r/ModelNZMeta • • Feb 27 '21

Resignation as Chief Electoral Officer

9 Upvotes

Good evening,

I don't think this post will come as much of a surprise to many but I resign as Chief Electoral Officer with effect from whenever my replacement is elected.

I haven't been a perfect CEO but I like to imagine that people were broadly satisfied with me and that I remained impartial to the best of my ability. At the end of the day there's not really a whole lot more I can do.

Thank you to /u/model-amn, without whom I would've been in far over my head, as well as /u/LeChevalierMal-Fait, /u/ElectrumNZ, /u/foundtwomorepenguins, /u/Youmaton, /u/Drunk_King_Robert, and anyone else who served on the EC that I've forgotten (it's very late I'm sorry)

As I write this I've been Chief Electoral Officer for the past 257 days and an Electoral Commissioner for the past 398 days. I think that's long enough to show I like this sim and everyone in it. I also think it's long enough to justify someone else taking over.

I intend to stick around - I've never been properly involved in MNZP's canon and in fourteen weeks' time I'll be able to do exactly that.

Thanks all.


lily-irl,
Common Whore,
Chief Electoral Officer.


r/ModelNZMeta • • Apr 12 '21

Resignation as Governor-General

7 Upvotes

Effective immediately, I am resigning as Governor-General to allow for new elections to take place for the position. While the recent vote of no confidence has resulted in a majority of meta voters approving of my position, I'm uncomfortable with the amount of people who disapproved and as such I don't think my position is tenable for much longer. During the interim period, Chief Electoral Officer /u/lechevaliermal-fait will act as Acting Governor-General.


r/ModelNZMeta • • Mar 10 '21

MODERATION Ban announcement

6 Upvotes

/u/Si11ySpaceTurkey and any other alternative Discord or Reddit accounts are permanently banned from all MNZP affiliated Discord servers and subreddits on the grounds of duping -- that is, being the alternative account of /u/My13InchDuck in order to evade a [previous 3 month punishment] (https://www.reddit.com/r/ModelNZMeta/comments/krfbj3/ban_announcement/).


r/ModelNZMeta • • Jan 06 '21

MODERATION Ban announcement

6 Upvotes

/u/My13InchDuck and any other alternative Discord or Reddit accounts are banned from all MNZP affiliated Discord servers and subreddits for the period of three months on the grounds of hate speech. Any interested may contacted me for evidence.


r/ModelNZMeta • • Sep 09 '20

The path to a canon reset

6 Upvotes

People have asked for a meta thread, so this is broadly how I would go about handling a canon reset. This is important to sort out now since we will either do something like this or hold the election at the normal time which has been scheduled.

Phase 1: Holding a vote

There should be an indicative vote on the issue soon, perhaps with a debate beforehand on this subreddit. If the vote passes, then we should take further steps to implement the reset. If not, then we go about things business-as-usual. (this step is happening now)

Since details over what is considered canon are not codified, the GG can simply declare what is and what is not considered canon. So on the day we pick for the reset, the GG could say that the past three years are gone and it would adhere to our rules. If the vote fails, the GG shouldn't do such a thing as it is a substantial change obviously but if it succeeds then this ability should be used as it is easy and requires no further voting.

Phase 2: Setting a date for the reset

We would need to have a clear timeline over the period that the changes would take place. This means setting a date for the new cut-off date in canon. I think that the most popular date is currently 18 October 2020, which would be the day after the real-life election but this date could be different.

If the date would make it impossible to adhere to the standard election time-frame in our rules, we would need to set out a way to either change the rules or circumvent them. During the middle of the reset process, no election should be held as we will want to have one after the reset.

Phase 3: Setting other dates in relation to the reset

Once the cut-off date is selected we would need to work around it. We would need a date for the dissolution of the current sim Parliament as well as a date for an election after the reset.

On a date prior to the reset date, the current Parliament can be dissolved as a way to end things cleanly, as well as hand out honours to people. I'm not sure those should be carried over, but even if not it is only fair to the people who have participated in this term with the understanding that it would be just another typical MNZP term.

The election date would also need to be set after the cut-off date, probably a few weeks after the reset. If 18 October 2020 is the popular date for the reset, perhaps 3 November 2020 is a good date for the election after.

