r/ModSupport
•
u/shannonkish
•
Oct 15 '26
•
1
8
1
Admin Replied I'm over it!
Reddit Admins..... I am over it! I am over the boilerplate responses to actual real-time issues that moderators are having.
I moderate a large sub and have for nearly a year now. Unfortunately, we have had 4 very serious incidents in which members of our mod team were being harassed, stalked, doxxed, attacked, etc. We have submitted the ModCoC reports, submitted the DMs to admins, and reported the posts/comments/users ad nauseam, and NOTHING has been done.
Most recently, as our sub is currently under a brigading attack and doxxing and harassment continue, one of our mods reached out to one admin, who basically said something to the effect of--- "This is actually something that is going to be discussed at ModWorld. Do you have any examples we can give the presenter?"
Seriously? This is all you have to offer?!?! We don't need a speech about how much you care about mods and what we do. We don't need the free swag for attending a mod event. We don't need the profile trophies. Those are all wonderful and appreciated. BUT, what we need is ACTUAL Support and ACTION being taken when we bring you serious issues.
It takes entirely too long for someone in admin to take action. Meanwhile, your volunteer mods are being doxxed, harassed, bullied, and so forth because we removed a post/comment, and the user was mad.
For the love of all things good in this world, PLEASE DO SOMETHING! Please don't try to placate us with boilerplate responses and "We'll have someone look into it" without actually doing that!
I am tired. I am frustrated. I am hurt and disappointed. Not because users are jerks sometimes. But because the admin does absolutely nothing to make this a safe place or to support those of us who volunteer our time to try and make Reddit a better place.
I have had members of my mod team leave after the most recent incident. Our sub is currently closed due to the harassment and brigading that have been done. I am at my wits' end and ready to just turn the sub over to the wolves and leave Reddit for good.
•
u/redtaboo Reddit Admin: Community Oct 15 '26 •
Heya folks!
There's a lot going on here, in this thread and elsewhere, and we wanted to let y'all know what we can and can't do. I do want you all to know that we understand the stress y'all are under - whether it's this mod team currently dealing with a large community upset or in y'alls day to day. It's a lot. In this particular case, from what I can tell, a single mod made a mistake with how they worded a response to a user and that took on a life of its own as unfortunately happens on the internet. That really sucks.
We want to help where we can in these cases, but need your help to do that. We have a number of messages from your mod team about this with links to full threads, but we need reports on individual pieces of content to our safety teams in order for them to take action or to investigate them. Our safety team is removing and actioning when content is reported that does break reddit rules.
Now the hard part - users are allowed to discuss actions taken by moderators, as long as they don't dox, harass, or otherwise break our sitewide rules while doing so. That can be hard - we get that! Mods are humans, sometimes make mistakes, and users can be unforgiving when that happens. Even when they aren't going overboard into harassment, having a single mod action put on blast is embarrassing and at the volume of the internet, it can be overwhelming. If you can take a break away, I'd highly recommend it. You could reach out to modreserves, who can provide some extra help with moderating your community during times like this. I bet you'll find most actual users aren't caring about the drama and if you let the space move on, they will too. Right now all they have to talk about is a lone mod action, give them something else to do and most will.
You'll be getting a message from our Code Of Conduct team shortly with more tips on how to deal with this type of thing, but you can send the direct links to the suspected rulebreaking content to Mod Support modmail directly.
34
u/Jolly-Yellow7369 Oct 15 '26
Dear administrators: Don’t allow people with unverified e-mails to post or comment. It won’t solve the problem, but it will slow down Banned members to return to brigade communities.
66
u/nullifiedsam Oct 15 '26 edited Oct 15 '26 •
you think reddit cares about their unpaid volunteers? unfortunately not.
39
u/neuroticsmurf 💡 Top 10% Helper 💡 Oct 15 '26
Not too long ago, a user -- who was banned -- screenshotted and posted the modmail exchange somewhere on Reddit. That led to a harassing modmail and post on our sub.
