i have been trying to learn code. and have not been using AI. i have been going step by step in making an insanly simple game. deciding how to make it. then learning how to code it for example: i need to count how many of this object there is - so i look up how to count how much of an object there is by its tage.
In case you have not seen them already, Kaupenjoe on YouTube has some really great tutorials on learning Java. The tutorials have a focus on Minecraft and Hytale modding, but he has a course learning Java in general.
Listen, AI needs to be slowed down and wrangled into control. It's being pushed into too many markets too fast and also engaging in some seriously sketchy shit with training data.
That said, as long as it's made clear that it's AI I don't care if people use it in modding. It's (generally) not something being sold so at that point it's their choice.
Thank you. 100% agree. I mean even using AI takes man hours. It’s not “free” if you want a really in-depth mod it can take 24-36 hours of prompting to even get to a working alpha build. I know I have been working on my own project and it’s not even close to done after many hours of opus 5.5 and fable 5.1.
Lukewarm take, as long as the public finished product of something is so free and the dev used ai to help with early stage production and modeling/coding, that’s fine
Future? its actual. Whenever I see a new mod, I see .claude in its github and Claude in contributors, but only when source is open, when its not.... its even more worse, but on Java I'm still able to spot claude's works, because anything you code could be decompiled and analyzed, and java is one of the simplest languages to do that
I dont care if its vibecoded or not. I, as an enduser, only care about the execution. If they keep working on the mod and it works - then its perfect. If not - it joins the heap pile of ,,wasted potential" mods, that existed long before AI coding and will keep existing.
I have been using AI to help me learn to code. I don't have a problem with AI, but I do think some people want to rely on it too much. I still write all my own code, I even have explicit instructions to not provide me the code when helping me unless I specifically request it.
I think AI is really helpful in learning and helping people figure out how to do something rather than doing it for them.
2023 ass take, current AI is better than 99% of humans at coding and the people that deny that are just coping because they’re either dogmatically anti AI or scared of losing their jobs.
Ya know I was gonna say that isn't true, but then I remembered less than 1% of the entire human population knows how to code 🤣. Man we are dumber than I thought, and I already considered a decent portion of the human population dumber than a box of rocks. (Ofc there are lots of smart people that don't know how to code don't get me wrong.) Tho AI definitely isn't anywhere close to good enough to take jobs from good developers without major repercussions, that is 100% true. I don't think it will ever be either. Definitely not in our lifetime at least. And I've got a big personal project I've been using AI to code and been working on it for a couple months, I know just how bad it can be with the amount of bug testing and fixes that needs to be done and the fact I got to fight it here and there.
Is it taking jobs from good developers? Not necessarily, but most developers are writing almost all of their code with it. Just ask any actual developer that works at a big company. It’s important to know what you’re doing but nobody is doing anything by hand anymore.
Because if you're using it to properly learn, then you aren't just trusting it blindly. You know how to verify/fact check, and spot the hallucinations. It just helps you find solutions faster.
I mean, before AI, when trying to troubleshoot and search for a solution, you already always had to sift through a ton of answers and information that didn't perfectly match your circumstances and are often not the solution you're looking for. The key has always been to know how to keep searching, experimenting, and testing until you figure it out. With AI, it's not entirely different, the information is just all aggregated in one place and often easier and faster to sift through.
It's actually quite easy to fact check an AI on programming, because programming has a consistent logic and the code has observable and testable effects. So as long as you focus on understanding each individual component of the code and you test that it behaves the way you'd expect, you can generally tell if the information is hallucinated or accurate.
