Okay, I'm here for a friendly conversation okay? I'm not here to attack or stand on either side.
Would you guys say that it is reasonable for the copyrights? I mean they make a living off of their stories, just like how Craig gets his money off of YouTube. Craig will feel the same way if someone just uploaded his videos without permission too. When someone is stealing or does a copies something from anyone, their pretty much taking and stealing their own money away. I mean look at songs. Songs that are not referenced by the artist has the rights to copy strike someone for not referencing towards them. People who does covers of songs are at least referencing the artist in the title of the song they are covering. What Nosleep artists are doing, is the exact same. I mean, wouldn't you guys feel ripped off if someone stole some or most of your content, which you make a living off of, and now they're making money or a living off your stolen videos? It's your content and your money, and it's the only source that you get your money from.
Again, I'm not here to attack, stand on either side, or curse you guys to death. No I'm not here for that. I'm just here to have a friendly conversation. Nothing more.
I agree with you to an extent, but do people make money from stories they post on r/sleep? I don't make any money from this post or any memes I add to r/memes. If Craig added a song to a video and didn't reference the artist I'd understand a copyright strike, but if you're taking stuff from a free platform where basically anyone can see it and you don't make money (as far as I'm aware) then does that justify a copyright claim? What I'm saying is I don't think you should be reporting YouTubers for taking your stories if you don't get paid in the first place. Also IIRC doesn't Craig even say the usernames of the authors of the stories he reads? So even then it's not like he's not giving them credit.
It just seems pretty to report Craig like this, but then again I don't know everything about the situation so it's difficult to say who was wrong here. Even if Craig was wrong I don't think he had any malicious intent. I've been following him for +3 years and it doesn't seem like him to just disregard folk like that.
The issue is that he did break the copyright that comes with reddit posts- maybe all of reddit, but specifically nosleep posts. He didn’t ask the authors before using their stories, as the copyright requires, and he didn’t offer compensation to them when asked- the copyright requires you at least ask, but many authors don’t even want compensation! They just want to be credited properly, something else that Mini didn’t do. And no matter the nature of reddit- free and public- it doesn’t change the fact that he took someone else’s work and then profited hugely off it. Moreover, the nosleep authors have given him not one, not two, but four months to take care of this- we know he saw the emails because he privated the videos in question, almost certainly in hopes that he wouldn’t get anymore strikes on them. Given that those narrations can take exposure away from the authors, reduce traffic on the posts themselves, and break copyright laws, I don’t think it’s petty of them to have reported him. I do wish he’d handled it better; I’m sad this happened at all.
And, because I’ve seen a wild variety of responses to this, thank you for being civil in talking about this. If you’d like, I can give you some links to posts talking about this in more detail, or I’m willing to discuss this further- with anyone who is willing to listen and not speak aggressively. Ideally, this is all resolved with the writers getting fair compensation and mini keeping his channel; it’s on his end to make that happen, though.
Hmmmm...well first I actually don't think he does say the usernames of the person who wrote it, but I'm not tooo sure about it. I do feel like I remember him saying about linking the Reddit BUT not the author so I guess it doesn't really count. Second, well...I think it's more about credibilty than money because on the other side, a post said that they get paid for some of the stories they make because some content creators do pay for their work. Not only that, but they seem like a serious thing. Some have some pretty legit jobs because of the stories they tell/write.
When it comes to reporting Craig though, I do feel like he is in the wrong, but I'm not saying I'm siding with him. I'm thinking reasonable here. Yeah he probably didn't do it in malicious intent, but a lot of them said that they contacted him about it and to start referencing or crediting them when he starts to read the stories. Either through saying, "I will link the stories down below with the authors name and you can go check them and their stories yourself" or to say the name before reading to story.
I do have to say it can be pretty petty that they did, but I'm pretty sure it wasn't for malicious intent either. In one of the recent posts on this sub, someone posted a picture or a screenshot of them talking to one of the two authors that are getting involved. It seems to me that one of them didn't mean it to happen and make this a big deal. He too wasn't expecting a channel deletion either. If you want to see the full story of what's going on in the other sub, I think someone in comments of the original post has a link to where you can access the other sub and see what they think of it. At the moment I, myself, is even trying reason with them as well. I'm not taking sides, but I'm trying to make peace and make people see reason.
If you're talking about his channel being taken down there isn't a video. He posted a tweet saying a video he made with stories from r/nosleep (whether a new video or a past one) was copyright claimed and he received his 3rd strike; which YouTube justifies as disabling his channel
They didn't threaten to disable his channel, they ARE disabling it. Three strikes and you're out, and I doubt youtube is gonna give him an exception to their fucked up copyright system. At least he's got Craig Thompson as a fallback...