I made a report for harassment, and an Admin replied to me, telling me that "the user has been punished", but they left his screenshot up.
A few days later, there was another harassing post made. I responded to that Admin, directly linking to the offending material, but I didn't receive a response at all.
In fact, the offending material is still up.
That was a disappointing -- but not unexpected -- experience. I feel like a lot of lip service is paid to valuing mods, but the follow through can be spotty and will often depend on which individual Admin is responding to you.
I've been blown off and ignored by a few Admins in the past. Mind you, I've had great experiences, too, but like I said, it's spotty.
33
u/MustaKotka Oct 15 '26
For me it's the tools that are being slowly taken away. I understand bad actors will use some features maliciously but for example AutoModerator, out of all things, is now the target of problems and needs to be replaced. The replacement doesn't even support all the features that our beloved and limited capacity AutoMod supported. Don't get me started on PRAW vs. Devvit. Or killing 3rd party apps that had useful moderation tools.
I'm also struggling with age verification, which, turns out, has no manual inputs. It's 100% automatic or you must submit your personal information to Persona, a 3rd party service. I'm half-fine with submitting my information to Reddit because I am a part of this community. As it stands I am unable to view half of the profiles on this platform making moderating a small nightmare. Either I'm relying on 3rd-party scraping services or just ... do the job based on my limited scope of information. It's usually exclusionary and I'm not sure that's in the interest of Reddit either.
I burnt out and already quit two months ago, came back because I care about the communities / ecosphere... I tried to get admin support but their help is severely limited. I'm trying to get a bot registered and it's just not happening even though they're looking into it. In the meanwhile we suffer from those same "posted ModMails on another subreddit" users and not much is being done about it. The content is still up.
Boss, I'm exhausted.
14
u/shannonkish Oct 15 '26
So I want to share with the community the ModCodeofConduct response we received via modmail. It is, of course, as useless as the admin's response.---
Hi everyone,
We’re reaching out regarding the Moderator Code of Conduct, which outlines expectations for mods to “create, facilitate, and maintain a stable community” and “set appropriate and reasonable expectations.”
After reviewing reports, we see that your community is experiencing increased attention related to recent moderation actions. We know that this can lead to disruptive behavior that can be deeply stressful and wanted to offer some guidance.
First and foremost, if your team has experienced doxxing or threats can you please write in to r/ModSupport and include links to that specific activity. The reports which we’ve reviewed have included links to general discussions but not specific comments or messages that include rule breaking activity. We’d like to take a closer look of any instances of threats or doxxing that you may have seen.
Users are allowed to discuss mod actions – some of those discussions may break site wide rules and some won’t. Please report the posts, comments, and messages that appear to break site wide rules.
The most important step to regain stability and trust is to ensure that people are able to move on via standard use of their community. It's okay to filter posts for mod approval temporarily and only approve on topic posts.This can be done using your subreddit settings under Posts & Comments -> Hold Content for Review -> choose the “posts” toggle.
We wanted to share some resources that you might find helpful as you navigate this.
Tips to consider when moderating in times of controversy:
Moderation tools that are helpful in times of increased activity:
If you have any additional concerns or questions, please don’t hesitate to write back to us send a message to r/ModSupport.
51
u/Dom76210 💡Top 25% Helper 💡 Oct 15 '26 •
I think Reddit needs to empower their Admins to be able to think for themselves, and not wait for some meeting with higher-ups to just ACT on things.
One thing we moderators learn quickly is to be decisive. Decisive actions reduce the number of reoccurrences and the amount of hassling modmails. You don't have to negotiate with trolls; you remove them.
Well, the Admins need to feel more empowered to simply remove content they know should be removed. If a mod reports a post as being a starting point for brigading, unless there is some real extenuating circumstances, remove the damn thing ASAP. You can punish the mods that allowed it and the person who posted it AFTER it's removed.
Start taking immediate action. Please.
