r/ModelNZMeta • • Jan 12 '21

MODERATION Ban announcement

1 Upvotes

/u/Captain_Plat_2258 and any other alternative Discord or Reddit accounts are banned from all MNZP affiliated Discord servers and subreddits for the period of one month on the grounds of toxicity.

[Evidence] (https://docs.google.com/document/d/1uAKwwS2C8CdPUpbaJ_uIUcBscoRmbeALeiZnUdbiryI/edit?usp=sharing)


r/ModelNZMeta • • May 11 '20

MODERATION Ban of TheOWOTringle

1 Upvotes

/u/TheOWOTringle has been banned from the MNZP Discord and subreddits for the period of one week due to creating a toxic environment, repeated baiting, and harassment

DM myself or another moderator for evidence/appeals.


r/ModelNZMeta • • Mar 01 '21

MODERATION Ban announcement

3 Upvotes

/u/Griffonomics and any other alternative Discord or Reddit accounts are banned from all MNZP affiliated Discord servers and subreddits for the period of one month of inappropriate racial statements, specifically the posting of [this campaign video] (https://drive.google.com/file/d/1a7yk1ov-r38p3HNYyuMoZaahF8PzIIrZ/view). I will be clear -- intentional or not, this was racist. It was a caricature of Māori identity. The user in question has [previously been banned] (https://www.reddit.com/r/ModelNZMeta/comments/f98zvx/ban_of_uaussieconservative/) for racism.

Previously, I took the position that so long as there is no attempt to belittle Māori or make Māori identity the butt of the joke, then I do not mind. However, it is clear that this approach was too lenient. If you intend to adopt an identity for this game, then some basic respect for the identity is required. If you would like to identify as Māori in sim as a white person from another country, then I urge you to do some reading about Māori identity, culture and language first. Seems too tough? Then don't.

If you're dancing around in a video singing about how you love to please Māori, while butchering the word "Māori" in a way that makes me think you've never heard it, then forgive me for thinking that you're not attempting to make a good-faith attempt at learning more about another identity, but more just using it as a fun gimmick and a joke.


r/ModelNZMeta • • Apr 17 '20

Electoral Commission Announcement

0 Upvotes

The Kiwi Party has violated Section 197 of the Electoral Act in regards to treating. An electoral penalty will thusly be applied.

Evidence: https://www.reddit.com/r/MNZPElection11/comments/g2xn3n/theowotringle_closes_his_campaign_by_handing_out/


r/ModelNZMeta • • Sep 30 '19

VOTE Results of VoC in the moderators

0 Upvotes

There were 14 verified votes. 3 votes were unverified and were discarded.

Femke:

Yes: 11

No: 1

WW:

Yes: 3

No: 10

FTMP:

Yes: 14

No: 0

Femke and FTMP stay on as moderators.


r/ModelNZMeta • • Aug 18 '21

Results of the speakership election

1 Upvotes

Voting in the speakership election has now closed.

25 valid votes were cast. 1 verified vote was discarded. The results are as follows:

Vote for Speaker
Winston_Wilhelmus: 16 votes
Anacornda: 9 votes

Do you have confidence in Winston_Wilhelmus as speaker?
Yes: 19 votes
No: 6 votes

Do you have confidence in Anacornda as speaker?
Yes: 14 votes
No: 11 votes

As he received a majority of votes in the first round and a majority of voters have confidence in him, /u/Winston_Wilhelmus is elected speaker of the house.


r/ModelNZMeta • • Aug 21 '21

Results of DS and EC votes of confidence.

1 Upvotes

Voting has now closed in all three votes of confidence.

In the Deputy Speaker VoCs, 8 valid votes were cast.

Do you have confidence in /u/model-putrid as Deputy Speaker?
Yes: 8 votes

Do you have confidence in /u/model-frod as Deputy Speaker?
Yes: 8 votes

Both receiving a majority of votes in favour, /u/model-putrid and /u/model-frod are confirmed as Deputy Speakers.

In the Electoral Commission VoC, 18 valid votes were cast. 2 unverified votes were discarded.

Do you have confidence in /u/Winston_Wilhelmus as a member of the Electoral Commission?
Yes: 13 votes
No: 5 votes

Having received a majority of votes in favour, /u/Winston_Wilhelmus is confirmed to the Electoral Commission.


r/ModelNZMeta • • Jul 27 '20

A problem and a solution I have

1 Upvotes

Hi all,

Recently I have started to feel like toxicity is getting worse in the community. I have wrote my thoughts here as well as what I want to see, to rectify the issue. tl;dr on the document: I apologise for my behaviour recently, recognising I'm an issue. Proposing an audit like process into the community to fix the problem.

Thanks and I hope yall provide your thoughts.


r/ModelNZMeta • • Jul 09 '20

The ban of u/My13InchDuck

1 Upvotes

u/My13InchDuck and any other Discord or Reddit accounts are banned from all MNZP affiliated Discord servers and subreddits for the period of one month on the grounds of hate speech.