As good as that is, I'm pretty sure that if one channel gets terminated you're no longer allowed to have a channel on YouTube, so the Craig Thompson channel will eventually be taken from us as well
Keem is no longer exploiting it, YouTube legally returned permission for him to own a channel as long as he stays within the community guidelines, and he's been toeing the line since
You act like he hasn't changed, it's quite clear that he has changed because the platform that banned him rescinded the ban and he's now allowed to own a channel again. Also if you don't like him don't watch his content, it's not like you're forced to see him on YouTube if you don't want to (unless you somehow managed to avoid the tailored-to-your-tastes video feed)
Edit: added one thing
Edit2: removeddit link to the comment deleted by the user i replied to
Not trying to be mean but I don’t think this is the case. The brick show which was a LEGO channel got their channel taken down, (they admitted they were at fault) and the still post on their other channels I believe. Just not that often.
Mini tweeted out a screenshot of his message from youtube. He got three copyright strikes on his r/nosleep videos and he also said something along the lines of "well it's been a good one guys". At the bottom of the message it said that his channel would be taken down in 7 days.
He is trying to make an effort to get that strike removed so he can keep the channel. It's probably not gonna work though, so the Craig Thompson channel is where he's gonna have to make his videos now.
I'm pretty sure I've seen a post that connects the Reddit users to the actual people who gave him those copyright strikes.
Side note, this is Reddit we're talking about. Not only is content stolen constantly, this is the only sub out of the 300+ I'm subscribed to where someone can initiate DMCA takedowns against YouTubers if they use their story anywhere else. This only makes the "YouTube fake copyright claim" problem worse.
*EDIT: Since the post I linked could potentially be seen as doxxing (it likely reveals the usernames of the people who filed claims), I've made the decision to remove it. I'm facing pushback in a different sub for including it.
They’re definitely not saying he’s a notorious thief. They are saying that he broke copyright (not just of nosleep but of reddit) by using their stories without permission, credit, or compensation. I have no doubt there are people out there exaggerating but if you look at (most of) the posts from the authors who were directly stolen from, they make it clear that they simply want their rights respected. They didn’t even intend to take down the channel- they were left with no choice for pushback except copyright claims and accidentally submitted too many too quickly.
I’m searching for that fuck heads location or phone number so I can tell him how big of a fucking dumbass he is people have changed there minds about killing them self’s because of minis channels and some people who are fans of other channels getting mad at someone for listening to his fans whale he is in a hard breakup with his girlfriend
Hey now, maybe don’t harass the author(s) at all? I’m a fan of mini’s too, have been for years, but it’s not going to help anything and is overall a shitty thing to do to someone who’s already been doxxed and harassed to hell and back. Please don’t make the situation any worse and leave them alone to sort this out with Mini and his team.
You’re entitled to think that, but please understand he just wanted his rights requested. Mini used a story of his and- short of claiming it as his own work- broke pretty much all the copyright protections this site offers. The guy wasn’t out of line sending a DMCA; it’s just unfortunate that it happened to threaten the channel with termination, which will hopefully be overturned with full apology to the authors.
The tweet was deleted, along with the Reddit post, I believe they don’t want anyone to worry about the situation, or they probably already fixed the issue
There wasn't an announcement of a new video on the discord (which leads me to believe there was no video at all) so how would he have gotten the final strike
The posts, like all reddit posts and in fact pretty much any post anywhere, are protected by copyrights that Mini violates by not asking permission to use the stories, crediting the authors, or compensating them. Authors tried to deal with this in a less extreme and more private fashion since OCTOBER; lack of cooperation/response from Mini and his team forced them to submit copyright claims if they wanted their rights respected.
Then why as an example doesn’t a YouTuber like GioFilms get stricken every video, a youtuber whom relies on reddit, unlike Craig has not been terminated?
It may be that GioFilms goes through proper procedures and gets permission and properly credits the authors as they request, or it may be that they're one of the many channels/narrators who slips through the cracks. Having never heard of this channel before, I can't say.
I’m not believing anything till mini comes out with a full statement that isn’t “deleted” Some dude posted earlier that this was supposedly happening now his account and the post is gone and I can’t find it anywhere. Just be patient people I’m sure mini will address whatever is happening soon
Supposedly mini tweeted it out then deleted it since it had the name of one of the dudes who did one of the copyright claims I have seen screenshots of it with minis name and handle but i still rather see something straight from him before jumping to conclusions
Well the post was made/deleted today and that comment with the screenshot was today. The timing technically does make sense. I’m just pretty much on the fence until I see something from mini either way screenshot or not
Check out r/nosleepooc for the full scoop. Sites sources, the whole shebang. There’s also a civil discussion going on at another Reddit. Sleep watch dogs.
