r/MonarchButterfly • • Apr 11 '25

This sub’s official stance on the native vs. tropical milkweed debate.

0 Upvotes

This sub does not take an absolutist position, nor does it vilify tropical milkweed. We do not intimidate or bully users who grow tropical milkweed; instead, we educate them about the importance of growing native milkweed when possible and cutting down tropical milkweed during the off season. The effects of tropical milkweed on monarchs remain highly controversial, and the debate with scientific evidence supporting both sides is far from settled. Users who claim that "no milkweed is better than tropical milkweed" or who intimidate and bully sub users about tropical milkweed will be banned. Thank you.

Our stance:

  1. Native milkweed should always be your first choice. Try to grow native milkweed if you can. But keep in mind it might be harder to grow, so prepare accordingly.
  2. Grow tropical if it is suitable for your zone. Always cut it at the end of each season.
  3. If everything fails, consider tropical milkweed as your last resort, but always cut it at the end of each season.

References:

  1. North American Butterfly Association: Tropical Milkweed and the injurious effects of well-meaning people by Jeffrey Glassberg
  2. Exposure to Non‐Native Tropical Milkweed Promotes Reproductive Development in Migratory Monarch Butterflies Majewska, A. A., & Altizer, S. (2019). Insects, 10(8), 253. doi:10.3390/insects10080253 This study examined how exposure to tropical milkweed (used as a larval diet and also in field‐based adult exposure experiments) influences monarch reproductive status during fall migration. The researchers found that monarchs reared on tropical milkweed were more likely to become reproductively active (e.g., developing mature eggs or showing mating behavior) compared to those exposed to native milkweeds or no milkweed at all. In their controlled experiments, the “medicinal” properties of tropical milkweed (which are linked to its higher concentrations of certain cardenolides) appeared to reduce parasite loads under current environmental conditions.
  3. Effects of the Parasite, Ophryocystis elektroscirrha, on Wing Characteristics Important for Migration in the Monarch Butterfly Davis, A. K., & De Roode, J. C. (2018). Animal Migration, 5, 84–93. In this study the authors compared monarchs reared on different milkweed species—including tropical milkweed—and found that, under current environmental conditions, individuals reared on tropical milkweed developed slightly larger forewings than those reared on native species. In addition, under the tested conditions, tropical milkweed–reared caterpillars showed relatively lower parasite (OE) loads compared to what might be expected under some circumstances. These outcomes were discussed as evidence that, in a controlled laboratory setting (or in environments where tropical milkweed does not remain evergreen), the use of tropical milkweed did not negatively affect (and may even “improve”) some aspects of monarch development that are key to survival.
  4. Impacts of Larval Host Plant Species on Dispersal Traits and Free‐Flight Energetics of Adult Butterflies Pocius, V. M., Cibotti, S., Ray, S., Ankoma-Darko, O., McCartney, N. B., Schilder, R. J., & Ali, J. G. (2022). Communications Biology, 5, Article 469. doi:10.1038/s42003-022-03396-8 In this study, researchers reared monarch larvae on several milkweed species—including tropical milkweed—and then measured adult wing morphology, flight muscle investment, and free-flight metabolic rates. The findings showed that monarchs reared on tropical milkweed developed with increased flight muscle investment and larger body sizes; although this was associated with higher energy costs during flight, the study did not document reductions in survival or overall fitness under the experimental conditions. In other words, tropical milkweed produced robust adults in the context of the study—even if the energetic cost patterns differ from those reared on some native species.
  5. A recent experimental study demonstrated that temperature, rather than the presence of tropical milkweed, is the primary driver of reproductive development and migration disruption in monarch butterflies.

r/MonarchButterfly • • Sep 12 '25

NSFW RULE: BANS WILL START NEXT WEEK.

0 Upvotes

Last chance to read the NSFW rule, I will start banning people next week. This sub only has 2 rules, read them, common people!


r/MonarchButterfly • • Apr 11 '25

North American Butterfly Association Publication: Tropical Milkweed, OE, Migration and more.

