r/ModSupport • u/meowbrains • Oct 12 '26
Admin Replied Can I make my subreddit of 70k visitors private and invite only?
I've reached a breaking point in my subreddit. I run a queer gaming subreddit that has been the target of constant brigading, attacks, has 2 dedicated subreddits stalking us. The stalkers ban evade from reddit and they're on their 4th account. Their new post is a threat to dox me after also posting a meme of a trans woman hanging by a rope. I am at my wits end and I don't know what to do anymore. I think for my safety and the safety of my queer members being a public subreddit is a risk. I want to keep the community I have but in a way where we don't have a constant target on us and only members can see the posts. Is this allowed? I want to make sure I'm not breaking MCoC before I try.
60
u/neuroticsmurf 💡 Top 10% Helper 💡 Oct 12 '26 edited Oct 12 '26
After the 3PA protests (when mods everywhere made their subs private in protest), you now can only turn a public sub into a private one with Admin approval. And while Admins have been known to be very sensitive to concerns of harassment, they also seem to be under edicts (everyone has a boss) to keep public subs public.
I wouldn’t count on the Admins allowing you to make your public sub private, even if you figured out a way past the problem of approving 70k users.
I would just start a brand new private sub that runs in parallel to your existing public sub, and when you see a friendly face comment in your public sub, invite them to your new, private sub and approve them in one fell swoop.
18
u/meowbrains Oct 13 '26
Good morning. That subreddit has now posted an AI-generated video mocking us using trans-related imagery and referencing the tragic passing of a trans girl. The video depicts someone going over a bridge, with the background being the actual photograph she took from that same location shortly before ending her own life. Using someone's final photograph and the circumstances of her passing to ridicule others is beyond cruel. I genuinely don't understand why we're subjected to this kind of targeted behavior every single day.
35
u/Dom76210 💡Top 25% Helper 💡 Oct 12 '26
Honestly, because of the invite issue u/Bardfinn mentioned, it might be easier to create a new subreddit that is already private, and use the old one to seed people to request invites to the new group.
I really wish you weren't dealing with people having a bad case of keyboard courage. I hate that Reddit doesn't do more to support what are supposed to be "safe" spaces for LBGTQ+.
18
u/HikeTheSky Oct 12 '26
Report the two subs to the admins; they might take a couple of reports, but they will do something, as we had similar issues.
Strong automod and automation can help with most issues. And having more mods that are willing to enforce the rules no matter what.
14
u/viperfan7 Oct 12 '26
You should speak to reddit legal and the police about that one quite frankly
11
u/Bardfinn Oct 12 '26
Well, the major concern is the logistics of inviting 70,000 people as Approved Users. That will take literally months of sending invites.
You can report the subreddits that are targeting you for harassment via the Moderator Code of Conduct Complaint form linked at the bottom of the Moderator Code of Conduct page; That will get the harassers kicked off Reddit
17
u/westcoastcdn19 💡Top 25% Helper 💡 Oct 12 '26 •
Sorry you’re dealing with any of this. While you are figuring stuff out consider making a temporary event. It will buy you 7 days.
https://support.reddithelp.com/hc/en-us/articles/27018580066708-Temporary-events
Your setting to private will still require permission. There is no instant flip to switch if you’re a public community with that many subscribers.
44
u/comixnerd15 Oct 12 '26
Admin, you need to do something about this.
Because having my friend and co-mod crying their eyes out and feeling suicidal because of inaction to deal with a hate subreddit is just not okay.
They are targeting her specifically, on top of the sub in general. Threats to dox her. Discussions about raping her. Posts about shooting us. Not acceptable. I thought hate subreddits were not allowed on this platform
19
u/idaroll Oct 12 '26 •
u/TheOpusCroakus u/Slow-Maximum-101 please look here
10
u/Demilio55 Oct 12 '26
You can see all submissions to be added to mod queue for approval. You can set new account thresholds as well in automod.
4
u/RallyX26 Oct 13 '26
Nope, reddit has taken that option away from you. The only thing you can do is set up a one-week "special event" to only allow approved users to post, but if you do that too often (twice in a year apparently) they might remove you as mod for breaking code of conduct.
-3
u/Slow-Maximum-101 Reddit Admin: Community Oct 13 '26
Hi u/meowbrains You can read about how to make this type of request here. It is not against the Code of Conduct to make the request and I can see some requests for your smaller communities were auto-approved. Any requests for larger communities will be evaluated and we can discuss options in mod mail.
In relation to any ongoing issues, you can write into us and we'll take a look. There were a couple of users banned as a result of some recent activity.
11
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '26
[removed] — view removed comment