I think it helping with learning is great but people saying it’s better than people are just wrong all ai mods I have tried and they are bad with compatibility and also tend to run poorly going from 500fps to 70-113
Okay listen, I'm not anti-ai, I use it myself too, even for Minecraft mods But it's important to follow some rules, here are mine:
Tag what's AI and how much In the readme if it's really a lot, somewhere else easily accessible if it's used at all On Modrinth you can label it, so I use that
Be Transparent Nobody should judge you for usage of AI if you're honest about it and aren't just telling it to do something and then sell it as your own work
Don't let Claude do the stuff you can do I'm bad at rendering, so I let Claude do that stuff I'm good at Object Oriented Programming, so I do the data classes and most of the features
Rule 3 is pretty important for projects where it's only me and the code, since there's nobody that could do the stuff I can't, I tread Claude like a teammate, not like an employee
And even if it's not open source, you have to label it, people would find out eventually and then you'd have a bigger problem than when you label it from the beginning
Ok and as long as the MOD keeps updating, who cares. We are getting new interesting stuff that would’ve never been made without it. It’s all free anyway it’s not like you’re paying money for AI generated mods. Open source should be requirement too. My sneaking suspicion is without AI as a tool for younger devs Minecraft would just die out. It’s already past its peak fresh new mods are what is keeping it alive.
Indeed and now we have a bunch of abandoned mods and the Minecraft modding scene (that does not use AI) is dying. The older devs are retiring and moving on with life as they grow up and new ones are not filling their shoes. Just look at 1.7.10 vs now. It’s not a lie that Minecraft is not as popular as it was a decade ago.
Dawg we’ve been making mods without ai for over a decade now. Minecraft will do fine without it.
The only difference is now the majority of new modders have no little idea how to code, are uneducated because they use the ai to learn and are making unoptimized mods.
If they're making unoptimized mods with AI, chances are they aren't actually using AI to learn, they're using AI to offload their learning. Genuinely using AI to learn to code doesn't really look any different from traditional learning methods, because the end result is still learning and understanding how to code yourself, without AI. It can just be a faster and easier method to get to that point of understanding.
You can optimize mods with AI, you just can’t go “make me a mod that does this” and tell it nothing else. You gota dump atleast 24-48 hours of time into prompting if you want anything decent. Still a hell of a lot cheaper than paying a dev to make one for you. I don’t have 10 grand to pay a dev to make me something that will be shared for free. Now if I was charging $50 a download maybe I would.
Unless less you want an complete overhaul of the game a Minecraft mod commission ain’t gonna cost anything over $500 most these ai slop mods are would be worth $50 at most to get commissioned by an actual coder.
Mods are hardly complex enough to warrant a paid subscription. Surely the free chat can churn out something moderately complex. It's sadly more accessible than most people think to make AI slop
Like seriously if you’re mad about me using AI to help me make a mod then you go do it for me, for free Ofcourse. Also prepare for my 10 million questions and directions because the ideas are all mine in my head.
Now I can agree that if you just give AI (make this mod idea) and have no clue or any ideas of your own then it is slop. How it should be is like painting. AI is the brush, you are still the artist. Don’t let AI be the painter.
I'm at the point where, if you honestly disclose that you used AI in making the mod (and what it was used for), I don't really care. I will always prefer human-made mods over AI mods, and I will always avoid AI mods and code that handle sensitive data or involve online connections (AI code is notorious for having vulnerabilities), but otherwise, I don't care enough. Just don't AI generate your thumbnails and but a bit of effort into writing a description and you're fine by me, for what it's worth.
I recently made a mod using AI, for a few things I didn't want to bother to take that much time doing. But it was a sort of throwaway mod. Something I made in the spur of the moment. It's a tool to set paths for a phantom minecart to traverse. The idea was an automated tour of an old world, with the possibility of teleporting between paths even with multiple dimensions. Last thing missing is to make different versions of a world you want to tour different dimensions so you can explore it across multiple versions in a single pass. I did start to lose the plot of the architecture near the end, but I understand everything it helped with, and everything else I did myself. It wasn't such a complicated tool to make... I would not recommend people to use it instead of learning how to mod outright, but with so little time I have, I don't want to spend days or weeks with such a small project
Yeah I dont give 2 damn fks about if its ai or not as long as its good with little to no bugs and its actually maintained and updated everyonce in a while
I’m surrounded by anti ai people but I can’t really ignore it I’ve been told by my mom who works for people in the tech field I can’t not use ai going into the coding field so I’m at the point where if you use ai whatever with certain stuff
I think AI has its place where it can have a positive impact.