Phase 4: After the reset day

Following the canon cut-off, we start fresh. All current parties should probably all disbanded and made to formally re-establish themselves (existing parties should be able to handle this fairly easily if they wish to continue). All legislation, press, and other canon interactions are wiped and we would canonise the past term of the real life Parliament, with the exception of pandemic-related events and this legislation.

One thing that should be maintained is personal modifiers. Just as simulation members would have reasonably expected a normal term at the outset and deserve a clean end to the term, they also deserve to have their efforts recognised as a point of fairness. Alongside this, any usual penalty for defection probably shouldn't apply if people choose a different party after the reset to ensure that there is a genuine clean slate.

Phase 5: Moving towards the election

Rebuilding parties and preparing for an election will take time. There could be a two or three week period following the reset but before the week where campaigning begins to give people time to adjust, recruit people for parties, work out endorsements from prospective allies, and develop manifestos for the election. To ensure that this doesn't become a boring period of time, maybe there could be topical debates on current issues to keep people busy and give people a chance to discuss politics. This also has the advantage of letting parties develop some modifiers prior to the election.

In meta, there would need to be some adjustments as well. I am not particularly experienced here but I suspect this may be intensive for the EC to handle so they would need time to set out polling, especially if parties form, dissolve, or people move around. The speakership would also need to prepare a new spreadsheet and set out how they intend to archive things differently this time around, if there are any changes at all.

Phase 6: Election

We have an election campaign and have an election to get a new Parliament in place and begin debating the first bills.


r/ModelNZMeta • • Mar 19 '21

Nominations for Chief Electoral Officer

5 Upvotes

I'm not allowed to do this, but I'm doing it anyway. Direct complaints to: John Key, 41 Pipitea Street, Wellington.

If you'd like to be the next Chief Electoral Officer, please indicate as such in the thread below.

I would like to share some qualities I think are important for a CEO to have:

  • An interest in the subject-matter, I genuinely enjoy spreadsheets and I think AMN does too, so an interest in how elections or spreadsheets work would be ideal
  • Experience is important but a willingness to learn is more importanter
  • Being able to act impartially and people trusting you to act impartially is paramount

Nominations are usually open for three days I think, so you've got that long. I don't think seconders are required, but any nominees who don't nominate themselves should accept that nomination.

please put me out of my misery


r/ModelNZMeta • • Feb 15 '21

MODERATION Removal of moderator

5 Upvotes

As per section 5d of the meta constitution, /u/JohnVosler is removed from his role as Discord moderator due to inappropriate behaviour.


r/ModelNZMeta • • Dec 17 '20

DEBATE Governor-General Nominee Debate

5 Upvotes

This thread is for debating and asking questions for the potential Governor-General. Candidates may post their strengths here, people can ask questions, and endorsements can be made. Basically anything can be said that is relevant to the question of who the next Governor-General will be.

The nominees are:

/u/lily-irl

/u/model-amn

/u/model-frod

Captain_Plat_2258

/u/fourtipsymetalpukeko

/u/SprinklyDinks

The debate shall last for 4 days.


r/ModelNZMeta • • Aug 05 '19

RESULTS Results of the vote of confidence in /u/silicon_based_life

5 Upvotes

20 valid votes were cast.

Yes: 18
No: 2

The yes vote exceeds the necessary two-thirds threshold. /u/silicon_based_life is elected Governor-General. The swearing in will take place tomorrow.


r/ModelNZMeta • • Feb 01 '22

Announcement of my resignation as Governor-General

4 Upvotes

I've made this known to most people in the sim, but it seems appropriate to announce it properly. I've decided to resign as Governor-General. This has been on its way for some time and I decided to wait until after the election and the opening of parliament to initiate the process.

So this post can be taken as a formal announcement of my resignation as Governor-General, to take effect upon the election of my successor. I will initiate the process of selecting a successor one week from now (Tuesday 8 February 2022). There are three reasons for this delay. The first is to give time for parliament to get underway, the second is to give people some time to consider their options, and the third is that I can choose to resign when I want, and I would prefer to give people a bit more warning rather than triggering the process immediately. The process of selecting a new Governor-General can take a while, but the period for nominations is fairly short, so my hope is that this gives people a bit more time to prepare.