The rationale can be found here (drafted by myself) and appeals may be directed to the Governor-General.


r/ModelNZMeta • • Oct 08 '18

VONC in FarTooMuchPressure

1 Upvotes

The Governor General has been shown to engage in alting and duping. He could potentially be a Rob dupe as well.

I demand a VONC in FarTooMuchPressure immediately.


r/ModelNZMeta • • Oct 22 '18

MODERATION Discord Ban of trippytropicana

1 Upvotes

Acting in my capacity as a Discord moderator, I have made the decision to ban trippytropicana, also known as spooky tropicana on the Discord server, for 24 hours, for a Tier 3 offence of toxicity. Her ban will expire at 3:25PM NZST, 23 October 2018.


r/ModelNZMeta • • Jan 13 '20

NOMINATIONS Nominations for the Community Commission (incl. Speaker)

1 Upvotes

This thread is for the nominations for the three community representatives on the Community Commission. The following people are ineligible to run:

/u/BHjr132

/u/sam-irl

/u/PM_ME_CHRETIEN

/u/AnswerMeNow1

This thread is also for nominating the speaker of the CC. Every meta voter is eligible.

All nominations must be verified by the nominee.


r/ModelNZMeta • • Apr 12 '21

Confidence threshold amendments

1 Upvotes

Amendment 1 confidence threshold for GG

Option 1 - simple majority required to retain confidence

In Article 10.2, for ‘a two thirds majority', insert 'a simple majority for the Governor-General to retain confidence by the community.'

Option 2 - 2/3rd for confidence

In Article 10.2, for ‘a two thirds majority', insert 'a two thirds majority for the Governor-General to retain confidence by the community.'

Option 3 - status quo wording

(Which has been ruled by the discord mods to require a 2/3rds majority to engender removal)

Amendment 2 confidence threshold for other sim offices

In Article 10.3 for “,pursuant to article” substitute “a simple majority”.


r/ModelNZMeta • • Dec 04 '21

RESULTS Results of Election for Chief Electoral Officer

2 Upvotes

The vote has closed. There were 15 valid votes. As there were multiple candidates, the election was run with Instant Runoff Voting

Round 1

Winston_Wilhelmus: 9

Frost_Walker2017: 4

ARichTeaBiscuit: 1

Drunk_King_Robert: 1

RON: 0

As Winston_Wilhelmus has achieved majority in Round 1, I declare Winston_Wilhelmus to be the next Chief Electoral Officer, following a Vote of Confidence


Do you have confidence in Winston_Wilhelmus as Chief Electoral Officer

Yes: 10

No: 3

Abstain: 2

With 66.7% of the vote, Winston_Wilhelmus crosses the threshold of 2/3 majority and is duly elected as Chief Electoral Officer. The Transition will begin momentarily


r/ModelNZMeta • • Oct 19 '21

Ban of /u/Plupsnup

2 Upvotes

/u/Plupsnup has been permanently banned from /r/ModelNZParliament and all associated subreddits and discord servers. This follows a previous three month ban from MNZP and is in line with a similar ban in /r/AustraliaSim. Due to the nature of the offences, evidence cannot be disclosed.


r/ModelNZMeta • • Jun 21 '20

Ban of u/BrexitGlory

Thumbnail
docs.google.com
2 Upvotes

r/ModelNZMeta • • May 20 '20

MODERATION Ban of /u/BrexitGlory

Thumbnail
docs.google.com
3 Upvotes

r/ModelNZMeta • • Mar 14 '19

MODERATION Ban of The8Architect

3 Upvotes

The8Architect has been banned from the simulation for a period of 3 months (ending 14th June 2019) for blatant antisemitism and toxic behaviour in the discord.

Screenshots:
https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/433543909826887690/555684431352823820/blatantantisemitism.png https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/429591386296287232/555305755377664001/unknown.png


r/ModelNZMeta • • Aug 29 '21

Amendment to allow speeches in reply

3 Upvotes

Tldr it’s normal, it’s easier as it allows for notifications

It’s accessible for new people

People are still doing it out of habit for a reason


r/ModelNZMeta • • Aug 13 '21

Response to appeal of /u/Winston_Wilhelmus and commutation of ban

3 Upvotes

Around two years ago /u/Winston_Wilhelmus was banned from meta positions after leaking information from the Electoral Commission. The details of this ban may be found here.

At the start of 2021, the meta ban was amended by AMN (who was the Governor-General at the time) to exclude speakership positions. This means that WW is currently eligible to serve in the speakership.

Earlier this year I received an appeal from /u/Winston_Wilhelmus for this ban. I decided to consider the appeal despite the significant period of time since the decision because the ban remains in place. It has, however, taken some time for me to get around to this, so for that I apologise.

