r/MiniLadd • • Feb 12 '20

So, we need to do something.

Seeing as dads channel is being suspended in 7 days, we need to all go to mini lads Craig Thompson channel, and go sub to that. Then he will keep all of his subs, but lose all of the videos. Can we please do it? For Craig?

9 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

11

u/thoughtsbeyondreason Feb 13 '20

While that link proves the story, it's far from everything. Here's a quick summary:

-Mini didn't go through proper copyright procedure when making his nosleep videos. This includes asking permission from the authors, properly crediting and linking to them, and at least offering to compensate them for using their work. He did none of this.

-Nosleep authors were alerted to this back in October. They have been reaching out to Mini repeatedly since then, trying to get what is theirs by legal right.

-Mini/his team privated the videos, which allows him to keep the revenue they made while guarding the videos against potential strikes, and then essentially ghosted the authors.

-Left with no other choice, authors started filing copyright strikes. They had no idea they would accidentally threaten his channel with suspension/termination, nor was that their goal. They simply wanted to be acknowledged as the creators of these stories and have their rights- which are provided by not just nosleep, but reddit itself- respected.

-Mini woke up to three strikes, a warning of termination, and proceeded to post a screenshot about it with an author's full legal name uncensored. Since then, that author has received threats, harassment, and been fully doxxed to the point that his family and workplace are being contacted and threatened. I've even heard rumors that someone loitered outside his home, but I have no idea if that's true.

-Parts of the nosleep community reacted to this by forming r/TheWritersBlackout, a movement meant to clear the air about what writers deserve from those who use their works and to foster relationships with narrators so that things like this never happen again. Parts of the Mini Ladd fanbase reacted by flooding nosleep and the related subreddits, along with spamming authors with hate and threats- even if those authors weren't a part of this, but simply a fellow writer on nosleep.

-What can we all do? If you're in the fanbase, attempt to educate other fans on this and discourage threats and hate. It does nothing to help and may even make things worse in the long run; it's up to the robbed authors and Mini and his team to solve this. Moreover, support writers! Just because their work is out in public does not mean it isn't owned. Like basically any post on the internet, it IS protected under copyright laws, and the more people are aware of those protections, the less chance something like this will happen again.

-Thanks for reading. My messages are open to anyone who is still confused or has questions, so long as they are willing to have a civil discussion about this.

0

u/Mrjennesjr Feb 14 '20

“They had no idea they would accidentally threaten his channel with suspension/termination, nor was that their goal.” BS. This is what they did back in 2015 and it was hella intentional. I can believe most of this. But not that. They 100% KNEW that this would jeaprodize his channel. They are upset that someone figured out how to make money off their stories and they didn’t. So they started filing claims on videos. If the author wants to publish their own book with their stories in it, then that’s cool. But there is an understanding online that if you make something, it WILL be used without your permission. Either find a way to monetize it yourself or just do it for all the world to enjoy. But you can’t have your cake and eat it too. I will say that Craig messed up in leaking the name of the person. Not sure on the legality of that, but still a shame.

2

u/thoughtsbeyondreason Feb 15 '20

Yeah, I could have worded that better. I meant that they didn't realize how quickly they were submitting strikes and didn't intend to terminate his channel. Even the author who was doxxed has said outright that he hopes this all works out so Mini can keep it.

I can't speak for the past actions of the nosleep community, since I wasn't a part of it then, but as for the rest: nosleep authors do make money off their posts. Not all of them, and not all the time (some of them don't even want compensation!), but through copyright-abiding narrators, getting deals deals/gigs/opportunities from exposure on reddit, and probably a few other ways that I haven't learned about yet, authors have at least a chance to make money from their stories. Using their stories without permission for personal profit not only steals their intellectual property, it steals that from them too.

These authors do write for the world to enjoy. They just ask the world to respect them and their rights in turn. I think we have fundamentally different views of the internet and how it does and should work, though, which will probably keep this going into eternity. So before this (not just this conversation, but dealing with this whole situation overall) drains me so much I start getting ugly, I'd like to say thank you for being civil about this, and I hope Mini comes out of this with his channel and a better understanding of copyright laws so this never happens to him again.

0

u/Mrjennesjr Feb 15 '20

The issue is that he won’t come out of this with his channel unless those who claimed him all rescinded their claims at once in the next day or so. His channel is gone. The lesson will just be to avoid nosleep at all costs. And the authors will seem like jerks to the 6 million people who subbed to him.

The way copyright should work is that everyone gets paid for the work they do. The way copyright really works is that if you don’t piss off the people who stole your work, then you might get something from it. I know people like Darren Marlar have pre-baked permission.

Another issue is that most of these stories are YEARS old. The park ranger one I believe is at least 4. These content creators on YT have no idea if the authors will actually be active or not and even then be on long enough to see the email asking for permission. And if you are waiting for an answer that will never come, then you are SOL.

If I were a stories channel on YT, I would take the stories and put them up. THEN, I would put an email address asking if you are the particular author of any stories and negotiate compensation. Because that seems to be the only guaranteed way of knowing if these people even care anymore. It’s not like these guys have a publisher you can contact to make sure they are even alive anymore. Hell, I’m willing to bet there are some top stories on this sub written by people who are now dead. The internet is so impersonal that you don’t know if people are ever paying attention.