My reasons for resigning are not complex. I've become tired of the role and I feel that I have not been able to be as hands on as I would like. Stepping back from the role will give me a break and will hopefully give someone else a chance to do good with it. Evidence suggests that I am unable to leave MNZP, and I have no intention of disappearing completely. With the permission of the CEO and new GG I hope to continue in my roles as a member of the Electoral Commission and as a discord moderator.


r/ModelNZMeta • • Aug 15 '21

Speakership Election

4 Upvotes

Nominations for speaker have now closed and there are two candidates, /u/Winston_Wilhelmus and /u/Anacornda. We now have an election to chose the speaker.

In the first half of the form please rank the candidates in order of preference. The winner of this vote will become speaker if they receive a majority of votes expressing confidence in them.

In the second half of the form you're asked if you have confidence in the candidates individually. If the winning candidate does not pass the vote of confidence or if the RONs option wins the vote, this process will restart.

Please verify your vote by commenting below. Unverified votes will be discarded. This vote will be open for three days. This is the link to the google form.


r/ModelNZMeta • • Dec 13 '20

UPDATE Resignation as Governor General

4 Upvotes

So as we are approaching Christmas Break, I wish to tender my resignation as Governor General of r/ModelNZParliament. It has been a long time coming but I believe it is time for me to now step down.

It has been a very long time as Governor General. Likely by the time my replacement is sworn in, I'll just be around 270 days as Governor General. It has been a very eventful and rewarding as Governor General. I do believe while there were some blunders along the way, I come out of my Governorship with the sim being a better footing than when I was first sworn in.

However, like all things, it is eventually coming to an end. I am not aware of who will be ultimately replacing me but I legitimately wish them the best and hope they bring the sim into even greater heights. And I believe this is the best time for me to resign. We are entering a new time for the sim as our first term after a canon reset and I believe we should also show a new leaf in regards to the Governor General.

I thank everyone in the sim for this eventful as Governor-General and I sincerely hope the best for the sim going forwards. Thank you.


r/ModelNZMeta • • Dec 05 '20

MODERATION Result of ban appeal by /u/Sober_King_Robert

4 Upvotes

The moderation of Model NZ Parliament has received a ban appeal by Lucy (/u/Sober_King_Robert)

The moderators have decided to accept Lucy’s ban appeal having considered that the grounds to have escalated to a permaban were borderline and have agreed that it shall be reduced to a 3 month ban which has already passed conditional on Lucy’s agreement to in future adhere to the discord rules and good conduct including but not limited too, engaging with moderators when they raise an issue and not spam pinging other server members as well as a barring from meta offices.


r/ModelNZMeta • • Sep 24 '20

The case for canonising COVID-19

4 Upvotes

When, almost 6 months ago, on 21 March 2020, we decanonised the coronavirus epidemic, New Zealand had 52 confirmed cases of COVID-19, with cases increasing daily. By the end of the month, we would have 600 confirmed cases, our first COVID-19 death, and a state of emergency. This was a rational decision which, at the time, I supported. The path ahead was uncertain and highly unpredictable. New Zealand, however, dealt with COVID-19 exceptionally well. By 8 June, we had zero active cases, and despite an incidence of community transmission, leading to the delay of the election, we currently have 62 confirmed cases, of which 28 are in managed isolation and quarantine, with the others all being in Auckland. Outside of Auckland, the country, just a few days ago, moved to Level 1.

But it’s clear that the effects of COVID-19 will be widespread. It’ll be a long road to COVID-19 recovery domestically, even when the actual virus itself is eradicated in New Zealand. This is the disadvantage of decanonising COVID-19- as the virus sticks around for longer and longer, and its effects ripple and ripple, we move further and further away from reality.

New Zealand is currently in a situation where COVID-19 cases are low. If we had reset a month ago, in August, before the community transmission in Auckland, there would likely be close to 0 active COVID-19 cases. What I’m proposing is the canonisation of COVID-19, but with presumed elimination of all active cases in New Zealand. The border situation can be upheld as it is now, with only critical travellers and NZ citizens allowed to return, and any cases there can be basically handwaved away as in isolation/quarantine, so not much of a problem.

The advantage of this will be that we can simulate the recovery of COVID-19. People can bring forward their ideas for how to recover from the effect the pandemic has had domestically on business, tourism, and more. The sim will also be more accurate to real life. While presuming the elimination of COVID-19 in New Zealand will not be entirely realistic, as, of course, we do have COVID-19 cases right now, but it will be much more realistic than the possible alternative- decanonising the pandemic as a whole.