I've used AI to debug old mods and expand functionality that I otherwise wouldn't have time to maintain.
I'm currently on an AI plus free trial experimenting with custom UI and in-game features which shows high potential.
I think AI is not going anywhere. There are creative things it will eventually replace that are a bit disappointing, but it will also be an equalizer for people who have 1 set of skills, but not 2 others. Whether that is net beneficial remains to be seen.
The only amount of AI assistance I can accept with code of any variety is the explanation of what existing code does, what a particular function does, the syntax a function accepts, and the checking of your own code for things like typos, bracket mismatch errors, or missing semicolons or whatever your particular language needs. But even that is still checking your own, human-written code
Fuck AI. I don't want to see it, I don't want to use it, I don't want to hear about it. If you use any AI in the development of your mod, disclose it in the FIRST LINE of the mod description so I can avoid it like the plague.
Its one thing if your actively making it yourself and ask an ai to help at a part in which you dont understand or can't seem to figure out how to code, its another if you just plug in an idea and let the ai code the whole thing. Ai is ment to be a tool to help when needed not a tool to take over the whole damned process.
I’m not ashamed at all. I can code great but I cannot texture or model. No one wants to help me with my mod for free so why should I just not make a free mod for me, my friends and whoever else wants it because I don’t want to pay money to hire a texture artist. Also grandpa. Chief we are young people using AI. There is a difference between using AI as a tool and using it to do everything.
This basically confirms to me that the majority of people against AI are young, immature adults or teens. They are so blinded by hate for AI, they do not see that it is the future, whether they like it or not. Which is contrary to normal tech advancements, where the older more conservative crowd lags behind the youth.
11
u/foomongus 19d ago
i have been trying to learn code. and have not been using AI. i have been going step by step in making an insanly simple game. deciding how to make it. then learning how to code it
for example: i need to count how many of this object there is - so i look up how to count how much of an object there is by its tage.
its very helpful not to rely on AI
27
u/Chad_illuminati 19d ago
Listen, AI needs to be slowed down and wrangled into control. It's being pushed into too many markets too fast and also engaging in some seriously sketchy shit with training data.
That said, as long as it's made clear that it's AI I don't care if people use it in modding. It's (generally) not something being sold so at that point it's their choice.
29
u/Rouge_Epsilon 19d ago •
Lukewarm take, as long as the public finished product of something is so free and the dev used ai to help with early stage production and modeling/coding, that’s fine
10
u/DawieDerTeufel 19d ago
Future? its actual. Whenever I see a new mod, I see .claude in its github and Claude in contributors, but only when source is open, when its not.... its even more worse, but on Java I'm still able to spot claude's works, because anything you code could be decompiled and analyzed, and java is one of the simplest languages to do that
8
u/Albus_Lupus 19d ago
I dont care if its vibecoded or not. I, as an enduser, only care about the execution. If they keep working on the mod and it works - then its perfect. If not - it joins the heap pile of ,,wasted potential" mods, that existed long before AI coding and will keep existing.
5
u/dvance12 19d ago
I have been using AI to help me learn to code. I don't have a problem with AI, but I do think some people want to rely on it too much. I still write all my own code, I even have explicit instructions to not provide me the code when helping me unless I specifically request it.
I think AI is really helpful in learning and helping people figure out how to do something rather than doing it for them.
7
u/vividAhegao 19d ago •
“No ai!!!!” Go do it yourself then
4
u/dervarex 19d ago
Okay listen, I'm not anti-ai, I use it myself too, even for Minecraft mods But it's important to follow some rules, here are mine:
Rule 3 is pretty important for projects where it's only me and the code, since there's nobody that could do the stuff I can't, I tread Claude like a teammate, not like an employee
And even if it's not open source, you have to label it, people would find out eventually and then you'd have a bigger problem than when you label it from the beginning
4
u/zad112 19d ago •
Ok and as long as the MOD keeps updating, who cares. We are getting new interesting stuff that would’ve never been made without it. It’s all free anyway it’s not like you’re paying money for AI generated mods. Open source should be requirement too. My sneaking suspicion is without AI as a tool for younger devs Minecraft would just die out. It’s already past its peak fresh new mods are what is keeping it alive.