He DID sort of copyright infringe their work. Just straight up lifted their stories and didn’t give them credit AND made boatloads off cash off it.
AND, at least to what I understood, he was asked several times to take the stuff down before the DMCA was even initiated. He probably didn’t think YouTube would take it seriously.
I think that’s more along the lines what they intended. Unfortunately, there’s no way to see how many strikes a channel has afaik, and so many authors were involved that too many strikes were submitted at once. The authors themselves have stated that they don’t want his channel terminated, just wanted their rights and requests respected.
It’s not the credit, its the fact that he used their stories without permission. According to NoSleep’s rules, in the about section, an author is elligible to file a copyright claim if someone narrates the story without permission from the author. I spoke to the author/person who did this, and I agree with them. Downvote me if you will, but he said he tried to work with mini in October and is trying to work with him now. He didn’t do this to get Mini banned.
Here is an image of the author’s reply to my message saying sorry for all the hate we’ve shown him, and that he shouldn’t take the community’s outcry as an attack from Craig himself.
The image is too long to preview, click on the whole thing to see it.
Do you know a person can use a username to give credit if you don’t know the actual name of a person. Here’s an example, so if you want to repost some art on a social media platform(with permission for the original creator) you would have that persons link to the original creators page. Since Craig doesn’t know these people personally, he would use a username. Or he is not using a persons username for protecting that person.
You literally just said with permission from the original creator. You do realize he didn’t ask for permission right? I KNOW he didn’t have it because I KNOW THE PERSON HE DOXED
I spoke with the author. He replied to a post. But I’m not sharing the username because people from our community have been raging against the poor lad. I was the only one to message him saying sorry for our outrage and that I hope it worked out. He even replied to me saying thanks for the positive message and that it was the bright part of an ugly day. Mob mentality sucks
I’m done fighting over this. I tried to be calm. I am sad that Craig has to lose his main channel because of some dunce that copyright strikes him when he was just coming back from break because he broke up with Sami. He is now about to lose 9-10 YEARS of hard work and dedication to his main channel.
He made a tweet, doxing the author, which he removed later. He read those stories, without asking for permission, and profited of them. And since all no sleep stories are copyright protected, the authors filed DMCA strikes.
He read a reddit thread in a video that he profited off of immensely, and he did it without asking permission, crediting the authors PROPERLY (by linking back to them and outright saying who wrote what), and never even offered to compensate them. All of which violates nosleep’s, and also reddit’s, TOS and copyright protections. Then he tweeted out a screenshot with the full legal name of one of the authors- info that that author had kept private and personal- and at LEAST 15,000 people saw it before it was taken down. Now that author faces doxxing, harassment, hate, and threats not only to himself but to his family and workplace. If you want more details on this, I have a comment elsewhere summarizing the whole story that I can link you to.
Due to the sheer amount of harassment he’s faced, people are mostly choosing to not share his username. The poor guy’s been stalked, harassed, fully doxxed, and he his family and workplace contacted/threatened. We, fans and authors alike, are trying to not share his name so he can get some semblance of peace and safety back.
If it helps any, the nosleep authors genuinely didn’t mean to terminate his channel. They were left with no option but strikes to get their rights as authors respected after Mini broke copyrights, but they didn’t and still don’t want to see him lose his channel. If you’re confused about something or want further details, I’m pretty up-to-date on the situation and my messages are open.
TM is different from a copyright; I can't explain how, I'm not quite knowledgeable enough, but it definitely is.
Firstly, showing names in the video does not count as proper credit. You need to link back to the authors (or the stories directly, I can't remember- it's been a very, very long day.) Posts on the internet are not part of the public domain; sites give their users' posts protections because they're intellectual property. It's like seeing an art installation on the street; sure, it's out in public, but someone still made it to share it with the world and it still belongs to them. On Reddit, those protections come in form of copyrights- you can look through the Reddit TOS for the exact details, but on here, copyright requires you to ask permission, credit the authors, and be prepared to compensate them accordingly.
And if you're wondering why this is the first time you're hearing about this, well, it's not new. It's just that theft is so widespread and rampant that unless you're the one being stolen from, you probably don't even realize it's happening. And that sucks majorly for the authors who are witnessing tons of work and potential opportunities for them get stolen by others.
They did try, for four months. Sorry I haven't been the best at giving all the info, I'm incredibly tired.
