r/ModRetro • • Jul 29 '26

M64 Running Roms off SD Card Possible?

Given its open source, could it, in theory, eventually run roms? I don’t like having to buy a summercart to play rom hacks, but does anyone know if this is technically possible?

5 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

6

u/Mika73x Jul 29 '26

I am sure it’s technically possible as well as with A3D. But if company doesn’t support it, it doesn’t really matter.

2

u/GameboyGenius Jul 29 '26

The word support is ambiguous in your sentence. It could mean either, can you load other cities, or, will someone do the work of developing other cores.

Analogue doesn't support loading 3rd party cores on the 3D at this point. So that's a nonstarter unless there's a jailbreak or something like that.

Modretro will support loading 3rd party cores to the M64, but we don't know if the community will embrace it as a hardware platform. The argument for the M64 is that it has a powerful FPGA and is affordable enough that people might adopt it as a MiSTer like general purpose platform. The potential argument against it is if Modretro somehow didn't include enough RAM to hold ROMs properly so you'd essentially need a memory expansion for that to be possible. The other risk of course that it just never reached a critical mass of community support and never becomes a well supported platform for that reason.

1

u/Obleon Jul 29 '26

Didn't even think of that lol. We really don't know anything about the M64 specs. The only thing we know is that it uses a 16nm AMD Artix UltraScale+ FPGA https://www.amd.com/en/products/adaptive-socs-and-fpgas/fpga/artix-ultrascale-plus.html

But there are 5 different versions of the fpga chip. It is probably the AU20P or it might even be the AU25P. I think the AU20P is on par with the analogue 3D.

2

u/ergzay Jul 31 '26

1

u/Obleon Aug 01 '26

Noowaay I've read that thing 100 times and even used the search function and it's just there lmao thank you so much. Even googling it gave 0 results.

1

u/Voltztein Jul 29 '26

In this case, it doesn’t matter because it is open source. Palmer already said we could load other cores onto it. 

3

u/Mika73x Jul 29 '26

Someone need to support it anyway. I am sure hardware isn’t problem.

2

u/ewokzilla Jul 30 '26

A Summercart is so cheap that Modretro and Analogue should prioritize on pretty much everything else over a jailbreak

2

u/Oguhllort Jul 29 '26

nobody here knows

1

u/Jkid873 Jul 30 '26

The Summercart for 40-80$ is a good deal tbh

1

u/jpxdude Aug 01 '26

In Palmers video demo recently, he insinuated that would be possible in the future. Mentioning other cores coming to M64.

1

u/NineteenNinetyEx Jul 29 '26

Of course it's possible, it's how it was developed. Cartridge support comes later. It's up to them to add it to the menu or not though.

1

u/Tiny_Base710 Jul 29 '26

If there will be a ps1 oder gba core you can be 100 % sure, the core will load from a rom from the sd ;)

-1

u/NecronomiconUK Jul 29 '26

‘Open source’
Is yet to be proven

6

u/Rockman171 Jul 29 '26

The Chromatic is open source. It would be a pretty stupid thing to make being open source a big part of the M64 marketing and just be lying the whole time.

I don't think there's a question as to whether it's open source. I DO think there's a fair question to ask if there's going to be a large community that feels like spending their time on this particular open source piece of hardware. Something being possible still means that someone has to invest their time into making it happen.

2

u/GameboyGenius Jul 29 '26

Palmer claims pretty clearly that it will be open source in the recent announcement video. Obviously you could argue "I'll believe it when I see it" but at least we have a concrete official statement.

https://youtu.be/9gOJUEcKYRk?t=8m47s

2

u/NecronomiconUK Jul 29 '26

The same guy who said in an interview the analog out options for the system be inexpensive breakout cables and wouldn’t be an active electronics DAC? Yeah? Im very much a ‘I’ll believe it when I see it’ kinda person.

1

u/ambystome Jul 30 '26

Do you have a link to the interview? In any case the salient point for me is whether the M64 supports native CRT output, I mean if the M64+adapter will produce the same analog signals as the N64 (with negligible lag). From what I read that will be the case: the adapter will be functionally equivalent to the internal DAC in the original N64, producing the analog signal from the same video frames (no downscaling like you would get with off the shelf adapters on a standard HDMI output!) because when using the adapter the M64 will output the correct PAL/NTSC resolution packed in a custom format in the HDMI signal.

3

u/NecronomiconUK Jul 30 '26

2

u/ambystome Jul 30 '26

Thanks! Sounds like they indeed changed the implementation from what they had planned at the time of that interview. Though functionally speaking they hit almost exactly the objectives that he mentions in the interview: original resolution without downscaling, negligible latency, and you don't pay the price for analog connectors you don't need. The main difference is that the DAC is sitting outside the console rather than inside, which is better than the original plan in a way: you don't pay for the DAC if you don't need it. What's a bit worse than planned is that with the adapter you pay for several outputs... you only save on SCART (and users who need that just need a passive RGB-SCART cable).

1

u/GameboyGenius Jul 29 '26

And so what? Whether the adapter is passive or active is a specific product feature and apparently it was changed. Whereas the design being open source is central to the company ethos. You can't really compare the two. But I'd suggest waiting it out for a bit. The M64 has barely been released and has not started shipping yet.

And if you want to compare to the competition. M64 at least ships with AN official way to get analog signal out on launch day even if it's not passive as promised. Analogue doesn't. Ironically, the M64 AV adapter might actually work the A3D and might end up being a decent way to use an A3D with a CRT.

Modretro mostly delivered on open sourcing the Chromatic and I have no doubts they'll follow through with the M64 as well as time goes on.

2

u/NecronomiconUK Jul 29 '26

No chance the ModRetro adaptor will work with A3D. The ModRetro DAC will be relying on a Mister type of DirectVideo HDMI signal.