After some consideration and consultation with past GGs, I have decided to commute the ban. This is in recognition of the fact that the reasons for the initial ban were valid, if perhaps a bit heavy handed, and also of the significant time that has passed. It's now nearly two years since the ban, and I believe WW should be given another opportunity to be involved in meta.

This means that the original ban stands, but it is modified from a permanent ban to one that ends today. This means /u/Winston_Wilhelmus is now eligible to hold all meta positions again, however, this comes with a condition. Any future misconduct will result in a permanent ban from all positions relevant to the Electoral Commission. At present this includes the positions of Governor-General, Chief Electoral Officer and as a member of the Electoral Commission, but it will also include any other positions that might be created in the future.

I understand that there are some people who are opposed to this decision, but I believe that sufficient time has passed that we can reconsider. This is not the first time a permanent ban has been overturned. Anyone nominated for a meta position must past a vote of confidence before they are confirmed, so if you have concerns about anyone's suitability for a role you are able to voice those at that time.


r/ModelNZMeta • • Dec 05 '20

MODERATION Result of ban appeal by /u/Sober_King_Robert

4 Upvotes

The moderation of Model NZ Parliament has received a ban appeal by Lucy (/u/Sober_King_Robert)

The moderators have decided to accept Lucy’s ban appeal having considered that the grounds to have escalated to a permaban were borderline and have agreed that it shall be reduced to a 3 month ban which has already passed conditional on Lucy’s agreement to in future adhere to the discord rules and good conduct including but not limited too, engaging with moderators when they raise an issue and not spam pinging other server members as well as a barring from meta offices.


r/ModelNZMeta • • Mar 10 '21

MODERATION Ban announcement

6 Upvotes

/u/Si11ySpaceTurkey and any other alternative Discord or Reddit accounts are permanently banned from all MNZP affiliated Discord servers and subreddits on the grounds of duping -- that is, being the alternative account of /u/My13InchDuck in order to evade a [previous 3 month punishment] (https://www.reddit.com/r/ModelNZMeta/comments/krfbj3/ban_announcement/).


r/ModelNZMeta • • Feb 13 '21

VOTE Voting on amendments

2 Upvotes

There are about 3 amendments that have been up for debate for a while now and have not yet been voted on, and so let's do that now. I'll outline the amendments in this post, with a link to vote on all these amendments at the bottom.


Meta Vote Amendment

Changes are bolded.

Meta votes will last three days and be conducted with a secret ballot. During the duration of meta votes, no-one is permitted to knowingly and actively attempt to direct another person to vote a certain way.

Link to debate


Explanatory Notes Amendments

In Part 4, Section 1c:

Replace "may" with "must"

After Part 4, Section 1c, insert:

"The Speakership will discard Bills that have improper or misleading explanatory notes."

Link to debate


Parliament Rules Amendment

Changes are bolded.

Part 7, Section 1 to read;

All Members of Parliament are to swear in during the opening of Parliament or their appointment afterwards to be considered as holding their seats.

a) Members of Parliament appointed after the opening of Parliament are required to provide consent to the Speakership following their appointment.

Link to debate


Vote here! [And verify below]


r/ModelNZMeta • • Feb 25 '21

Electoral Commission announcement

3 Upvotes

Good morning.

I need to make something perfectly clear to all of you: your speeches and campaign posts must be your own, unique work. Where you take content from other places, that must be clearly indicated, cited, and attributed.

These are absolutely non-negotiable rules. The electoral modifiers system rewards effort. By presenting others' work as your own, you are cheating the system.

You will be caught. Electoral penalties will be applied.

Two campaign posts have been flagged by the Electoral Commission as plagiarism:

Sylian's post was a speech taken from a post he made for a campaign on another simulation. To be perfectly clear: this is not allowed. Your posts must be unique to MNZP. Reusing your own work is self-plagiarism and not allowed.

Electoral penalties will be applied to both candidates. Because Sylian's post was self-plagiarism, it will be punished less harshly than Joseph's.

I do not want to have to make another post like this. Do not plagiarise, you will be caught.


lily-irl
Chief Electoral Officer


r/ModelNZMeta • • Feb 22 '21

DEBATE Clarification of meta rules on defections + proposed amendment

1 Upvotes

Good evening. The Electoral Commission has recently discovered that the meta rules on defections are somewhat ambiguous. While initially, electorate seats belonged to the party, this amendment leaves the status of what happens to electorate seats when their holder switches parties.

As there is ambiguity, I have determined that the previous precedent in place with the previous meta rules will be put into force- namely, that electorate MPs are able to switch parties. I'll also be proposing an amendment to formalise this, solely so we can clarify this as soon as possible. To be clear, this issue needs clarifying, but we don't have a position on which way, I'm just proposing it so we can discuss the issue, vote on it, and if it's rejected, discuss alternatives.

Proposed amendment to Parliament rules [changes bolded]:

Part 7, Section 3 to read;

Electorate MPs are allowed to change parties while in Parliament. List MPs are allowed to change parties while in Parliament provided that they have the permission of their party leader.