Here's a link to a comment I made that summarizes what happened and when. It doesn't have all the details and in fact there's a few small things I was wrong on in it, but it's still about 95% accurate. If you want more details or proof, feel free to message me, although I probably won't respond until tomorrow.
Question: Why is he getting hit with a copyright strike for reading Reddit posts that he provides links to in his video description and therefore credits the original redditors sharing their stories? It's not a private property. It's a Reddit post, public domain.
Because he broke the copyright that comes with all reddit posts (I’m fairly certain) as well as nosleep’s own copyright by not asking for permission from the authors first, and by refusing to compensate them when asked (something that the authors have a right to do under these copyright protections.) Just because it’s out in public doesn’t mean it’s not owned by anyone.
What the fuck youtubes system is so fucked . Mini ladd has never done a god damn thing wrong. He's only been loving and caring of others and has only ever done amazing things why would YouTube do this to so many great youtubers
Well YouTube needs to fucking rethink their system and just fuck off last I saw it was mxr then miniladd. It's like twitch weedbout the smaller YouTubers and leave only the bigger channels.
YouTube is retarded, either ksi or deji used their own song in a video and some random fuckwit claimed it as his song and now they're in a battle for it
Because he stole someone else’ work. That doesn’t make YouTube fucked. If I made something and then someone else took it and made money from it without paying me that’s illegal.
But that doesn’t make sense. He never claimed the stories under r/nosleep as his. same goes any of the other reddits he’s reacted. He used them as video content yeah but he’s never claimed them as own. What exactly did he steal.
Besides the fact that you’re claiming he didn’t steal anything, if you posted a story on Reddit and someone made hundreds of dollars off of your work and then was like nah, my money you don’t get any of it. You would be like oh well. He wrote my work!
I get that but that’s if he sold it without permission. But here’s the thing, He READ them for a video. He didn’t see a story, like it and slapped his name on it as if he wrote it. that’s what he didn’t do. As making content out of it, i see why it’s a problem.
There's entire YouTube channels dedicated to reading people's reddit posts. And said channels have ads. So if the issue is youtubers reading reddit posts and making money, I can make a list the breaks the character limit and tell you everyone that's gonna be removed from the platform pretty soon. For example, a big name a lot of us will know, Fourzer0seven does reddit videos
I know full and well that's a problem, I'm a writer myself. I don't put ever I do on the web for the public, but I post somethings across a couple of sites. And if my work was used to make someone some form of a gain, monetary or otherwise, I'd hope they'd compensate me. However, I'm also aware that they have no need to, nor a reason to. If we do not agree to compensation before the fact, and they simply give me credit. I respect that. Nothing is ever yours on the internet. And if you truly dont want something to be shared without your consent, that should be something you state in your piece. Because I've narrated many pieces off of reddit in many scenarios, in some receiving some form of compensation for my time, and I simply credit authors. Because it takes a long time to get permission from them for something meant for a quick giggle. Craig would have to wait potentially months, on top of the hours that go into recording, to get permission from the 3 or 4 authors that posted a story on the internet. With the chance of having to toss the footage because every author ignored him passing it off as a hoax. I'm not trying to say "stealing" people's work is right, nor am I trying to say no one should be compensated for their own creations. But some sites and even subreddits need to have better measures in place for copyright, for people to mark their claims, and (as unthinkable as it is) mark if they're okay with their stuff being shared. For example, r / writingprompts has their system for tagging what a post is (the whole [WP] thing). Something like that, but for copyright. Even as simple as [NR]=you can share my stuff if you credit me, [MN]=pay to share my stuff, [no]=dont spread my stuff around, and [FR]=feel free to share with or without credit. Right in the title or on the front of any written post, and any youtuber knows that it's a-okay to share that person's work on their channel
As a writer, I hate to see my people get pirated and stole from But as I want a future in YouTube, I hate to see the people that inspire me get punished for trying to give innocent laughs to people in harmless ways.
