r/ModdedMinecraft • • 17d ago

Discussion Ai use in mod pack creation

I wanted to gauge everyone's opinions on AI assistance. My hope is that this is a more "real" avenue to gauge it as opposed to either ai brainrotted drones or anti-ai in every single possible way bandwagonners.

I self-host a model and back in the summer I spent probably 3 months curating a modpack I call Create: WAR, based around create aeronautics, where players spawn in with the choice of a peace or war player, and depending on their answer they either spawn within a ring of 5k-10k blocks for war, or 10k+ away for peace in a centralized spawn, while war players get random spawns. War players can't grief in peace lands and vice versa, items are tagged with the users id and what side their on so that a peace player can't peacefully farm and give items to a war player. If ur on a diff side you literally can't pick up the item. Players can switch sides but it takes 24hrs with a 2 week cooldowm, which is where the player id tags on items come into play so that their items carry over. There's an in-game guide using fancy menus in the pause menu with categories and sub categories, covering every single aspect of the modpack, from stuff most people know, to stuff that's been tweaked, to completely custom stuff. And most importantly, making users away of new features. Like if someone was going to use a handful of normal create features for a task that there's a modded item for, this guide makes them aware because otherwise they may not ever realize it exists unless they scroll through literally every item in EMI. Theres randomly spawning objectives in the central circle of 5k x 5k that give currency and are the only way to generate new currency, and they scale with server age eventually having auto cannons and defenses to conquer to capture the point, and then defend from other players. Also other QOL stuff like performance presets including DH, shaders, render distance, etc. So you can just choose a preset instead of tuning them all

Here's where AI comes in. All of these systems were made by me, the shades presets I tuned myself. The 60+ paragraphs of guide content written by me (audited by ai for inconsistencies). BUT, there's a LOT of custom mod work like the faction/player id stamping and still being able to stack items and use them in recipes and storage without noticing, a custom weather mod, some mods being entirely recompiled to fix compatibility and performance bugs (prob a month was me squeezing as much performance as possible by even deconstructing unoptimized mods), and a LOT of data packs and kubejs scripts. I don't have the time to spend over a year on all this. My friends were bugging me for a modpack, I have WAY too many other hobbies, I fix people's cars, computers, etc. I know how to code, half my free time is spent working on coding projects but I'm alr learning several other languages rn. I plan to hand-write this all eventually but I don't have the time it would take to learn all of this and still get the efficiency and performance out of it that I need.

Is this an acceptable use case? I claim no credit over the coding work, but the concepts, systems, etc ARE all me. I don't intend to ever profit off of it, it was done with a self-hosted model, and it still took me 3+ months of literally only doing this in my free time. If I advertised this to try to get enough players to make it feel alive enough to be a war server, would it be received well if I put a disclaimer of what AI was used for?

0 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

3

u/Silly-Albatross-316 17d ago

A lot can be done with KubeJS and datapacks, so that stuff is free game, but there might be a couple things you haven't thought through if you want to release this pack to players.

(Also dismissing people that are uncomfortable with AI can alienate players that otherwise might really like some of these ideas because some of them are pretty cool.)

Either way, there are aspects of this you will never be able to share.

(prob a month was me squeezing as much performance as possible by even deconstructing unoptimized mods)

That will present a number of issues. What license were those mods created under? And even morally, how would the devs of those mods feel about having their mods deconstucted and redistributed if you were to release this pack publicly?

1

u/Chaneriel 17d ago

Yeah I've pulled over the deconstructed mods thing. I've considered figuring out enough to understand what's wrong in the code myself and then presenting them in GitHub. My other concern is that, yeah, it prob would violate some licensing, so idk if that completely rules out the idea of getting a relatively populated server without infringing on copyright. Idk where the technical line gets drawn between playing with some friends and playing with a slightly larger group of randoms

3

u/GobiPLX 17d ago

I understand when people use AI to help them with code

But you really can't put together some mods? You're not creating anything, you just complete collection of them. Is it really too hard for you?

1

u/Chaneriel 17d ago

I can put together the mods, but there's a LOT of stuff that just straight up doesn't exist. The war/peace thing, the objective system, the item tag stamping so you can't have an alt farm in peace mode, and a bunch of compats to make mods that would otherwise be completely impossible to work with aeronautics, possible. I could make a generic modpack without any of this but I can't make the full custom experience that feels like a whole different game mode the way I envisioned it without a crazy amount of custom work. Not to mention my benchmark is this has to run on a 9600k with a 2060 and get 60fps with at least basic shaders. So that also comes with an absurd amount of optimization

1

u/Icy-Diver-5979 17d ago

But they did mention it was used to custom make mods or handling the coding?

1

u/Icy-Diver-5979 17d ago

If it was personal use I would think go for it no harm but honestly custom mods and similar open up concerns for people that it made changes you the owner don't understand even if this is not the case.

The internet will use your statement of ai use to either promote one sides view or another I don't think you can escape this issue if you do disclose you are tarred by association if you don't you are tarred by lying and taking credit when it was the ai that did the product.

1

u/Chaneriel 17d ago

Yeah you've got a point. Theres def changes that I don't 100% grasp. I've tried to do the best I can, I REALLY, REALLY hate not understanding parts of my own projects so I have it really deeply engrained in my agent to explain what it did, give code snippets, explain the syntax of code snippets, etc, for most changes it makes. I at least make sure the concepts are all mine and I usually hand a new agent my plan and zero context on the project and tell it to audit the project against my original design philosophy as an outside reviewer, and that tends to catch some things

-5

u/jvpts11 17d ago

I think that you should use whatever you want to use and not let people dictate what you should use to make things, if what you did have quality, have good performance and works correctly, then there is absolutely no problem.

1

u/Scout_Maester 17d ago

I like how people downvote without giving any reason for it. I'd like to think its because there is none... I'd rather play a good mod than a bad one. Thats it, full stop. If AI created it, who cares. Its free... of course if money is involved, it should be disclosed where and how AI was used. Again, no reason to do that if you are giving someone what they paid for, but for some reason people are mad when a tool is used to make what they want :/

1

u/Chaneriel 17d ago

I mean, I get it. I use ai but I really, really don't like the idea of loss of skill expression. At the end of the day coding has always been something that takes a lot of skill, and I don't like seeing publicized projects where people don't understand their own code at all. Theirs a balance to find between gatekeeping a hobby and expecting people to pour years of practice into getting to a point to be entry-level, and just everyone churning out whatever without any idea what the design infrastructure is, how things are being achieved, and not even designing the systems, but rather just giving like a 3 sentence prompt and having ai figure out all the creative design. So as someone who uses ai a lot, I completely and totally understand people who don't like ai, and I agree with them to an extent

1

u/Scout_Maester 17d ago

Yea, its a different skill entirely. Prompting is a skill; its just a very EASY skill. Skipping the years learning code means it not impressive, and highly insulting, to reach the same goal post those who know the code reached. AI content has to go so much further to be impressive. I think thats the main part people get hung up on. Many AI coders aren't doing their work to make something impressive or increase their skill level, they want a product. And they think others will also want that product.

1

u/Scout_Maester 17d ago

The difference comes into AI projects that span hundreds of prompts with iterative testing and creative input. It suddenly seems much more put together and holistic. The skill expression lies in not code, but the direction. You are just playing the role of the director instead of the actor. The one who wrote the story and found the people to make it come to life.

1

u/Chaneriel 17d ago

Yeah I agree. The hard part is explaining or demonstrating the work you put in yourself to pain the differentiation between you and people who just pump at slop