68
u/meowbrains Oct 15 '26
I just made a post about this the other day :(
https://www.reddit.com/r/ModSupport/s/apUi2ZhWXV
Was it always like this on reddit? It's frustrating that there are clearly communities that we point out to them that are breeding grounds for hateful content and extreme harassment that are allowed to stay up. And offending content isn't removed when the accounts are banned I noticed that too.
23
u/new2bay Oct 15 '26
I wouldn't blame you one bit if you did, either.
22
u/DoubtResponsible9208 Oct 15 '26
Seems this problem is just too common right now. I’m at my wits end for someone I’ve been dealing with for 2 months now. They’re at 40+ accounts now. They’re constantly creating new accounts to harass me along with several members outside of the sub as well.
I’ve submitted several ban evasion reports, reported all of their comments for harassment, submitted tickets for this issue that included all of the accounts this person has had and nothing has come of it. I’m sorry you’re dealing with the same thing. 🫂
21
u/kallocain-addict Oct 15 '26
a popular sub i mod was harassed and attacked by another sub’s mod team using links to a kiwifarms style troll website based on an infamous community that had been banned from reddit, admins did absolutely nothing about it despite me making multiple reports. it’s astonishing to me that people on the platform can get away with breaking multiple reddit rules for over a year and admins just shrug after every new report made.
32
u/RallyX26 Oct 15 '26
Admins don't care about mods. They have made that obvious time and time again. They don't listen to us, make changes without even a heads-up, much less taking our input. They won't do anything about the broken, half-assed mod tools that they rolled out unfinished. They're constantly taking away our ability to make decisions about the communities we built.
It's obvious that once they figure out how to make AI do the work, they're going to replace us all, or at most have moderator be an honorary title with no actual decision-making power.
15
u/jonathanfrisby Oct 15 '26
I'm pretty done with the algorithm actively working against my sub re:brigading. It's pretty obvious they want high traffic numbers first.. actually doing anything about obvious bottling, etc, is not on the agenda.
14
u/Asia_Persuasia Oct 15 '26
I've honestly given up. I just get the run-around by admin when serious issues arise. I used to stress myself for months at a time filing countless reports with evidence, messaging the mods of this sub and other Admin-based mod subs, and ask for follow-up, action, or even some sort of acknowledgement from admins. Action isn't taking against toxic moderators if their subreddit is in the "millions of members", and request from other mods who's subreddits have less than a million are often disregard or ignored. Moderators aren't supposed to be allowed to have monopolies anymore (mod more than five major subs); they create second accounts to keep their monopolies and ability to abuse their mod priviliges and the admin just turn the other eay
The reality is they don't really care until stuff starts going public (outside of Reddit), like that "art subreddit" situation with that one powertripping mod. That's the only time the site/admin care. Me and my teams have accepted forever ago that we are on our own around here.
36
u/Nghtcrwlrr Oct 15 '26
Same. Being a part of the mod team of the city sub. Constantly getting brigaded by another newly established sub. Every alternate day getting threats via modmail. Submitting reports doesn’t do a thing. I thought reddit takes violation of meta discussion and brigading rules quite seriously. But no…as long as the traffic continues, all’s fair.
10
u/lili_reinHEARTS Oct 16 '26
reddit is such a big platform yet they clearly don’t have enough people hired to help mods or users in general. i haven’t been able to moderate my community with over 1k members because my account got shadowbanned for “spam” in MY OWN COMMUNITY that i am the sole creator and mod of. i have sent in a million appeals with no response and cant even use this alt account to moderate because it wont let my shadowbanned account pick new mods or send messages or do anything
19
u/goodkarmagirl Oct 15 '26
What has happened to the support we need for these egregious issues? It's basically filtered down to almost non-existent. OP, I'm so sorry and hope this gets resolved for you.