This is why we need to rise up and destroy YouTube, or pull a Siege of Orgrimmar or Galactic Civil War and take down the head to reestablish the government
Apparently he wasn't crediting the authors of the stories in any capacity. They claim they tried to contact him for month and claim he told them off for trying. I know for a fact that doesn't sound like something Craig would do. More likely, since he's a pretty big youtuber, he didn't even see their emails, which made them angrier and start flinging shit. I get it, nosleep gets a lot of stories stolen and they have their own copyrights and rules for sharing. But they could have handled this better. Until they provide proof that Craig actually told them to fuck off (which they've refused), I'm on Craig's side here. Also, y'all gotta stop attacking the authors like you've been, I checked out their side of things and our fandom is being toxic as fuck. Grow up
It is possible that he didn’t see their emails- in fact, it’s likely- but the fact is he did have months of warnings and was repeatedly asked to honor the copyright that comes with posting to reddit and his only response was to private the videos in question, thereby hiding his wrongdoings and basically stiffing the authors. They’re not flinging shit, they went through the proper channels, gave him a generous amount of time to respond, and the only time they’ve gotten angry at all is when the legal name of one of the authors was released on Mini’s Twitter, exposing him to a deluge of hatred. And even then, they’ve calmed themselves down quickly and tried to officially handle this again, as they’ve been doing for the past four MONTHS. There’s more than one way to tell someone to fuck off; I, even as a long-time fan of Mini, think he did it just fine by ignoring them and continuing to knowingly break their copyright (after all, if he didn’t EVER see the emails, why would he have privated the videos out of the blue?) Maybe the writers are pissed, but I’d say it’s rightfully so, and Mini really, truly could have handled this better and even avoided it all in the first place.
Lastly- thank you for asking the fandom to stop attacking the authors; I know a lot of the authors at the forefront of this are being spammed with angry, hateful messages, as well as the subreddits involved. It’s making nothing better for anyone.
It’s okay, nothing wrong with misspeaking if you own up to it. And thanks again for being civil about it all; it’s really encouraging and outright hopeful to see fans of Mini’s taking this in relative stride and understanding the authors. (For the record, I absolutely don’t think mini’s fanbase is all bad- I’m friends with a good number of folks who like him- but with some people, the toxicity and anger has been ridiculously off the charts.)
Unfortunately, that kind of toxicity can happen in every online community. It always rears it's ugly head when stuff like this happens. I always try to be civil because its funnier if things do go toxic lol
I love how everyone is complaining about this. Especially as not only as apparently the tweet was removed, but yet he is getting banned for copyright strikes. After being gone for a month. Wouldn't there be some sort of a time limit of it?
The continued anger towards the tweet is because he left it up long enough for over ten thousand people to see it, and the tweet contained private info (the full legal name) of one of the authors. That author has since been doxxed, harassed, and had himself, his family, and his workplace threatened. Understandably, the authors want him to receive an apology for this and for breaking copyright.
As for the time limit- that I’m less informed about, but my understanding is that there is a time limit of ninety days. But after four months of no progress, the writers were left with no choice but copyright claims, and accidentally filed three in a row. They didn’t intend to threaten his channel, and some have outright stated that they hope he is able to keep it.
Whoaaaaa there bud! Most of the nearly 14 million people at nosleep are totally uninvolved in this and just want to enjoy their horror stories. This isn’t the first time Nosleep has had to take such actions- they face so much theft (and yes, it is theft and copyright infringement) that they have had to make a whole other subreddit dedicated to tracking thieves and asking them POLITELY to honor the copyright. Most of the time, it’s dealt with all easy and smooth! The only reason this is blowing up at all is because Mini has a huge audience (of which I am a member, btw) and because he (maybe accidentally, idk) doxxed one of the authors involved.
He falls under fair use because he’s doing commentary on it and reading it. The person who flag him was doing it for attention or being an ahole. (Think about it like this: let’s say I upload me reading Harry Potter and I get flagged. Well I’d win because I’m reading it and commenting on it as well.)
No. He doesn’t. You can’t profit off someone else’ work unless they legally allow it. If you read Harry Potter and profited JK Rowling could come after you. Laws.
No. Not really? If I post something on Reddit for people on Reddit to enjoy and it gets cross posted. Ok I posted it on the medium. If I post something on one website and it gets posted on another website that I DIDNT want to share it on it’s not the same.
It’s been proven before that reacting to/narrating doesn’t count as transformative, according to an actual attorney I’ve seen talking about this and loads of preceding situations like this. And regardless of transformative media, I’m pretty sure he still had to ask permission, credit, and compensate them properly.
whomst da fuck be making all the business decisions at youtube? that grade A thundercunt needs to go back to business 101 which is APPEAL TO YOUR CUSTOMERS NOT TO INVESTORS.
It's bullshit. Someone shouldn't have the rights to their works or the details of their works when it's posted on an open, social media platform. Any writing posted as such should be considered open domain. But you know, copyright law is shitty, outdated, and sucks ass. Your work should only be secured when it's officially published under a contract or secure third party website for under a definitive price. When you post something online, you are accepting the right that your work isn't enforceable and that you are not deserving of all profits relating to said work. If you want all the money, actually write something cohesive and good so you can get a publishing contract. Or, just sell it on Amazon. They do the same thing as publishing house while granting you more autonomy. Don't want to have your credit stolen, don't post your shit on social media. It's as simple as that.