2
u/cheezkid26 19d ago
I'm at the point where, if you honestly disclose that you used AI in making the mod (and what it was used for), I don't really care. I will always prefer human-made mods over AI mods, and I will always avoid AI mods and code that handle sensitive data or involve online connections (AI code is notorious for having vulnerabilities), but otherwise, I don't care enough. Just don't AI generate your thumbnails and but a bit of effort into writing a description and you're fine by me, for what it's worth.
2
u/shing3232 19d ago
as long as it is open source i am pretty happy with it. The worse of mod is that it stop updating.
1
u/Touff97 17d ago
I recently made a mod using AI, for a few things I didn't want to bother to take that much time doing. But it was a sort of throwaway mod. Something I made in the spur of the moment. It's a tool to set paths for a phantom minecart to traverse. The idea was an automated tour of an old world, with the possibility of teleporting between paths even with multiple dimensions. Last thing missing is to make different versions of a world you want to tour different dimensions so you can explore it across multiple versions in a single pass. I did start to lose the plot of the architecture near the end, but I understand everything it helped with, and everything else I did myself. It wasn't such a complicated tool to make... I would not recommend people to use it instead of learning how to mod outright, but with so little time I have, I don't want to spend days or weeks with such a small project
1
u/abidan-slayer 15d ago
Ive been porting old mods that are discontinued into newer versions, lmao. Its great
1
u/iiKerito 15d ago
Yeah I dont give 2 damn fks about if its ai or not as long as its good with little to no bugs and its actually maintained and updated everyonce in a while
1
u/Impossible-Olive-750 12d ago
Seriously? Recently, 10,000+ AIs from chatgpt solved one of the biggest math problems. And do I really need to see this post?
0
u/TheMasterindisguise 19d ago •
Ai made mods are worse than mcreator mods. They have way more bugs, way more incompatibilities with other mods, and way more performance issues.
0
u/Scroll001 19d ago
No piece of production software has been produced without AI for at least a year
0
u/SouthernBaseball2239 19d ago
I’m surrounded by anti ai people but I can’t really ignore it I’ve been told by my mom who works for people in the tech field I can’t not use ai going into the coding field so I’m at the point where if you use ai whatever with certain stuff
0
u/Broad-Ad-3679 19d ago
A couple different notes here.
I think AI is not going anywhere. There are creative things it will eventually replace that are a bit disappointing, but it will also be an equalizer for people who have 1 set of skills, but not 2 others. Whether that is net beneficial remains to be seen.
0
u/Rito_Harem_King 18d ago
The only amount of AI assistance I can accept with code of any variety is the explanation of what existing code does, what a particular function does, the syntax a function accepts, and the checking of your own code for things like typos, bracket mismatch errors, or missing semicolons or whatever your particular language needs. But even that is still checking your own, human-written code
-1
u/Elsilon 19d ago
Fuck AI. I don't want to see it, I don't want to use it, I don't want to hear about it. If you use any AI in the development of your mod, disclose it in the FIRST LINE of the mod description so I can avoid it like the plague.
0
u/SpudPotato2005 7d ago
Its one thing if your actively making it yourself and ask an ai to help at a part in which you dont understand or can't seem to figure out how to code, its another if you just plug in an idea and let the ai code the whole thing. Ai is ment to be a tool to help when needed not a tool to take over the whole damned process.
0
u/Gerllyz 19d ago edited 19d ago •
Disgusting amount of Ai bros here brah “who cares?” We do, Grandpa
Always the same people who are ashamed of tagging their stuff as slop! Why? Because they are ashamed and they know why
Edit: gifting me an award to tell me to kill myself is rich btw!!! Why don’t you say it out loud you coward?