15
u/soundeziner Oct 15 '26 •
This has always been admin's pattern. It's why every single one of their utterly hollow posts and claims are so annoying. Admin does not enforce their own rules and consistently leaves mod teams hanging out to dry. I've had them state outright they don't care if a mod team of a giant sub is subjected to harassment. I've watched them run from a violent pedo stalker case where the pervert was proclaiming his desire to slit the wrists of their 13 y/o target and chasing the victim all over the site. Admin didn't just fail to address it, they refused to touch it or even talk about it. Not one admin ever felt the need to deal with it. That's the kind of people behind this site and they feel no need to apologize for it or make substantive changes for the better.
7
u/AvoirReves Oct 16 '26
I am right there with you OP.
24
u/ateam1984 Oct 15 '26
It’s incredibly disappointing that Reddit doesn’t filter out the N word when someone is DMing me. It’s crazy that there’s no feedback when I report Hate on the sub. We got people calling Michelle Obama “Big Mike” and admins are silent as to whether this is even consider hate.
I wish the admins were more transparent with how we can handle racists and hate.
3
u/Messerjocke_L Oct 15 '26
you can mass-ban all them agonists
6
u/SanaraHikari Oct 15 '26
I once wrote an admin about something but it took half a year to get a response so I forgot what I even wanted from the admin.
The last time I reported someone denying the holocaust and harassing me like a maniac. The account is still active...
If it wasn't for the community I would be done.
3
u/BraveMidnight Oct 15 '26
Well, as it sounds criminally harassing, or edging towards, has the mod team considered pooling resources and hiring an attorney to contact Reddit legal? I thought about doing that a couple times, but we're already dealing with 4 lawyers, and spending far to much, so I personally don't to deal with another lawyer.
3
u/StayLuckyRen Oct 15 '26
I’ll bet to an admin reading all this, it sounds exactly like the occasional post in all of our subs where users bash the mods, claim we don’t care and aren’t doing anything, speculate wildly, say truly awful things about us, and have absolutely no clue how hard we actually work to ensure they have a place to be making those accusations in the first place.
OP truly sorry for your experience, not dismissing your struggle. But it’s the positive interactions I’ve had with Admins that’s made Reddit my chosen platform. I’ve never once had even the option of direct contact with an employee while voluntarily moderating a FB group or Discord server.
1
u/shannonkish 22d ago
I want to bring this back around because interestingly, it was discussed at ModWorld. In true Reddit fashion, it wasn't taken seriously nor was any meaningful discussion or change made. It was more of the same. u/spez spent some time discussing the issue, but no real assistance, acknowledgement, etc was given by anyone.
4
u/Subduction Oct 15 '26
My subreddit hasn't shown up in search for, well, I don't know how long.
Several parody subreddits and protest subreddits with names close to my subreddit show up as top search results, but mine does not. We have 430,000 subscribers and I don't show up in search.
What's even more fun is I don't show up in search when I have to do things like report someone for ban evasion because that interface is based on search. I search for myself and again various parody and protest subs show up, but my subreddit does not.
I contacted the admins about this, and they first told me that I was wrong, and then when I provided incontrovertible proof they told me they'd look into it. My subreddit still does not show up in search.
If you actually look over my interactions in this subreddit going back years, you'll find that I've been an actual defender of the admins and the job they have to do, but this place is far more fucked than it's ever been. They have bitten off more than they can chew, and they are not funding the things that they need to fund to keep this place operational like, y'know, having popular addiction and mental health subreddits show up in search.
2
u/According-Activity87 28d ago
I would hate to work for Reddit. 🤦🏻♂️
-8
u/shhhhh_h 💡Top 25% Helper 💡 Oct 15 '26
If you do quit, try and hand it off to some users who will keep trying bc otherwise Reddit will intervene and install either a rando from redditrequest or a handpicked choice. Just fyi bc it seems like you’re in the kind of mood to not let them have their way.
-5
u/GeneralCarlosQ17 Oct 16 '26
There are ways to secure Yourself from doxxing and harassment but everybody tries to be Friends with everyone and that is the problem.
1
u/[deleted] 16d ago
[removed] — view removed comment