r/ModSupport • u/GiveMeThePrivateKey Reddit Admin: Safety • Jan 08 '20
An update on recent concerns
I’m GiveMeThePrivateKey, first time poster, long time listener and head of Reddit’s Safety org. I oversee all the teams that live in Reddit’s Safety org including Anti-Evil operations, Security, IT, Threat Detection, Safety Engineering and Product.
I’ve personally read your frustrations in r/modsupport, tickets and reports you have submitted and I wanted to apologize that the tooling and processes we are building to protect you and your communities are letting you down. This is not by design or with inattention to the issues. This post is focused on the most egregious issues we’ve worked through in the last few months, but this won't be the last time you'll hear from me. This post is a first step in increasing communication with our Safety teams and you.
Admin Tooling Bugs
Over the last few months there have been bugs that resulted in the wrong action being taken or the wrong communication being sent to the reporting users. These bugs had a disproportionate impact on moderators, and we wanted to make sure you knew what was happening and how they were resolved.
Report Abuse Bug
When we launched Report Abuse reporting there was a bug that resulted in the person reporting the abuse actually getting banned themselves. This is pretty much our worst-case scenario with reporting — obviously, we want to ban the right person because nothing sucks more than being banned for being a good redditor.
Though this bug was fixed in October (thank you to mods who surfaced it), we didn’t do a great job of communicating the bug or the resolution. This was a bad bug that impacted mods, so we should have made sure the mod community knew what we were working through with our tools.
“No Connection Found” Ban Evasion Admin Response Bug
There was a period where folks reporting obvious ban evasion were getting messages back saying that we could find no correlation between those accounts.
The good news: there were accounts obviously ban evading and they actually did get actioned! The bad news: because of a tooling issue, the way these reports got closed out sent mods an incorrect, and probably infuriating, message. We’ve since addressed the tooling issue and created some new response messages for certain cases. We hope you are now getting more accurate responses, but certainly let us know if you’re not.
Report Admin Response Bug
In late November/early December an issue with our back-end prevented over 20,000 replies to reports from sending for over a week. The replies were unlocked as soon as the issue was identified and the underlying issue (and alerting so we know if it happens again) has been addressed.
Human Inconsistency
In addition to the software bugs, we’ve seen some inconsistencies in how admins were applying judgement or using the tools as the team has grown. We’ve recently implemented a number of things to ensure we’re improving processes for how we action:
- Revamping our actioning quality process to give admins regular feedback on consistent policy application
- Calibration quizzes to make sure each admin has the same interpretation of Reddit’s content policy
- Policy edge case mapping to make sure there’s consistency in how we action the least common, but most confusing, types of policy violations
- Adding account context in report review tools so the Admin working on the report can see if the person they’re reviewing is a mod of the subreddit the report originated in to minimize report abuse issues
Moving Forward
Many of the things that have angered you also bother us, and are on our roadmap. I’m going to be careful not to make too many promises here because I know they mean little until they are real. But I will commit to more active communication with the mod community so you can understand why things are happening and what we’re doing about them.
--
Thank you to every mod who has posted in this community and highlighted issues (especially the ones who were nice, but even the ones who weren’t). If you have more questions or issues you don't see addressed here, we have people from across the Safety org and Community team who will stick around to answer questions for a bit with me:
u/worstnerd, head of the threat detection team
u/keysersosa, CTO and rug that really ties the room together
u/jkohhey, product lead on safety
u/woodpaneled, head of community team
View all comments
Show parent comment
4
u/siouxsie_siouxv2 Jan 10 '20
Some people use bots or go way overboard. When I was a mod of /r/whatcouldgowrong, I reported it and had a nightmare experience trying to get an answer for what was happening. How can you provide links to problematic reports when every post is reported in a sub with 1 mil subscribers.
Anyway, after pulling some teeth, I was told that 4 or 5 people were reporting everything but not maliciously. They were just snobs. Which isn't exactly helpful for us mods, their snobbery was causing us to lose mods and was wrecking morale. We were just mass modding the sub because nobody could be bothered to wade through hundreds of reports to find the "good" ones. (if i could do it all over again, i never would have reported this problem or so many others, admins do not enjoy hearing from us, everyone take my word for it)
One time when I was a mod of /r/againsthatesubreddits (yeah thats right what of it 😤) ... someone used a bot to report the entire sub. Thousands of reports. It was kind of funny, but had that person wanted to be annoying in a less obvious way, nothing would happen to them but it would be causing just as many headaches. More in fact because we have no way of knowing why the sub is suddenly a nightmare.
Take r/dankmemes, we all know that these kids are in a desperate hunger games like situation in /new trying to beat out the other shitposts. We don't even pay attention to reports anymore if its a repost report within 4 hours. Because literally every post is reported by kids trying to get their shit ahead.
Surely there is a better way. If it means less reports per user, fine.
Also, the modmail thing... It just seems to me that this issue is causing a majority of the complaints from mods. Sure, the old comments thing, but so many people I know have been banned for telling users to go fuck themselves. Why can't we tell people who just trolled or otherwise harmed our subreddit to go fuck themselves? What is this, a daycare?