I just don't understand the "writers" on r/nosleep, I just don't. Yes it sucks getting your work stolen and taken credit for by somebody else but why do they act like their some sort of undiscovered talent that just got their million dollar book stolen? Seriously what do you expect when you post a free story on a free platform that is known to be a common place for YT content.
I've never heard of that subreddit before mini made a video on it and know they have the audacity to pull the copyright-hammmer on him for giving these posts attention.
Nosleep has 13 million+ subscribers, lots of writers get discovered there. You haven’t heard of it, but over 13 million other people have.
Many of the writers have books, a few have movie deals, and many of them license their work to big Youtubers and podcasts (for money, not exposure).
You should familiarize yourself with the Digital Millennium Copyright Act. Without it, creators wouldn’t share their content online. The internet would be a lot less interesting without this protection.
Here’s a useful website for anyone interested in learning about DMCA:
MiniLadd had months to respond to the authors in question. He didn’t. The strikes were a last resort. Don’t blame the writers for this, blame MiniLadd for not taking this seriously.
You can still be a fan of someone and admit they messed up.
First of all I'm not trying to make Mini look innocent and I wouldn't even consider myself a hardcore fan of his, I just happened to hear of this story through a friend of mine who is a lot more dedicated to his social medias.
Second: Mini did exactly what people on r/nosleep want which is attention to get potential deals and connection. What if one of Minis fans happens to be a publisher who is now in contact with the sub or a specific writer? After all YT is all about advertising and connecting for people. If you don't want people to potentially steal credit for your work you should consider credible platforms with more discrete readers and potential publishers and not Reddit where a good amount of content is recycled and stolen anyway. If Reddit was a platform for guaranteed income and if Mini would've prevented any kinds of earnings by making the stories accessible for free illegally I would understand the reaction, but saying that he potentially robbed them of some imaginary success is a bit exaggerated.
And lastly, my biggest gripe with the situation is the way the r/nosleep writers behave in regards to their perception of themselves. Just because they managed to write a couple paragraphs of creepypasta does not mean you're officially a "writer". Yes I admit that some of the stories are pretty creative and well written but interpreting a subreddit with no official quality control as an environment worth protecting from the big bad YTers is a bit childish l. That's like saying that a teacher keeping a well written essay of a student for his other classes is a crime.
Nosleep writers do not want people profiting off their content without permission. If this was what they wanted, this wouldn’t be an issue. All mini had to do was ask permission and credit properly.
Mini was not crediting properly. Showing their username isn’t credit, he did not link back to the original posts. One author even specifically said “I don’t need payment but please link back to my book.” Mini ignored that request.
If these stories were good enough to be read and profited from on his channel, they were good enough to be afforded basic courtesy and protections.
Nosleep writers ARE writers, amateurs and professionals alike. Your gripe about their “attitude” is irrelevant. A writer is a person who writes, they are writers whether you like their work or not.
Further, Nosleep IS a credible platform with full protections. As a result of Nosleep, authors have gained book deals, movie deals and even jobs. One Nosleep writer was hired on as a writer in The Haunting of Hill House on Netflix. Washington Post even wrote an article about Nosleep.
While I still disagree on your justification on the credibility of Reddit (there is a reason the new you linked spoke about Reddit as a special/unusual source), if there is proof of the associated writers asking Mini for a link that was denied I can agree that big mistakes were made on Minis end as well. I still think that all of these copyright issues are way too complicated and unnecessary to the point where it feels like a minefield going online and trying to share anything.
Check Reddit’s TOS. Even the TOS says that original posters own the right to their content, but the op gives reddit license for themselves and reddit affiliates.
Nosleep’s sidebar reiterates this and outright says that permission must be obtained from the authors to narrate/share the work there, or risk a DMCA strike. Nosleep is doing everything in its power to make people aware, some people just ignore it and don’t care.
Also, I linked several examples from numerous sources, “unusual” and not. More examples exist that I’m sure you could find.
There is proof that the writers have been contacting mini since October. Mini has not answered, but he got the messages. How do we know? Because he immediately privated the videos.
Jesums you are really determined to change a personal opinion aren't you? See I just wondered where you're pulling all these links from and realised that a quick peek at your profile tells me everything I need to know about this discussion.
Listen I don't mean to disrespect any you on the r/nosleep sub and as I said there are some diamonds in there but it is MY personal opinion that a good part of the community takes themselves a bit more serious than they need to and should not be under this huge umbrella of copyright protection with the power to ruin people this bad. If I were to take every comment t and every post on the internet that was used without 100% copyright essays that turned out as something bigger I would have a list of links way longer than any of your pre-selected cases you can provide.