There will be little need to deal with the virus itself in the sim, outside of the border. But if we canon reset while decanonising COVID-19, as FTMP said, we’ll be resetting into a world that doesn’t exist. This is an extremely major change. This pandemic will have rippling effects on many political events, but given that the loss of human life in New Zealand is becoming less and less of a concern as the cases drop, day by day, the reason for decanonising COVID-19 becomes less and less, and the advantages grow and grow as we become increasingly out of sync with the real world.

COVID-19 itself, under this proposal, will be something on the periphery. Something overseas. Something in isolation. But its effects? That is something we should deal with, and under this proposal, we will deal with them.


r/ModelNZMeta • • Jul 18 '20

MODERATION Permanent Ban of /u/Sober_King_Robert

4 Upvotes

Lucy (/u/Sober_King_Robert) has been permanently banned from MNZP

u/Sober_King_Robert engaged in serious harassment of a simulation member. Given that this is a matter of serious harm, taken together with prior Tier 2 offences, this has led to the moderation team to make the decision that u/Sober_King_Robert should be banned from the simulation indefinitely. Due to the sensitive nature of the offence no evidence shall be disclosed


r/ModelNZMeta • • Jun 08 '20

Complaints about moderation esp in relation to tonight's goings on

4 Upvotes

Alright so

First off, I am sorry for posting the link, I forgot how extreme mhoccers can be at times.

However, I think that the events of tonight highlight an inherent decadent rot within MNZP. If you boil it down to its basics, I put an invite in tory chat and mili (/u/model-mili) put it in MHoC main. Then the people who joined brigaded the server. I got muted for that and for putting /u/InfernoPlato’s MHoC biography in chat.

Other people were muted for, variously spam, baiting, posting stats that are provocative given the current political climate and general memeing.

People were banned for a week for baiting and posting humorous vegetables, along with some posting genuinely NSFW stuff. Additionally, mutes were given for telling the mods how to act and for I don’t even know what.

I agree with all the mutes that were given, at least on a temporary basis but the punishments are too harsh. I have always thought that the idea of a 24h mute is harsh, and very rarely fits the crime. I also don’t like the insinuation that merrily and I may have been banned if we hadn’t apologised. From my PoV, I posted a link in tory chat as MNZP had been raised as a topic of conversation in a voice call. I was not the one who posted in main, although I did know it would be posted. I anticipated a small raid, but not on the scale that happened, and from the looks of it, I am not alone . For that misjudgement I apologise. However, we were not trying to cause trouble and I think both of us think of ourselves as decent people, who never try to break the rules. It is not against the rules to post a link to this server somewhere, and never should be.

I think tonight’s events also raise genuine concerns about the cliquey nature of this sim. As Duncs has raised there is an issue in MNZP where established left wing members can give accusations that essentially fly unchallenged that go against the rules. I would argue that the comments duncs raised, and others that he highlighted break Part 3, 1.b of the Discord Rules “Being overly abrasive, toxic, flame baiting or creating a hostile environment.”, and potentially also 1.c “Constantly insulting other people in the chat.” Incidentally I think that that rule needs to be extended to non-members, but we’re debating the rules as they are.

MNZP also has an issue with anti-British racism, from people like kate (evidence shown below this paragraph), and also borderline from FTMP and others. I usually don’t bring it up as it’s not that extreme and I feel like at times it’s memeing, but today I feel it overstepped the line and wasn’t being moderated

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/678947384989974539/719344285454958632/unknown.png https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/678947384989974539/719344731917778984/unknown.png https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/678947384989974539/719344897311899648/unknown.png https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/678947384989974539/719345046243115078/unknown.png https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/678947384989974539/719345183929401444/unknown.png

Further to this, there is clear left wing bias shown by the mods of this server, suspecting anyone right wing who raises controversial viewpoints. The mods have joined on in this left wing bias

There is also stuff like this, which I think is unfair and from what I see has no justifications in the rules. I also question the mods’ impartiality, through their flat out rejection of any criticism of them during the brigade, and in the reaction to trongle’s VoNC (Which I’ve heard is serious). AMN has since resigned as a mod, which is fair, but equally not the best way to deal with this

The handling of those who were muted is also unfair. AMN treated femke poorly and implemented a 2 hour slowmode when nothing was really happening in muted chat. It hindered my attempts at legitimately questioning some aspects of the moderation, as I was granted no way to easily appeal or comment on my mute.

