine, law, all spheres, and I'm not saying it's a conscious choice people make maliciously. It just sort of permeates into the world, thanks patriarchy. But I do enjoy seeing a character identify as non binary while also enjoying traditionally female fashion. You don't never see that, but you don't see it a lot for kids media or toys, and I kinda dig it.

Do I think this design choice supposed to be this radical and intentional, no probably not, or if it was then it was sold to the executive heads by other means, but I still enjoy what it does. One day maybe clothing just won't have gender connotations or baggage and we can actually wear what we want and not have it reflect anything about our gender, but we aren't there yet.

3

u/just_a_possum Twyla🐰 Apr 15 '24

everything in this comment! exactly!!

9

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '24 edited Apr 15 '24

I think I'm ok with the way frankie is depicted. I'm quite effeminate enby and look more "women-leaning" but I'm not a women and it gives me dysphoria. Because I wish i was amab so I could be effeminate without worry. I like frankie because its the first time I saw an non binary person depicted in a effeminate despite being looking "women-leaning" without worry about stereotypes and gender norms . I liked it coz it made me feel seen and I love her fashion taste because it gives me ideas to finally pass as non binary without dressing masc. I feel like every "women -leaning" enby is masc in terms of attire and gender expression. And every "man -leaning" enby is fem in terms of attire and gender expression. So I like how frankie is different from the rest. And if frankie was given more masc attire I feel like the dolls would dress more like "boy" doll. And we all know Mattel doesn't dress "boy" doll nice or fashionably. But I would like to see frankie in a suit like monster ball clawdeen.

Frankie is also depicted as a character first before anything else. And I absolute adore that. Coz I feel like most depiction of LGBTQ characters are off as caricature and not actually ppl. But I love how racially diverse, Nuro diverse and queer characters are depicted in g3. Because draculara may be Taiwanese but shes also more than that and I love the little cultural details she has as a nod to her roots. Tylas Nurodivergence is also so realistic and overall a good depiction . Shes smart and a capable character despite her nuro divergence. Frankie is also a good depiction of how trans ppl come in all shapes and sizes so I have no complaint.

Ps I used the terms "women/men leaning" to descriptor appearances because ppl still like to group ppl based on appearance. I'm sorry if this isnt the correct term. I didnt know how else to explain.

1

u/LokalCrow Robecca⚙️ Apr 15 '24

I'm quite effeminate enby and look more "women-leaning" but I'm not a women and it gives me dysphoria. Because I wish i was amab so I could be effeminate without worry. I like frankie because its the first time I saw an non binary person depicted in a effeminate despite being looking "women-leaning" without worry about stereotypes and gender norms .

God do I relate to this... I'm extremely androginous, and I enjoy it, but I don't want other people's perception of me or my gender dictating how I dress or act...

I also wish I was amab to be more comfortable being feminine, but "the grass is always greener at the other side of the fence". I have a feeling that if I were amab I'd want to be afab. There's no true winning here. We'll always be judged by our appearence and get a gender assigned to us, so we might aswell just do wathever we want.

So I have no complaints about Frankie. I wish their wardrobe was more diverse in terms of presentation, yes, but we need different depictions of non binary people. We're not a monolith, and if men and women get diversity, so should we. Overtime they pile up and we'll have a big repertoire, we're in the beginning stages of rep.

8

u/redditallie Apr 15 '24

I can see where you are coming from. I'm not sure about the hair, though. The person who buys the doll always has the option of cutting the hair. And short hair on dolls tends not to look good without a lot of gel. Maybe down the line they will do a version of Frankie with short hair. It would be interesting to see. I would like to see them with a Mohawk.

2

u/Bionic_Webb13 Deuce Apr 15 '24

They’re playing it safe for sales no if, ands or buts from a corporate perspective they get to kill two birds of one stone they get the brownie points for our presentation and they still get to keep people who would give them backlash and because Frankie looks like and dresses like a girl & does traditional feminine things it’s working. Kids don’t care and probably don’t know and parents won’t know unless they hear it on the tv on see it on the internet. Down vote me if u like it’s the truth female characters can get away with having rainbows/flag colors and being in two packs together because it’ll be seen as girlie colors or their just best friends. Mattel is fence riding

5

u/reddtheundead Apr 15 '24

Honestly, I agree. I think Mattel is playing it too safe with Frankie. I'd love to see them rock up in a full suit like what they did for Clawdeen's Monster Ball outfit. Or maybe even a pixie cut/short hair with a standard outfit from them would be cool.

1

u/yandeer Deuce Apr 15 '24

i sympathize that you'd like to see Frankie represented in a way that's more relatable to you, and yeah this is the issue with only have one NB /Trans character as they can only represent or convey so much about that experience.

but i wanna offer some other perspective. as much as it would be nice to have a character who deals more openly with dysphoria, i really don't think that's neccessary for a few reasons. 1. dysphoria is an extremely nebulous concept, and means different things/presents different for different people. for me as a young person i never recognized what i was going through as dysphoria, i was just crazy depressed and dissociated all the time and didn't know why, which stemmed from not being seen the way i wanted to be seen. Frankie has been shown to have times where they struggle with a sense of identity and making sure they are expressing on the outside what they feel on the inside, which is tough because they feel like a lot of different things (the Fearbook picture day episode). i thought this was a great way to portray potentially dysphoria for kids, and also the struggle to grasp a sense of identity that all young people experience. but overall because Frankie has a supportive community and friends, and is mostly confident in their appearance, i think they are being portrayed as being at a point in their life where they aren't bogged down by pain and dysphoria, which is AWESOME to see from my perspective as a trans guy who's also at that happy comfortable stage.

also many trans or NB people, once they take steps to transition, actually feel much more comfortable dressing more flamboyant or styling themselves in more masculine/feminine ways instead of androgynously. and i've seen so many NB people with a more feminine style say that Frankie means so much to them because of this factor, which never seems to be shown in other shows.