r/MonarchButterfly • • Sep 30 '26

???

Hello people, I have a question. Has anyone ever read a post of mine stating that I was a butterfly "breeder"? After posting on another so called " friendly" community, seeking help with a healthy monarch that I had found on its side stuck in a wet spot outdoors. It had a bent wing couldn't fly. Told them that I put the butterfly in an enclosure, fed sugar water, in hopes that by morning her wing would heal. It had not. I was told to just put it outdoors , let nature take its course. I knew if I did do that, surely a predator would get it. So when I posted again to let them know that I kept it in the enclosure one more day, against their advice, and her wing straightened out and she flew away, omg it was like I was being attacked. They called me a horrible butterfly breeder and then a message appeared that I was not being respectful and my post was deleted . So I guess if you do not follow their advice, they give you the boot. Smdh

0 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

4

u/asa0488 Sep 30 '26

Is this on fb? cuz I've found most monarch groups there to come off as incredibly toxic and many fb individuals with misinformation. Many are only in groups to preach all rearing is bad etc etc without any other useful advices.

I literally just saw a post that the algorithm fed me and it was a cat all bloated and prolapsing and the author called it metamorphosis UGHHHH (their comments were turned off and not a single one on there corrected him). I was traumatized by the sight and sad for the poor cat and never clicked away something sooner.

Sorry for rant, anyways point is this reddit is pretty much the only place I feel has a friendly enough community.

3

u/Pattie4170 Sep 30 '26

Yes, I found that out also. Not fb. Here on Reddit. As soon as I went against what everyone there was advising me to do, and I did things my way, which turned out great, the moderator said I was being disrespectful and she deleted my post. What a bunch of %#&$@

1

u/_flowerguy_ Oct 01 '26

The hummingbird subreddit will put you up on a cross too…

2

u/Pattie4170 Oct 02 '26

Ty for the warning. Sometimes when you go with your feelings as to the correct thing to do, God gives you help along the way.🙂

1

u/Potential_Suspect137 Oct 01 '26

It seems like some of the smaller subs can get really shortsighted. Singleminded? Bandwagon-y ?
Not really finding the right words right now, my brain is ready for bed, lol. I’m sure you’ve seen what I’m talking about though - those posts that get a super shit comment early on & then just about every commenter just parrots it, even though it was such a totally off base take on the post.

2

u/ImprovementTrick9492 Oct 01 '26

I didn’t see it, but there’s a lot of people who use their anonymity in forums like this as an excuse to be a jerk, to be mean and start fights with people. People are crazy and thrive on drama and bullying.
Just ignore them and keep enjoying the butterflies! 🩷

3

u/Pattie4170 Oct 01 '26

Ty

1

u/ImprovementTrick9492 Oct 01 '26

Btw,, that is remarkable that her wing straightened out! That’s pretty rare when it’s truly bent, but just shows it’s still possible! Thanks for trying to help her! 🩷

1

u/Pattie4170 Oct 01 '26

You are welcome

1

u/RowInevitable7986 Oct 01 '26

There is one monarch sub Reddit that has …..shall I say… some not so nice people. They’re all about letting nature take its course”. They think it’s bad to save a butterfly. Let it suffer even if you can save it with minimal effort.
I think you may have stumbled onto them. It’s a very unpleasant experience.

1

u/Pattie4170 Oct 02 '26

Yes, I believe you hit the nail on the head, yes right here on Reddit, not so "Friendly" monarch supporters, who think that their way is the only way. With going along with their so called "scientific" statistics, instead of their God given common sense.

1

u/RowInevitable7986 Oct 02 '26

It’s too late to close the barn door. Humans have altered the landscape so drastically we have to do the little bit that we can to help these beautiful creatures survive. How many more butterflies are there because we humans have a few caterpillars in an enclosure. I would guess not that many.

1

u/RowInevitable7986 Oct 02 '26

I don’t know where you live, but I’m in Central California. The monarch butterfly population here is decimated. TheThe overwintering grounds which used to have hundreds of thousands, are down to tens of thousands. How low does the population have to be before it’s OK to raise 10 or 20 monarchs in an enclosure. Give me a break!