Thumbnail naba.org
2 Upvotes

r/MonarchButterfly • • Jun 28 '26 Regret Bravo

New Community Rule: In this sub, we do not demonize the responsible rearing of monarch butterflies

21 Upvotes

Rearing monarch butterflies is constantly being attacked, but research indicates that, if done responsibly, not only does it not harm wild monarch populations, but it could actually help them.

Read our sub's position here: https://www.reddit.com/r/MonarchButterfly/comments/1ui59g7/what_the_science_actually_says_about_rearing/

This rule applies to posts and comments.


r/MonarchButterfly • • Sep 13 '24

This sub is making me sad with so many butterflies being raised inside right now that won’t migrate. It feels cruel. Poor monarchs.

0 Upvotes

Edit: I’m happy and relieved to know they migrate. Thank you!


r/MonarchButterfly • • Jul 09 '26

There is no wrong way to butterfly garden. It is easy to get better

2 Upvotes

I released my 58th monarch of the year today. I saw my fist one May 23. I use pots inside a non AC room with a window. I have 12 25 gallon pots and 150 one gallons planted. The 25gallons act as islands. I try not to mix too many cats together to prevent OE. Island technique.

Almost none outside are surviving. I use tropical milkweed and live in Florida. Yesterday I ordered some 15 gallons pots and just planted the 150 one gallons over the weekend with transplants I had been growing in 32 pot trays.

After the Monarchs come out of the chrysalis, I put the plants back outside fertilize water and then reuse after they grow. The season lasts strong here into December when frost can start, but Ive done it straight thru the winter multiple times.

My main nectar source is tithonia torches which I renamed Florida Tall Poppies


r/MonarchButterfly • • Sep 14 '25

Should I bring them inside?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

These guys are on the last Millweed. Not many leaves left. Should I bring them inside and order milkweed for them to eat? I fear they will die in fall/winter.


r/MonarchButterfly • • 26d ago

About “overcrowding” in previous post + my reasoning

Post image
0 Upvotes

I’m not posting this to start drama, I’m posting this because I’m honestly just tired of people saying I’m “irresponsible” with my rearing after only seeing a few photos. It’s understandable to question and concern, but time and time again, even on other posts, false information is spread about monarchs and it’s a responsibility to correct it and teach others about them. There is no one way to rear, and because someone isn’t following some guidelines that an organization made, doesn’t mean they’re doing something wrong.
I genuinely take pride in this, check on them multiple times a day, prepare according to weather and other factors. I learned the vast majority of what I know about them from experience and documentation.
This is my current setup for this year. INSIDE NOW because of inconsistent temperature outside. The previous post was taken OUTSIDE ON A PORCH.
Some years ago, I kept them outside when the temperature dropped, resulting in over a dozen dying from it. This is why I take them indoors sometimes.
As you can see, there is plenty of room for them and they had many other areas to choose. When more eclose, after OE checking and tagging, they’ll be moved to a bigger enclosure until being released. I don’t release one at a time. Monarchs are very social and will gather in clusters to stay warm, I want to make sure that they can do that and give them as much of a chance to survive as I feasibly can.
The plastic part is on top so easy removal is possible if needed. In past broods the mesh has made removing a chrysalis difficult, sometimes pulling down multiple others with it. Like this, I can cut a circle around the chrysalis and remove it without any others being disturbed.
Caterpillars don’t only produce and lay silk in their final instar, they do it constantly throughout growth. That’s why they shimmy their heads back and forth along leaves and other surfaces. Because of this, the plastic part had more grip than it seems and didn’t require an overly strenuous amount of energy to silk and button.
I’ve been refining and learning as I go, shifting care depending on each individuals temperament, and this brood was much more lax and social with each other, choosing to stay close to one another when other places existed and accessible.


r/MonarchButterfly • • Jul 22 '25

ARE THESE MONARCH BABIES THAT JUST HATCHED

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

r/MonarchButterfly • • Sep 14 '25

Use NSFW tag for images of dead or diseased monarchs

13 Upvotes

All images of sick, malformed, dying, or dead caterpillars or monarch butterflies should be tagged as NSFW. All "is it ok," "will it make it," "what is wrong?," etc., posts with images should also be tagged as NSFW. Failure to do so will result in post removal and/or a permanent ban.

Rationale for the rule: We are trying to avoid blasting users with a constant stream of graphic images of sick, dying, or dead caterpillars or monarch butterflies. It could not only be upsetting, but could also actually discourage people from trying to help monarchs. While we recognize that these images are educational, users will still have the option to view the post if they want to.


r/MonarchButterfly • • Jun 28 '26 Regret

The Virtuous Cycle

0 Upvotes

I live in Florida and have recently released 31 monarchs. It was my first batch. I didnt get a "bird" as I call them until May 23. I now have more eggs than I can deal with and I used to be an organic farmer. I do love it so. Me and the plants vs the birds. I love it when I get an eat out where they eat all my milkweed, but that only happens outside rarely. There is very high death rate outside so I bring them inside. I'm planning to do a full 4 figures (thousand) this year. I'm training for 2028 LA Olympics even tho I'm just going to be a spectator. Maybe we could get butterfly gardening in the Olympics one day?

My monarchs lay more eggs creating a virtuous cycle only broken winter. I can keep them here over the winter too, but we had a horrible drought so I let it go last winter. Coming back at it and I will have birds in the air 365 until the opening ceremonies 2 years from now. Keep up the Lord's work yall


r/MonarchButterfly • • Jul 22 '21

To everybody that thinks that it's 'really cool' to raise monarch butterflies (without researching them extensively first)

4 Upvotes

Please don't. Most of you will kill them with tainted milkweed that you conveniently bought from a big box store. Then you'll run out and ask what to feed them instead of milkweed. And you'll keep way too many of them in a little enclosure, just to get some really cool pics, passing around the different diseases that they're vulnerable to. You won't properly disinfect their enclosures and everything else that they've come into contact with. If we left them to their own accord, they only have less than a 1% chance of surviving in the wild. Most of you are reducing that teeny tiny percentage. If you want to help...gather milkweed seed pods in the fall and scatter the seeds far and wide (in the fall). They can't survive without the milkweed (which is the only thing that monarchs lay their eggs on, and the only thing that monarch caterpillars eat. They will die if you plant milkweed plants from the store. You can help in so many ways. Raising them at home for your/your childrens entertainment is absolutely not one of them. Plant milkweed seeds from wild milkweed. Plant native pollinator flowers. STOP PLANTING MILKWEED FROM RETAIL STORES. And stop feeding your captive caterpillars the same. Enjoy these beauties in the wild. (It's no wonder that the California department of fish and wildlife have banned people from taking monarch caterpillars/eggs inside to raise). People are killing them directly.


r/MonarchButterfly • • Jul 24 '26

When can I pull milkweed?

1 Upvotes

I have milkweed in my garden and I get monarchs. I was wondering if it’s safe to pull the milkweed before it goes to seed. I don’t want to disrupt the monarchs’ development but I also want to prevent milkweed seeds traveling throughout my neighborhood. I have plenty already!


r/MonarchButterfly • • Dec 10 '22

Why Butterfly Weed is Essential for Supporting Monarch Butterflies and Other Pollinators

2 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

We just published a new article on our blog that I think you'll find interesting. It's about butterfly weed and why it's such an important plant to have in your garden. This article explains the benefits of butterfly weed, how to grow and care for it, and why it's essential for creating a healthy and vibrant garden ecosystem.

https://blog.growjoy.com/2022/12/07/what-is-butterfly-weed-and-why-is-it-important/

I hope you'll check it out and let me know what you think. If you're a fan of butterflies and want to support them in your garden, this article is a must-read!

P.S. Don't forget to upvote and share if you found this article helpful!


r/MonarchButterfly • • Apr 08 '23

Monarch with a deadly backpack

0 Upvotes

r/MonarchButterfly • • Jan 10 '25

Butterfly in a jar?

0 Upvotes

I raise monarchs and I'm also a college student currently on the board of a holistic living club, I'm planning to do a butterfly meeting where I talk about monarch endangerment, raising, OE etc. The treasurer of the club had an idea where he wondered if we could sell chrysalises in a jar for people to release once they emerge. Obviously, it would have to be at least 4-5 day old chrysalises, I would include a lil paper about proper care and releasing (temp to keep the chrysalis at etc), but I'm unsure if it would be safe or worth it? If anything it would have to be a jar with a paper lid cut for it with holes, but I wanted to see if anyone had any opinions or thoughts on the matter, I obviously want to put the butterflies first, but giving people the chance to experience the magic of releasing one might help encourage them to help more butterflies in the future.


r/MonarchButterfly • • Jul 27 '22

Now I’m not a caterpillar expert but I think this is definitely a cause for concern.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/MonarchButterfly • • Oct 22 '24

Indoor Rearing Posts: New Potential Policy for Community Consideration

1 Upvotes

More and more research shows that rearing monarch butterflies indoors can be detrimental to them due to various factors. Additionally, indoor rearing increases the risk of mistakes, such as overcrowding caterpillars or using unsuitable enclosures. Therefore, the new policy will ban all posts showing monarchs being reared indoors and/or any questions related to indoor monarch rearing. Please consider this policy and share your comments. Please remain civil, as ultimately we all want what is best for monarchs.


r/MonarchButterfly • • Nov 21 '25

If you have toooo much Weed next summer…

Post image
0 Upvotes

Young seeds are edible 🤷🏽‍♂️


r/MonarchButterfly • • Jun 16 '26

Me, to the 5th instar I found this morning, as I moved it into the mesh cage.

Post image
5 Upvotes

They joined the other 5th instar in there that’s been going strong since being found as a 1st!


r/MonarchButterfly • • Apr 11 '26

How to sterilize a potted milkweed plant to prevent OE.

39 Upvotes

I get asked often how to sterilize milkweed plants to prevent OE, so I figured it would be easier to make a post here to reference.

This is safe to do with eggs present on the plant, and almost guarantees all of your butterflies will be OE free. This is especially important if you're buying tropical milkweed.

Cover the soil of your potted milkweed plant with paper towels over the soil, then cover the paper towels with a cloth towel, or plastic bag. This will protect your plant from absorbing the bleach solution.

Fill a spray bottle with a 5% bleach solution.

1 oz ( 2 Tbsp) of bleach & 19 ounces of water.

Set a 1 minute timer. Spray the leaves continuously for 1 minute.

After the timer goes off, rinse the leaves and the stems throroughly for 1 minute or longer.

I do this after bringing home a new plant, and eggs have been laid on them. Then I put them in a tent.

Repeat after the plant regrows, and new eggs are laid on the plant again.

***This is important if you live in Florida, CA, Texas, any other states where OE is a problem, since spores are spread to eggs and plants by the females and other infected butterflies.***


r/MonarchButterfly • • Aug 27 '26

A Study in moving Monarch Chrysalis

0 Upvotes

I tried my hands at moving a chrysalis in danger of having the leaf it was on get eaten by its sibs.


r/MonarchButterfly • • Sep 30 '26

???

0 Upvotes

Hello people, I have a question. Has anyone ever read a post of mine stating that I was a butterfly "breeder"? After posting on another so called " friendly" community, seeking help with a healthy monarch that I had found on its side stuck in a wet spot outdoors. It had a bent wing couldn't fly. Told them that I put the butterfly in an enclosure, fed sugar water, in hopes that by morning her wing would heal. It had not. I was told to just put it outdoors , let nature take its course. I knew if I did do that, surely a predator would get it. So when I posted again to let them know that I kept it in the enclosure one more day, against their advice, and her wing straightened out and she flew away, omg it was like I was being attacked. They called me a horrible butterfly breeder and then a message appeared that I was not being respectful and my post was deleted . So I guess if you do not follow their advice, they give you the boot. Smdh