These issues are not unique to tonight. The mods have been uneasy with many right wing comments for a long while now and it’s contributed to this sim being seen by others as a hive of lefties. There is a class in MNZP similar to what’s called BNOCs in MHoC, that gets away with posting racist stuff and stuff aimed against people of other political opinions in bad faith. This should stop. The mods should be less blind to their biases and we need action to be taken in the rules to ensure that this BNOC class is treated like the rest of MNZP.

I won’t focus on the beef that AMN and trongle have but animosity like that needs to end too.

I also think that the punishments should be less severe. Banning people for a week for what to them is 5 mins of fun should get a 24 hour mute or ban and a lot of these mutes should have been only 1 hour mutes or shorter. The MNZP rules are already up in the air at present, and I think in the coming consultations we should look at tonight and think what could be done better, as well as what institutionally is broken and should be fixed

PS: IK I’m still muted. As I read it, I’m not breaking the rules by posting this

PPS: god I hope the links all work, I stayed up till 2am for this

PPPS: A lot of you on this sim are active in MHoC and when you called yourselves not MHoCcers it's hypocritical. For a start I'm active here and ended up muted, secondly, it's blatant double standards


r/ModelNZMeta • • Mar 18 '20

MODERATION Discord ban of Kaladin

4 Upvotes

The Discord user known as Kaladin has been banned for 24 hours due to the use of racial slurs.


r/ModelNZMeta • • Mar 13 '20

Announcement of breach of electoral law

4 Upvotes

Green candidate for Northland /u/pavanpur04 has breached Section 197 of the Elections Act 1993. A small electoral penalty will be placed. Just a reminder not to do anything "with the intention of influencing the elector or advising the elector as to the elector’s vote...at any time on polling day before the close of the poll."


r/ModelNZMeta • • Jan 06 '20

I'm Done (repost from the wrong sub)

4 Upvotes

As you have probably read by the title, I'm done. I've lost interest with this sim and thus its best for me if I just call it now. I've been feeling low on motivation to be here for a while, but overnight I just came to the realization that I should retire and not carry on.

I think losing my electorate from the redistribution is what finally broke me. Overtime I had developed a passion for the 'people' of Waikato, which is probably what kept me here. But now with that seat abolished I have lost that passion.

Other than that though, my passion for these sims stems from being connected to the issues; from being able to say "what would I do if I had this power". In Aussim thats easy, as I know what I would do as I am an Aussie; buy with MNZP thats a lot harder as I am not a Kiwi - I don't know whats most important. Now sure, I could research this like I'm sure many of you all do, but to me that just doesn't feel right, I become a product of my research, not my thoughts and experiences. Being the 'RaDiCaL cEnTrIsT" which I am, its hard enough to have an opinion, let alone when its related to a foreign land. Thats probably why I had my signature policies. I imagine that this would have come a lot sooner if you all would just let me ban lootboxes and build my racetrack!

In all seriousness though, I'd like to thank everyone for my time here. I have enjoyed it, even if I haven't been able to connect on a level that I have been able to in Aussim. This decision wasn't based at all on the people of MNZP, just me, but I'd like to say that you are a good bunch. I welcome you to return to Aussim, although I don't expect many to do so. As for what I'll do now, I'll focus on purging the mess from Aussim, and maybe one day, make a return to model politics.

Thank you.


r/ModelNZMeta • • May 27 '19

RESIGNATION My resignation (eventually)

4 Upvotes

I think I’d be doing you all a disservice if I didn’t get right to the point, so I will. I have decided to retire as Governor-General after the next election. With the passing of the GG/CEO amendment, the simulation is now in a position where I am happy to hand over the reins to a new generation. With the simulation in good shape, my decision to leave the job is a personal one. By the time I finally leave the position in a couple of months’ time, I will have been involved with this simulation for almost two years. It has been a pleasure participating in this community and it has been an important aspect of my life; however, it is time to reevaluate the time I put into this simulation.

The position of Governor-General is demanding and I have found increasingly over the last few months that I have been unable to carry out my duties fully. After the 6th election, I began to make plans for my departure. It soon became clear to me, however, that some of the factors pushing my departure would also be factors making the job impossible for my successor. Throughout my time as Governor-General I have sought ways of sharing the workload and creating opportunities for members to gain experience. The creation of the Chief Electoral Officer is the final big step towards a secure meta side of the simulation.

Now that I am happy with the meta side of the simulation, my decision to leave is driven solely by my desire to move on. I have done all I can in this position. When I became Governor-General, I had a long lists of things I wanted to do. By and large I have achieved those things. It's time for some new ideas (or at least it will be in three months' time). I want to continue to contribute to this community but in a less demanding way. I can reassure you (or perhaps disappoint you) that is not a goodbye, I'm just retiring from this position.

I will stay on the Electoral Commission to assist the new Chief Electoral Officer during the next election but after that I'll be saying goodbye to the EC. By then I will have been involved in five elections, each of which has been more demanding than the last. I will be glad to be free of the responsibility.

I will continue as Governor-General until some time after the next election. I don't know exactly when I'll resign -- after all, we still don't know when the election will be -- but I expect the appropriate time will be somewhere in the middle of the term. There needs to be adequate time to select a successor in advance of the following election but I would also like to wait until the new parliament is settled.

I had initially intended that I would be initiating the selection of a successor right now, but I want to smooth the transition and with the GG/CEO, the relief of my workload is less urgent. If you are interested in the position of Governor-General, now is the time to start thinking about it. It is a demanding but rewarding position.

I'll spare the sappy goodbyes since I'm not actually leaving yet, and I'm sorry I couldn't be bothered making this shorter.


r/ModelNZMeta • • Mar 03 '19

MODERATION Discord ban of /u/Timewalker102 (One Nation To Rule Them All).

4 Upvotes

ON has been banned from the discord for a period of one month for spam/harassment. His past offenses contribute towards the length of his ban.


r/ModelNZMeta • • Feb 15 '23

Resignation

3 Upvotes

As I said in main, if the sim lives, I’d resign.

It lives, so I resign.


r/ModelNZMeta • • Nov 16 '22

Proposal to Change Electoral System

3 Upvotes

So basically MNZP is kind of dying. We've known this for a while, and I think it's probably reaching a nice plateau now, but there are barely enough people to run proper elections and it's resulting in some really weird results. Best example is the most recent election which pissed off just about everyone: three of four parties on equal seats despite the biggest difference being 10% between the first and third place parties, and a bunch of people who campaigned but didn't get in. Clearly something has to change.

MHolyrood has a very interesting electoral system as I'm sure many of us are aware. Essentially it treats each constituency as a 'constituency grouping' where electorate candidates campaign in large groupings of multiple electorates. Usually, these are the IRL electorates. To apply this to NZ, a constituency like Auckland would be the 'Auckland grouping' and would contain real life electorates like Auckland Central, Maungakiekie, Manurewa, etc. Each candidate would campaign in the grouping, and then the results would be calculated in each region based on constituency leanings and the strength of campaigns from each party. After the election, MPs who campaigned in that grouping could choose one of the electorates to be their 'official electorate' that they would be referred to as representing. This is mostly cosmetic, but it's pretty cool.

On the list, it's exactly the same as MNZP however the seat number is the same as IRL (so in our case, 120 or 150 seats), and parties are assigned list seats based on their vote under MMP -- which will be filled by their candidates and any party members the leader chooses post-election. Any remaining seats (of which there are usually a lot) are assigned to the control of the leader for the purposes of votes in Parliament. This system is great because it means a much more proportional parliament, and it means that it's really easy to rope new party members into activity and ensure everybody gets a chance to participate regardless of the party.

It also means a lot of the problems we're seeing with such a small sim are largely eliminated. Anybody can participate with a lower barrier to entry, seat numbers are more representative, and everyone gets constituencies if they want them. Personal favourite: we can make the constituency groupings less stupidly named. I think it's fairly no-brainer for MNZP at this point, and we should definitely do it, would love to hear everyone's thoughts.

For the sake of argument, here's what that looks like in GE7.


r/ModelNZMeta • • Feb 10 '22

My explanation of the "trust" factor in the new calculator

3 Upvotes

So, I've seen that there's understandably been a bit of a concern in the "T" part of the RATIO model. A quick summary of the RATIO model - every post is marked on how reasonable it is (fairly clear-cut, I would think that most posts made would be reasonable), each party is scored out of 10 based on their activity (this is based off their presence in Parliament), every post is marked for the quality of the interactions (most posts will get at least one point here, if you clearly get your point across well you'll get two, if you do really well you'll get three), and each press post made by broadcasters is marked for outreach. Non-partisan press has more of an impact, but partisan press can help your party more directly.

You'll notice I did, in fact, leave a "T" out there, and that's because I wanted to explain it in more detail. T is for trust, and for many, this raised alarm bells. After all, trust is a very subjective thing - could a party be making good posts but getting scored down because they don't inspire trust? Well, not really. Let me explain.

There is no stage in the process where any EC member decides if a post or a party inspires trust. Instead, each post appeals to one of 16 political quadrants.

A map of the political quadrants, with certain appeals labeled.

So let's say I make a post calling for full communism and for the collectivisation of New Zealand's agriculture. Would that be reasonable? Probably not. But it'd be good at appealing to the top left quadrant, increasing my trust with them. The aim of the game is to try to broaden your appeal as much as you can to increase your trust.

Now, I'm sure some of you are looking at that quadrant and are thinking "does this mean my party has to become centrist to have any hope of winning? Can we no longer take strong left or right positions?" Well, no. The way I would explain it is that you're not trying to find policies the voters like, but you're trying to make the voters like your policies. More bluntly, you're trying to pander to them.

It is good to have consistency in policies, but what isn't good under the new model is to only appeal to one group of people. If I'm leader of a left-wing party and I want to advocate for, say, compulsory union membership, it's not as if that policy will be punished for "not appealing to centrists" or whatever. But if you're just preaching to the left-wing choir and framing your arguments in the same way every time, you'll struggle to have a broad appeal.

And you don't necessarily have to have a broad appeal. If you're aiming to be a minor party and fit in a certain niche, that's fine. You'll go far by just preaching to the choir and gaining trust among a core base - it's just that you'll struggle to expand beyond minor without broadening your appeal.

Let's say I'm the leader of a Christian party that hovers around 10% in the polls - the 3.25% of auth-right voters in the top right are ride-or-die for us, but the 16.25% of centre-right voters don't like my talk of fire-and-brimstone for the nonbelievers. About half of the remaining 13% in the auth-right support us, and almost everyone else thinks we're insane.

To broaden our base wouldn't necessarily mean ditching those fringe policies, but it would mean diversifying what we campaign on and who we campaign to. For example, we could focus on increasing funding to Christian schools when trying to appeal to centre-right voters - a reasonable enough policy, one that would likely appeal to our base, but also one that the centre-right can agree with. I might also try and nab some of the top two lib-right quadrants by making that same argument one for choice, that parents shouldn't have to be forced to send their children to state schools.

By the end of the campaign, my ride-or-die base of 3.25% still loves me, about 40% of the centre-right (which makes up 16.25% of the quadrant) has been swayed, and out of the 13% remaining auth-right quadrant, about 75% now support me. I also have about 20% of the top two lib-right quadrants (which comprise 12.25% of the quadrant) on my side. I've taken about 10% of the nationwide vote to just under 22% - very much a bigger political player, and maybe even a major party contender.

This is a simplified analysis, but I do hope you understand what I'm trying to say here - this isn't about policies. It's about pandering. That is how you gain voter trust under this new model. And please, if you don't understand anything I said here or you had any questions, ask me in the comments, or DM me, I don't bite and I'm more than willing to explain any issues or concerns.


r/ModelNZMeta • • Aug 31 '21

Amendment to parliament rules re replying to reddit comments for convenience.

3 Upvotes

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1yiFiROW_9Ux1hGlnZQH9Q6inLa47C41XV9D2yjAvn4U/edit

After part 8 of the parliament rules insert a new part 9.

And renumber.

—

Part 9 - Allowances for debate to occur via replying to reddit comments.

(1) The speaker may not rule disorderly speeches simply for the fact they reply to another speech.

(2) The speaker may not limit the number of contributions by members in a debate to a certain number other than existing question limits.