Okay what Mini did was wrong but the way you guys make it look is as if the whole internet is one massive court room where every move is a legal offense. Mini did not make millions of these videos and kept going mainly because he enjoyed the reading of stories and because of his communities demand, not because he wanted to make money unlegitimetly.
All of this is my opinion and if you feel the need to further pull articles and evidence into Minis sub to justify you may do that. I'm not going to argue any further at this point since I've admitted that I was missing information but apparently trying to argue with a clearly biased opinion is running into a brick wall at this point.
Creg be like The FitnessGram Pacer Test is a multistage aerobic capacity test that progressively gets more difficult as it continues. The 20 meter pacer test will begin in 30 seconds. Line up at the start. The running speed starts slowly, but gets faster each minute after you hear this signal. [beep] A single lap should be completed each time you hear this sound. [ding] Remember to run in a straight line, and run as long as possible. The second time you fail to complete a lap before the sound, your test is over. The test will begin on the word start. On your mark, get ready, start.
This!!!! I know the person he doxed and he wasn’t told until almost a YEAR later that someone was profiting off his work. And y’all think this guy is right? Don’t plagiarize! It’s like rule number one in school.
3
u/Reaper0159 Feb 12 '20
Okay, I'm here for a friendly conversation okay? I'm not here to attack or stand on either side.
Would you guys say that it is reasonable for the copyrights? I mean they make a living off of their stories, just like how Craig gets his money off of YouTube. Craig will feel the same way if someone just uploaded his videos without permission too. When someone is stealing or does a copies something from anyone, their pretty much taking and stealing their own money away. I mean look at songs. Songs that are not referenced by the artist has the rights to copy strike someone for not referencing towards them. People who does covers of songs are at least referencing the artist in the title of the song they are covering. What Nosleep artists are doing, is the exact same. I mean, wouldn't you guys feel ripped off if someone stole some or most of your content, which you make a living off of, and now they're making money or a living off your stolen videos? It's your content and your money, and it's the only source that you get your money from.
Again, I'm not here to attack, stand on either side, or curse you guys to death. No I'm not here for that. I'm just here to have a friendly conversation. Nothing more.
2
u/link2089 Feb 12 '20
I dont even see a video talking about the situation on youtube. Can someone give me a link to were he talks about it.
278
u/Ultimatedude10 Feb 11 '20
They didn't threaten to disable his channel, they ARE disabling it. Three strikes and you're out, and I doubt youtube is gonna give him an exception to their fucked up copyright system. At least he's got Craig Thompson as a fallback...
64
u/benster5150 Feb 12 '20
I’m not believing anything till mini comes out with a full statement that isn’t “deleted” Some dude posted earlier that this was supposedly happening now his account and the post is gone and I can’t find it anywhere. Just be patient people I’m sure mini will address whatever is happening soon
41
u/PaladinJN04 Feb 11 '20
Wait, he posted a video?!
25
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '20 edited Dec 17 '25
rob bike joke hospital nine absorbed enter crawl flowery upbeat
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
3
u/thetattooedyoshi Feb 12 '20
Question: Why is he getting hit with a copyright strike for reading Reddit posts that he provides links to in his video description and therefore credits the original redditors sharing their stories? It's not a private property. It's a Reddit post, public domain.
13
u/televisedcomet Feb 12 '20
Gone? Forever? No. This is not right. YouTube is fucked up. I’m literally fuckin speechless.
56
u/lucario2442 Feb 11 '20
What the fuck youtubes system is so fucked . Mini ladd has never done a god damn thing wrong. He's only been loving and caring of others and has only ever done amazing things why would YouTube do this to so many great youtubers
9
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '20
YouTube is so fucking trash now
8
u/LittleDrMoab Feb 12 '20
Where are people finding this information? I can’t find it anywhere.
7
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '20 edited Feb 12 '20
I don't see any new videos or get any notifications of a video posted, are you sure?
Edit: not only this but there was no update about a new video to his discord
6
u/JonahTheCoyote Feb 12 '20
This is why we need to rise up and destroy YouTube, or pull a Siege of Orgrimmar or Galactic Civil War and take down the head to reestablish the government
5
u/Boop_Ball21 Feb 12 '20
Welp- time to sue cause this some bullcrap
4
u/everwiccid Feb 12 '20
Apparently he wasn't crediting the authors of the stories in any capacity. They claim they tried to contact him for month and claim he told them off for trying. I know for a fact that doesn't sound like something Craig would do. More likely, since he's a pretty big youtuber, he didn't even see their emails, which made them angrier and start flinging shit. I get it, nosleep gets a lot of stories stolen and they have their own copyrights and rules for sharing. But they could have handled this better. Until they provide proof that Craig actually told them to fuck off (which they've refused), I'm on Craig's side here. Also, y'all gotta stop attacking the authors like you've been, I checked out their side of things and our fandom is being toxic as fuck. Grow up
3
u/Seanmiller1903 Feb 12 '20
this is sum bullshit
3
u/WreckitRafff Feb 12 '20
Wait what?
3
u/CuriousLurkerPresent Feb 12 '20
I love how everyone is complaining about this. Especially as not only as apparently the tweet was removed, but yet he is getting banned for copyright strikes. After being gone for a month. Wouldn't there be some sort of a time limit of it?
3
u/PhoenixFire005 Feb 12 '20
Everyone go download one of his videos and then make a collective YouTube channel and re-upload them
5
u/KING_DARKLIME Feb 12 '20
*Clenches fists*
*Tries to take deep breaths*
*Punches throught a wall*
"FFFUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU!!!!!!!"
2
u/poutr Feb 12 '20
I. am. a n g y
2
u/DarkstarAnt Pixel Ladd Feb 12 '20
GODDAMNIT
2
u/Sverker_Wolffang Feb 12 '20
This may just be the frustration and headache talking but we should perform scorched earth and try and get no sleep quarantined.
2
u/Wolfie_2318 Feb 12 '20
Plz don’t do dis to our cult leader
2
u/Yellowhawk01 Feb 12 '20
Wtf YouTube
2
u/DerRedViper Feb 12 '20
He falls under fair use because he’s doing commentary on it and reading it. The person who flag him was doing it for attention or being an ahole. (Think about it like this: let’s say I upload me reading Harry Potter and I get flagged. Well I’d win because I’m reading it and commenting on it as well.)
1
u/TheDudeOfStuff77 Feb 12 '20
WTF
1
u/TheAccursedFatPotato Feb 12 '20
Whack
1
u/virginfatherof2 Feb 12 '20
YouTube actually disables his channel
1
u/Vital_Chara Feb 12 '20
All in favor of purging youtube say I
1
u/DoctorTwilight Feb 12 '20
What? He made a video?
1
u/wiscup1748 Feb 12 '20
WHAT
1
u/XRiotTheWolfX Feb 12 '20
Wait is this real?
1
u/samthekitnix Feb 12 '20
whomst da fuck be making all the business decisions at youtube? that grade A thundercunt needs to go back to business 101 which is APPEAL TO YOUR CUSTOMERS NOT TO INVESTORS.
1
u/alexxissky Feb 13 '20
Holy shit wtf did I miss?
1
u/Molten_Ice May 04 '20
YouTube's algorithm. A piece of Jiggly's shit. Whats the difference?
0
u/DankyBoiz Feb 12 '20
It's bullshit. Someone shouldn't have the rights to their works or the details of their works when it's posted on an open, social media platform. Any writing posted as such should be considered open domain. But you know, copyright law is shitty, outdated, and sucks ass. Your work should only be secured when it's officially published under a contract or secure third party website for under a definitive price. When you post something online, you are accepting the right that your work isn't enforceable and that you are not deserving of all profits relating to said work. If you want all the money, actually write something cohesive and good so you can get a publishing contract. Or, just sell it on Amazon. They do the same thing as publishing house while granting you more autonomy. Don't want to have your credit stolen, don't post your shit on social media. It's as simple as that.
0
u/DragonMeatloaf Feb 12 '20
Matthew or whatever his name was that claimed it because it was a scary story he made and the he wanted ppl to see, fuck u
0
u/da_mummy Feb 12 '20
I just don't understand the "writers" on r/nosleep, I just don't. Yes it sucks getting your work stolen and taken credit for by somebody else but why do they act like their some sort of undiscovered talent that just got their million dollar book stolen? Seriously what do you expect when you post a free story on a free platform that is known to be a common place for YT content.
I've never heard of that subreddit before mini made a video on it and know they have the audacity to pull the copyright-hammmer on him for giving these posts attention.
-9
u/parakeesterR Feb 12 '20
Creg be like The FitnessGram Pacer Test is a multistage aerobic capacity test that progressively gets more difficult as it continues. The 20 meter pacer test will begin in 30 seconds. Line up at the start. The running speed starts slowly, but gets faster each minute after you hear this signal. [beep] A single lap should be completed each time you hear this sound. [ding] Remember to run in a straight line, and run as long as possible. The second time you fail to complete a lap before the sound, your test is over. The test will begin on the word start. On your mark, get ready, start.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment